No Detail Found!

Assessing the Indoor Thermal Comfort and Adaptive Behaviours of Older People in the Residences of Warm and Humid Climate, India

Author(s)
Niveditha Sudarsanam Department of Architecture, National Institute of Technology,Tiruchirappalli, Tamil Nadu,India
D. Kannamma School of Architecture (V-SPARC), Vellore Institute of Technology, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
Abstract
Population aging, extreme weather conditions, and rising energy costs present significant challenges, especially in developing Asian countries like India. A key sustainability goal for future age-friendly cities is to ensure that older adults live in housing tailored to their specific needs. However, existing thermal comfort studies in India often treat the adult population as homogeneous, overlooking the unique thermal comfort requirements of the older people. This study addresses this gap by examining seasonal variations in indoor thermal comfort and associated behavioural adjustments among older adults in their residences of warm and humid climate of India. Data were collected from 1,480 respondents through a longitudinal survey and simultaneous measurements of indoor environmental variables. Linear regression analysis revealed that comfort temperatures (TSV ±1) for the older people are 30°C in summer, 28.1°C in winter, and 29.2°C overall. The steeper slope of the summer regression indicates that even minor increases in indoor temperature significantly affect thermal sensations, highlighting the difficulties older adults face in warmer months. At a prevailing mean outdoor temperature (PMOT) of 25°C, the comfort band for older individuals ranges from 26°C to 31°C. Under ASHRAE 55-2020 conditions (TSV ±0.5), the comfort range is 26.9°C to 29.7°C. Notably, the comfort range for older individuals in this study is narrower compared to IMAC R, IMAC NV, and ASHRAE 55-2020 models, with a regression slope of 0.56 indicating heightened sensitivity to temperature variations. Additionally, relative importance index analysis shows that older males favour active cooling measures in summer, such as wearing lighter clothing and seeking airy spaces, while females prioritize modifying daily routines. In winter, both genders adopt warming strategies, with males emphasizing hot showers and females choosing heavier clothing.
Publication Details
Page(s) 190-214
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Adaptive behaviour, Thermal Comfort, Warm and humid climate, Environmental controls
References
Banerjee S. .2021 .Determinants of rural-urban differential in healthcare utilization among the elderly population in India. [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9], 21 : 939.
L. M. Vaishnav S. H.,Joshi A. U.,Joshi A. U.,Mehendale A. M. .2022 .The National Programme for Health Care of the Elderly: A Review of its Achievements and. Ann Geriatr Med Res, 26 : 183-195.
Naz L.,Ghimire U.,Zainab A. .2021 .Behavioral factors associated with utilization of healthcare services among elderly in Pakistan: evidence from a nationally representative survey. BMC Geriatr, 21 : 42.
UN- DESA .2022 .. , : .
Lee Y.,Hwang J.,Lim S.,Kim J. T. .2013 .Identifying Characteristics of Design Guidelines for Elderly Care Environments from the Holistic Health Perspective, Indoor. , 22 : 242-259.
.2023 .Caring for Our Elders. International Institute for Population Sciences & United Nations Population Fund, : .
James S. .2015 .. , 10 : 73-77.
Bloom D. E.,Sekher T. V.,Lee J. .2021 .Longitudinal Aging Study in India (LASI): new data resources for addressing aging in India. Nat Aging, 1 : 1070-1072.
Ramraj B.,Logaraj M. .2021 .Is home bound a major burden towards health access among the elderly population? A community based cross sectional study in the selected northern districts in Tamilnadu, Clinical Epidemiology. , 9 : 132-136.
.2022 .. Accessed: May, 23 : .
Simoni M.,Jaakkola M. S.,Carrozzi L.,Baldacci S.,Di Pede F. .2003 .Indoor air pollution and respiratory health in the elderly. European Respiratory Journal, 21 : 15S-20s.
.2008 .Did you know the when you have climate change strategies, you are improving your health?. , : .
J. van Hoof ,Schellen L.,Soebarto V.,Wong J. K. W.,Kazak J. K. .2017 .Ten questions concerning thermal comfort and ageing. Building and Environment, 120 : 123-133.
Baquero M. T.,Vergés R.,Gaspar K.,Forcada N. .2023 .A Field Investigation of the Thermal Comfort of Older Adults in Cold Winter Climates. , : 1-14.
Guergova S.,Dufour A. .2011 .Thermal sensitivity in the elderly: A review. Ageing Research Reviews, 10 : 80-92.
Roelofsen P. .2017 .Healthy ageing: differences between elderly and non-elderly in temperature sensation and dissatisfied. , 9 : 123-136.
Jiao Y.,Yu Y.,Yu H.,Wang F. .2023 .The impact of thermal environment of transition spaces in elderly-care buildings on thermal adaptation and thermal behavior of the elderly. Building and Environment, 228 : 109871.
Edholm O.,Hopkinson R. G. .1976 .Thermal Balance and Thermal Comfort in the Built Environment. , 5 : 73-74.
.2020 .Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2020. , : .
. .. [20] ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2017, : 66.
Sharma A.,Kumar A.,Kulkarni K. S. .2021 .Thermal comfort studies for the naturally ventilated built environments in Indian subcontinent: A review. Journal of Building Engineering, 44 : 103242.
Vergés R.,Gaspar K.,Forcada N. .2023 .Assessment of the energy implications adopting adaptive thermal comfort models during the cooling season: A case study for Mediterranean nursing homes. Energy and Buildings, 299 : 113598.
Hoof J. V.,Hensen J. L. M. .2006 .Thermal comfort and older adults. Gerontechnology, 4 : 223-228.
Schellen L.,Loomans M. G. L. C.,Toftum J.,M. H. De Wit J. .2010 .Differences between young adults and elderly in thermal comfort, productivity, and thermal physiology in response to a moderate temperature drift and a steady-state condition: Differences between young adults and elderly in thermal comfort, productivity, and thermal physiology. Indoor Air, 20 : 273-283.
Novieto D. T.,Y. Zhang, D. T. .2010 .Thermal Comfort Implications of the Aging Effect on Metabolism, Cardiac Output and Body Weight. , : 9-11.
Ryti N. R. I.,Guo Y.,Jaakkola J. J. K. .2016 .Global Association of Cold Spells and Adverse Health Effects: A Systematic Review and MetaAnalysis. , 124 : 12-22.
Zhan H.,Yu J.,Yu R. .2021 .Assessment of older adults' acceptance of IEQ in nursing homes using both subjective and objective methods. Building and Environment, 203 : 108063.
Forcada N.,Gangolells M.,Casals M.,Tejedor B.,Macarulla M.,Gaspar K. .2021 .Field study on thermal comfort in nursing homes in heated environments. Energy and Buildings, 244 : 111032.
Zheng W.,Shao T.,Lin Y.,Wang Y.,Dong C.,Liu J. .2022 .A field study on seasonal adaptive thermal comfort of the elderly in nursing homes in Xi'an, China, Building. , 208 : 108623.
Forcada N.,Gangolells M.,Casals M.,Tejedor B.,Macarulla M.,Gaspar K. .2020 .Summer thermal comfort in nursing homes in the Mediterranean climate. Energy and Buildings, 299 : 110442.
Healy K. .2002 .. , 8 : 283-289.
Kovats R. S. .2006 .Heat waves and health protection. BMJ, 333 : 314-315.
J.-M. Robine .2007 .000 in Europe during the summer of 2003, Comptes Rendus. Death toll exceeded 70, 331 : 171-178.
Mendes A. .2013 .Indoor Air Quality and Thermal Comfort-Results of a Pilot Study in Elderly Care Centers in Portugal. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, 76 : 333-344.
Jiang Y.,Ryu Y.,Kagawa H. .2008 .Measurement of thermal environment and mental reaction of elderly people in welfare facilities. Nihon Kenchiku Gakkai Kankyokei Ronbunshu, 73 : 191-197.
Wang Z.,Cao B.,Lin B.,Zhu Y. .2020 .Investigation of thermal comfort and behavioral adjustments of older people in residential environments in Beijing, Energy. , 217 : 110001.
R.-L. Hwang ,M.-C. Ho .2009 .general adaptation methods and occupant's idea about the trade-off between thermal comfort and energy saving in hot-humid regions. Building and Environment, 44 : 1128-1134.
Indraganti and K. D. Rao M. .2010 .Effect of age, gender, economic group and tenure on thermal comfort: A field study in residential buildings in hot and dry climate with seasonal variations. Energy and Buildings, 42 : 273-281.
Peng C. .2010 .Survey of thermal comfort in residential buildings under natural conditions in hot humid and cold wet seasons in Nanjing, Front. Archit. Civ. Eng. China, 4 : 503-511.
Becker R.,Paciuk M. .2009 .Thermal comfort in residential buildings - Failure to predict by Standard model. Building and Environment, 44 : 948-960.
Natsume K.,Ogawa T.,Sugenoya J.,Ohnishi N.,Imai K. .1992 .Preferred ambient temperature for old and young men in summer and winter. Int J Biometeorol, 36 : 1-4.
Xiong J.,Ma T.,Lian Z. .2019 .Perceptual and physiological responses of elderly subjects to moderate temperatures. Building and Environment, 156 : 117-122.
Wu Y. .2019 .Thermal adaptation of the elderly during summer in a hot humid area: Psychological, behavioral, and physiological responses. Energy and Buildings, 203 : 109450.
Yang J.,I. Nam J.,Sohn J.-R. .2016 .The influence of seasonal characteristics in elderly thermal comfort in Korea, Energy. , 126 : 583-591.
Hwang R.-L.,Chen C.-P. .2010 .Field study on behaviors and adaptation of elderly people and their thermal comfort requirements in residential environments: Thermal comfort requirements of elderly people. Indoor Air, 20 : 235-245.
Indraganti M. .2010 .Behavioural adaptation and the use of environmental controls in summer for thermal comfort in apartments in India, Energy. , 42 : 1019-1025.
.2014 .Old-age Homes: Providing Security and Company for the Aged. , : .
Maheshwari S. K.,Chaturvedi R.,Sharma P. .2021 .Effectiveness of psychoeducational intervention on psychological distress and self-esteem among resident elderly: A study from old age homes of Punjab, India, Clinical Epidemiology. , 11 : 100733.
Zhou H. .2024 .Adaptative thermal comfort analysis in the elderly based on Fried frailty classification in residential buildings during summer. Building and Environment, 252 : 111262.
Jin Y.,Wang F.,Payne S. R.,Weller R. B. .2022 .A comparison of the effect of indoor thermal and humidity condition on young and older adults' comfort and skin condition in winter. Indoor and Built Environment, 31 : 759-776.
Sansaniwal S. K.,Mathur J.,Garg V.,Gupta R. .2020 .Review of studies on thermal comfort in Indian residential buildings. Science and Technology for the Built Environment, 26 : 1-22.
Kumar and M. K. Singh S. .2019 .Field investigation on occupant's thermal comfort and preferences in naturally ventilated multi-storey hostel buildings over two seasons in India, Building. , 163 : 106309.
Thapa S.,Indraganti M. .2020 .Evaluation of thermal comfort in two neighboring climatic zones in Eastern India-an adaptive approach. Energy and Buildings, 213 : 109767.
Andersen R. V.,Toftum J.,Andersen K. K.,Olesen B. W. .2009 .Survey of occupant behaviour and control of indoor environment in Danish dwellings. Energy and Buildings, 41 : 11-16.
Balvedi B. F.,Lamberts R. .2018 .A review of occupant behaviour in residential buildings. Energy and Buildings, 174 : 495-505.
R. de Dear J.,Xiong J.,Kim B.,Cao B. .2020 .A review of adaptive thermal comfort research since 1998, Energy. , 214 : 109893.
Thapa S. .2019 .Insights into the thermal comfort of different naturally ventilated buildings of Darjeeling, India - Effect of gender, age and BMI, Energy. , 193 : 267-288.
Singh S.,Chani P. S. .2018 .Thermal comfort analysis of Indian subjects in multi-storeyed apartments: An adaptive approach in composite climate. Indoor and Built Environment, 27 : 1216-1246.
Aghamolaei R.,Ghaani M. R. .2020 .Balancing the impacts of energy efficiency strategies on comfort quality of interior places: Application of optimization algorithms in domestic housing. Journal of Building Engineering, 29 : 101174.
Niemelä T.,Vinha J.,Lindberg R.,Ruuska T.,Laukkarinen A. .2017 .Carbon dioxide permeability of building materials and their impact on bedroom ventilation need. Journal of Building Engineering, 12 : 99-108.
Bentayeb M. .2015 .Indoor air quality, ventilation and respiratory health in elderly residents living in nursing homes in Europe. Eur Respir J, 45 : 1228-1238.
Sudarsanam N.,Kannamma D. .2023 .Investigation of summertime thermal comfort at the residences of elderly people in the warm and humid climate of India, Energy. , 291 : 113151.
Building Code National .2016 .. , : .
Betti G.,Tartarini F.,Nguyen C.,Schiavon S. .2024 .A free and open-source web application for climate analysis tailored to sustainable building design. Build, 17 : 493-508.
Rockwood K. .2005 .A global clinical measure of fitness and frailty in elderly people. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 173 : 489-495.
Accessed ,K. B. Debnath D. P.,Jenkins S.,Patidar S.,Peacock A. D. .2020 .Understanding Residential Occupant Cooling Behaviour through Electricity Consumption in Warm-Humid Climate. , 10 : 78.
Bhandari N.,Tadepalli S.,Gopalakrishnan P. .2023 .Influence of non-uniform distribution of fan-induced air on thermal comfort conditions in university classrooms in warm and humid climate. India, Building and Environment, 238 : 110373.
Kubota H. B.,Rijal H. B. .2018 .. , : 165-174.
Thapa S.,Indraganti M. .2020 .Evaluation of thermal comfort in two neighboring climatic zones in Eastern India-an adaptive approach. Energy and Buildings, 213 : 109767.
Nicol F.,Humphreys M. .2010 .Derivation of the adaptive equations for thermal comfort in free-running buildings in European standard EN15251, Building. , 45 : 11-17.
Hanada K,Mihira K,Sato Y .1983 .Studies on the thermal resistance of men's underwear. Journal of Japan Research Association for Textile End- Users, 24 : 363-369.
Indraganti Madhavi,Lee Juyoun,UK Juyoun .2016 .Making comfort relevant. , : 18.
M. A. Kassem M. A.,Khoiry N.,Hamzah N. .2020 .Using Relative Importance Index Method for Developing Risk Map in Oil and Gas. , 32 : 85-97.
Malik J.,Bardhan R.,Hong T.,Piette M. A. .2020 .Contextualising adaptive comfort behaviour within low-income housing of Mumbai, India, Building. , 177 : 106877.
Ponni M.,Baskar D. R. .2017 .7. International Journal of Engineering Science Invention, 6 : .
Subramanian C. V.,Ramachandran N.,Senthamil S.,Kumar S. .2017 .Design and Analysis of Solar Passive Architecture for Thermal Comfort of Residential Buildings in Warm-Humid Climate of Thanjavur Region. Indian Journal of Science and Technology, 10 : 1-8.
Dili A. S.,Naseer M. A.,Varghese T. Z. .2010 .Thermal comfort study of Kerala traditional residential buildings based on questionnaire survey among occupants of traditional and modern buildings. Energy and Buildings, 42 : 2139-2150.
Rajasekar E.,Ramachandraiah A. .2010 .Adaptive comfort and thermal expectations - a subjective evaluation in hot humid climate, presented at the Adapting to Change: New thinking on comfort, Cumberland Lodge. , 18 : .
H. B. Rijal M. A.,Humphreys J. F.,Nicol J. F. .2017 .Towards an adaptive model for thermal comfort in Japanese offices. Building Research & Information, 45 : 717-729.
M. K. Singh R.,Ooka H. B.,Rijal M.,Takasu M. .2017 .Adaptive thermal comfort in the offices of North-East India in autumn season. Building and Environment, 124 : 14-30.
Kumar S.,Mathur A.,Singh M. K.,K. B. Rana M. K. .2021 .Adaptive thermal comfort study of workers in a mini-industrial unit during summer and winter season in a tropical country. India, Building and Environment, 197 : 107874.
Rawal R. .2022 .Adaptive thermal comfort model based on field studies in five climate zones across India, Building. , 219 : 109187.
Manu S.,Shukla Y.,Rawal R. .2016 .Field studies of thermal comfort across multiple climate zones for the subcontinent: India Model for Adaptive Comfort (IMAC), Building. , 98 : 55-70.
Shafighfard T.,Kazemi F.,Asgarkhani N. .2024 .Machinelearning methods for estimating compressive strength of high-performance alkali-activated concrete. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 136 : 109053.
Shafighfard T.,Kazemi F.,Bagherzadeh F.,Mieloszyk M.,D. Yoo, M. .2024 .Chained machine learning model for predicting load capacity and ductility of steel fiber-reinforced concrete beams. Computer aided Civil Eng, 39 : 3573-3594.
Mieloszyk .2023 .Prediction of maximum tensile stress in plain-weave composite laminates with interacting holes via stacked machine learning algorithms: A comparative study. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 195 : 110315.
Kazemi F.,Asgarkhani N.,Shafighfard T.,Jankowski R. .2025 .Machine-Learning Methods for Estimating Performance of Structural Concrete Members Reinforced with Fiber-Reinforced Polymers. Arch Computat Methods Eng, 32 : 571-603.
Sudprasert S. .2020 .9. International Journal of Building, 16 : .
Bureau .2001 .. National Building Code of India (NBC, : .
Sharma A.,Tiwari R. .2007 .Evaluation of data for developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and preference. , 27 : 73-81.
Indraganti M. .2010 .Using the adaptive model of thermal comfort for obtaining indoor neutral temperature: Findings from a field study in Hyderabad, India, Building. , 45 : 519-536.
Kumar S. .2016 .An adaptive approach to define thermal comfort zones on psychrometric chart for naturally ventilated buildings in composite climate of India, Building. , 109 : 135-153.
M. K. Singh S.,Mahapatra S. K.,Atreya S. K. .2011 .Adaptive thermal comfort model for different climatic zones of North-East India. , 88 : 2420-2428.
K. I. Praseeda M.,Mani B. V. V.,Reddy B. V. V. .2014 .Assessing Impact of Material Transition and Thermal Comfort Models on Embodied and Operational Energy in Vernacular Dwellings (India). Energy Procedia, 54 : 342-351.
Udaykumar A.,Venkateswaran R. .2015 .Thermal comfort characteristics in naturally ventilated, residential apartments in a hot-dry climate of India, Indoor. , 24 : 101-115.
Bills R. .2019 .Addressing the relationships between ageing, thermal comfort, house design and health: A study in South Australia. , : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

138

Views