The optimization of oil recovery from aging reservoirs involves the strategic application of artificial lift systems under specific well conditions. In this study, an exhaustive assessment of three significant artificial lift methods, Electric Submersible Pumps (ESP), Jet Pumps, and Sucker Rod Pumps (SRP) was conducted using the PROSPER simulation software. Each method was studied under different reservoir pressures, water cuts, and operating parameters to assess its performance in improving oil recovery. The findings show that ESPs provide the highest production rates and economic payback in high-pressure conditions, while SRPs are more feasible in low-pressure and shallow-well conditions. Although Jet Pumps are relatively less efficient, they offer operational flexibility, particularly in wells with complicated geometries or high solid content. This study also strongly underscores the need for the customization of artificial lift systems to particular reservoir conditions and production objectives.