No Detail Found!

Enhancing Patent Dispute Resolution in Indonesia: The Case for Mandatory Mediation Under Perma No. 1/2016 and Law No. 65/2024

Author(s)
Raymond R. Tjandrawinata Dexa Group and Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia,Jakarta,Indonesia
Henry Soelistyo Budi Faculty of Law, Pelita Harapan University,Tangerang,Indonesia
Ina Heliany Faculty of Law, IBLAM School of Law,Jakarta,Indonesia
Abstract
Patent dispute resolution in Indonesia plays a critical role in safeguarding intellectual property rights and fostering innovation. Despite the establishment of Law Number 13 of 2016 concerning Patents, legal uncertainties remain, particularly regarding the absence of mandatory mediation in civil patent disputes. This article explores the principle of legal certainty in the Indonesian patent litigation framework and proposes the institutionalization of mandatory mediation as a preliminary step to litigation. Through a normative juridical and qualitative approach, this paper highlights how the current voluntary mediation process is underutilized, contributing to court congestion and prolonged disputes. Drawing from Richard Posner's Economic Analysis of Law, Legal Realism, and Law and Development theories, this paper advocates for amending the Patent Law to mandate mediation, enhancing legal certainty, expediting dispute resolution, and fostering a more innovation-friendly environment. Comparative analysis of best practices in jurisdictions such as the U.S., EU, Japan, and Singapore underscores the potential benefits of mandatory mediation for Indonesia's economic growth and technological advancement.
Publication Details
Page(s) 5860-5873
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Patent Dispute Resolution Mandatory Mediation Intellectual Property Law Patent Law
References
Adwani A.,Peerzada S.,Sawant N. .2024 .ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution) in intellectual property disputes: Trends and challenges. Tuijin Jishu/Journal of Propulsion Technology, 45(2) : 4847-4856.
Alexander N.,Woo M.,Cadiet L.,Menétrey S. .2024 .Comparative procedural law and justice (Part XV, Chapter 4). , : .
Alexander N.,Chong S. .2023 .Mediation and appropriate dispute resolution. Singapore Academy of Law Journal, 36(24) : 23-45.
Aprilia N.,Syahputra A. F.,Hunyang M. C.,Rahmasari E.,Ramayanti F.,Kuspraningrum E. .2024 .Efektivitas hukum kekayaan intelektual Indonesia dalam menjamin penyelesaian sengketa hak paten. Notary Law Journal (NoLaJ), 3(2) : 126-138.
Baideng K. S.,Kalalo M. E.,Soputan M. .2024 .Gugatan ganti rugi oleh penerima lisensi di pengadilan niaga terhadap yang menggunakan paten tanpa hak. Lex Privatum, 14(1) : 1-14.
Barton T. D.,Cooper J. M. .2012 .Symposium introduction: Advancing intellectual property goals through prevention and alternative dispute resolution. California Western International Law Journal, 43(1) : 5-34.
Bessen J.,Meurer M. J. .2008 .Patent failure: How judges, bureaucrats, and lawyers put innovators at risk. , : .
Cappelli R.,Corsino M.,Laursen K.,Torrisi S. .2023 .Technological competition and patent strategy: Protecting innovation, preempting rivals and defending the freedom to operate. , 52(6) : 104785.
Chien C. V. .2009 .Of trolls, Davids, Goliaths, and kings: Narratives and evidence in the litigation of high-tech patents. North Carolina Law Review, 87(6) : 1571-1615.
Chien C. V. .2012 .Startups and patent trolls. Stanford Technology Law Review. Santa Clara Univ. Legal Studies Research, : 09-12.
Commission European .2023 .Strengthening the EU's patent system: The Unified Patent Court as a driver for innovation. , : 3004.
Gans J. S.,Hsu D. H.,Stern S. .2007 .The impact of uncertainty intellectual property rights on the market for ideas: Evidence from patent grant delays. SSRN, : .
Gayo S. .2024 .Mandatory mediation under Indonesia legal system. International Journal of Research and Review, 11(11) : 30-45.
Gómez K. F.,K. F. Gómez K. F.,Guadamuz K. F. .2019 .The role of mediation in international commercial disputes: Reflections on some technological, ethical and educational challenges. , : 152-172.
.2016 .13 of 2016 concerning Patents. Government of Indonesia, : .
.2016 .Peraturan Mahkamah Agung No. 1 of 2016 concerning Mediation Procedures in Courts. Government of Indonesia, : .
.2024 .. UU No. 65 Tahun 2024 - Perubahan Ketiga atas Undang-Undang Nomor 13 Tahun 2016 tentang Paten, : .
Gurgula O.,Padamczyk M.,Shemtov N. .2022 .Specialised IP judiciary: What are the key elements to consider when establishing or reforming an effective IP court. , 71(3) : 206-212.
Hadrian E. .2019 .Optimizing the implementation of mediation to overcome civil case backlog in Indonesia. South East Asia Journal of Contemporary Business, Economics and Law, 20(5) : 151-157.
Hapsari E. H.,Permatasari V. S. P.,Karyono H. .2016 .Hukum sebagai pelindung UMKM dan pertumbuhan UMKM: Bagaimana seharusnya? Paper presented at the 3rd East Java Economic Forum. , : .
Hariadi H.,Sitorus W.,Latif B. .2023 .Mediation empowerment in resolution of civil claims in state court. Legal Brief, 12(1) : 47-56.
Hall B. H.,Harhoff D. .2012 .Recent research on the economics of patents. Annual Review of Economics, 4(1) : 541-565.
Hadrian E. .2019 .Optimizing the implementation of mediation to overcome civil case backlog in Indonesia. South East Asia Journal of Contemporary Business, Economics and Law, 20(5) : 151-157.
Medina A. F. .2024 .Indonesia's overhauled patent law: A guide. ASEAN Briefing., : .
Menkel-Meadow C. J. .2014 .Contemporary issues in international arbitration and mediation: The Fordham papers. , : .
Ministry .2022 .New legislation to enhance intellectual property dispute resolution. , : .
Nakamura ,Partners. .2023 .Patent litigation country comparative guide. , : .
Nolan-Haley J. .2018 .Mediation, self-represented parties, and access to justice: Getting there from here. Fordham Law Review, 87(1) : .
Nurahmasari R.,Amirulloh M.,Afriana A. .2021 .Mediasi sebagai kewajiban penyelesaian sengketa perdata pelanggaran paten di Indonesia demi kepastian dan kemanfaatan hukum. ACTA DIURNAL: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum Kenotariatan, 5(1) : 123-138.
Nuryakin C.,Satyagraha I. P. B.,Nursahla R. S. A. .2008 .-patents-and-innovation_fa65ded2/3d4b7785-en. OECD Publishing, 079 : .
Peng M. W.,Wang D. Y. L.,Jiang Y. .2008 .An institution-based view of international business strategy: A focus on emerging economies. Journal of International Business Studies, 39 : 920-936.
Pooley J. H. A.,Huang V. T. .2011 .Multi-national patent litigation: Management of discovery and settlement issues and the role of the judiciary. Fordham Intellectual Property, Media & Entertainment Law Journal, 22(1) : 45-70.
Posner R. A. .2014 .Economic Analysis of Law (9th ed. , : .
Purwaningsih E. .2020 .Patent law and its enforcement in Indonesia, Japan, and the USA. Jurnal Media Hukum, 27(1) : 1-15.
Rouse. .2021 .-ip-litigation-enforcement-guide.. , : .
Roy S. K. .2018 .The role of the Intellectual Property Rights Act in protecting innovation and creativity. International Research Journal of Education and Technology, 1(1) : 27-42.
Sanyal P. .2004 .Intellectual property rights protection and location of R&D by multinational enterprises. Journal of Intellectual Capital, 5(3) : 464-475.
Sidik J.,Rozali A.,Sulistianingsih D.,Masalah-Masalah Hukum .2023 .The implementation of intellectual property dispute resolution through mediation & arbitration. , 52(3) : 237-248.
Sinaga V. S. .2021 .Journal of the Faculty of Law, Universitas Gadjah Mada. , : .
Siregar A. N.,Saraswati D. A. .2021 .Invoking compulsory licensing amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Law and Human Rights, : 44-50.
Stipanowich T. J. .2004 .ADR and the "vanishing trial": The growth and impact of "alternative dispute resolution". Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, 1(3) : 843-912.
Strong S. I. .2016 .Realizing rationality: An empirical assessment of international commercial mediation. , 73(4) : 1973-2084.
Tan J. A.,- J. A. .2022 .-wipo-alternative-dispute-resolution-options. WIPO Arbitration, : .
Taduri J. N. A. .2021 .The legal certainty and protection of foreign investment against investment practices in Indonesia. Lex Scientia Law Review, 5(1) : 119-138.
Tietz J. I. .2019 .The Unified Patent Court and patent trolls in Europe. Michigan Technology Law Review, 25(2) : 303-336.
Tsakalerou M. .2018 .Intellectual property as a key driver of business performance: The case of Singapore and its implications for innovation in a knowledge-based economy. International Journal of Learning and Intellectual Capital, 15(1) : 83-97.
Tuerah S. .2017 .Ketentuan pidana dan penyelesaian sengketa hak paten menurut Undang-Undang Nomor 13 Tahun 2016 tentang Paten. Lex Et Societatis, 5(10) : 18496.
Van Rhee C. H. .2021 .Mandatory mediation before litigation in civil and commercial matters: A European perspective. , 4(12) : 7-24.
Vidal K.,Kalay L. G.,Menell P. S.,Powers M.,Venkat S. .2019 .Patent mediation guide. , : .
Vandermeulen B. .2020 .IP Enforcement Strategies for SMEs. les Nouvelles - Journal of the Licensing Executives Society, 55(2) : 6-12.
Wissler R.,Hinshaw A. .2023 .What the early stages of mediation look like today. ABA Dispute Resolution Magazine, 29(1) : 7.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

72

Views