No Detail Found!

Sensitivity Analysis and Optimization of Facade Design to Improve Daylight Performance of Tropical Classrooms with an Adjacent Building

Author(s)
Atthaillah Architecture Program, Faculty of Engineering,Universitas Malikussaleh, Jl. Cot Teungku Nie, Aceh Utara 24355,Indonesia
Rizki A. Mangkuto Built Environment Performance Engineering Research Group, Department of Engineering Physics, Faculty of Industrial Technology, Institut Teknologi Bandung,Jl. Ganesha 10, Labtek VI, Bandung 40132,Indonesia
Andik Bintoro Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering,Universitas Malikussaleh, Jl. Cot Teungku Nie, Aceh Utara 24355,Indonesia
Abstract
This study examines the daylighting performance of a classroom with bilateral opening typology and an adjacent building on one side. The openings are located on the east and west sides of the classroom, with the adjacent building situated on the west side. The case selection is based on the observation that many Indonesian urban classrooms are often blocked from daylight by the adjacent building. Accordingly, this study examines the optimal design for annual visual comfort and daylighting performance criteria for such cases, which are prevalent in the tropical regions of Indonesia. To achieve this, computational simulation was conducted. The model was constructed using Ladybug Tools, while the annual visual comfort and daylight simulation was performed simultaneously using Radiance under Grasshopper. Sensitivity analysis was conducted to identify the most significant façade design variables, including external horizontal shading depth, shading elevation, window-to-wall ratio (WWR), and distance to the adjacent building on a bilateral opening typology classroom. The most optimal design was obtained from multilinear regression prediction model based on 5,731 simulation samples. The three most influential design variables on the annual visual comfort and direct sunlight are the horizontal shading depth, shading elevation, and WWR on the east facade. The optimal design solution for the horizontal shading depth, shading elevation, and window-to-wall ratio (WWR) on the east and west façades have similar values of 2.6 m, 2.7 m, and 10%, respectively. The distance to adjacent buildings is recommended to be maintained at 0.5 m from the edge of the external shading on the west side.
Publication Details
Page(s) 235-251
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Optimization, Sensitivity Analysis, Daylighting, Facade design
References
Berardi U. .2017 .A cross-country comparison of the building energy consumptions and their trends. Resource Conservation, and Recycling, 123 : 230-241.
K. Anderson .2014 .. , : .
G. D. Ander .2016 .. Whole Building Design Guide (WBDG), : .
.2018 .. , : 01.
Primanti A. H.,Mangkuto R. A.,Koerniawan M. D.,R. C. G. M. Loonen M. D. .2020 .Sensitivity analysis on daylighting, visual comfort, and energy consumption of automated venetian blinds for open-plan offices in tropical climate. in Proceedings of the EduARCHsia & Senvar 2019 International Conference (EduARCHsia, : 48-52.
Bahdad A. A. S.,Fadzil S. F. S.,Taib N. .2020 .Optimization of daylight performance based on controllable light-shelf parameters using genetic algorithms in the tropical climate of Malaysia. Journal of Daylighting, 7(1) : 122-136.
Bakmohammadi P.,Noorzai E. .2020 .Optimization of the design of the primary school classrooms in terms of energy and daylight performance considering occupants' thermal and visual comfort. Energy Reports, 6 : 1590-1607.
Shishegar N.,Boubekri M. .2016 .Natural Light and Productivity: Analyzing the Impacts of Daylighting on Students' and Workers' Health and Alertness. Biological and Life Science, : 151-156.
Boubekri M.,Lee J.,Bub K.,Curry K. .2020 .Impact of daylight exposure on sleep time and quality of elementary school children. European Journal of Teacher Education, 2(2) : 10-17.
Liu Y.,Chen K.,Deng Q. .2023 .e21598. Heliyon, 9(11) : .
Pellegrino A.,Cammarano S.,Savio V. .2015 .Daylighting for Green Schools: A Resource for Indoor Quality and Energy Efficiency in Educational Environments. , 78 : 3162-3167.
Abdelhakim M.,Lim Y. W.,Kandar M. Z.,Abdelhakim M. Z.,Lim M.,Kandar Y. W. .2019 .Optimum glazing configurations for visual performance in Algerian classrooms under mediterranean climate. Journal of Daylighting, 6(1) : .
Majeed M. N.,Mustafa F. A.,Husein H. A. .2019 .Impact of building typology on daylight optimization using building information modeling: Apartments in Erbil city as a case study. J. Daylighting, 6(2) : 187-201.
Liu Y.,Chen K.,Deng Q. .2023 .e21598. Heliyon, 9(11) : .
Liu J.,Li Z.,Zhong Q.,Wu J.,Xie L. .2024 ., Multi-objective optimization of daylighting performance and energy consumption of educational buildings in different climatic zones of China. Journal of Building Engineering, 95 : 110322.
Mo X.,Pons-Valladares O.,Donoso S. I. Ortega .2024 .Visual Comfort Using Waste-Based Shading and Its Validation in Mediterranean Schools. , 16(23) : .
Atthaillah R. A.,Mangkuto M. D.,Koerniawan B.,Yuliarto B. .2022 .On the interaction between the depth and elevation of external shading devices in tropical daylit classrooms with symmetrical bilateral openings. Buildings, 12(6) : .
Atthaillah R. A.,Mangkuto M. D.,Koerniawan B.,Yuliarto B. .2022 .Optimization of daylighting design using self-shading mechanism in tropical school classrooms with bilateral openings. Journal of Daylighting, 9(2) : 117-136.
Atthaillah R. A.,Mangkuto M. D.,Koerniawan F. X. N.,Soelami F. X. N. .2022 .Daylight annual illuminance investigation in elementary school classrooms for the tropic of Lhokseumawe, Indonesia. Journal of Applied Science and Engineering, 25(1) : 129-139.
Atthaillah A.,Mangkuto R. A.,Subramaniam S.,Yuliarto B. .2024 .Daylighting design validation and optimisation of tropical school classrooms with asymmetrical bilateral opening typology. Indoor and Built Environment, 33(3) : 551-570.
Atthaillah R. A.,Mangkuto M. D.,Koerniawan S.,Subramaniam B.,Yuliarto B. .2024 .Formulation of climate-based daylighting design prediction model for high performance tropical school classrooms. Energy and Buildings, : 113849.
Brembilla E.,Mardaljevic J. .2019 .Climate-Based Daylight Modelling for compliance verification: Benchmarking multiple state-of-the-art methods. Building and Environment, 158 : 151-164.
Mardaljevic J. .2000 .Daylight simulation: validation, sky models and daylight coefficients. , : .
Kharvari F. .2020 .An empirical validation of daylighting tools: Assessing radiance parameters and simulation settings in Ladybug and Honeybee against field measurements. Solar Energy, 207 : 1021-1036.
Geisler-Moroder D.,Lee E. S.,Ward G. J. .2017 .Validation of the five-phase method for simulating complex fenestration systems with radiance against field measurements. in Proceedings for the 15th International Conference of the International Building Performance Simulation Association, : .
McNeil A.,Lee E. S. .2012 .A validation of the Radiance three-phase simulation method for modelling annual daylight performance of optically complex fenestration systems. Journal of Building Performance Simulation, 6(1) : 24-37.
Pendidikan Nasional Kementerian,RI Kementerian,Ruang Kelas Rusak Rehabilitasi .2011 .Pembangunan Ruang Kelas Baru Beserta Perabotnya, dan Pembangunan Ruang Perpustakaan Beserta Perabotnya untuk SD/SDLB. Peraturan Menteri Pendidikan Nasional No 32 Tahun 2011 Lampiran II: Standar dan Spesifikasi Teknis [28] [30] [32] [34] [36], : .
Alkhatatbeh B. J.,Kurdi Y.,Asadi S. .2023 .Enhancing learning Environments: Exploring optimal classroom design connected to DoubleLoaded corridors across the U.S. Climate zones. Energy and Buildings, 298 : 113562.
Atthaillah R. A.,Mangkuto M. D.,Koerniawan M. D. .2022 .Investigation of Direct Sunlight in Existing Classroom Design in Indonesia: Case Study of Lhokseumawe. , : 135-144.
Syahreza R. N.,Husini E. M.,Arabi F.,Ismail W. N. W.,Kandar M. Z. .2018 .Secondary school classrooms daylighting evaluation in Negeri Sembilan, Malaysia. in IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 401, : 012024.
Mangkuto R. A.,Rohmah M.,Asri A. D. .2016 .Design optimization for window size, orientation, and wall reflectance with regard to various daylight metrics and lighting energy demand: a case study of buildings in the tropics. Applied Energy, 164 : 211-219.
Tregenza P. .1983 .The Monte Carlo method in lighting calculations. Lighting Research Technology 15, 4 : 163-170.
Subramaniam S. .2018 .Parametric Modeling Strategies for Efficient Annual Analysis of Daylight in Buildings. , : .
Roudsari M. S.,Pak M. .2013 .Ladybug: A Parametric Environmental Plugin For Grasshopper to Help Designers Create An Environmentally-Conscious Design. in 13th Conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association, : 3128-3135.
Tregenza P.,I. Waters P. .1983 .. Lighting Research Technology, 15(2) : 65-71.
Subramaniam S.,Mistrick R. G.,Accurate A More .2017 .Approach for calculating Illuminance with Daylight Coefficients. The IES Annual Conference, : .
Subramaniam S. .2017 .. Daylighting Simulations with Radiance using Matrixbased Methods, : .
Wienold J.,Christoffersen J. .2006 .Evaluation methods and development of a new glare prediction model for daylight environments with the use of CCD cameras, Energy. , 38(7) : 743-757.
Jones N. L. .2019 .Fast climate-based glare analysis and spatial mapping. Building Simulation Conference Proceedings, 2 : 982-989.
Engineering Society (IES) LM- Illuminating .2013 .Approved method: IES spatial daylight autonomy (sDA) and annual sunlight exposure (ASE. , : .
States Green Building United,Washington DC .2013 .Council (USGBC), LEED Reference Guide for Building Design and Construction, LEED v4. [41] [43] [45] [47] [49], : .
States Green Building Council United .2020 .. , : 25.
States Green Building United .2021 .Council (USGBC). LEED v4.1: Building Design and Construction, : .
Nabil A.,Mardaljevic J. .2006 .Useful daylight illuminances: A replacement for daylight factors. Energy and Buildings, 38(7) : 905-913.
Mardaljevic J. .2010 .Climate-Based Daylight Analysis for Residential Buildings Impact of various window configurations , external obstructions , orientations and location on useful daylight illuminance. Leicester, : .
Mangkuto R. A.,Siregar M. A. . M. A. A.,Handina A. .2018 .Faridah, Determination of appropriate metrics for indicating daylight availability and lighting energy demand using genetic algorithm. Solar Energy, 170 : 1074-1086.
IES IESNA,LM IESNA,Method Approved .2012 .: IES Spatial Daylight Autonomy (sDA) and Annual Sunlight Exposure (ASE. , 83 : .
Heschong L.,Wright R. L.,Okura S. .2002 .Daylighting Impacts on Human Performance in School. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 31(2) : 101-114.
Heschong L. .2003 .Windows and classrooms: a study of student performance and the indoor environment. , : .
Boubekri M. .2008 .. Architecture and Health: Building design strategies, : .
Ayoub M. .2019 .A multivariate regression to predict daylighting and energy consumption of residential buildings within hybrid settlements in hot-desert climates. Indoor and Built Environment, 28(6) : 848-866.
Lakhdari K.,Sriti L.,Painter B. .2021 .Parametric optimization of daylight, thermal and energy performance of middle school classrooms, case of hot and dry regions. Building and Environment, 204 : 108173.
Sudarsono .2021 .Building envelope design optimization of a hypothetical classroom considering energy consumption, daylighting, and thermal comfort: Case study in Lhokseumawe. International Journal of Technology, 12(6) : 1217-1227.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

17

Views