No Detail Found!

Reviewers' Responses to Medical Research Articles.

Author(s)
Saba Sohail Department of Publications, College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan (CPSP), Karachi, Pakistan
Jamshed Akhtar Department of Publications, College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan (CPSP), Karachi, Pakistan
Abstract
Objective: To document the reviewers' responses in terms of reviewers' demographic and professional characteristics, promptness of reply, and duration of reply to the request to review medical research articles for a general biomedical research journal. Study Design: Cross-sectional, observational study. Place and Duration of Study: Department of Publications, College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan (CPSP), from October to December 2015. Methodology: Peer reviewed articles edited by a single staff editor were included. Editorials and correspondence were excluded. Manuscript category, discipline, and the total number of reviewers per manuscript were noted. Responses were divided into no response, regrets, and responded, i.e. provided with the review comments; and further sub-divided into timely response, i.e. within 21 days, or later. Total duration of response was counted in days from the date of dispatch to the date of receiving. Among those who provided a review, reviewers' characteristics were noted as designation, institute affiliation, qualification, and gender. Number and percentages of the studied variables were determined. Chi-square test of proportions was used for comparing the proportions with significance at p<0.05. Results: Reviewers for 50 articles including 28 original articles, 15 case reports, three letters to the editor, two short communications, and two new techniques, were evaluated. A total of 598 reviewers were contacted for those 50 articles; forming an average of 11.96 reviewers contacted and 2.2 responded per manuscript. Four hundred and seventy (78.59%) did not reply at all, 18 (3.01%) regretted, and 110 (18.39%) responded (79/110=71.81% timely, and 31/110=28.18% late). Earliest reply was received in one day and the delayed reply in 87 days. Maximum number of reviewers was 24 for a single original article (internal medicine) and 22 for a case report (cardiology). Significantly, more fellows, professors and females (p=0.004, p=0.002, and p=0.017, respectively) provided timely response. Conclusion: An overwhelming majority of the reviewers did not reply at all despite the incentives of CME credits and honorarium, adversely affecting the processing time. Majority of those who replied, were on time. Reasons for those who did not reply need to be explored.
Publication Details
Page(s) 29-32
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Journal of College of Physicians and Surgeons--Pakistan : JCPSP, Volume: 29, Issue: 1, Year: 2019

Request the full text from PASTIC

References
LovejoyTI,RevensonTA,FranceCR, 2011.Reviewing manuscripts for peer-review journals: a primer for novice and seasoned reviewers,Ann Behav Med 42 1 -13
TriggleCR,TriggleDJ, 2007.What is the future of peer review? Why is there fraud in science? Is plagiarism out of control? Why do scientists do bad things? Is it all a case of: "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing",Vasc Health Risk Manag 3 39 -53
KurdiMS, 2015.Scholarly peer reviewing: The art, its joys and woes,Indian J Anaesth 59 465 -70
SohailS. Fortifying, 2015.the external peer review: An editorial perspective,J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 25 2 -3
TiteL,SchroterS., 2007.Why do peer reviewers decline to review? A survey,J Epidemiol Community Health 61 9 -12
NguyenVM,HaddawayNR,GutowskyLF,WilsonAD,GallagherAJ,DonaldsonMR, 2015.How long is too long in contemporary peer review? Perspectives from authors publishing in conservation biology journals,PLoS One 10 e0132557 -
MutzR,BornmannL,DanielHD, 2012.Heterogeneity of inter-rater reliabilities of grant peer reviews and its determinants: a general estimating equations approach,PLoS One 7 e48509 -
GilbertJR,WilliamsES,LundbergGD, 1994.Is there gender bias in JAMA's peer review process,JAMA 272 139 -42
Das D. TH-C-, 2016.Improving manuscript quality via structured reviews, enhanced scientific category Taxonomy, and outreach,Med Phy 43 3868 -9
GasparyanAY,YessirkepovM,VoronovAA,GerasimovAN,KostiyukovaEL,KitasGD, 2015.Preserving the integrity of citations and references by all stakeholders of science communication,J Korean Med Sc 30 1545 -52
FranceCR, 2011.Reviewing manuscripts for peer-review journals: a primer for novice and seasoned reviewers,Ann Behav Med 42 1 -13
HoRC,MakKK,TaoR,LuY,DayJR,PanF., 2013.Views on the peer review system of biomedical journals: an online survey of academics from high-ranking universities,BMC Med Res Methodol 13 74 -
GargPK, 2015.Financial incentives to reviewers; double-edged sword,J Korean Med Sci 30 832 -3
GasparyanAY,GerasimovAN,VoronovAA,KilasGD, 2015.Rewarding peer reviewers: Maintaining the integrity of science communication,J Korean Med Sci 30 360 -4
DiamandisEP, 2017.The current peer review system is unsustainable - awaken the paid reviewer force!,Clin Biochem 50 461 -3
VercelliniP,BuggioL,ViganoP,SomiglianaE., 2016.Peer review in medical journals: beyond quality of reports towards transparency and public scrutiny of the process,Eur J Int Med 31 15 -9
GasparyanAY,KitasGD, 2012.Best peer reviewers and the quality of peer review in biomedical journals,Croat Med J 53 386 -9
CohenA,PattanaikS,KumarP,BiesRR,de BoerA,FerroA, 2016.Organised crime against the academic peer review system,Br J Clin Pharmacol 81 1012 -7
LarsonBP,ChungKC, 2012.A systematic review of peer review for scientific manuscripts,Hand (NY) 7 37 -44
0

Citations

0

Downloads

35

Views