No Detail Found!

Optimisation of Indoor Spatial and Temporal Aspects of Deep Architectural Studio on Visual Comfort

Author(s)
Rizky Amalia Achsani Department of Architecture, SAPPK, Institut Teknologi Bandung,Jl. Ganesha 10, Bandung, 40132,Indonesia
Surjamanto Wonorahardjo Building Technology Research Group, SAPPK, Institut Teknologi Bandung,Jl. Ganesha 10, Bandung, 40132,Indonesia
Sugeng Triyadi Building Technology Research Group, SAPPK, Institut Teknologi Bandung,Jl. Ganesha 10, Bandung, 40132,Indonesia
Abstract
Visual comfort in deep rooms with side lit openings varies by positions and time; thus, interventions are required to provide comfort for all users in a room. This study aims to identify the conditions affecting visual comfort and potential interventions on spatial and temporal aspects of a room. This experiment comprises two layout settings: semi-enclosed studio layout and open studio layout with variables of zone (perimeter and core), viewing direction (north window, east wall, south window, and west wall), and temporal aspect (morning, midday, and afternoon), which determines how each aspect influences visual comfort. In this study, visual comfort is indicated using vertical eye illuminance (Ev) and daylight glare probability (DGP). Field measurements of daylighting performance were taken over five days and three times per day using a light meter to capture Ev and HDR images, which were then processed using Aftab Alpha software to produce DGP values. The results indicate that visual comfort in a deep room sequentially depends on view direction, zone, layout, and time. The value of Ev in deep rooms is significantly influenced by the type of opening, specifically the side lighting, which results in short penetration and does not reach the room core. Additionally, it depends on outdoor conditions. Consequently, the value at the perimeter is much higher than that at the core. By contrast, the glare sensation was not influenced by outdoor conditions during the day. Adjusting the view direction can control the less-than-ideal sitting position to obtain visual comfort. Additionally, correcting the sitting position in the zone can improve visual comfort at various times. Obstruction in the room plays a positive role in controlling glare and plays a negative role when reducing Ev. The period of visual discomfort throughout the day identified that the worst conditions occur in the morning owing to the lack of Ev. The optimum condition occurs during the day in the west wall and south window view direction, south perimeter zone, and semi-enclosed studio layout. Therefore, view direction and zone are effective features for obtaining visual comfort. Nevertheless, the layout type, room surface properties, and obstruction can also enhance visual comfort in various time conditions such as in the morning, afternoon, or evening. Horizontal plane components such as ceilings can expand the effects of Ev and reduce the effects of DGP in the morning or on cloudy days. The findings have implications for the design of deep rooms such as offices, studios, museums, and galleries in arranging the characteristics of horizontal and vertical surfaces of furniture and layout room that can affect the performance of the user.
Publication Details
Page(s) 40-50
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 12, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Visual Comfort, Indoor daylighting, Vertical eye illuminance, Glare sensation
References
Kasule S.,Congress VI,Elsevier VI .2000 .. , : 641-644.
Knoop M.,Stefani O.,Bueno B.,Matusiak B.,Hobday R.,Wirz-Justice A.,Martiny K.,Kantermann T.,Aarts M.P.,Zemmouri N.,Appelt S. .2020 .Daylight: What Makes the difference?. Lighting Research & Technology, 52 : 423-442.
Achsani R. A.,Wonorahardjo S.,Triyadi S. .2021 .Visual Environment for Learning in the Digital Era: A Review, in: ARTEPOLIS 8-the 8th Biannual International Conference. , : 73-79.
Bellia L.,Fragliasso F. .2021 .Good Places to Live and Sleep Well: A Literature Review about the Role of Architecture in Determining Non-Visual Effects of Light. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18 : 1002.
Tomassoni R.,Galetta G. .2015 .How Light Influences the Health and Psyche. , 06 : 1216-1222.
Y. A. W. .2019 .. Tutorial: Theoretical Considerations When Planning Research on Human Factors in Lighting, LEUKOS, 15 : 85-96.
W. de Kort Y. A.,Veitch J. A. .2014 .From Blind Spot into the Spotlight. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 3 : 1-4.
Tabadkani A.,Roetzel A.,Li H. X.,Tsangrassoulis A. .2021 .Daylight in Buildings and Visual Comfort Evaluation: The Advantages and Limitations. Journal of Daylighting, 8 : 181-203.
Vos J. J. .2003 .. , 35 : 163-175.
Hopkinson R. G. .1972 .. , 3 : 206-215.
Shafavi N. S.,Zomorodian Z. S.,Tahsildoost M.,Javadi M.,Experiments Lab .2020 .Occupants Visual Comfort Assessments: A Review of Field Studies. , 208 : 249-274.
Suk J. Y.,Schiler M.,Kensek K. .2024 .GLARE_METRICS_Investi gating_their_accuracy_and_consistency_in_daylight_glare_evaluation_by _using_human_subject_study_data/links/580a3e4908ae2cb3a5d2ff47/DIS COMFORT-GLARE-METRICS-Investigating-their-accuracy-andconsistency-in-daylight-glare-evaluation-by-using-human-subject-studydata. pdf (accessed: October, 02 : .
Wienold J. .2024 .. in: Proceedings of the 11th International IBPSA Conference, (accessed October 02) : 9-51.
K. Van Den Wymelenberg M.,Inanici M. .2014 .A Critical Investigation of Common Lighting Design Metrics for Predicting Human Visual Comfort in Offices with Daylight. LEUKOS, 10 : 145-164.
Chaloeytoy K.,Ichinose M. .2020 .Chien, Determination of the Simplified Daylight Glare Probability (DGPs) Criteria for Daylit Office Spaces in Thailand. , 10 : 180.
Mangkuto R. A.,Kurnia K. A.,Azizah D. N.,Atmodipoero R. T.,Soelami F. X. N. .2017 .Determination of Discomfort Glare Criteria for Daylit Space in Indonesia. , 149 : 151-163.
Bian Y. .2017 .Investigation of Visual Comfort Metrics from Subjective Responses in China: A Study in Offices with Daylight. Building and Environment, 123 : 661-671.
Karlsen L.,Heiselberg P.,Johra H. .2015 .Verification of Simple Illuminance Based Measures for Indication of Discomfort Glare from Windows, Building. , 92 : 615-626.
.2024 .International Commission on Illumination (CIE), Vertical Illuminance, eILV (International Lighting Vocabulary). , (accessed October 02) : .
Jakubiec J. A.,Reinhart C. F. .2024 .Towards an Integrated Framework for Predicting Visual Comfort Conditions from Luminancebased Metrics in Perimeter Daylit Spaces. pdf (accessed October 02, : 1189-1196.
Suk J. Y. .2019 .Luminance and Vertical Eye Illuminance Thresholds for Occupants' Visual Comfort in Daylit Office Environments. , 148 : 107-115.
Bian Y.,Dai Q.,Ma Y. .2020 .Variable Set Points of Glare Control Strategy for Side-lit Spaces: Daylight Glare Tolerance by Time of Day. , 201 : 268-278.
Khademagha P. .2024 .Smart Renovation of Matrix building: The Value of Comfort and Energy. Doctorate Thesis, (accessed October 02) : .
J. O'Connor E.,Lee F.,Rubinstein S.,Selkowitz S. .2024 .Tips for Daylighting with Windows. , 39945(accessed October 02) : LBNL.
Achsani R. A.,Wonorahardjo S.,Soelami F. X. N. .2018 .A Vision of Daylight Technologies for High-Rise Residential Building in Tropic. , 152 : 012013.
Hu J.,Du J. .2011 .The Assessment of Advanced Daylighting Systems in Multi-story Office Buildings Using a Dynamic Method. in: Proceedings of the World Renewable Energy Congress, Low Energy Architecture [28] [30] (LEA), : 1867-1874.
pdf .2024 .. , (accessed October 02) : 017.
S. M. Mousavi T. H.,Khan L. Y.,Wah L. Y. .2018 .Impact of Furniture Layout on Indoor Daylighting Performance in Existing Residential Buildings in Malaysia. Journal of Daylighting, 5 : 1-14.
M. B. Hirning G. H.,Lim G. P.,Reimann G. P. .2016 .Discomfort Glare in Energy Efficient Buildings: A Case Study in the Malaysian Context. in: Proceedings of the CIE, : 212-223.
Malaysian-Context .2024 .Efficient_ Buildings_A_Case_Study_in_the_Malaysian_Context/links/56debdba08ae b8b66f95f82d/Discomfort-Glare-In-Energy-Efficient-Buildings-A-CaseStudy-in-the-. pdf (accessed October 02, : .
Yao J. .2020 .Appropriate Seating Position and View Direction in Office Buildings: A Stochastic Shade Control Based Multiobjective Visual Comfort Optimization. Journal of Green Building, 15 : 15-36.
M. S. Khanie J.,Stoll S.,Mende J.,Wienold W.,Einhäuser M.,Andersen M. .2013 .Investigation of Gaze Patterns in Daylit Workplaces: Using Eye-tracking Methods to Objectify View Direction as a Function of Lighting Conditions, in: Proceedings of the CIE Centenary Conference" Towards a New Century of Light". CIE Central Bureau, : 250-259.
.2024 .. , (October 02) : .
Abdollahzadeh N.,Tahsildoost M.,Zomorodian Z. S.,Of A Method .2020 .Partition Design For Open-Plan Offices Based On Daylight Performance Evaluation. Journal of Building Engineering, 29 : 101171.
Santos L.,Caldas L.,Assessing The Glare Potential Of Side-Lit Indoor Spaces: A Simulation-Based Approach .2021 .. Archit Sci Rev, 64 : 139-152.
Liberska M.,Provision Daylighting .2021 .. J Phys Conf Ser, : 012134.
Miri M. .2024 .. , (accessed October 02) : .
Daich S.,Saadi M. Y.,Piga B. E.,Daiche A. M. .2021 .A Combined Method for an Exhaustive Investigation of the Anidolic Ceiling Effect on Improving Indoor Office Daylight Quality: An Approach Based on HDR Photography and Subjective Evaluations. Journal of Daylighting, 8 : 149-164.
S. M. Yacine Z.,Noureddine B. E. A.,Piga E.,Morello D.,Safa D. .2017 .Towards a New Model of Light Quality Assessment Based on Occupant Satisfaction and Lighting Glare Indices. , 122 : 805-810.
Ostertagová E.,Ostertag O.,Kováč J. .2014 .. Methodology and Application of the Kruskal-Wallis Test, Applied Mechanics and Materials, 611 : 115-120.
Jones B.,Quality Engineering .2021 .. The Prediction Profiler at 30, 33 : 417-424.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

72

Views