Objective To compare the medical and surgical treatments for early ethmoidal nasal polyps. Subjects and Methods Sixty patients of grade I and II ethmoidal nasal polyps were selected through non-probability convenience sampling technique. They were divided in two groups; A and B with 30 patients in each group. In group A, patients were given medical treatment i.e. tablet prednisolone 0.5mg/kg/day for fourteen days in tapering doses along with two puffs of intranasal fluticasone in both nasal cavities equivalent to 50mcg/spray for three months while in group B, patients were treated surgically i.e. intranasal polypectomy with intranasal ethmoidectomy. The outcome in both groups was compared by evaluating reduction in size of polyps, nasal obstruction, sense of smell, postnasal drip and snoring. Results Mean age of the patients was 34.11±9.48 years. Male to female ratio was 1.7:1. Out of total 60 patients, 23 patients had grade I polyps while 37 patients had grade 2 polyps. 17 grade 1 polyps were treated medically while 6 were treated surgically. Similarly, 13 grade 2 polyps were treated medically and 24 were treated surgically. At the end of treatment, in Group A, reduction in polyp size to grade 0 was seen in 66% of the patients while it was seen in 90% of the patients in group B. There was significant reduction in nasal obstruction, post nasal drip and snoring with surgical treatment however sense of smell showed significant improvement with medical treatment. Conclusion Intranasal polypectomy with intranasal ethmoidectomy was better than oral plus intranasal steroids in regard to reduction in size of polyps, nasal obstruction, post nasal drip and snoring. However, loss of smell is better controlled with medical treatment.