No Detail Found!

Evaluating Visual and Beyond-Vision Light Effects and Energy Consumption for Luminous and Temporal Light Factors: A Single Office Case

Author(s)
Alyaá Tabbah Department of Construction Engineering and Lighting Science, School of Engineering, Jönköping University,Jönköping,Sweden
Peter Johansson Department of Construction Engineering and Lighting Science, School of Engineering, Jönköping University,Jönköping,Sweden
Myriam B C Aries Department of Construction Engineering and Lighting Science, School of Engineering, Jönköping University,Jönköping,Sweden
Abstract
Light influences human physiology and psychology through visual and beyond-visual effects, collectively termed 'integrative lighting.' Human responses depend on luminous (quantity, spectrum, directionality) and temporal (timing, duration, history) factors, yet no studies examined their combined influence on integrative lighting. Therefore, this study evaluates representative metrics integration by designing, implementing, and testing a comprehensive lighting simulation framework incorporating luminous and temporal factors to address integrative lighting needs while assessing energy consumption. A quantitative approach was employed, integrating multiple criteria through computational simulations using Rhinoceros/Grasshopper, Lark, ClimateStudio, and Ladybug/Honeybee. Simulations are performed in a single office with nine control points, four vertical viewing directions, and one horizontal, each testing eight window sizes and different electric lighting combinations of ceiling panels and wallwashers with varying melanopic-content across four seasonal days. Including beyond-visual effects in multi-criteria optimisation introduces complexity due to the interplay between luminous and temporal aspects. Results show that beyond-visual effects depend on light quantity, spectral composition, and spatial distribution. Increasing window-towall ratio or melanopic-content lighting alone does not ensure uniform beyond-visual performance. Instead, directing wall washers at opaque surfaces enhances background luminance, reduces glare, and improves retinal exposure. Beyond-vision criteria are challenging due to temporal dependencies, often requiring window size and lighting energy use trade-offs. These findings highlight the need for lighting designs that optimise light levels, spectrum, and directionality at the right time. Future approaches should use multi-objective optimisation to balance visual and nonvisual outcomes, automate adjustments, and enhance well-being while maintaining energy efficiency.
Publication Details
Page(s) 306-342
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Daylight, visual light effects, beyond-vision light effects, window-to-wall ratio
References
Klepeis N. E.,Nelson W. C.,Ott W. R.,Robinson J. P.,Tsang A. M. . .. [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6], : .
Switzer J. V.,Behar S. C.,Hern W. H.,Engelmann W. H. .2001 .The National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS): a resource for assessing exposure to environmental pollutants. Journal of Exposure Science & Environmental Epidemiology, 11(3) : 231-252.
Andersen M.,Mardaljevic J.,Lockley S. W. .2012 .A framework for predicting the non-visual effects of daylight - Part I: photobiology- based model. Lighting Research & Technology, 44(1), : 37-53.
Andersen M.,Gochenour S. J.,Lockley S. W. .2013 .Modelling 'non-visual' effects of daylighting in a residential environment. Building and Environment, 70 : 138-149.
Sánchez-Cano .2021 .Evaluation of Visual and Nonvisual Levels of Daylight from Spectral Power Distributions Considering Orientation. , 11(13) : .
Vetter C. .2022 .A Review of Human Physiological Responses to Light: Implications for the Development of Integrative Lighting Solutions. , 18(3) : 387-414.
Price L. L. A. .2019 .Linking the non-visual effects of light exposure with occupational health. Int J Epidemiol, 48(5) : 1393-1397.
L. J. M. Schlangen B. M. I. van der Zande .2022 .The power of healthy daytime lighting in indoor settings: melanopic lighting advances and office applications. , : .
.2018 .System for metrology of optical radiation for ipRGC-influenced responses to light. [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] CIE, : .
T. M. Brown .2022 .e3001571. PLOS Biology, 20(3) : .
Hattar S.,Liao H. W.,Takao M.,Berson D. M.,Yau K. W. .2002 .. Science (American Association for the Advancement of Science), 295(5557) : 1065-1070.
Mardaljevic J.,Andersen M.,Roy N.,Christoffersen J. .2014 .A framework for predicting the non-visual effects of daylight - Part II: The simulation model. Lighting Research & Technology, 46(4), : 388-406.
CIE .2020 .-lightingintegrative-lighting-non-visual-effects.. Report No. ISO/CIE TR 21783, : .
Houser K. W.,Esposito T.,Human-Centric Lighting .2021 .Foundational Considerations and a Five-Step Design Process. , 12 : 630553.
Y. A. W. de Kort J. A.,Veitch J. A. .2014 .From blind spot into the spotlight: Introduction to the special issue 'Light, lighting, and human behaviour'. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 39 : 1-4.
Cajochen C.,Münch M.,Kobialka S.,Kräuchi K.,Steiner R.,Oelhafen P.,Orgül S.,Wirz-Justice A. .2005 .High Sensitivity of Human Melatonin, Alertness, Thermoregulation, and Heart Rate to Short Wavelength Light. The journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism, 90(3) : 1311-1316.
Rüger M.,M. C. M. Gordijn D. G. M.,Beersma S.,Daan S. .2006 .Time-of-day-dependent effects of bright light exposure on human psychophysiology: comparison of daytime and nighttime exposure. American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology, 290(5) : R1413-R1420.
Li Y.,Fang W.,Qiu H.,Wang J. .2024 .The non-visual effects of correlated color temperature on the alertness, cognition, and mood of fatigued individuals during the afternoon. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 101 : .
Schlangen .2022 .e12786. Journal of Pineal Research, 72(2) : .
Spitschan M.,Vidafar P.,Cain S. W.,Phillips A. J. K.,Lambert B. C. .2024 .Power Analysis for Human Melatonin Suppression Experiments. Clocks and Sleep, 6(1) : 114-128.
L. M. Huiberts ,K. C. H. J. Smolders Y. A.,W. De Kort Y. A. .2017 .Seasonal and time-of-day variations in acute non-image forming effects of illuminance level on performance, physiology, and subjective well-being. , 34(7) : 827-844.
K. C. H. J. Smolders Y. A.,W. de Kort and P. J. M. Cluitmans Y. A. .2012 .A higher illuminance induces alertness even during office hours: Findings on subjective measures, task performance and heart rate measures. Physiology & Behavior, 107(1) : 7-16.
Spitschan M. .2021 .Time-Varying Light Exposure in Chronobiology. , 12 : .
M. G. Figueiro R.,Nagare L.,Price L. .2018 .Non-visual effects of light: how to use light to promote circadian entrainment and elicit alertness. Light Res Technol, 50(1) : 38-62.
Czeisler C. A.,Duffy J. F.,Shanahan T. L.,Brown E. N.,Stability E. N. .1999 .-hour period of the human circadian pacemaker. Science, 284(5423) : 2177-2181.
Duffy J. F. .2011 .Sex difference in the near-24-hour intrinsic period of the human circadian timing system. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(supplement_3), : 15602-15608.
Kenneth T. .2013 .Rusterholz and Evan, Entrainment of the Human Circadian Clock to the Natural Light-Dark Cycle. Current Biology, 23(16) : 1554-1558.
Eto T.,Higuchi S. .2023 .Review on age-related differences in non-visual effects of light: melatonin suppression, circadian phase shift and pupillary light reflex in children to older adults. Journal of Physiological Anthropology, 42(1) : .
Feigl B.,Ojha G.,Hides L.,Zele A. J. .2018 .Melanopsin-Driven Pupil Response and Light Exposure in Non-seasonal Major Depressive Disorder. Front Neurol, 9 : 764.
Laurenzo S. A. .2016 .Pupillary response abnormalities in depressive disorders. Psychiatry Research, 246 : 492-499.
Tao L.,Jiang R.,Zhang K.,Qian Z.,Chen P.,Lv Y.,Yao Y. .2020 .Light therapy in non-seasonal depression: An update meta-analysis. Psychiatry Research, 291 : .
.2009 .wavelength in light treatment of Seasonal Affective Disorder. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 120(3) : 203-212.
K. A. Roecklein .2021 .Melanopsin-driven pupil response in summer and winter in unipolar seasonal affective disorder. Journal of Affective Disorders, 291 : 93-101.
Khademagha P.,M. B. C. Aries A. L. P.,Rosemann E. J. van Loenen .2016 .Implementing non-image-forming effects of light in the built environment: A review on what we need, Building and. , 108 : 263-272.
Baek and B.-K. Min H. .2015 .Blue light aids in coping with the post-lunch dip: an EEG study. Ergonomics, 58(5) : 803-810.
Viola A. U. P.,James L. M.,Schlangen L. J. M. P.,Dijk D.-J. P. .2008 .Blueenriched white light in the workplace improves self-reported alertness, performance and sleep quality. Scandinavian Journal of Work, 34(4) : 297-306.
Brainard .2003 .Inferior Retinal Light Exposure Is More Effective than Superior Retinal Exposure in Suppressing Melatonin in Humans. Journal of Biological Rhythms, 18(1) : 71-79.
Rüger M.,M. C. M. Gordijn D. G. M.,Beersma S.,Daan S. .2005 .Nasal versus Temporal Illumination of the Human Retina: Effects on Core Body Temperature, Melatonin, and Circadian Phase. Journal of Biological Rhythms, 20(1) : 60-70.
M. L. Amundadottir S.,Rockcastle M. Sarey,Khanie M.,Andersen M. .2017 .A human-centric approach to assess daylight in buildings for non-visual health potential, visual interest and gaze behavior, Building and. , 113 : 5-21.
M. Te Kulve L. J. M.,Schlangen L. J. M.,W. D. van Marken Lichtenbelt .2019 .Early evening light mitigates sleep compromising physiological and alerting responses to subsequent late evening light. Sci Rep, 9(1) : 16064.
Hébert M.,Martin S. K.,Lee C.,C. I. Eastman C. .2002 .The effects of prior light history on the suppression of melatonin by light in humans. Journal of Pineal Research, 33(4) : 198-203.
Schöllhorn I.,Stefani O.,Blume C.,Cajochen C. .2023 .Seasonal Variation in the Responsiveness of the Melanopsin System to Evening Light: Why We Should Report Season When Collecting Data in Human Sleep and Circadian Studies, Clocks. , 5(4) : 651-666.
Martin J. S.,Hébert M.,Gaudreault M.,Laberge L. .2012 .Work-Related Fatigue in Student Workers. , 29(3) : 295-304.
Lowden A.,Öztürk G.,Reynolds A.,Bjorvatn B. .2019 .Evidence based interventions using light to improve circadian adaptation to working hours. Ind Health, 57(2) : 213-227.
Lockley S. W.,Evans E. E.,Scheer F. A. J. L.,Brainard G. C.,Czeisler C. A.,Aeschbach D. .2006 .Short-Wavelength Sensitivity for the Direct Effects of Light on Alertness, Vigilance, and the Waking Electroencephalogram in Humans. , 29(2) : 161-168.
Bano-Otalora B.,Moye M. J.,T. M. Brown M. J.,Lucas C. O.,Diekman and M. D. C. Belle C. O. .2020 .Daily electrical activity in the master circadian clock of a diurnal mammal. , : .
M. Brown B. Mino,Dc R. J.,Lucas R. J. .2020 .Daytime light enhances the amplitude of circadian output in a diurnal mammal. , : .
Roenneberg T.,Wirz-Justice A.,Merrow M. .2003 .Daily Temporal Patterns of Human Chronotypes. Journal of Biological Rhythms, 18(1) : 80-90.
Boubekri M.,Lee J.,Woo M.,Schuyler L.,Tinianov B.,Satish U. .2020 .The Impact of Optimized Daylight and Views on the Sleep Duration and Cognitive Performance of Office Workers. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 17(9) : .
Leger D.,Bayon V.,Elbaz M.,Philip P.,Choudat D. .2011 .Underexposure to light at work and its association to insomnia and sleepiness: A crosssectional study of 13 296 workers of one transportation company. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 70(1) : 29-36.
Hartmeyer S. L.,Andersen M. .2023 .Towards a framework for lightdosimetry studies: Quantification metrics. Lighting Research & Technology, 56(4), : 337-365.
Nowozin C.,Wahnschaffe A.,Papakonstantinou A.,Hädel S.,Rodenbeck A.,Bes F.,Kunz D. .2025 .Living in Biological Darkness II: Impact of Winter Habitual Daytime Light on Night-Time Sleep. European Journal of Neuroscience, 61(2) : .
Hao H.,Xu J.,Schlangen L. J. M. .2024 .Evaluation and optimization of annual light variations for visual and non-visual effects within a ground-floor middle school classroom. Journal of Building Engineering, 98 : 111293.
Kim and M. D. Casement S. .2024 .Promoting adolescent sleep and circadian function: A narrative review on the importance of daylight access in schools. , 41(5) : 725-737.
Liu J.,Li Z.,Zhang Z.,Xie L.,Wu J. .2024 .Evaluation and Optimization of Interior Circadian Daylighting Performance for the Elderly in Traditional Dwellings: A Case Study in Western Hunan. , 16(9) : 3563.
Mukherjee B.,Boubekri M. .2025 .Sustainable Architecture and Human Health: A Case for Effective Circadian Daylighting Metrics. , 15(3) : .
Mantua and R. M. C. J. .2017 .Spencer, Exploring the nap paradox: are mid-day sleep bouts a friend or foe?. Sleep Medicine, 37 : 88-97.
Takahashi M.,Nakata A.,Haratani T.,Ogawa Y.,Arito H. .2004 .Post-lunch nap as a worksite intervention to promote alertness on the job. Ergonomics, 47(9) : 1003-1013.
Askaripoor T.,Motamedzade M.,Golmohammadi R.,Farhadian M.,Babamiri M.,Samavati M. .2019 .Effects of light intervention on alertness and mental performance during the post-lunch dip: a multi-measure study. Industrial Health, 57(4) : 511-524.
Qian L.,Ru T.,Chen Q.,Li Y.,Zhou Y.,Zhou G. .2021 .e13242. Journal of Sleep Research, 30(4) : .
Slama H.,Schmitz R.,Peigneux P.,Leproult R. .2015 .e0125359. PLOS ONE, 10(5) : .
Zhou Y.,Chen Q.,Luo X.,Li L.,Ru T.,Zhou G. .2021 .Does Bright Light Counteract the Post-lunch Dip in Subjective States and Cognitive Performance Among Undergraduate Students?. , 9 : .
M. B. C. Aries F.,Beute G.,Fischl G. .2020 .Assessment protocol and effects of two dynamic light patterns on human well-being and performance in a simulated and operational office environment. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 69 : 101409.
Kompier M. E.,K. C. H. J. Smolders W. D. van Marken,Lichtenbelt Y. A.,W. de Kort Y. A. .2020 .Effects of light transitions on measures of alertness, arousal and comfort. Physiology & Behavior, 223 : 112999.
Peeters S. T.,K. C. H. J. Smolders Y. A. W. .2020 .What you set is (not) what you get: How a light intervention in the field translates to personal light exposure. Building and Environment, 185 : 107288.
Phipps-Nelson J.,Redman J. R.,Dijk D.-J.,Rajaratnam S. M. W. .2003 .. Decreases Sleepiness and Improves Psychomotor Vigilance Performance, Sleep, 26(6) : 695-700.
Wienold J.,Christoffersen J. .2006 .Evaluation methods and development of a new glare prediction model for daylight environments with the use of CCD cameras, Energy. , 38(7) : 743-757.
.2021 .Swedish Institute for Standards, SS-EN 12464-1:2021 Light and lighting - Lighting of work places - Part 1: Indoor work places. , 12464 : 12021.
Kompier M. E.,K. C. H. J. Smolders R. P.,Kramer W. D. van Marken,Lichtenbelt Y. A. W. .2022 .Contrasting dynamic light scenarios in an operational office: Effects on visual experience, alertness, cognitive performance, and sleep. Building and Environment, 212 : 108844.
Borisuit A.,Linhart F.,Scartezzini J. L.,Münch M. .2014 .Effects of realistic office daylighting and electric lighting conditions on visual comfort, alertness and mood. , 47(2) : 192-209.
Hamedani Z.,Skates H.,Hine T.,Fernando R.,Lyons J.,Dupre K. .2019 .Visual discomfort and glare assessment in office environments: A review of light-induced physiological and perceptual responses. Building and Environment, 153 : 267-280.
Pierson C.,Wienold J.,Bodart M. .2018 .Review of Factors Influencing Discomfort Glare Perception from Daylight. , 14(3) : 111-148.
Chi F.,Wang Y.,Wang R.,Li G.,Peng C. .2020 .An investigation of optimal window-to-wall ratio based on changes in building orientations for traditional dwellings. Solar Energy, 195 : 64-81.
Shen H.,Tzempelikos A.,Atzeri A. M.,Gasparella A.,Cappelletti F. .2015 .Dynamic Commercial Façades versus Traditional Construction: Energy Performance and Comparative Analysis. Journal of Energy Engineering, 141(4) : .
Jia Y.,Liu Z.,Fang Y.,Zhang H.,Zhao C.,Cai X. .2023 .Effect of Interior Space and Window Geometry on Daylighting Performance for Terrace Classrooms of Universities in Severe Cold Regions: A Case Study of Shenyang, China. , 13(3) : 603.
Heirani Pour M.,Fayaz R.,Mahdavinia M. .2021 .. Optimization of Window Dimensions Regarding Light and Heat Parameters in Residential Buildings of Cold Climate; Case Study: Ilam City, Armanshahr Architecture & Urban Development, 14(35) : 91-101.
Mousavi S. M.,Khan T. H.,Wah L. Y. .2018 .Impact of furniture layout on indoor daylighting performance in existing residential buildings in Malaysia. Journal of Daylighting, 5(1) : 1-63.
Khademagha P. .2021 .Light directionality in design of healthy offices. Technische Universiteit Eindhoven: Eindhoven, : .
Stothard E. R. .2017 .Circadian Entrainment to the Natural Light-Dark Cycle across Seasons and the Weekend. Current Biology, 27(4) : 508-513.
Sithravel R.,Ibrahim R.,Lye M. S.,Perimal E. K.,Ibrahim N.,Dahlan N. D. .2018 .Morning boost on individuals' psychophysiological wellbeing indicators with supportive, dynamic lighting in windowless open-plan workplace in Malaysia. PLOS ONE, 13(11) : 1-28.
K. C. H. J. Smolders Y. A.,W. de Kort and S. M. van den Berg .2013 .Daytime light exposure and feelings of vitality: Results of a field study during regular weekdays. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 36 : 270-279.
M. A. M. Yusoff J.,Ahmad A. N.,Mansor R.,Johari K.,Othman N. C.,Hassan N. C. .2016 .Evaluation of School Based Assessment Teacher Training Programme. , 07(04) : 627-638.
Jalilzadehazhari E.,Johansson P.,Johansson J.,Mahapatra K. .2019 .Developing a decision-making framework for resolving conflicts when selecting windows and blinds. Architectural Engineering and Design Management, 15(5) : 357-381.
Jalilzadehazhari E.,Johansson J.,Johansson P. .2019 .Application of multi-objective optimization for resolving conflicts when selecting windows. in: The 9th International Conference on Sustainable Development in the Building and Environment, 28 : .
. .. [131] SOLEMMA ClimateStudio v1.9.8389, : .
Gkaintatzi-Masouti M.,Pierson C.,J. Van Duijnhoven C.,Andersen M.,Aarts M. .2022 .A simulation tool for building and lighting design considering ipRGC-influenced light responses. E3S Web of Conferences, 362 : 01001.
Andersen M.,Mardaljevic J.,Lockley S. W. .2012 .A framework for predicting the non-visual effects of daylight - Part I: photobiology- based model. Lighting Research & Technology, 44(1) : 37-53.
Inanici M.,Brennan M.,Clark E.,of IBPSA .2015 .Computing Circadian Light. in: Proceedings of Building Simulation, : 1245-1252.
CIE ,Standard General Sky,-iso- Sky .2016 .. , : 1210088.
Perez R.,Ineichen P.,Seals R.,Michalsky J.,Stewart R. .1990 .Modeling daylight availability and irradiance components from direct and global irradiance. Solar Energy, 44(5) : 271-289.
Maskarenj M.,Deroisy B.,Altomonte S. .2022 .A new tool and workflow for the simulation of the non-image forming effects of light. Energy and Buildings, 262 : .
Color Science Laboratory Munsell .2002 .. , : .
Wyszecki G. n.,Stiles W. S. .2000 .Color science : concepts and methods, quantitative data and formulae. , : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

75

Views