No Detail Found!

Occupant-centric visual comfort assessment and optimization of passive solar façade shading systems through view-based analysis of daylight glare probability, view content, and spatial frequency distribution

Author(s)
Martin Ivanov The University of Tokyo,Kashiwa, Chiba, 277-8563,Japan
Jun Sato The University of Tokyo,Kashiwa, Chiba, 277-8563,Japan
Abstract
This study introduces a comprehensive computational framework integrating image-based simulations, spatial frequency analysis, and multi-objective optimization to evaluate and optimize passive solar shading devices from an occupant-centric perspective. While traditional façade optimization primarily addresses daylight performance and glare control, critical gaps remain in objectively and simultaneously quantifying visual comfort and preference, as well as external view content and quality-both essential to user satisfaction and psychological well-being. To bridge these gaps, spatial frequency metrics, historically utilized in image classification and visual assessments, are proposed as quantitative indicators for evaluating shading devices. The methodology employs first-person interior views analyzed through advanced computational techniques-daylight glare probability, image segmentation and power spectrum analysis-to objectively assess visual comfort, view content and spatial frequency composition. The proposed framework employs an adaptive optimization algorithm that iteratively generates and refines shading device configurations, effectively balancing glare reduction, external visibility, and visual complexity. Two experimental studies validate the approach: the first systematically evaluates multiple predefined shading patterns to identify optimal characteristics, while the second demonstrates that algorithmic optimization of highly irregular shading configurations can simultaneously improve multiple visual comfort metrics, significantly outperforming regular shading patterns in terms of glare reduction, view preservation, and spatial frequency performance.
Publication Details
Page(s) 293-305
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Optimization, passive solar shading, spatial frequency analysis, Visual Comfort
References
Pastore L.,Andersen M. .2022 .The influence of façade and space design on building occupants' indoor experience. Journal of Building Engineering, 46 : 103663.
Bazazzadeh H.,Świt-Jankowska B.,Fazeli N.,Nadolny A.,B. A. .2021 .Safar ali najar, S.S. Hashemi safaei, M. Mahdavinejad, Efficient shading device as an important part of daylightophil architecture; a designerly framework of high-performance architecture for an office. , 14 : 8272.
M.F. Gimat ,M.K.A.M. Sulaiman .2020 .Effect on thermal performance by different types of fixed sun shading devices. International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology, 9 : 3713-3718.
M.H. Abedini H.,Gholami H. .2025 .Sangin, Multi-objective optimization of window and shading systems for enhanced office building performance: A case study in Qom, Iran. Journal of Daylighting, 12 : 91-110.
Rezaei F.,Sangin H.,Heiranipour M.,Attia S. .2024 .A multi-objective optimization of window and light shelf design in office buildings to improve occupants' thermal and visual comfort. Journal of Daylighting, 11 : 55-68.
Lee K.,J K. .2016 .Feasibility study on parametric optimization of daylighting in building shading design. Sustainability, 8(12) : 1220.
Li L.,Qi Z.,Ma Q.,Gao W.,Wei X. .2024 .Evolving multi-objective optimization framework for early-stage building design: Improving energy efficiency, daylighting, view quality, and thermal comfort. Building Simulation, 17(11) : 2097-2123.
Shan R.,L. R. .2023 .Junghans, Multi-objective optimization for high-performance building facade design: A systematic literature review. Sustainability, 15(21) : 15596.
Radwan G.A.N.,Osama N. .2016 .Biomimicry, an approach, for energy efficient building skin design. Procedia Environmental Sciences, 34 : 178-189.
K.M. Al-Obaidi M.A.,Ismail H.,Hussein A.M.A.,Rahman A.M.A. .2017 .Biomimetic building skins: An adaptive approach. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 79 : 1472-1491.
Kellert S.R.,Calabrese E.F. .2025 .The Practice of Biophilic Design, BiophilicDesign. com (Accessed 3 July, : .
Wienold J.,Christoffersen J. .2006 .Evaluation methods and development of a new glare prediction model for daylight environments with the use of CCD cameras, Energy. , 38(7) : 743-757.
Mehrabadi E.,Pilechiha P.,Mahdavinejad M.,Nadiri P.,Mahdavinejad M.,Pilechiha P. .2019 .Optimization of building façade to control daylight excessiveness and view to outside. Journal of Applied Engineering Sciences, 9(2) : 161-168.
Pilechiha P.,Mahdavinejad M.,Pour Rahimian F.,Carnemolla P.,S. P. .2020 .Seyedzadeh, Multi-objective optimisation framework for designing office windows: quality of view, daylight and energy efficiency. Applied Energy, 261 : 114356.
Torralba A.,A A. .2003 .. Network: Computation in Neural Systems, 14(3) : 391-412.
Oliva A.,Torralba A. .2001 .Modeling the shape of the scene: A holistic representation of the spatial envelope. International Journal of Computer Vision, 42(3) : 145-175.
Spehar B.,Clifford C.W.G.,Newell B.R.,Taylor R.P. .2003 .. Computers & Graphics, 27(5) : 813-820.
Spehar B.,Taylor R.P.,Human Vision,Electronic Imaging XVIII Vision .2013 .Fractals in art and nature: Why do we like them?. February, 865118 : 4.
Viengkham C.,Spehar B. .2018 .Preference for fractal-scaling properties across synthetic noise images and artworks. , 9 : 1439.
L. O'Hare P.B.,Hibbard P.B. .2011 .Spatial frequency and visual discomfort. Vision Research, 51(15) : 1767-1777.
Juricevic I.,Land L.,Wilkins A.,Webster M.A. .2010 .Visual discomfort and natural image statistics. , 39(7) : 884-899.
C.M. Hagerhall T.,Purcell R.,Taylor R. .2004 .Fractal dimension of landscape silhouette outlines as a predictor of landscape preference. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 24(2) : 247-255.
Geller H.A.,Bartho R.,Thömmes K.,Redies C. .2022 .Statistical image properties predict aesthetic ratings in abstract paintings created by neural style transfer. , 16 : 999720.
Kirimtat A.,Koyunbaba B.K.,Sariyildiz S. .2016 .Review of simulation modeling for shading devices in buildings. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 53 : 23-49.
Davoodi A.,Johansson P.,Aries M. .2021 .The implementation of visual comfort evaluation in the evidence-based design process using lighting simulation. Applied Sciences, 11(11) : 4982.
Elkhayat Y.,Hamada M.,Wahba M. .2023 .Visual comfort as a design approach for intelligent facades: A review. , 6(1) : 371-386.
Shafavi N.S.,Zomorodian Z.S.,Tahsildoost M.,Javadi M. .2020 .Occupants visual comfort assessments: A review of field studies and lab experiments. Solar Energy, 208 : 249-274.
Ko W.H.,Kent M.G.,Schiavon S.,Levitt B.,Betti G. .2022 .A window view quality assessment framework. LEUKOS, 18(3) : 268-293.
Lee J.H.,Ostwald M.J. .2023 .The 'visual attractiveness' of architectural facades: Measuring visual complexity and attractive strength in architecture. Architectural Science Review, 66(1) : 42-52.
Zeng W.,Zhang H. .2024 .A virtual reality window view evaluation tool for shading devices and exterior landscape design. in: Phygital Intelligence, : 163-179.
Gircys M.,Ross B. .2019 .Image evolution using 2D power spectra. Complexity, : 1-21.
Huang Y.,Niu J.-L. .2016 .Optimal building envelope design based on simulated performance: History, current status and new potentials. Energy and Buildings, 117 : 387-398.
Khoroshiltseva M.,Slanzi D.,I. D. .2016 .Poli, A Pareto-based multi-objective optimization algorithm to design energy-efficient shading devices. Applied Energy, 184 : 1400-1410.
Ivanov M.,Sato J. .2024 .Façade design pattern optimization workflow through visual spatial frequency analysis and structural safety assessment. Journal of Facade Design and Engineering, 12(1) : 43-62.
Ivanov M.,Sato J. .2025 .Evolving tensegrity façade systems: Computational morphogenesis through multi-step optimization and digital fabrication of structural modules. Journal of the International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures, : .
Y.M.S. Abdelhamid S.M.,Wahba M. .2023 .ElHusseiny, The effect of parametric patterned façade variations on daylight quality, visual comfort, and daylight performance in architecture studio-based tutoring. Journal of Daylighting, 10 : 173-191.
Pouyanmehr M.,Pilechiha P.,Carnemolla P. .2022 .External shading form-finding: Simulating daylighting and dynamic view access assessment. Journal of Building Performance Simulation, 15(3) : 398-409.
Kirimtat A.,Krejcar O.,Ekici B.,Tasgetiren M.F. .2019 ., Multi-objective energy and daylight optimization of amorphous shading devices in buildings. Solar Energy, 185 : 100-111.
Suphavarophas P.,Wongmahasiri R.,Keonil N.,Bunyarittikit S. .2024 .A systematic review of applications of generative design methods for energy efficiency in buildings. , 14(5) : 1311.
Parsaee M.,C.M.H. Demers A.,Potvin M.,Hébert J.-F.,Lalonde J.-F. .2021 .Window view access in architecture: Spatial visualization and probability evaluations based on human vision fields and biophilia. , 11 : 627.
Ko W.H.,Schiavon S.,Santos L.,Kent M.G.,Kim H.,Keshavarzi M. .2023 .View access index: The effects of geometric variables of window views on occupants' satisfaction. Building and Environment, 234 : 110132.
Abd-Alhamid F.,Kent M.,Wu Y. .2023 .Quantifying window view quality: A review on view perception assessment and representation methods. Building and Environment, 227 : 109742.
Kim J.,Kent M.,Kral K. .2022 .Seemo: A new tool for early design window view satisfaction evaluation in residential buildings. Building and Environment, 214 : 108909.
Tarkhan N.,Klimenka M.,Fang K.,Duarte F.,Ratti C.,Reinhart C. .2025 .Mapping facade materials utilizing zero-shot segmentation for applications in urban microclimate research. Scientific Reports, 15(1) : 5492.
Li M.,Yeh A.G.O.,Xue F. .2024 .CIM-WV: A 2D semantic segmentation dataset of rich window view contents in high-rise, high-density Hong Kong based on photorealistic city information models. Urban Informatics, 3(1) : 12.
Georgiou T.T. .2007 .Distances between power spectral densities. IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing, 55(8) : 3995-4003.
Wortmann T. .2016 .Black-box optimisation methods for architectural design. April, 30 : 177-186.
Costa A.,RBFOpt: A. .2018 .An open-source library for black-box optimization with costly function evaluations. Mathematical Programming Computation, 10(4) : 597-629.
Nannicini G. .2021 .On the implementation of a global optimization method for mixed-variable problems. Open Journal of Mathematical Optimization, 2 : 1-25.
Hashemloo A.,Inanici M. .2016 .GlareShade: A visual comfort-based approach to occupant-centric shading systems. Journal of Building Performance Simulation, 9(4) : 351-365.
Tabadkani A.,Roetzel A.,Li H.X.,Tsangrassoulis A. .2021 .Daylight in buildings and visual comfort evaluation: The advantages and limitations. Journal of Daylighting, 8 : 181-203.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

76

Views