No Detail Found!

Enhancing year-round thermal comfort with solar control films: a solar-adjusted and spatial assessment considering adaptive clothing behavior

Author(s)
Maureen De Gastines Instituto de Ambiente, Hábitat y Energía (INAHE) - Centro Científico Tecnológico Mendoza - Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET) - A. Ruiz Leal s/n,5500 Mendoza,Argentina
Darío Jaime Instituto de Ambiente, Hábitat y Energía (INAHE) - Centro Científico Tecnológico Mendoza - Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET) - A. Ruiz Leal s/n,5500 Mendoza,Argentina
Andrea E. Pattini Instituto de Ambiente, Hábitat y Energía (INAHE) - Centro Científico Tecnológico Mendoza - Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET) - A. Ruiz Leal s/n,5500 Mendoza,Argentina
Abstract
Windows significantly contribute to thermal discomfort in high solar irradiance climates by allowing excessive heat gains and uneven indoor temperatures. This study introduces a solar-adjusted analytical framework for evaluating year-round indoor thermal comfort, integrating dynamic shortwave solar radiation effects, spatial zoning, and occupant behavior into comfort assessments. The methodology employs the Predicted Mean Vote adjusted via the SolarCal model and long-term comfort metrics to evaluate the effectiveness of Solar Control Films (SCFs) across twelve orientations at 30º intervals, in a cold arid (BWk) climate. Results demonstrate that absorbing SCFs with solar transmittance values between 0.22 and 0.40 reduce heat-related discomfort by 70-90% on average across all orientations, while the reflective film completely eliminates heat-related discomfort under all studied conditions. Although SCFs increase cold discomfort hours, the overall impact remains beneficial. Integrating hourly clothing adjustments into the framework reduces predicted warm discomfort by more than half and cold discomfort by 28% on average, offering a more realistic evaluation of occupant experience. Importantly, the choice of metric influences performance rankings: for average Thermal Comfort Availability (TCAmean), the reflective film excels in north, northwest, and west orientations, while absorbing films perform best in east and northeast. For time Thermal Comfort Usability (tTCU10-90), the reflective film outperforms other options across most orientations, doubling hours with 90% of the space in comfort conditions in north and northeast orientations, where heat discomfort is most critical. SCFs also reduce overheating near windows and homogenize thermal comfort across spaces, enabling optimized HVAC operation. This work highlights the potential of integrating solar radiation impacts and dynamic, spatially resolved metrics into thermal comfort assessments, providing insights for retrofitting strategies and climate-responsive design.
Publication Details
Page(s) 343-358
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Solar Radiation, low-cost retrofitting, thermal comfort indicators, Adaptive behavior
References
Jaffal I.,Inard C.,Ghaddar N.,Ghali K. .2020 .A metamodel for long-term thermal comfort in non-air-conditioned buildings. Architectural Engineering and Design Management, 16 : 441-472.
Ma N.,Zhang Q.,Murai F.,Braham W. W.,Samuelson H. W. .2023 .Learning building occupants ' indoor environmental quality complaints and dissatisfaction from text-mining Booking . com reviews in the United States. Building and Environment, 237 : 110319.
Zhai Y.,Wang Y.,Huang Y.,Meng X. .2019 .A multi-objective optimization methodology for window design considering energy consumption, thermal environment and visual performance. Renewable Energy, 134 : 1190-1199.
Teixeira H.,Gomes G.,Rodrigues A. Moret,Pereira J. .2021 .InService Thermal and Luminous Performance Monitoring of a Refurbished Building with Solar Control Films on the Glazing System. , 14 : 1388.
Song B.,Bai L.,Yang L. .2024 .The Effects of Exterior Glazing on Human Thermal Comfort in Office Buildings. , 17 : 776.
Zhang H.,Duan D.,Yang X.,Zheng W. .2023 .Application of CPMV * for improving the indoor thermal environment under global solar radiation. Indoor and Built Environment, 32 : 797-814.
Chetouni A.,Kaitouni S. I.,Jamil A. .2025 .Climate change impacts on future thermal energy demands and indoor comfort of a modular residential building across different climate zones. Journal of Building Engineering, 102 : 111927.
Murtyas S.,Qian R.,Matsuo T.,Tuck N. W.,Zaki S. A.,Hagishima A. .2024 .Thermal comfort in a two-storey malaysian terrace house: Are passive cooling methods sufficient in present and future climates?. Journal of Building Engineering, 96 : 110412.
Li C.,Tan J.,Chow T.,Qiu Z. .2015 .Experimental and theoretical study on the effect of window films on building energy consumption. Energy and Buildings, 102 : 129-138.
Moretti E.,E. Lascaro, E. .2015 .The influence of solar control films on energy and daylighting performance by means of experimental data and preliminary unsteady simulations. Energy Procedia, 78 : 340-345.
Pereira J.,Teixeira H.,G H.,Rodrigues A. M. .2022 .Performance of Solar Control Films on Building Glazing: A Literature Review. Applied Sciences, 12 : 5923.
Rodriguez R. G.,Garretón J. Yamin,Pattini A. E. .2016 .Glare indicators : an analysis of ocular behaviour in an office equipped with venetian blinds. Indoor and Built Environment, 25 : 69-80.
J. M. Monteoliva J. A. Y.,Garretón J. A. Y.,Pattini A. E. .2021 .Comparative Investigation of Daylight Glare Probability ( DGP ) Comfort Classes in Clear Sky Condition. Journal of Daylighting, 8 : 284-293.
Ko W. H. .2022 .. Window View Quality: Why It Matters and What We Should Do, Leukos, 18 : 259-267.
Lee E. S.,Szybinska B.,D. S. E.,Selkowitz L.,Heschong L. .2022 .Advocating for view and daylight in buildings : Next steps. Energy and Buildings, 265 : 112079.
Oliveira A.,A. Pedrini, A. .2023 .Thermal performance of highly glazed office buildings in the tropics : Contradicting architects ́ expectations, Energy. , 296 : 113344.
Moghaddam S. A. .2021 .Low-Emissivity Window Films as an Energy Retrofit Option for a Historical Stone Building in Cold Climate. , 14 : 7584.
Wang H.,Hang J.,Yang J.,Gao Z.,Zhao J.,Xu F. .2024 .Reduced-scale experimental study on the cooling effect of solar control films and cool materials. Energy and Buildings, 320 : 114636.
Navarro A. L. .2019 .Occupant-Centred Control strategies for Adaptive Facades : A preliminary study of the impact of shortwave solar radiation on thermal comfort. September, : 4910-4917.
Hodder S. G.,Parsons K. .2007 .The effects of solar radiation on thermal comfort. International journal of biometeorology, 51 : 233-250.
Godbole S. .2018 .Investigating The Relationship Between Mean Radiant Temperature ( MRT ) And Predicted Mean Vote ( PMV ) A case study in a university building. , : .
Chan M. Y.,Mak C. W. .2008 .Thermal Comfort Levels in a Room with Solar Radiation, Indoor. , 852 : 516-524.
Hwang R.,Fang P.,Chen W. .2023 .Impact of solar radiation on indoor thermal comfort near highly glazed façades in a hot-humid subtropical climate : An experimental evaluation, Build. August, 243 : 110725.
A. M. Atzeri .2017 .Thermal and Visual Comfort -- Integrated Building Performance Modelling and Measurement. , : .
Huang L.,Z. L. .2020 .Critical review and quantitative evaluation of indoor thermal comfort indices and models incorporating solar radiation effects. Energy and Buildings, 224 : 110204.
M. M. Pinto F. S.,Westphal F. S. .2022 .Assessment of thermal comfort in workstations located near highly glazed façades: solar - adjustment models. Ambiente Construído, 22 : 155-177.
Xiang X.,He Y.,Li N. .2024 .Evaluating annual thermal discomfort time ratio of indoor occupants caused by solar radiation using a novel model. Architectural Intelligence, 3(1) : 26.
Arens E.,Hoyt T.,Zhou X.,Huang L.,Zhang H.,Schiavon S. .2015 .Modeling the comfort effects of short-wave solar radiation indoors. Building and Environment, 88 : 3-9.
A. ASHRAE .2017 .Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy: ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-. , : .
Enescu D. .2017 .A review of thermal comfort models and indicators for indoor environments. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 79 : 1353-1379.
Huizenga C.,Zhang H.,Yu T.,and E. Arens, T. .2006 .Window performance for human thermal comfort. ASHRAE Transactions, 111 : 254-275.
Fang P.,Lu Y.,Chen W.,Hwang R. .2023 .Impacts of glazing system design factors upon dynamic indoor thermal comfort incorporating solar radiation effects. E3S Web of Conferences, 396 : 01030.
Chaiyapinunt S.,Khamporn N. .2021 .Effect of solar radiation on human thermal comfort in a tropical climate. Indoor and Built Environment, 30 : 391-410.
Kheybari A. G.,Gutai M.,Mok B. .2025 .Thermal comfort of standard and advanced glazed building envelopes. Energy and Buildings, 329 : 115211.
Teixeira H.,Gomes M. G.,Rodrigues A. Moret,Pereira J. .2020 .Thermal and visual comfort, energy use and environmental performance of glazing systems with solar control films. Building and Environment, 168 : 106474.
Moretti E.,Belloni E. .2015 .Evaluation of energy , thermal , and daylighting performance of solar control fi lms for a case study in moderate climate. Building and Environment, 94 : 183-195.
Chaiyapinunt S.,Phueakphongsuriya B. .2005 .Performance rating of glass windows and glass windows with films in aspect of thermal comfort and heat transmission. Energy and Buildings, 37 : 725-738.
Chaiyapinunt S.,Khamporn N. .2009 .Selecting glass window with film for buildings in a hot climate. Engineering Journal, 13(1) : 29-42.
M. C. Singh S. N.,Garg R.,Jha R. .2008 .Different glazing systems and their impact on human thermal comfort - Indian scenario. Building and Environment, 43 : 1596-1602.
Zhang S.,Touchie M. F.,W. M. F. .2020 .O'Brien, Quantifying overheating in highly glazed buildings and evaluationg films as a mitigation strategy. August, : 178-181.
Teixeira H.,Gomes M. G.,Rodrigues A. M.,Aelenei D. .2024 .Solar responsive building glazing : Experimental analysis of the impact of photochromic glazing on indoor thermal and luminous conditions. Journal of Building Engineering, 92 : 109812.
Liu J.,Yao R.,Mccloy R. .2014 .An investigation of thermal comfort adaptation behaviour in office buildings in the UK, Indoor. , 23 : 675-691.
M. De Carli B. W.,Olesen A.,Zarrella R.,Zecchin R. .2007 .People ' s clothing behaviour according to external weather and indoor environment. Building and Environment, 42 : 3965-3973.
Conejo J.,Fernández J. .2021 .Towards occupant-based building performance simulations : Considering Spatial Thermal Comfort Conditions and Personal Clothing Adaptation in the Evaluation of Sun-Irradiated Indoor Environments. , : .
Yang R.,Zhang H.,Zheng W.,Zheng X. .2020 .Study on the thermal comfort index of solar radiation conditions in winter. Building and Environment, 167 : 106456.
Kramer T.,Schiavon S.,Garcia-Hansen V. .2024 .Spatial Thermal Autonomy ( sTA ): A New Metric for Enhancing Building. Proceedings of CATE 2024 Conference, : 20-22.
Li P. .2020 .Improved long-term thermal comfort indices for continuous monitoring. Energy and Buildings, 224 : 110270.
A. M. Atzeri F.,Cappelletti A.,Tzempelikos A.,Gasparella A. .2016 .Comfort metrics for an integrated evaluation of buildings performance. Energy and Buildings, 127 : 411-424.
Jalilzadehazhari E.,Johansson P.,Johansson J.,Mahapatra K. .2018 .Developing a decision-making framework for resolving conflicts when selecting windows and blinds. , 15 : 357-381.
Nazari S. .2023 .A multi-objective optimization approach to designing window and shading systems considering building energy consumption and occupant comfort. Eng. Reports, 5 : 12726.
Zhao J.,Du Y. .2020 ., Multi-objective optimization design for windows and shading configuration considering energy consumption and thermal comfort: A case study for office building in different climatic regions of China. , 206 : 997-1017.
Rubel A.,Joarder A. R. .2024 .Performance of Shading Against West Glass Facades to Optimise Daylight , Thermal Comfort and Energy Efficiency of Office Buildings. Journal of Daylighting, 11 : 131-148.
Rezaei F.,Sangin H.,Heiranipour M.,Attia S. .2024 .A Multi-objective Optimization of Window and Light Shelf Design in Office Buildings to Improve Occupants ' Thermal and Visual. Journal of Daylighting, 11 : 55-68.
Schiavon S.,Lee K. H. .2013 .Dynamic predictive clothing insulation models based on outdoor air and indoor operative temperatures. Building and Environment, 59 : 250-260.
Ibrahim Y. .2022 .Integration of Advanced Techniques for The Optimisation of Energy Consumption and The Mitigation of Urban Heat Island. , : .
M. de Gastines A. E.,Pattini A. E. .2020 .Window energy efficiency in Argentina - Determining factors and energy savings strategies. Journal of Cleaner Production, 247 : 119104.
Kim J.,Caradonna C.,Parker A. .2025 .and. html (accessed 7 July, : .
Lawrie L. K.,Crawley D. B. .2022 .Development of Global Typical Meteorological Years (TMYx). (paper in progress), : .
M. de Gastines ,Pattini A.,Balneário Camboriú .2017 .and. September, : 1647-1655.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

38

Views