No Detail Found!

Substantive Justice in Regional Election Dispute Resolution: Analyzing the Constitutional Court's Approach and Challenges in Indonesia

Author(s)
Misbahuddin Gasma Fakultas Hukum Universitas Hasanuddin, Indonesia
Abdul Hamid Fakultas Hukum Universitas Hasanuddin, Indonesia
Irwansyah Fakultas Hukum Universitas Hasanuddin, Indonesia
Ali Rahman Fakultas Hukum Universitas Sawerigading, Indonesia
Abstract
In the 2020 regional election period, the Constitutional Court tried to provide as much space as possible for justice seekers to file their cases. On this occasion, the Constitutional Court developed the concept of implementing substantive justice in its resolution. Purpose This research is intended to find an ideal election dispute resolution model. The method used in this research, which uses a normative approach, tries to trace and find out what is being debated in the concept applied by the Constitutional Court, including the researcher's criticism of its implementation. The study results indicate that applying substantial justice in resolving regional head elections disputes at the Constitutional Court is a solution to various things that hinder justice seekers from getting justice in the chaos of implementing regional head elections throughout Indonesia. However, it is necessary to review the initial examination mechanism for cases exceeding the percentage provisions stated in Article 158 of Law No. 10 of 2016.
Publication Details
Page(s) 3880-3888
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Substantive Justice Substantive Justice Regional Election Dispute Constitutional Court’s
References
Abdulkadir M. .2004 .. Law and Legal Research. PT. Citra Aditya Bakti . Bandung., : .
Asshiddiqie J. .2015 .The constitution of the state: The practice of dignified and democratic statehood. , : .
Black H. C. .1991 .Black's law dictionary, abridged sixth edition. , : .
Gaffar JM,Budiarti RT .2012 .Constitutional democracy: The practice of Indonesian state administration after the amendment of the 1945 Constitution. , : .
Muladi. .2002 .Human Rights, Politics and the Criminal Justice System. , : .
Shaban R.,Sage Publications .1998 .Robert K. Yin. Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 5 : 13.
Widodo H. .2018 .Procedural Law of regional election disputes: dynamics at the Constitutional Court. , : .
Ali MM,W. MM,RTJ MM,Asih T.,PG T. .2012 .Constitutional Interpretation of Systematic, Structured and Massive Regional Election Violations. Constitutional Journal, 9(1) : 189-230.
ABI AR .2019 .Principles of Establishing Legislation in Drafting Regional Regulations. Restorative Justice Journal, 3(1) : 1-13.
Faqi AF,Amaliyah M.,Iskandar A.,Munandar I. .2023 .Perception of students as new voters towards the normalization of money politics in general elections. Integritas: Journal of Anti-Corruption, 9(1) : 17-30.
Haryono H. .2012 .Law Enforcement Based on Substantive Justice Values (Study of Constitutional Court Decision No. 46/PUU-VII/2012 Dated February. Progressive Law Journal, 7(1) : 20-39.
Inggit AB,Ilyas A.,A. A. .2014 .The Nature of DPRP Regulations on the Rules of Procedure of the Makassar City DPRD. , : .
Librayanto R.,Riza M.,Ashri M.,Abdullah K. .2019 .Arrangement of the Authority of the Constitutional Court in Strengthening the Independence of the Judicial Power. Amanna Gappa, : 43-66.
Malang FH .2009 .. Constitutional Journal, 2(1) : 115164.
Sari SS,Ilmar A.,Djafar EM,Faiz PM .2023 .Disregarding the Constitutional Court Decision Concerning the Prohibition of Concurrent Deputy Minister Positions: Disregarding the Constitutional Court Decision Concerning the Prohibition of Concurrent Deputy Minister Positions. Constitutional Journal, 20(4) : 604-621.
Soedharmanto S.,Azisa MS,N. MS .2022 .Synchronization of Constitutional Court Decisions on the Application of the Retroactive Principle. Amanna Gappa, : 75-87.
Sumadi AF .2011 .Constitutional Court Procedural Law in Theory and Practice. Constitutional Journal, 8(6) : 849-880.
Aswanto .2023 .Technical Procedure of the Constitutional Court, Important for Advocates. Berita&id=16514 access data September 15, 21 : 35.
.2024 .-konsisten-pengacara-pemilukada-dipersoalkanlt58eb74232f21b/. Access Data, March, 12 : 20.
.2024 .?page=all What's that Justice Collaborator ? Access Data, April 3. , 14 : 37.
- ,- ,- .2024 .. 2017 . Access Data, March, 12 : 25.
. .. Berita&id=12813, : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

32

Views