Analyzing Passive Design Retrofits using Pareto Front Optimization to Reduce Operational Carbon in Commercial Laboratory Spaces

Lahari Vishwanath; D Kannamma

doi:10.15627/jd.2024.21

Author(s)

Lahari Vishwanath Architecture Department, National Institute of Technology,Tiruchirappalli,India

D Kannamma Architecture Department, National Institute of Technology,Tiruchirappalli,India

Abstract

Buildings are one of the leading sources of carbon emissions in the world. Most of the carbon emissions are released during the operation phase of the building. It is essential for buildings to provide thermal and visual comfort for the users. In the case of existing buildings, it is necessary to offer retrofit solutions so that the operational carbon emissions can be reduced without compromising on the other essential factors. In this study a Multi-Objective Optimization (MOO) of passive design strategies was conducted for a commercial laboratory in India situated in a moderate climate zone. The design variables considered for the study are wall and roof insulation, glazing material, window-wall ratio (WWR), depth of shading device and the number of shading devices used. The objective functions are: 1. reduced energy use intensity and operational carbon emissions, 2. increased thermal comfort hours and 3. increased daylight autonomy. Rhinoceros and grasshopper software along with Ladybug and Honeybee plug-ins were used for the study which resulted in 1296 iterations. MOO technique namely Pareto front optimization was used to optimize the objective functions. Out of 1296 solutions (excluding base case), 72 solutions were non-dominated. Two methods are described in the study to identify the recommendations for retrofit. The first method describes a Heuristic method of selection using Design Explorer recommending 5 good solutions. In the second method a factor is evolved to identify the 5 best solutions in sequential order. The overall study recommends the use of EPS insulation for the RCC roof, WWR of 20% on all sides, 3 horizontal shading devices of depth 0.75 m for all window openings. When compared with the base case scenario, this solution minimizes the EUI by 3.7%, maximizes average TCH by 106.6% and maximizes average DA by 66.9%. The overall operational carbon emissions are reduced by 7095.6 kgCO2.

Publication Details

Page(s) 290-311

DOI 10.15627/jd.2024.21

Published Journal: Journal of Daylighting, Volume: 11, Issue: 2, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords

Multi-objective Optimization, Thermal comfort, Daylight autonomy, Passive design strategies

References

UNEP .2020 .. 2020 GLOBAL STATUS REPORT FOR BUILDINGS AND CONSTRUCTION, : .

Danish ,Ozcan B,Ulucak R .2021 .An empirical investigation of nuclear energy consumption and carbon dioxide (CO2) emission in India: Bridging IPAT and EKC hypotheses, Nuclear Engineering. , 53 : 2056-2065.

Rawal R,Vaidya P,Ghatti V,Ward A,Seth S,Jain A .2012 .Energy Code Enforcement for Beginners: A Tiered Approach. , : .

Hensen J,Lamberts R .2011 .Building performance simulation for design and operation. , : 1-14.

Meadows DH,Meadows DL,Randers J,William W B .1972 .The limits to growth. , : 17-24.

.2024 .-meetings/what-are-united-nations-climatechange-conferences (accessed April 4,. , : .

.2024 .[7] What is the Kyoto Protocol?. , (accessed April 4) : .

.2024 .. , (accessed April 4) : .

Jankovic L .2017 .Designing zero carbon buildings using dynamic simulation methods. , : 3-8.

Modi .2024 .-speech-a-declaration-that-india-will-do-thingsdifferently/articleshow/87690172.cms?from=mdr (accessed April 4,. , : .

Satish Kumar .2010 .. Total Commercial Floor Space Estimates for India, : .

McKinsey .2009 .Company, Environment and energy sustainability - an approach for India. , : .

Manu S,Shukla Y,Rawal R,Thomas LE,De Dear R .2016 .Field studies of thermal comfort across multiple climate zones for the subcontinent: India Model for Adaptive Comfort (IMAC), Building. , 98 : 55-70.

Ihara T,Gustavsen A,Jelle BP .2015 .Effect of facade components on energy efficiency in office buildings. Applied Energy, 158 : 422-432.

Verma R,Rakshit D .2023 .Comparison of reflective coating with other passive strategies: A climate based design and optimization study of building envelope. Energy and Buildings, 287 : 112973.

Kreyszig E .2011 .. , : 970-1008.

Kamazani MA,Dixit MK .2023 .Multi-objective optimization of embodied and operational energy and carbon emission of a building envelope. Journal of Cleaner Production, 428 : 139510.

Abdeen A,Mushtaha E,Hussien A,Ghenai C,Maksoud A,Belpoliti V .2024 .Simulation-based multi-objective genetic optimization for promoting energy efficiency and thermal comfort in existing buildings of hot climate. , 21 : 101815.

Zahra Benaddi F,Boukhattem L,Cesar Tabares-Velasco P .2024 .Multi-objective optimization of building envelope components based on economic, environmental, and thermal comfort criteria. Energy and Buildings, 305 : 113909.

Giouri ED,Tenpierik M,Turrin M . .Zero energy potential of a high-rise office building in a Mediterranean climate: Using multi-objective [70]. , : .