Pakistan's intersecting energy insecurity, climate vulnerability, and development imperatives demand comprehensive renewable energy transitions. This research systematically evaluates three biofuel pathways biodiesel, bioethanol, and biogas across technological effectiveness, economic viability, environmental sustainability, and implementation feasibility within Pakistan's specific context. Comparative analysis demonstrates that biogas technology emerges as the immediate priority for rural energy access expansion, offering superior costeffectiveness (35-40% internal rate of return for household systems), exceptional climate mitigation potential (85-95% greenhouse gas reductions), and proven deployment success through 5,000+ installed systems across Pakistan. Molassesbased bioethanol represents the optimal medium-term opportunity, strategically leveraging existing industrial infrastructure to achieve 4-6 year capital cost recovery and 18-25% annual returns at industrial scale. Waste oil biodiesel provides an emerging opportunity contingent on integrated municipal waste management systems, while Jatropha-based biodiesel requires sustained longterm investment in agronomic research and market linkage development. Life cycle assessment findings reveal biogas systems achieve net negative emissions (-0.5 to -0.8 kg CO2 emission per kilowatt-hour) through avoided methane emissions from manure decomposition, substantially exceeding climate mitigation performance of fossil fuel alternatives. Water footprint analysis demonstrates biogas and waste oil biodiesel maintain sustainability thresholds (200-400 L/L and 100-200 L/L respectively), while irrigated bioethanol production exceeds water sustainability constraints in Pakistan's water-scarce context. Feedstock availability assessments indicate 120,000-315,000 million liters annual biofuel production potential from livestock manure alone, equivalent to 8-10% of Pakistan's total energy consumption. Strategic policy implementation through coordinated mechanisms spanning fiscal support, blending mandates, sustainability governance, and capacity development can mobilize $2-4 billion cumulative investment, generating 50,000-200,000 employment opportunities while advancing climate commitments and sustainable development objectives.