No Detail Found!

Drawing the Ideal Teacher: An Art-based Exploration of Pre-Service English Teachers' Visions

Author(s)
Özkan Kırmızı Department of English Language and Literature, Faculty of Letters, Karabük University,Merkez, 78050, Karabük,Türkiye
Derya Şahhüseyinoğlu Children's Research Center,Via Tower Trade Center, No: 7, Yenimahalle, 06560 Ankara,Türkiye
Arda Arikan Department of English Language and Literature, Faculty of Letters, Akdeniz University, Konyaaalti, 07058, Antalya, Türkiye
Mehmet Galip Zorba Department of English Language and Literature, Faculty of Letters, Akdeniz University, Konyaaalti, 07058, Antalya, Türkiye
Abstract
In educational sciences, traditional qualitative research methods often focus on utterances or behaviors to explore more insights into the phenomena. Despite the effectiveness of such methods, they also tend to fail to unpack, uncovering unuttered meanings that remain incommunicable. Art-based research is heavily anchored in the notion that art inspires people, evokes them for better expression, and awakens visions, using diverse forms of artistic expression to explore unuttered meanings. With this in mind, this study’s actual raison d’e^tre was to find alternative ways of acquiring future teachers’ notions of the ideal teacher, assuming that non-traditional research methods could provide details that studies following traditional methods had not. Specifically, we sought answers to two research questions: (1) How might a close and critical analysis of the work of pre-service teachers inform us about the ideal teacher they want to be in the future? (2) How can an exploratory ABR study such as ours help us develop and enhance our understanding of the theories and practices of arts-based research? This study was conducted with twelve pre-service English teachers at a state university in Tu¨rkiye. Data were collected through participants’ drawings and a focus group interview. The visual data were analyzed through criteria for drawing, whereas thematic analysis was employed for verbal data. The analysis of the drawings highlighted the teacher as an ABR object, professional and cultural identity, engaging teaching styles, positive classroom atmosphere, and holistic education as the main aspects of the ideal teacher. These themes are critical as some align with the previous research on the ideal English teacher, whereas others yielded insights that might otherwise remain unexplored in traditional data collection methods. Therefore, we proposed that arts-based research (ABR) methods provide a robust and innovative framework for eliciting nuanced and unarticulated conceptions of the ideal teacher among pre-service teachers, offering deeper insights into professional and cultural identities, pedagogical approaches and educational philosophies that may remain inaccessible through traditional qualitative methodologies.
Publication Details
Page(s) 3908-3926
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Art-Based Research Drawings Ideal Teacher Pre-Service Teachers Teaching English
References
Ahn .2021 .Visualizing the interplay of fear and desire in English learner's imagined identities and communities. System, 10 : .
Ahn S-Y.,West G. B. .2018 .Young learners' portrayals of 'good English teacher' identities in South Korea. -1064, 10 : 225-248.
Allegranti B. .2011 .Ethics and body politics: Interdisciplinary possibilities for embodied psychotherapeutic practice and research. British J. Guid. and Couns, 10 : 487-500.
Barnes B.,Lock G. .2013 .Student perceptions of effective language teachers: A quantitative investigation from a Korean university. Australian J. Teach. Edu, 10 : 2-36.
Bell T. R. .2005 .Behaviors and attitudes of effective foreign language teachers: results of a questionnaire study. For. Lang. Annals, 38 : 259-270.
Birt L.,Scott S.,Cavers S.,Campbell C.,Walter F. .2016 .Member checking: a tool to enhance trustworthiness or merely a nod to validation? Qual. Health Res, 10 : 1802-1811.
Bogale Y. N.,Wale B. D. .2024 .The matrix of ELT (English language teaching): Students' perceptions about qualities of an effective teacher. Cogent Edu, 10 : .
Braun V.,Clarke V. .2019 .Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qual. Res. Sport, Exer. & Health, 10 : 589-597.
Briell J.,Elen J.,Depaepe F.,Clarebout G. .2017 .The exploration of drawings as a tool to gain entry to students' epistemological beliefs. Elec. J. Res. in Edu. Psychol, 10 : 1396-88.
Brown A. .2009 .Students' and teachers' perceptions of effective foreign language teaching: a comparison of ideals. The Modern Language J, 00827 : 4781-60.
Çelik S.,Arikan A.,Caner M. .2013 .In the eyes of Turkish EFL learners: what makes an effective foreign language teacher? Porta Linguarum. , 10 : 287-297.
Chilton G.,Leavy P.,Leavy P. .2020 .“Arts-based research: merging social research and the creative arts” in The Oxford handbook of qualitative research. , : 601-632.
Cohen L.,Manion L.,Morrison K. .2018 .Research methods in education. , : .
De Ruyter D.,Conroy J. .2002 .The formation of identity: the importance of ideals. Oxford Rev. of Edu, 10 : 509-522.
Deleuze G.,Guattari F. .1987 .A thousand plateaus: Capitalism and schizophrenia. , : .
Dinham J.,Chalk B.,Beltman S.,Glass C.,Nguyen B. .2016 .Pathways to resilience: how drawings reveal pre-service teachers' core narratives underpinning their future teacher-selves. AsiaPacific J. Teacher Edu, 10 : 126-144.
Donati P. .2010 .Relational sociology: A new paradigm for the social sciences. Oxon: Routledge., : .
Eisner E. .2002 .The arts and the creation of mind. , : .
Fugard A.,Potts H. W. W.,Delamont S.,Cernat A.,Sakshaug J. W.,Williams R. A. .2019 .“Thematic analysis” in Sage research methods foundations. doi: 10.4135/9781526421036858333, : .
Gerber N.,Myers-Coffman K.,Leavy K. .2017 .“Translation in arts-based research” in Handbook of artsbased research. , : 587-607.
Gerber N.,Bryl K.,Potvin N.,Blank C. A. .2018 .Arts-based research approaches to studying mechanisms of change in the creative arts therapies. Front. Psychol, 10 : .
Gerth H. H.,Wright C .2009 .From Max Weber: essays in sociology. , : .
Goopy S.,Kassan A. .2019 .Arts-based engagement ethnography: an approach for making research engaging and knowledge transferable when working with harder-to-reach communities. Int. J. Qual. Methods, 10 : 1-10.
Hişmanoğlu M. .2019 .A study on the qualities of effective EFL teachers from the perspectives of preparatory program Turkish EFL students. Int. J. Curri. and Inst, 11 : 101-124.
Holm G.,Leavy G. .2020 .“Photography as a research method” in The Oxford handbook of qualitative research. , : 569-600.
Irwin R. L. .2013 .. , 10 : 198-215.
Irwin R. L.,Beer R.,Springgay S.,Grauer K.,Xiong G.,Bickel B. .2006 .The rhizomatic relations of a/r/tography. , 10 : 70-88.
Kara H. .2015 .Creative research methods in the social sciences: A practical guide. , : .
Katz P.,McGinnis J. R.,Hestness E.,Riedinger K.,Marbach-Ad G.,Dai A.,Pease R. .2010 .Professional identity development of teacher candidates participating in an informal science education internship: a focus on drawings as evidence. Int. J. Science Edu, 10 : 1169-1197.
Khanolainen D.,Semenova E. .2020 .School bullying through graphic vignettes: developing a new arts-based method to study a sensitive topic. Int. J. Qual. Methods, 10 : 1-15.
Kress G. .2010 .Multimodality: A social semiotic approach to contemporary communication. , : .
Külekçi G. .2018 .Identifying the perceptions of prospective English language teachers on characteristics of effective teachers: Who is the ideal teacher? Novitas-. , 12 : 1-15.
Lapum J. L.,Leavy J. L. .2017 .“Installation: the voyage never ends” in Handbook of arts-based research. , : 377-395.
Lawler S. .2014 .. , : .
Leavy P.,P. P. .2015 .Method meets art: Arts-based research practice (2nd ed. Arts Res, 10 : 6-10.
Leavy P.,Leavy P. .2018 .“Introduction to arts-based research” in Handbook of arts-based research. , : 3-21.
Lyon D.,Carabelli G. .2016 .Researching young people's orientations to the future: the methodological challenges of using arts practice. Qual. Res, 10 : 430-445.
McDermott M. .2010 .Outlaw arts-based educational research. J. Curri. and Pedag, 10 : 6-14.
Miles M. B.,Huberman A. M. .1994 .Qualitative data analysis. Thousand Oaks, : .
Morris J.,L. J. .2021 .Rethinking arts-based research methods in education: enhanced participant engagement processes to increase research credibility and knowledge translation. Int. J. Res. & Method in Educ. 45, 10 : 1-14.
Morrison A. P. .2009 .On ideals and idealization. Self and Syst, 04352 : 6632-85.
Nathan S.,Hodgins M.,Wirth J.,Ramirez J.,Walker N. .2022 .The use of arts‐based methodologies and methods with young people with complex psychosocial needs: a systematic narrative review. Health Expect, 10 : 795-805.
Palmer B. R.,Gignac G.,Ekermans G.,Stough C.,Emmerling V. K.,Shanwal V. K.,M. K. Mandal V. K. .2008 .“A comprehensive framework for emotional intelligence” in Emotional intelligence: Theoretical and cultural perspectives. , : 17-38.
Panova E.,Danilova J.,Platonova E.,Otts E.,Yakushkina N.,Lobanova J. .2024 .Stylistic aspects of advertising posters in the Soviet Union. , 10 : 160-166.
Rezalou A. .2024 .Turkish EFL students' perceptions of effective EFL teachers. Int. J. Lang. Acad, 10 : 320-331.
Roger K. S.,Blomgren C.,Qual J. .2019 .Elicitation as a mind-set: why visual data matter? Int. , 10(1) : 9.
Rolling J. H. .2010 .A paradigm analysis of arts-based research and implications for education. Stud, 10 : 102-114.
Rose G. .2012 .Visual methodologies: An introduction to researching with visual materials (3rd ed. , : .
Scherer L. .2016 .Children's engagements with visual methods through qualitative research in the primary school as art that didn't work. Socio. Res. Online, 10 : 1-16.
Scotti V.,Chilton G.,Leavy G. .2018 .“Collage as arts-based research” in Handbook of arts-based research. , : 355-376.
Snowber C. .2012 .Dance as a way of knowing. New Direct. for Adult and Contin. , 10 : 53-60.
Stevens M.,Elen J. .2023 .Picturing' instruction: an exploration of higher education students' knowledge of instruction, Stud. , 49 : 206-220.
Tarajová R.,Metruki R. .2020 .Characteristics of an effective EFL teacher: perspectives of Slovak EFL students and teachers. European J. Edu Stud, 10 : 3419-330.
Thomas S.,Nielsen A. L.,Cole J. G. .2001 .Knowles (Northumberland. , : 273-282.
Tian M. .2023 .Arts-based research methods for educational researchers. , : .
Verlie B. .2018 .From action to intra-action? agency, identity and 'goals' in a relational approach to climate change education. Envir. Edu. Res, 10 : 1266-1280.
Visse M.,Hansen F.,Leget C. .2019 .The unsayable in arts-based research: on the praxis of life itself. Int. J. Qual. Methods, 10 : 1-13.
Vuichard A.,Botella M.,Puozzo & Capron,I. & Capron .2023 .Creative process and multivariate factors through a creative course keep calm and be creative. J. Intel, 10 : .
Weber S.,C. S.,Goodson I. F.,Hargreaves A .2003 .and. eds., : 109-126.
Wendy S.,Verburgh A.,Elen J. .2014 .general and contextualised research conceptions. , 10 : 79-94.
Williams M.,Burden R. L. .2007 .Psychology for language teachers. , : .
Wong B.,Chiu B.,Y-L. T. B. .2018 .University lecturers' construction of the 'ideal' undergraduate student. J. Further and Higher Edu, 10 : 54-68.
Yalvaç B.,Soylu F.,Arikan A. .2011 .Bedenlenmiş biliş ve eğitim [Embodied cognition and education]. ETHOS: Dialog. in Philo. and Soc. Sci. 4, : 1-20.
Zamana F. .2022 .The future of education as a creative ecosystem: A sociocultural framework for the development of creativity. J. Intel, 10 : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

54

Views