No Detail Found!

Peer-assisted Learning: Who Should Be the Tutor, Fellow Student or Senior Resident?.

Author(s)
Shahid Sarwar Department of Medicine, Gujranwala Medical College, Gujranwala, Pakistan
Shandana Tarique Department of Medicine, Gujranwala Medical College, Gujranwala, Pakistan
Abstract
Objective: To compare student-tutor guided peer-assisted learning (ST PAL) and resident-tutor guided peer-assisted learning (RT PAL) for its impact on performance of students in summative assessment. Study Design: Quasi-experimental study. Place and Duration of Study: Gujranwala Medical College, from February to September 2015. Methodology: Four batches each of final year MBBS students were first trained for clinical skills by resident-tutors for 2 weeks and had a pre-test. Two students with highest marks were selected as student-tutors. Half of the batch had a further 2 weeks skill training by the student-tutors while other half by resident-tutor, post-test was carried out after 2 weeks. Improvement in scores was compared between ST PAL and RT PAL groups, using unpaired student t-test. The batch underwent same intervention for the next month with cross-over of ST PAL and RT PAL groups. Results: Study population was 152 out of expected 188 as batch D underwent the study only once and 13 students were either absent or had decline in scores, so were excluded. Among 74 (48.68%) ST PAL and 78 (51.23%) RT PAL students, median improvement in scores was 8 for ST PAL group as compared to 7 for RT PAL group; the difference was not statistically significant (p= 0.61). Conclusion: Student-tutor guided peer-assisted learning is as effective as resident-tutor peer assisted learning in improving performance of the students.
Publication Details
Page(s) 573-576
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Journal of College of Physicians and Surgeons--Pakistan : JCPSP, Volume: 26, Issue: 7, Year: 2016

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Assessment. Peer-assisted learning. Resident-tutor. Student-tutor
References
MuradMH,VarkeyP, 2008.Self-directed learning in health profession education,Ann Acad Med Singapore 37 580 -90
AagaardE,TeheraniA,IrbyDM, 2004.Effectiveness of the one minute preceptor model for diagnosing the patient and learner: Proof of concept,Acad Med 79 42 -9
HenningJM,WeidnerTG,JonesJ, 2006.Peer assisted learning in the athletic training and clinical setting,J Athl Train 41 102 -8
2015.Peer assisted learning. Benefits to the participants,(Cited October 23 -
KassabS,Abu-HijlehMF,Al-ShaboulQ,HamdyH, 2005.Student led tutorials in problem based learning: Educational outcomes and student's perceptions,Med Teach 29 521 -6
GlynnLG,MacFarlaneA,KellyM,CantillonP,MurphyAW, 2006.Helping each other to learn: A process evaluation of peer assisted learning,BMC Med Educ 6 18 -
BoudD,CohenRS,SampsonJ, 2001.,Peer learning in higher education -
GlynnLG,MacFarlaneA,KellyM,CantillonP,MurphyAW, 2006.Helping each other to learn: A process evaluation of peer assisted learning,BMC Med Edu 6 18 -
VygotskyLS, .Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes, -
KnobeM,MunkerR,SelleiRM,HolschenM,MooijSC,Schmidt, 2010.Peer teaching: A randomized controlled trial using student teachers to teach musculoskeletal ultrasound,Med Educ 44 148 -55
HendelmanWJ, 1986.Reciprocal peer teaching by medical students in the gross anatomy laboratory,J Med Educ 61 674 -80
GeorgeJH,DotoFX, 2001.A simple five step method of teaching clinical skills,Fam Med 33 577 -8
Lawshe CH, 1975.A quantitative approach to content validity,Personnel Psychology 28 563 -75
YawarA,ShahSS, 2003.Faculty and student survey: Methods of imparting knowledge suitable for undergraduate medical students,J Med Res 42 245 -9
KwanCY, 2000.What is problem based learning (PBL)? It is magic, myth and mindset,Center Develop Teach Learn Brief 3 1 -2
ArnoldL,ShueCK,KrittB,GinsburgS,StemDT, 2005.Medical students views on peer assessment of professionalism,J Gen Intern Med 20 819 -24
NestelD,KiddJ, 2003.Peer tutoring in patient centered interviewing skills in experience of a project for first year students,Med Teach 25 398 -403
WatkinsC, 2005.Classrooms as learning communities: What's in it for schools, -
HeckmannJG,DutschM,RauchC,LangC,WeihM,Schwab S, 2008.Effects of peer assisted training during the neurology clerkship: A randomized controlled study,Eur J Neurol 15 1365 -70
BurkeJ,FayazS,GrahamK,MethewR,FieldM., 2007.Peer assisted learning in the acquisition of clinical skills: A supplementary approach to musculo-skeletal system,Med Teach 29 577 -82
NaqiSA, 2014.Peer assisted learning as a formal instructional tool,J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 24 169 -72
DonohoeCL,ConneelyJB,ZilbertN,HennessyM,SchofieldS,ReynoldsJV, 2015.Peer-assisted learning improves the knowledge gain of tutors in the highest quartile of achievement but not those in the lowest quartile,J Surg Educ S1931 -7204
KummalagaM,Thabrew H, 2011.Student led peer assisted learning: The Kuppi experience at the medical school of the university of Ruhuna in Sri Lanka,Educ Health 24 1 -13
HudsonJN,TonkinAL, 2008.Clinical skills education: Outcomes of relationships between junior medical students, senior peers and simulated patients,Med Educ 42 901 -8
ManzoorI., 2014.Peer assisted versus expert assisted learning: A comparison of effectiveness in terms of academic scores,J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 24 825 -9
0

Citations

0

Downloads

75

Views