No Detail Found!

A combined method for an exhaustive investigation of the anidolic ceiling effect on improving indoor office daylight quality: an approach based on hdr photography and subjective evaluations

Author(s)
Safa Daich Department of architecture, LaCoMoFa Laboratory, Biskra University,,Algeria
Mohamed Yacine Saadi Department of architecture, LaCoMoFa Laboratory, Biskra University,,Algeria
Barbara EA Piga Departement of Architecture and Urban Studies, Laboratorio di Simulazione Urbana Fausto Curti,Politecnico di Milano,Italy
Ahmed Motie Daiche Department of architecture, Bejaia University,,Algeria
Abstract
Lighting quality in office environments is a broad concept that must be taken into account in the design stage to deliver comfortable spaces to reduce workers' stress. Indeed, daylight should be sufficient to perform visual tasks while avoiding excessive brightness, high contrast, or intense sunlight reflections that can cause discomfort glare. This research aims to test the Anidolic Integrated Ceiling (AIC) performance in creating a visually comfortable space by reducing the probability of glare. A combined method was adopted for investigating the influence of the building orientation and the workers' view directions in the different moments of the day in the winter season. Data collection was performed in an experimental environment, i.e., a physical scale model of 1:4 under real sky conditions. Three variables were: (i) the viewer's positions (parallel and face to the window), (ii) the façade orientation, (iii) the time of the day (morning and afternoon). To investigate the correlation between the simulated environment and the subjective comfort, we collected the following data in parallel: illuminance level, Daylight Glare Probability Index (DGIP), Luminance Contrast Ratios (LCR) for assessing the daylighting environments, and people reactions to the lighting setting to evaluate the perceived discomfort glare. The findings indicate that the Anidolic system's performance differs according to the occupant's orientation and her\his visual direction. The performance of the north façade of the case study application in Biskra, Algeria, was the best one. Indeed, the AIC system allows a harmonious luminance distribution without creating discomfort glare. Glare assessment shows that glare is perceived imperceptible in the lateral view (less than 0.30) and varies between imperceptible and perceptible in the parallel view (LCR values between 1:1 and 1:29). The questionnaire results show that the subjects were more satisfied with the luminous atmosphere of the lateral view than the parallel view where people more likely perceived discomfort. The statistical analysis shows that participants' perceptions of contrast and sensitivity to glare have a strong relationship with DGIP and LCR (0.000) and no correlation with illuminance and LCR.
Publication Details
Page(s) 149-164
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 8, Issue: 2, Year: 2021

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Visual Comfort, Subjective evaluations, Luminance contrast ratios, HDR photography
References
Choi J. H.,Beltran L.O.,Kim H.S. .2012 .Impacts of indoor daylight environments on patient average length of stay (ALOS) in a healthcare facility. Building and Environment, 50 : 65-75.
M.B.C. ,Veitch J.A.,Newsham G.R. .2010 .office characteristics predict physical and psychological discomfort. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 4 : 533-541.
Yacine. S.M.,Noureddine Z.,Piga. B.E.A.,E. Morello. B.E.A.,Safa D. .2017 .Towards a new model of light quality assessment based on occupant satisfaction and lighting glare indices. Energy Procedia, 122 : 805-810.
Kontadakis. A.,A. Tsangrassoulis. A.,Doulos L.,Zerefos S. .2018 .A Review of Light Shelf Designs for Daylit Environments. Sustainability, 10 : 1-24.
Littlefair P. J. .1995 .Light shelves: computer assessment of daylighting performance. International Journal of Lighting Research and Technology, 27(2) : 79-91.
Hee W.J.,Alghoul. M.A.,Bakhtyar B.,Elayeb O.K.,Shameri M.A.,Alrubaih M.S.,Sopian K. .2015 .The role of window glazing on daylighting and energy saving in buildings. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 42 : 323-343.
Konis K. .2013 .Evaluating daylighting effectiveness and occupant visual comfort in a side-lit open-plan office. Building and Environment, 59 : 662-677.
Hamedani. Z.,Hine T.,Skates H.,G. Isoardi. H.,Fernando R. .2020 .Lighting for work: A study of the relationships among discomfort glare, physiological responses and visual performance. Building and Environment, 167 : 106478.
Allan. A.C.,Garcia-Hansen. V.,Isoardi. G.,Smith, S.S. .2019 .Subjective assessments of lighting quality: A measurement review. Leukos, 15 : 115-126.
Boyce P.R. .2014 .Human factors in lighting. Boca Raton (FL), : .
Osterhaus W. .2009 .Design guidelines for glare-free daylit work environments. In 11th European Conference on Lighting-Lux Europe, : .
Daich S.,Saadi. M.Y.,Zemmouri N.,E. Morello. N.,Piga. B.E.A.,Daiche A.M. .2016 .Evaluation quantitative et qualitative du système anidolique sous un climat chaud et aride. Proceedings of 3rd International Congress on Ambiances, : 219-226.
Daich S. . .Modélisation du système anidolique pour un environnement lumineux intérieur intégré, Doctoral dissertation. , : .
Obradovic B.,Biljana B.S. .2019 .Daylight Transport Systems for Buildings at High Latitudes. Journal of Daylighting, 6(2) : 60-79.
Roshan M.,Barau A. S. .2016 .Assessing Anidolic Daylighting System for efficient daylight in open plan office in the tropics. Journal of Building Engineering, 8 : 58-69.
Binarti F.,Satwiko P. .2018 .Assessing the energy saving potential of anidolic system in the tropics. Energy Efficiency, 11 : 955-974.
Hansen V. Garcia,I. Edmonds. V. Garcia,Hyde R. .2001 .The use of light pipes for deep plan office buildings: a case study of Ken Yeang's bioclimatic skyscraper proposal for KLCC, Malaysia. ANZAsCA, : .
Abdel-Aziz. D.,Al-Qudah. E. A.,H. Y. Yasien. E. A.,Hamad R. .2019 .Improving the daylighting of deep plan buildings by means of light piping technique: the case of architectural studios in the department of architecture. International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology, 10(4) : 599-608.
Obradovic B.,Matusiak B. S. .2020 .Daylight autonomy improvement in buildings at high latitudes using horizontal light pipes and light-deflecting panels. Solar Energy, 208 : 493-514.
Chirarattananon S.,S. Chedsiri. S.,Renshen L. .2000 .Daylighting through light pipes in the tropics. Solar Energy, 69(4) : 331-341.
Beltrán L. O. .2020 .Assessing the Lighting Performance of an Innovative Core Sun lighting System. In Smart and Sustainable Cities and Buildings, : 633-643.
Görgülü S.,Ekrenb N. .2013 .Energy saving in lighting system with fuzzy logic controller which uses light-pipe and dimmable ballast. Energy and Buildings, 61 : 172-176.
I. Wong. ,Yang H. X. .2012 .Introducing natural lighting into the enclosed lift lobbies of High rise buildings by remote source lighting system. Applied Energy, 90 : 225-232.
D. M. Kennedy. F. .2015 .O'Rourke, Experimental analysis of a scaled, multiaperture, light-pipe, daylighting system. Solar Energy122, : 181-190.
Goerguelue S.,Ekren N. .2013 .Energy saving in lighting system with fuzzy logic controller which uses light-pipe and dimmable ballast. Energy and buildings 61, : 172-176.
Baglivo C.,Bonomolo M.,Congedo P. M. .2019 .Modeling of light pipes for the optimal disposition in buildings. Energies, 12(22) : 43-23.
Wittkopf S. K.,Energy S. K. .2007 .Daylight performance of anidolic ceiling under different sky conditions. , : 81151-61.
Scartezzini J.L. .2002 .Anidolic daylighting systems. Solar Energy, 73 : 123-135.
LONG B.,Tuaycharoen N. . .The Study of the Effects of Ceiling Characteristic and Transmission of Glazing of Anidolic Lighting on Daylighting in Office Building, Doctoral dissertation. , : .
Linhart F.,Scartezzini J.L. .2010 .Minimizing lighting power density in office rooms equipped with Anidolic Daylighting Systems. Solar Energy, 84 : 587-95.
C.E. Ochoa. ,Capeluto I. G. .2006 .Evaluating visual comfort and performance of three natural lighting systems for deep office buildings in highly luminous climates. Building and Environment, 41 : 1128-35.
Courret G. .1999 .Systèmes Anidoliques d'Éclairage Naturel, Doctoral dissertation. , : .
Mirkovich D.N. .1993 .Assessment of Beam Lighting Systems for Interior Core Illumination in Multi-Story Commercial Buildings. ASHRAE Transactions: Symposia, 99 : 1106-1116.
Tsikaloudaki. K.,Anagnostou S.,Nichoritis K. .2008 .Investigating the performance of anidolic vertical openings under real conditions in Greece, Passive and Low Energy Architecture (. , : .
E. Yuniarti. ,Soon I.K. .2006 .Prediction of energy savings with anidolic integrated ceiling across different daylight climates. Energy and Building, 38 : 1120-1129.
Baker N.,Fanchiotti A.,Steemers K. .1993 .Daylighting in Architecture: a European reference book, Commission of the European Communities, DG XII for Science, Research. , : .
Alwetaishi M. .2019 .Impact of glazing to wall ratio in various climatic regions: A case study. Journal of King, 31 : 6-18.
W.T. Welford. ,Winston R. .1989 .. , : .
Bodart M.,Cauwerts C. .2017 .Assessing daylight luminance values and daylight glare probability in scale models. Building and Environment, 113 : 210-219.
Ward G. .1994 .A contrast-based scale factor for luminance display. Graphics Gems 4, : 415-21.
Suk. J.Y.,Schiler M.,Kensek K. .2017 .Investigation of existing discomfort glare indices using human subject study data. Building and Environment, 113 : 121-130.
M.Y. Saadi . .Paramètres physiques Des ambiances lumineuses: Un modèle numérique pour l'évaluation des ambiances lumineuses, Doctoral dissertation. , : .
Pierson C.,Wienold M.,Bodart M. .2018 .Daylight discomfort glare evaluation with Evalglare: influence of parameters and methods on the accuracy of discomfort glare prediction. Buildings, 8 : 94.
Wienold J.,Christoffersen J. .2006 .Evaluation methods and development of a new glare prediction model for daylight environments with the use of CCD cameras, Energy and. , 38 : 743-757.
Jakubiec J. A.,Reinhart C. F. .2012 .-A concept for assessing discomfort glare throughout daylit spaces. Lighting Research & Technology, 44 : 149-170.
Chaloeytoy K.,Ichinose M.,Chien S. C. .2020 .Determination of the Simplified Daylight Glare Probability (DGPs) Criteria for Daylit Office Spaces in Thailand. Buildings, 10(10) : 180.
Bian Y.,Luo T. .2017 .Investigation of visual comfort metrics from subjective responses in China: A study in offices with daylight. Building and Environment, 123 : 661-671.
Magali B.,Arnaud D.,Nelly M. .2008 .Guide précis à l'aide de la construction des modèles réduits (pour utilisation et mesures sous ciel artificiel au. CSTB), : .
Yngvesson L.,E. Adolfsson, L. . .The impact of scale when using models of daylight analysis. Dissertation, : .
Motamed. A.,L. Deschamps. A.,Scartezzini J. L. .2017 .On-site monitoring and subjective comfort assessment of a sun shadings and electric lighting controller based on novel High Dynamic Range vision sensors. Energy and Buildings, 149 : 58-72.
Arsenault H.,Hebert M.,Dubois M.C. .2012 .Effects of glazing colour type on perception of daylight quality, arousal, and switch-on patterns of electric light in office rooms. Building and Environment, 56 : 223231.
KS. Konis . .Evaluating Daylighting Performance in the San Francisco Federal Building from the Perspective of Building Occupants, Doctoral dissertation. , : .
Akashi Y.,Boyce P.R. .2006 .A field study of illuminance reduction. Energy and buildings 38(6), : 588-599.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

14

Views