The contemporary research compares the effect of two API (American Petroleum Institute) grade lubricants namely CH-4 and CG-4 (commercial names of high speed four-stroke-cycle diesel engines oils) on the performance of an internal combustion engine. Elemental (Cu, Fe, Cr, Pb, Al and Si) wear rate, oxidation products (soot, oxidation, sulfation and nitration) and physical tests were performed on both used lube oils (CH- 4 and CG-4) for different working hours ranging from 200 hours to 800 hours. Performance of CH-4 lube oil shows better performance than CG-4 as its application resulted in less wear and oxidation products formation. Some basic lubricating oil analyses such as flash point, kinematic viscosity and total base number (TBN) were also performed for both lubricants. The values of TBN decreased with respect to working hours and found higher for CH-4 than CG-4. Thus, CH-4 was concluded as better lube oil than CG-4 and suitable for Internal Combustion Engines.