Two different control algorithms, sliding mode and model predictive control are employed to analyse the performance of a linear vehicle model equipped with an ACC (Adaptive Cruise Control) system. Both controllers are analysed under critical transitional maneuvers to investigate their suitability for the ACC system. The simulation results, for the same scenario, from both controllers approach have been compared. The results show that the model predictive controller is more robust than the sliding model controller. The results show that the sliding mode control algorithm is not suitable for the proposed vehicle model. The shortcomings of the sliding model controller have been highlighted and the comparisons are made with the previous studies. The proposed approach can be useful for the selection of the appropriate controller for the given application.