No Detail Found!

Investigation of the Effect of Parametric Patterned Façade and Resulting Daylight Illuminance on Students' Mood and Task Performance in Architecture Studio-Based Tutoring

Author(s)
Yasmine Mahmoud Saad Abdelhamid Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University,,Egypt
Sherine M. Wahba Department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University,,Egypt
Mennat-Allah ElHusseiny Department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University,,Egypt
Abstract
Parametric design is one of the thriving contemporary architectural treatments that not only has an influence on the design of building envelopes but is capable of affecting the users physically and psychologically. The efficiency of the daylight resulting from the facade is greatly affected by the envelope's perforation shapes, sizes, and distribution. This research builds upon a prior study which investigated the effect of Parametric Patterned Façade on daylight performance, quality, and visual comfort concluding with the choice of the highest-performing pattern for daylight metrics. The chosen pattern is the “Triangles Pattern” which was put in situ where the field experiment took place. The current study analyzed the effect of illuminance, and illuminance distribution resulting from the parametric patterned facade on architecture students' mood and task performance in the setting of an architecture studio-based tutoring. Both quantitative and qualitative research methods were adopted; quantitative through the utilization of a Spatial Ability Test to assess students' task performance, and qualitative through a self-reporting mood assessment, and subjective daylight perception questionnaire. The analysis was conducted through three types of tests to investigate the research hypothesis; statistical analysis of hypothesis (t-test), PANAS schedule for mood assessment, and comparative analysis of the subjective questionnaire between the base case condition and the parametric patterned façade condition. The results of paired sample study indicated that the students' performance was enhanced after the exposure to the second condition (PPF condition) over the first (BC condition). Also, for the NA assessment, both PANAS assessment and t-test analysis results showed a difference in means between the two conditions indicating that there was an enhancement of the NA. Finally, a framework is proposed for the utilization of a Parametric Patterned façade in an educational setting. The implications of this experiment inform architects of the importance of daylighting techniques to enrich the educational environment, and how to establish a research methodology for the enhancement of daylight design using both technical and psychological approaches.
Publication Details
Page(s) 312-333
Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 11, Issue: 2, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Daylight, Task Performance, Parametric pattern, Parametric design
References
Razon A. A.,A A. A. .2017 .Study on Window Configuration to Enhance Daylight Performances on Working Space of an Architect's Office in Chittagong. International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 8(2) : 1-9.
S. M. M. Shemirani G. H.,Memarian S. P.,Naseri V.,Vaziri A .2011 .Survey on Day Lighting Design Strategies in Schools. Journal of American Science, 7(5) : 751-758.
K. R. Piparsania P.,Vaidya P. C.,Kalita P. C. .2020 .Evaluation of Daylight Performance of Classroom Spaces in Ahmedabad. NordDesign, : 1-12.
Yunitsyna A.,Toska A. .2023 .Evaluation of the Visual Comfort and Daylight Performance of the Visual Art Classrooms. Journal of Daylighting, 10 : 117-135.
Shishegar N.,Boubekri M. .2016 .Natural Light and Productivity: Analyzing the Impacts of Daylighting on Students' and Workers' Health and Alertness. Int'l Journal of Advances in Chemical Engg., & Biological Sciences, 3(1) : 1-6.
Dahlan A. S.,Mahmoud P.,Eissa A. .2015 .and. International Journal of Soft Computing and Engineering (IJSCE), 4(6) : 1-4.
Heschong L. .1999 .Daylighting in Schools An Investigation into the Relationship Between Daylighting and Human Performance, Pacific Gas. , : .
Buhari A. A.,Alibaba H. Z. .2019 .Analysis of Daylighting Quality in Institutional Libraries. International Journal of Electrical and Electronics Research, 7(4) : 6-20.
Maesano C.,I. C. .2016 .Annesi-maesano, Impact of Lighting on School Performance in European Classrooms. in CLIMA 2016 Conference, : 1-14.
Boubekri M. .2008 .. Architecture and Health Building Design Strategies, First Edition, : .
Ahadi A. A.,Masoudinejad M. .2016 .Improving student performance by proper utilization of daylight in educational environments ( Case study : IUST 1 School of Architecture ). Acta Technica Napocensis: Civil Engineering & Architecture, 59(1) : 1-21.
Rashwan A.,El L.,Sheta S. .2019 .Evaluation of the effect of integrating building envelopes with parametric patterns on daylighting performance in office spaces in hot-dry climate. Alexandria Engineering Journal, 58(2) : 551-557.
Islami S. Y.,Jafari Z. .2022 .The Significance of Aperture Proportion for the Lighting Behaviour and Transparency of Moshabak. Journal of Daylighting, 9 : 242-256.
Elbatran R. M.,Ismaeel W. S. E. .2021 .Applying a parametric design approach for optimizing daylighting and visual comfort in office buildings. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, 12(3) : 3275-3284.
Eltaweel A.,Su Y. .2017 .Parametric design and daylighting: A literature review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 73 : 1086-1103.
M. K. Fahmy M.,Elsoudany M. .2023 .Parametric Mashrabiya as a Shading System for Optimized Daylighting in Egypt. , 177 : 76-95.
.2001 .. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Air and Radiation, : .
P. J. Aarts V.,Duijnhoven V.,M. B. C. V. .2017 .Aries, Performance of Personally Worn Dosimeters to Study Non-Image Forming Effects of Light: Assessment Methods, Building. , 117 : 60-72.
Bishop D.,Chase J. G. .2023 .A Luminance-Based Lighting Design Method: A Framework for Lighting Design and Review of Luminance Measures. , 15 : 1-16.
Kruisselbrink T.,Dangol R.,Rosemann A. .2018 .and. Photometric Measurements of Lighting Quality: An Overview, Building and Environment, 138 : 42-52.
Leccese F.,Rocca M.,Buratti C.,Belloni E. .2020 .A Method to Assess Lighting Quality in Educational Rooms Using Analytic Hierarchy Process. Building and Environment, 168 : 1-15.
Pujiyanti I.,Rahmat A.,Riri H. .2022 .. Architectural Studio Room Lighting Level in UNISA Yogyakarta Based on Software Dialux Evo 9 . 1, Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, 671 : 201-205.
Husain F. H.,Husri Z.,Amani F. .2015 .: An Analysis on Lighting Efficiency of the Architecture Studio in UiTM Perak. in Proceedings of Postgraduate Conference on Global Green Issues (Go Green), : 113-118.
Abdelhamid Y.,Wahba S. M. .2023 .Menna ElHusseiny, The Effect of Parametric Patterned Façade Variations on Daylight Quality , Visual Comfort , and Daylight Performance in Architecture Studio-Based Tutoring. Journal of Daylighting, 10 : 173-191.
Obralic A.,Jeghel S. .2021 .. European Scientific Journal, 17(1) : 19-45.
Veitch J. A. .1996 .Determinations of Lighting Quality II: Research and Recommendations. in 104th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, : 1-38.
Figueiro M.,Kalsher M.,Steverson B.,Heerwagen J.,Kampschroer K.,Rea M. .2018 .Circadian-effective light and its impact on alertness in office workers. Lighting Research and Technology, 51 : 1-13.
M. S. Rea M.,Figueiro J. D.,Bullough J. D. .2002 .Circadian photobiology : an emerging framework for lighting practice and research. , 34(3) : 177-190.
Dai Q.,Cai W.,Shi W.,Hao L.,Wei M. .2017 .A proposed lighting-design space: circadian effect versus visual illuminance. Building and Environment, 122 : 287-293.
H. M. Mosharraf .2014 .The Importance of Environmental Psychology in Design of Educational Spaces. Advances in Environmental Biology, 8(22) : 766-771.
Bayz A.,Amin H. .2019 .. Sulaimani Journal for Engineering Sciences, 6(2) : 21-34.
Zhu Y.,Yang M.,Yao Y.,Xiong X.,Li X.,Zhou G. .2017 .Effects of Illuminance and Correlated Color Temperature on Daytime Cognitive Performance, Subjective Mood, and Alertness in Healthy Adults, Environment. , 51(2) : 199-230.
Beute F. .2014 .Powered by Nature: the Psychological Benefits of Natural Views and Daylight. Final Thesis Doctoral of Philosophy of Industrial Engineering and Innovation Sciences Technische Universiteit, : .
Blume C.,Garbazza C.,Spitschan M. .2019 .Effects of Light on Human Circadian Rhythms, Sleep. , 23 : 147-156.
Wang N.,Boubekri M. .2011 .Design recommendations based on cognitive, mood, and preference assessments in a sunlit workspace. Lighting Research and Technology, 43 : 55-72.
Gou Z.,Lau S. S.,Qian F. .2015 .Comparison of mood and task performance in naturally-lit and artificially-lit environments Indoor. , 24(1) : 27-36.
Díaz- A. .2020 .Positive and Negative Affect Schedule ( PANAS ): psychometric properties of the online Spanish version in a clinical sample with emotional disorders. BMC Psychiatry, 20(56) : 1-14.
A. Ugoni, .1995 .THE t TEST An introduction. COMSIG REVIEW, 4(2) : 37-40.
The .2024 .. html., : .
. .. , : 12.
Gerber A.,Berkowitz M. .2020 .Training spatial abilities. A Workbook for students of architecture. , : .
Berkowitz M.,Gerber A.,Thurn C. M. .2021 .Elsbeth Stern, Spatial Abilities for Architecture: Cross Sectional and Longitudinal Assessment With Novel and Existing Spatial Ability Tests. , 11 : 1-16.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

102

Views