No Detail Found!

Reviewing a Manuscript: Disparity Amongst Peer Reviewers' Priorities from Basic Health Sciences and Clinicians.

Author(s)
Saeeda Baig Biochemistry, Ziauddin University, Karachi, Pakistan
Sana Ahmed Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry, Karachi, Pakistan
Hira Attique Basic Health Sciences, Ziauddin University, Karachi, Pakistan
Abstract
Objective: To determine the disparities and the priorities of basic health scientists and clinicians while assessing a manuscript. Study Design: Cross-sectional study. Place and Duration of Study: The study was conducted at Karachi, from January to April 2014. Methodology: The study was a proforma-based research, employed convenient sampling for data collection, in which 100 reviewers belonging to clinical and basic health science background were selected. The questionnaire used was a selfadministered one with close-ended questions. The results were analysed using SPSS software. Results: Out of 100 respondents, 50 were from Basic Health Sciences Reviewers (BRs) and 50 Clinicians Reviewers (CRs). The results depicted grammatical and improper referencing amongst formatting mistakes as the most common observation by the reviewers. The reviewers also raised concerns regarding validity of statistical analysis, use of outdated references and lack of acknowledgment of the sources of funding utilised by the authors. There were elements of manuscripts that BRs and CRs reviewers agreed upon and prioritised, but there were elements of the manuscript that they approached mostly in methods, results and conclusion components. Conclusion: The priorities of reviewers from Basic Health Sciences and Clinical background differed markedly in certain respects. This impacts how they review the manuscripts.
Publication Details
Page(s) 677-680
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Journal of College of Physicians and Surgeons--Pakistan : JCPSP, Volume: 26, Issue: 8, Year: 2016

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Medical research manuscript. Peer review. Biomedical research. Clinical research.
References
KronickDA, 1990.Peer review in 18th-century scientific journalism,JAMA 263 1321 -2
2011.Scientific peer review,Annu Rev Inf Sci Technol 45 197 -245
CroninB., 2005.The hand of science: Academic writing, -
HemlinS,RasmussenSB, 2006.The shift in academic quality control,Science, Technol Human Values 31 173 -98
LamontM., 2009.Reviewing peer review, -
AlbertsB,HansonB,KelnerKL, 2008.Reviewing peer review,Science 321 15 -
HojatM,GonnellaJS,CaelleighAS, 2003.Impartial judgment by the “gatekeepers” of science: Fallibility and accountability in the peer review process,Adv Health Sci Educ 8 75 -96
LovejoTI,RevensonTA,FranceCR, 2011.Reviewing manuscripts for peer-review journals: A primer for novice and seasoned reviewers,Ann Behav Med 42 1 -13
FlaminioS,ClaudioG, 2012.Saint Matthew strikes again: An agentbased model of peer review and the scientific community structure,J Informetr 6 265 -75
HamesI., 2007.Peer review and manuscript management in scientific journals: Guidelines for good practice,Published Online -
ArmstrongJS, 1997.Peer review for journals: Evidence on quality control, fairness, and innovation,Sci Eng Ethics 3 63 -84
CampanarioJM, 1998.Peer review for journals as it stands today,Science Communication 19 81 -211
OverbekeJ,WagerE., 2003.The state of the evidence: What we know and what we don't know about journal peer review,Peer review in health sciences. London 45 -61
SpeckBW, 1993.Publication peer review: An annotated bibliography, 7 -
1995.Refereeing of scholarly works for primary publishing,Annu Rev Inf Sci Technol 30 213 -50
DemicheliV, 2007.Peer review for improving the quality of grant applications,Cochrane Database Syst Rev 18 MR000003 -
RonaldNK, 2004.Research program peer review: Purposes, principles, practices, protocols, -
WesselyS., 1998.Peer review of grant applications: What do we know?,Lancet 352 301 -5
PitkinRM,BranaganMA, 1998.Can the accuracy of abstracts be improved by providing specific instructions? A Randomized Controlled Trial,JAMA 280 267 -9
EzealaC,NwekeI,EzealaM., 2013.Common errors in manuscript submitted to medical science journals,Ann Med Health Sci Res 3 376 -9
DuranRP,EisenhartMA,EricksonFD,GrantCA,GreenJL,HedgesLV, 2006.Standards for reporting on empirical social science research in AERA publications American Educational Research Association,Educ Res 35 33 -40
BooteDN,BeileP, 2005.Scholars before researchers: On the centrality of the dissertation literature review in research preparation,Educ Res 4 3 -15
0

Citations

0

Downloads

59

Views