No Detail Found!

Effectiveness of MCQs in Assessing Higher Order Cognition.

Author(s)
EHSAN SB Department of Medical Education, Punjab Medical College, Faisalabad,
Abstract
“If an assessment asks students to evaluate and create but our instruction asks only that they remember and comprehend, then we have taken a wrong direction”. (unknown) Researchers and educators have agreed upon this fact that there is no one method or tool by which we can assess a person's full ability. Assessment is an important part of curriculum and it needs proper planning and implementation because it not only helps in assessing student's ability, it also drives student's learning1. Thus planning, construction and implementation of assessment is not an easy task. In 1956, Dr Benjamin Bloom a psychologist and a team of educational experts presented three major domains of learning. These are cognitive, psychomotor skills and attitude or behavior. These three domains are present in every educational system but in medical education, it is worth imperative. It is stated that educators have to be very careful while designing curriculum, so that they design teaching methodologies and assessments keeping in mind all the learning domains.2 Cognition is the major domain which gives foundation for skills and behaviors. Cognitive is further explained by Bloom by dividing it into low order thinking and high order thinking process. It is commonly known as Bloom's taxonomy of understanding or knowledge. There are six categories i.e. recall, understanding, application, analysis, evaluation and synthesis. It is considered to be the stages of difficulty levels. One should master one stage before moving to the next. In short, this taxonomy gives us a panorama of range of educational possibilities against which any curriculum can be contrasted or compared.3 Written assessments are designed keeping in mind all the outcomes or objectives based on Bloom's taxonomies which help the assessors to assess different categories/levels of knowledge. In Bloom's Taxonomy first two levels are regarded as lower order learning or recall and rest of the four levels up to creation have been called higher order learning levels.4 These two broad levels of learning can be tested with written assessment. There are two major forms of written assessments, one is constructed response and other one is selected response format. Multiple choice questions, a selected response format, have been used very successfully for last many years. Selected res-
Publication Details
Page(s) 269-272
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Biomedica, Volume: 33, Issue: 4, Year: 2017

Request the full text from PASTIC

References
CaseSM,SwansonDB,,1999,Constructing written test questions for the basic and clinical sciences,,,-
Kern , Thomas, Hughes.,,1998,Curriculum development for medical education A six step approach,second edition,,-
KrathwohlDR,,2002,A revision of bloom's taxonomy, an overview,,,-
Anderson , L.W.,Krathwohl , D. R,,2001,A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom's Taxonomy of Educational Objectives,,,-
Ebel , R. L.,,1972,Essentials of educational measurement,Englewood Cliffs,,-
Kaufman,,2001,Assessing medical students: hit or miss,Student BMJ,,87-88
Van Der Vleuten , C.,,1996,The assessment of professional competence: developments, research and practical implications,Advances in Health Sciences Education,,41-67
PaulMcCoubrie,,2004,Improving the fairness of multiplechoice questions:a literature review,Medical Teacher,26,709-712
BerkR.A.,,1986,A consumers guide to setting performance standards on criterion referenced tests,Review of educational research,,137-172
Case , S.M.,Swanson , D.B.,Constructing Written,,2001,Test Questions for the Basic,Clinical Sciences, 3rd ed. (Philadelphia, National Board of Medical Examiners),,-
HaladynaTM,,1991,Developing and validating multiplechoice test items,Lawrence Er1baum,,-
HaladynaTM,,1994,Developing and validating multiple-choice test items,lawrence Er1baum,,-
BeanlandC,,1999,Schneider Z. etal. Nursing research: methods, critical appraisal and utilization,Mosby,,-
PolitOF,HunglerBP,,1999,Nursing research: principles and methods,Lippincott Williams & Wilkins,,-
ConsidineJ.,BottiM.,ThomasS.,,2005,Design, format, validity and reliability of multiple choice questions for use in nursing research and education,Collegian,12,-
GravetterF.,WallnauL,,2000,Statistics for the behavioral sciences,Wadsworth/Thomson Learning,,-
,,Essentials ofpsychological testing,Harper Collins,2990,-
Nunnally J. BernsteinI.,,1994,Psychometric theory,McGraw Hill,,-
DowningSM.,YudkowskyR..,,2009,Assessment in health professions education,,,-
Kane , M.,T.M. Haladyna,,,Content-related validity evidence in test development,Handbook of test development 2006,,131-153
LinnR,GronlundN.,,2000,Measurement and assessment in teaching,Prentice Hall,,-
Cronbach , L.J.,Meehl , P.E.,,1955,Construct validity in psychological tests,Psychological Bulletin,52,281-302
ViolatoC,,1991,Item difficulty and discrimination as a function of stem completeness,,69,739-743
Masters , J.,Hulsmeyer , B.,Pike , M.,Leichty , K.,Miller , M.,Verst , A.,,2001,Assessment of multiple-choice questions in selected test banks accompanying test books used in nursing education,Journal of Nursing Education;,40,25-32
Downing , S.M.,,2002,Threats to the validity of locally developed multiple choice tests in medical education: Construct-irrelevant variance and construct underrepresentation,Advances in Health Sciences Education,7,235-241
Honey , M.,Marshall , D.,Ascilite,,,The impact of on-line multiple choice questions on undergraduate student nurses' learning,Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education; 2003,1,236-243
0

Citations

0

Downloads

52

Views