No Detail Found!

Evaluation of Occupants' Visual Perception in Day Lit Scenes: A Virtual Reality Experiment

Author(s)
Maedeh Sadat Mirdamadi Department of Architecture and Urban planning, Shahid beheshti University,Tehran,Iran
Zahra Sadat Zomorodian Department of Architecture and Urban planning, Shahid beheshti University,Tehran,Iran
Mohammad Tahsildoost Department of Architecture and Urban planning, Shahid beheshti University,Tehran,Iran
Abstract
Daylight improves indoor environmental quality, the physical and mental health of occupants, and their efficiency. Research in the area of human-centric lighting that considers the visual and non-visual effects of light on human vision, have focused on examining human visual perception in response to a wide variety of lighting aspects. To investigate the effect of surface materials, window size, and shading patterns on participants' evaluation of brightness, daylight distribution, contrast, and satisfaction with view, a virtual reality experiment is implemented in a university classroom. Moreover, responses are compared with metrics (i.e., RAMMG and illumines level) to evaluate their performance and robustness. Thirty-three subjects evaluated thirteen immersive virtual environments (IVEs) with different glazing visible light transmittance, reflectance coefficient of surfaces, window to wall ratio, number of windows, and shading geometry using a Likert-type scale survey. The results indicated that participants' evaluation of brightness is influenced by reflection coefficient of the surfaces and WWR. While daylight distribution is affected by number of windows and shading geometry in addition to other studied parameters. Based on the subjects' responses the contrast is only affected by reflection coefficient of the surfaces. Their satisfaction with amount of outside view is also influenced by WWR and number of windows. Moreover, based on statistical results defining a specific range of acceptable contrast based on the RAMMG metric is not suggested, and users' evaluation depends on the surface material in addition to the reflection coefficient of them. Furthermore, the level of lighting perceived by people is affected by materials and their color (beside the reflection coefficient of the surfaces), number of windows (even with similar WWR), and shading pattern (even with the same aperture ratio) as well as the glazing visible light transmittance.
Publication Details
Page(s) 45-59
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 10, Issue: 1, Year: 2023

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
virtual reality, metrics, Daylight perception, Material
References
Lowenhaupt Collins B.,Survey A Literature .1975 .- Psychological Reaction to environments with and without windows, natural bureau of standards building science series (Thesis). NBS Building Science Series, : .
K. M. J. Farley J. a.,Veitch A Room,With A Room .2001 .A View: A Review of the Effects of Windows on Work and Well-Being, National Reserch Council Canada. , : .
Boyce P. R. .2014 .Human factors in lighting. , : .
Edwards L.,Torcellini P. .2002 .A Literature Review of the Effects of Natural Light on Building Occupants A Literature Review of the Effects of Natural Light on Building Occupants. , : .
Veitch J. A.,Galasiu A. D. .2011 .The physiological and psychological effects of windows, daylight and view at home. National Research Council of Canada, : .
Veitch J. A.,Newsham G. R. .1998 .Lighting quality and energy-efficiency effects on task performance, mood, health, satisfaction, and comfort. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society, 27 : 107-129.
Wong L. T.,Mui K. W.,Hui P. S. .2008 .A multivariate-logistic model for acceptance of indoor environmental quality (IEQ) in offices. Building and Environment, 43 : 1-6.
P. M. Bluyssen M.,Aries P. van Dommelen .2011 .Comfort of workers in office buildings: The European HOPE project. Building and Environment, 46 : 280-288.
Astolfi A.,Pellerey F. .2008 .Subjective and objective assessment of acoustical and overall environmental quality in secondary school classrooms. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 123, : 163-17.
A. C. K. Lai K. W.,Mui L. T.,Wong L. Y.,Law L. Y. .2009 .An evaluation model for indoor environmental quality (IEQ) acceptance in residential buildings. Energy and Buildings, 41 : 930-936.
Bellazzi A. .2022 .Virtual reality for assessing visual quality and lighting perception: A systematic review. Building and Environment, 209 : 108674.
Parpairi K.,Baker N. V.,Steemers K. A.,Compagnon R. .2002 .The Luminance Differences index: A new indicator of user preferences in daylit spaces. Lighting Research & Technology, 34 : 53-66.
Buttler and P. M.Biner D. L. .1989 .Effects of setting onwindow prefrences and factors associated with those prefrences. Environment and Behavior, 21 : 17-31.
Stone N. J. .1998 .Windows and environmental cues on performance and mood. Environment and Behavior, 30 : 306-321.
Matusiak B. .2004 .The impact of lighting/daylighting and reflectances on the size impression of the room. full-scale studies. Architectural Science Review, 47 : 115-119.
U. P. Moscoso C.,Matusiak B. .2015 .and Svensson, Impact of window size and room reflectance on the perceived quality of a room. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 32 : .
Ne E.,Hopkinson R. G. .1970 .Critical minimum acceptable window size: A study of window design and provision of a view. Lighting Research and Technology, 2 : 17-27.
R. D. J. L. P.,CHAUVEL J. B. COLLINS .1982 .Glare from windows: current views of the problem. Lighting Research & Technology, 14 : 31-46.
Keighley E. C. .1973 .Visual requirements and reduced fenestration in offices - a study of multiple apertures and window area. Building Science, 8 : 321-331.
.1970 .. , 2 : 17-27.
.1999 .Department for Education & Employment, Departmental Report. , : .
Küller R.,Lindsten C. .1992 .Health and behavior of children in classrooms with and without windows. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 12 : 305-317.
Don R. P.,Aumann R. P. .2003 .Windows and classrooms : a study of student performance and indoor environment. CLIMA 2007 Wellbeing Indoors 2, : .
Shafavi N. S.,Tahsildoost M.,Zomorodian Z. S. .2020 .Investigation of illuminance-based metrics in predicting occupants' visual comfort (case study: Architecture design studios. Solar Energy 197, : 111-125.
Shafavi N. S.,Zomorodian Z. S.,Tahsildoost M.,Javadi M. .2021 .Occupants visual comfort assessments: A review of field studies and lab experiments. Solar Energy 208, : 249-274.
Bulow-Hube H. .1995 .Subjective reactions to daylight in rooms: Effect of using low emittance coatings on windows. Lighting Research & Technology, 1 : .
Newsham G. R.,Cetegen D.,Veitch J. A.,Whitehead L. .2010 .Comparing lighting quality evaluations of real scenes with those from high dynamic range and conventional images. ACM Transactions on Applied Perception, 7 : 1-26.
Hendrick C.,Martyniuk O.,Spencer T. J.,Flynn J. E. .1977 .Procedures for Investigating the Effect of Light on Impression. Environment and Behavior, 9 : 491-510.
Newsham G. R.,Richardson C.,Blanchet C.,Veitch J. A. .2005 .Lighting quality research using rendered images of offices. Lighting Research and Technology, 37 : 93-112.
Moscoso C.,Matusiak B.,Svensson U. P.,Orleanski K. .2015 .Analysis of stereoscopic images as a new method for daylighting studies. ACM Transactions on Applied Perception, 11 : 1-13.
Chamilothori K.,Wienold J.,Andersen M. .2019 .Adequacy of Immersive Virtual Reality for the Perception of Daylit Spaces: Comparison of Real and Virtual Environments. , 15 : 203-226.
Moscoso C.,Nazari M.,Matusiak B. S. .2021 .Stereoscopic Images and Virtual Reality techniques in daylighting research: A method-comparison study. Building and Environment, 214 : 108962.
C. DeCoro and N. Tatarchuk .2007 .Real-time mesh simplification using the GPU. ACM SIGGRAPH Symposium on Interactive 3D Graphics and Games, : 161-166.
W. R. S ,A. B. M. K. Craig ,Understanding Virtual .2003 .. , : .
Abd-Alhamid F.,Kent M.,Bennett C.,Calautit J.,Wu Y. .2019 .Developing an Innovative Method for Visual Perception Evaluation in a Physical-Based Virtual Environment. Building and Environment, 162 : 106278.
Chen Y.,Cui Z.,Hao L. .2019 .Virtual reality in lighting research: Comparing physical and virtual lighting environments. Lighting Research and Technology, 51 : 820-837.
Marín-Morales J.,Llinares C.,Guixeres J.,Alcañiz M. .2020 .Emotion recognition in immersive virtual reality: From statistics to affective computing. Sensors, 20 : 1-26.
Hegazy M.,Yasufuku K. .2020 .Visualizing user perception of daylighting : a comparison between VR and reality Visualizing user perception of daylighting. , : .
Hong T.,Lee M.,Yeom S.,Jeong K. .2019 .Occupant responses on satisfaction with window size in physical and virtual built environments. Building and Environment, 166 : 106409.
Marzouk M.,M. M.,Mahmoud A. .2022 .Analysing user daylight preferences in heritage buildings using virtual reality. Building Simulation 15, : 1561-1576.
Grace L. .2022 .Evaluating daylight lighting appearances in virtual environments. Undergraduate Research Scholars Program, : .
Kuliga S. F.,Thrash T.,Dalton R. C.,Hölscher C. .2015 .Virtual reality as an empirical research tool - Exploring user experience in a real building and a corresponding virtual model. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 54 : 363-375.
Bellazzi A. .2022 .Virtual reality for assessing visual quality and lighting perception: A systematic review. Building and Environment, 209 : 108674.
Chamilothori K.,Rodrigues J.,Dan-Glauser E. S.,Wienold J.,Andersen M. .2019 .Subjective and physiological responses to façade and sunlight pattern geometry in virtual reality. Building and Environment, 150 : 144-155.
Chamilothori K. .2019 .Perceptual effects of daylight patterns in architecture (Thesis. Laboratoire de Performance Intégrée au Design, : .
Sawyer A. O.,Chamilothori K. .2019 .Influence of Subjective Impressions of a Space on Brightness Satisfaction: an Experimental Study in Virtual Reality, Simulation For Architecture and Urban Design (SimAUD. , : .
Moscoso C.,Window Size .2020 .Effects on Subjective Impressions of Daylit Spaces: Indoor Studies at High Latitudes Using Virtual Reality, LEUKOS (. , : 1-23.
Flor J. F.,Aburas M.,Abd-AlHamid F.,Wu Y. .2020 .Virtual reality as a tool for evaluating user acceptance of view clarity through ETFE double-skin façades. Energy and Buildings, 231 : 110554.
Chinazzo G.,Chamilothori K.,Wienold J.,Andersen M. .2020 .Subjective Indoor Environmental Perception and Physiological Responses in Virtual Reality. Human Factors, : .
Latini A.,Giuseppe E. Di,M. D'Orazio C.,Di Perna C. .2021 .Exploring use of immersive virtual reality to assess occupants' productivity and comfort in workplaces: An experimental study on the role of walls colour. Energy and Buildings, 231 : 110554.
Niu S.,Pan W.,Zhao Y.,Reality A Virtual .2015 .Supported Approach to Occupancy Engagement in Building Energy Design for Closing the Energy Performance Gap. Procedia Engineering, 118 : 573-580.
Heydarian A.,Pantazis E.,Carneiro J. P.,Gerber D.,Becerik-Gerber B. .2016 .Lights, building, action: Impact of default lighting settings on occupant behaviour. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 48 : 212-223.
Heydarian A.,Carneiro J. P.,Gerber D.,Becerik-Gerber B.,Hayes T.,Wood W.,Zhao Y.,Ni J.,Tian Y.,Chen Y. .2023 .Comparing three XR technologies in reviewing performance-based building design: A pilot study of façade fenestrations, Computer animation. in: Rethinking Comprehensive Design: Speculative Counterculture - Proceedings of the 19th International Conference on Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia, CAADRIA, : 729-738.
Castilla N.,Higuera-Trujillo J. L.,Llinares C. .2023 .The effects of illuminance on students′ memory. A neuroarchitecture study. Building and Environment, 228 : 109833.
Veitch J. A.,Newsham G. R. .2000 .Preferred luminous conditions in practice recommendations. Lighting Research and Technology, 32 : 24-30.
K. Van Den Wymelenberg M.,Inanici P.,Johnson P. .2010 .The effect of luminance distribution patterns on occupant preference in a daylit office environment. LEUKOS, 7 : 103-122.
Chamilothori K.,Wienold J.,Moscoso C.,Matusiak B.,Andersen M. .2022 .Regional Differences in the Perception of Daylit Scenes across Europe Using Virtual Reality. Part II: Effects of Façade and Daylight Pattern Geometry. , 18 : 316-340.
-Ray Illumination V,August V .2020 .. [60] [62] [64] [66] [68] Chaosgroup, : .
Reinhart C.,Breton P.,LEUKOS P. .2009 .. Experimental Validation of Autodesk 3ds Max Design 2009 and Daysim 3, : 7-35.
Reinhard E.,Stark M.,Shirley P.,Ferwerda J. .2002 .Photographic tone reproduction for digital images. in: Proceedings of the 29th Annual Conference on Computer Graphics and Interactive Techniques, SIGGRAPH '02, : 267-276.
Cauwert C. .2013 .Influence of presentation modes on visual perceptions of daylit spaces. Thesis, : .
Duff J.,Kelly K.,Cuttle C. .2017 .Perceived adequacy of illumination, spatial brightness, horizontal illuminance and mean room surface exitance in a small office. Lighting Research and Technology, 49 : 133-146.
M. C. Dubois F.,Cantin K.,Johnsen W. K. E. Osterhaus .2007 .The effect of coated glazing on visual perception: A pilot study using scale models. Lighting Research and Technology, 39 : 283-304.
Rockcastle S.,Chamilothori K.,Andersen M.,Simulation M. .2017 .An Experiment in Virtual Reality to Measure Daylight-Driven Interest in Rendered Architectural Scenes. , : 2577-2586.
Tamura C.,Schweiker M.,Moosman C.,Edinburgh C. .2017 .Visual Perception and Daylight Variables : Experiments in a Climate Chamber. , : 8.
Guidolin E. .2014 .Impact of window amount and size on user perception , daylighting and energy demand in an office space. Università degli Studi di Padova, : .
Bartosh A.,Krietemeyer B. .2017 .Virtual Environment for Design and Analysis (VEDA): Interactive and Immersive Energy Data Visualizations for Architectural Design. Technology Architecture and Design, 1 : 50-60.
Hegazy M.,Yasufuku K.,Abe H. .2020 .Evaluating and visualizing perceptual impressions of daylighting in immersive virtual environments. Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering, : 1-17.
Y. B. W. Nornadiah Mohd Razali .2011 .Power comparisons of Shapiro-Wilk, Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Lilliefors and Anderson-Darling tests. journal of statistical modeling and analytics 2, : 21-33.
Lund M. .2018 .Testing for Normality using SPSS Statistics. , : .
Rizzi A.,Algeri T.,Marini D. .2004 .A proposal for contrast measure in digital images. in: CGIV 2004 - Second European Conference on Color in Graphics, Imaging, and Vision and Sixth International Symposium on Multispectral Color Science, : 187-192.
Rockcastle S.,Andersen M. .2015 .Human perceptions of daylight composition in architecture: A preliminary study to compare quantitative contrast measures with subjective user assessments in hdr renderings. in: 14th International Conference of IBPSA - Building Simulation, : 1205-1212.
Rockcastle S.,Amundadottir M. L.,Andersen M. .2017 .Contrast measures for predicting perceptual effects of daylight in architectural renderings. Lighting Research and Technology, 49 : 35-40.
Rockcastle S. F. .2017 .. , : .
Rockcastle S.,Andersen M. .2016 .Contrast measures for predicting perceptual effects of daylight in architectural renderings. Lighting Research & Technology, 49 : 35-40.
Zomorodian Z. S.,Tahsildoost M. .2019 .Assessing the effectiveness of dynamic metrics in predicting daylight availability and visual comfort in classrooms. Renewable Energy, 134 : 669-680.
Michael A.,Heracleous C. .2017 .Assessment of natural lighting performance and visual comfort of educational architecture in Southern Europe: The case of typical educational school premises in Cyprus. Energy and Buildings, 140 : 443-457.
Heydarian A.,Pantazis E.,Wang A.,Gerber D.,Becerik-Gerber B. .2017 .Towards user centered building design: Identifying end-user lighting preferences via immersive virtual environments. Automation in Construction, 81 : 56-66.
Heydarian A.,Carneiro J. P.,Gerber D.,Becerik-Gerber B. .2015 .Immersive virtual environments, understanding the impact of design features and occupant choice upon lighting for building performance. Building and Environment, 89 : 217-228.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

41

Views