No Detail Found!

Feasibility Study of Five Solar Thermal Power Plants in Arequipa, Peru, and Their Comparison with Seto Targets

Author(s)
Harry Aarón Yapu Maldonado Escuela de Ingeniería Mecánica, Facultad de Ingeniería, Universidad Continental. Av.,Los Incas s/n, Arequipa,Perú
Abstract
Knowing the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) allows for evaluating the profitability of different energy generation technologies, identifying the options with the lowest costs, and, in turn, promoting the transition to more sustainable energy sources for governments and private companies. Therefore, it is essential to analyze the competitiveness of a concentrated solar power (CSP) plant in La Joya, Arequipa, Peru, in comparison with the local electricity provider (SEAL) tariff and the LCOE target set for 2030 by the U.S. Department of Energy's Solar Energy Technologies Office (SETO). This study focuses on assessing the feasibility of five CSP plant configurations with different capacities (19.9 MWe,50 MWe, 100 MWe, 150 MWe, and 200 MWe) in Arequipa by calculating the LCOE with varying durations of thermal energy storage (TES) from 0 to 18 hours. Additionally, the LCOE of the Gemasolar plant (19.9 MWe) in Seville, Spain, is analyzed and projected in Arequipa using economies of scale. The projected LCOEs of the CSP plants are compared with SETO's target (5 ¢/kWh) and SEAL's tariff (20 ¢/kWh). Finally, the LCOE is broken down into its main components to identify the most significant costs. The methodology was developed in three stages: (1) collection of technical, economic, and geographical parameters of Gemasolar along with climate and radiation data from Arequipa; (2) simulations in the System Advisor Model (SAM) software to optimize CSP plant design, considering the number and arrangement of heliostats, as well as the dimensions of the tower and receiver; and (3) processing of results in Excel to calculate the LCOE for each CSP configuration and the generation of contour maps in MATLAB to compare LCOE, TES, design power, and relative percentages against SETO targets, SEAL tariffs, and the Gemasolar plant. A total of 152 simulations were conducted in SAM to optimize the design. The results show that the LCOE of the analyzed CSP plants is between 120% and 260% above the SETO target, with values ranging from 11 to 18 ¢/kWh. However, the projected CSP LCOE is between 10% and 61% lower than SEAL's rate, with values between 12.2 and 18 ¢/kWh. The four main components account for 78.6% of the total LCOE, with thermal storage being the most significant (37.5%), followed by heliostats (21.89%), the receiver (11.54%), and the power block (8.23%). The average annual LCOE reduction for CSP technology is approximately 1.69%. In conclusion, none of the projected CSP configurations achieve the SETO target, and even with a reduction in the main components, the LCOE would remain between 86.28% and 226.28% above this target. Thermal storage is the component with the greatest cost reduction potential, potentially lowering the LCOE by 20%. Nevertheless, all the projected CSP configurations are attractive for public or private investment, as they offer electricity at a lower cost than the local SEAL provider. Although Peru has photovoltaic plants that harness solar radiation, the LCOE of the analyzed CSPs is 219.2% higher. However, CSPs offer a significant advantage in terms of capacity factors, reaching up to 65% compared to 33% for photovoltaic plants.
Publication Details
Page(s) 51-68
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Thermal Energy Storage, Gemasolar, Concentrated Solar Power, Levelized cost of electricity
References
Energía - Desarrollo Sostenible .2024 .. , 24 : .
Al-Adwan I.,Al-Hayek M.,Issa A. A.,Al Shawabkeh M. A.,Jaber and Q. .2019 .Using Matlab for simulating real-world photovoltaic system. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 13 : 21-25.
Lange J.,Hilgedieck J.,Kaltschmitt M. .2019 .Renewable resources of energy for electricity generation-development trends and necessities within the overall energy system. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 13 : 207-220.
Jaber J. O.,Awadi M. O.,Dalabeeh A. S.,Mansour and I. M. .2022 .Performance and Socioeconomics of 1st Wheeling PV Project Connected to Medium Grid in Jordan. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 16 : 567-579.
Cáceres G.,Anrique N.,Girard A.,Degrève J.,Baeyens J.,H. L. Zhang, J. .2013 .Performance of molten salt solar power towers in Chile. Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy, 5 : 053142.
Hu Y.,Xu Z.,Zhou C.,Du J.,Yao Y. .2020 .Design and performance analysis of a multi-reflection heliostat field in solar power tower system. Renewable Energy, 160 : 498-512.
G. M. Tashtoush M. A.,Alzoubi M. A. .2023 .An analysis of the Performance and Economic Feasibility of a Hybrid Solar Cooling System that Combines an Ejector with Vapor Compression Cycles, Powered by a Photovoltaic Thermal. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 17 : 41-54.
Al Tahaineh H.,Hassan W. .2023 .Performance Analysis of a Small-Scale Concentrating Solar Parabolic Dish System for Hot Water Generation. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 17 : 413-419.
M. T. Zamani A. A.,Amiri A. A. .2024 .Energy efficiency in smart schools using renewable energy strategy. Journal of Daylighting, 11 : 203-215.
He Q.,Zheng H.,Ma X.,Wang G. .2021 .Optical analysis of a sliding-type cylindrical Fresnel lens concentrating collector for agricultural greenhouse. Journal of Daylighting, 8 : 110-119.
Jiang J.,Moallem M.,Zheng Y. .2021 .An intelligent iot-enabled lighting system for energy-efficient crop production. Journal of Daylighting, 8 : 86-99.
Merrouni Alami .2023 .Performance investigation of seawater desalination system powered by central receiver concentrated solar thermal plant. , 225 : .
Ma X.,Liu S. .2019 .A review on solar concentrators with multisurface and multielement combinations. Journal of Daylighting, 6 : 80-96.
K. M. Bataineh A.,Gharaibeh A. .2018 .Optimization analyses of parabolic trough (CSP) plants for the desert regions of the middle east and North Africa (MENA. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 12 : 33-43.
Tarwaneh .2023 .. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 17 : 605-615.
Osinergmin .2019 .Experiencia y Perspectivas en la Ruta del Perú Hacia la Transición Energética. , : .
J. J. Ditta Granados .2018 .un sistema termosolar de receptor central para la generación de energía eléctrica en La Guajira. , : .
Desideri U.,Campana P. E. .2024 .Analysis and comparison between a concentrating solar and a photovoltaic power plant. Applied Energy, 113 : 422-433.
Concentración de Energía . .. [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17], : .
.2024 ._x_tr_sl=en&_x_tr_tl=es&_x_tr_hl=es&_x_tr_pto=sc (accessed Jul. , 26 : .
.2024 .. , 19 : .
Avila-Marin A. L.,Fernandez-Reche J.,Tellez F. M. .2013 .Evaluation of the potential of central receiver solar power plants: Configuration, optimization. Applied Energy, 112 : 274-288.
Gemasolar - Exera Energía .2024 .. , 27 : .
.2024 .. , 27 : .
Yapu H. A.,Maldonado H. A. .2018 .. MWe con almacenamiento en sales fundidas, : .
Toma ,Repositorio UCSP,Solar D. E. E.,C.-J. Winter R. .,Sizmann L. L.,Vant-Hull L. L. .1991 .un sistema fotovoltaico autónomo en las instalaciones de la UCSP. , : 2.
Collado F. J.,Guallar J. .2012 .A review of optimized design layouts for solar power tower plants with campo code. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 20 : 142-154.
Burgaleta J. I.,Arias S.,Ramirez D. .2011 .Gemasolar, the first tower thermosolar commercial plant with molten salt storage. , : 1-8.
W. B. Stine R. W.,Harrigan R. W. .1985 .Design: With Computer Applications. , : .
Biggs F.,Vittitoe C. N. .1979 .The Helios model for the optical behavior of reflecting solar concentrators. Springfield, : .
P. K. Falcone .1986 .A handbook for solar central receiver design. Livermore, : .
M. R. .2024 .On the design of solar external receivers. html (accessed Jul, 30 : .
.2024 .Calculation of heat loss from pipes. , 29 : .
Solar Power Tower Design Basis Document A. B. ZAVOICO,United States .2001 .. , : .
Frantz C.,Ebert M.,Schlögl-Knothe B.,Binder M.,Schuhbauer C. .2023 .Experimental Receiver Setup of a High Performance Molten Salt Test Receiver System. in AIP Conference Proceedings, : .
Kistler B. L. .1986 .A user's manual for DELSOL3: A computer code for calculating the optical performance and optimal system design for solar thermal central receiver plants. United States, : .
Resolución .2023 .Plataforma del Estado Peruano. , 23 : 12700-2016.
Collado F. J. .2009 .Preliminary design of surrounding heliostat fields. Renewable Energy, 34 : 1359-1363.
Pfahl A. .2017 .. Solar Energy, 152 : 3-37.
Dr M. .2008 .-descenso-de-lainflacion-en-mayo-y-se-ubica-en-el-centro-del-rango-meta/ (accessed Aug.. Master en Energías Renovables y Mercado Energético, 66 : .
Hoffschmidt B. .2012 .. Concentrating solar power, : .
Solar Power Concentrating .2021 .ATB | NREL. , : .
.2024 .. , 08 : .
Behar O.,Sbarbaro D.,Morán L. .2020 .A practical methodology for the design and cost estimation of solar tower power plants. Sustainability (Switzerland), 12 : 1-16.
Solar Power Concentrating .2023 .ATB | NREL. , : .
.2024 .. , 09 : .
Thermosolar Plant Gemasolar .2024 .-thermosolar-plant-solar-tres (accessed Aug. , 12 : .
Kuravi S. .2012 .. Thermal Energy Storage for Concentrating Solar Power Plants, Technology & Innovation, 14 : 81-91.
Kolb G. J.,Ho C. K.,Mancini T. R.,Gary J. A. .2012 .Power tower technology roadmap and cost reduction plan. , : .
Augustine C.,Kesseli D.,Turchi C. .2022 .Technoeconomic cost analysis of NREL concentrating solar power Gen3 liquid pathway. in AIP Conference Proceedings, : .
.2024 ./cost-ofconcentrated-solar-power-csp-projects-fell-from-usd-0-38-kwh-to-usd-0- 118-kwh-a-decline-of-69/# (accessed Aug. , 17 : .
Kurup P.,Turchi C. S. .2015 .. Parabolic Trough Collector Cost Update for the System Advisor Model (SAM), : .
Arredondo J.,Ramos M. .2020 .. , 30 : 27-32.
SIEE .2024 ."Sistema interactivo de eficiencia energética." [Online]. , 03 : .
Musi R. .2017 .Techno-economic analysis of concentrated solar power plants in terms of levelized cost of electricity. , : 160018.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

57

Views