No Detail Found!

Injection Sclerotherapy Versus Rubber Band Ligation for Second Degree Hemorrhoids.

Author(s)
Muhammad Ali Nasir Pakistan Air Force(PAF)Hospital, Mianwali Pakistan
Rehan Masroor Pakistan Air Force(PAF)Hospital, Mianwali Pakistan
Yasir Arafat Pakistan Air Force(PAF)Hospital, Mianwali Pakistan
Qasim Butt Combined Military Hospital Kohat/National University of Medical Sciences (NUMS) Pakistan
Shakil Sarwar Pakistan Air Force(PAF)Hospital, Mianwali Pakistan
Abstract
Objective: To compare the efficacy of injections Sclerotherapy (IST) and rubber band ligation (RBL) for the treatment of 2nd degree haemorrhoids in terms of improvement in symptoms severity score (SS score) in OPD patients. Study Design: Randomized controlled trial. Place and Duration of Study: It was conducted in surgical OPD of CMH Kohat, from 15th October 2010 to 10th April 2011 Material and Methods: A total of 116 patients with symptomatic 2nd degree haemorrhoids were randomly divided into two groups, RBL and IST (58 patients each) respectively and a baseline symptoms severity score was noted for each patient. Patients in RBL group were treated with RBL while in IST group were treated with IST. The outcome measures were relief of symptoms and improvement in SS score. Results: In RBL group, baseline SS score was 4.67 ± 2.01 which reduced to final mean SS score of 1.34 ± 0.96 whereas in IST group the baseline SS score was of 4.31 ± 2.13 which reduced to a final mean SS score of 1.6 ± 0.97. 44 (75.95%) patients had complete recovery and control of bleeding in RBL group; whereas in IST group 32 (55.1%) of the patients had this response by the end of two weeks. Conclusion: Rubber band ligation was found to have better patient outcomes as compared to injections sclerotherapy in treatment of 2nd degree hemorrhoids.
Publication Details
Page(s) 996-1002
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Pakistan Armed Forces Medical Journal, Volume: 67, Issue: 6, Year: 2017

Request the full text from PASTIC

References
HardyA,ChanCLH,CohenCRG,,2005,The surgical management of hemorrhoids-A review,Dig Surg,22,26,33
ReeseGE,von RoonAC,TekkisPP,,2009,,Clin Evid (online),,,
ShanmugamV,TahaMA,RabindranathKS,CampbellKL,SteeleRJ,LoudonMA,,2005,Systemic review of randomized trials comparing rubber band ligation with excisional haemorrhoidectomy,Br J Surg,92,1481,87
BouskelaE,SvensjoE,CyrinoFZ,LerondL,,1997,Oxidant-induced increase in vascular permeability is inhibited by oral administration of S-5682 (Daflon 500 mg) and alpha-tocopherol,Int J Microcirc Clin Exp,17,18,20
LyerVS,ShrierI,,2004,Gordon PH. Long term outcome of rubber band ligation for symptomatic primary and recurrent internal hemorrhoids,Dis Colon Rectum,47,1364,70
DehongY,XinQY,YantingH. Update,,2000,and improve haemorrhoids diagnosis and treatment,Chinese J Surg,38,890,91
FukudaA,KajiyamaT,KishimotoH,ArakawaH,SakaiM,,2005,Colonoscopic classification of internal hemorrhoids: usefulness in endoscopic band ligation,J Gastroenterol Hepatol,20,46,50
SadlerTW,,2009,Langman's medical embryology,Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins;,,,
HardyA,ChanCL,CohenCR,,2005,The surgical management of haemorrhoids A review,Dig Surg,22,26,33
CataldoP,EllisCN,GregorcykS,HymanN,BuieWD,ChurchJ,,2005,Practice parameters for the management of hemorrhoids (revised),Dis Colon Rectum,48,189,94
BronsteinM,IssaN,GutmanM,NeufieldD,,2008,Ligation under vision of haemorrhoidal cushions for therapy of bleeding haemorrhoids,Tech Coloproctol,12,119,22
SuMY,TungSY,WuCS,SheenIS,ChenPC,,2003,Chiu CT. Long term results of endoscopic hemorrhoidal ligation: two different devices with similar results,Endoscopy,35,416,20
DaviesRJ,,2006,,Clin Evid,15,711,24
KwokSY,ChungCC,TsuiKK,LiMK,,2005,A double-blind, randomized trial comparing Ligasure and Harmonic Scalpel hemorrhoidectomy,Dis Colon Rectum,48,344,48
GuptaPJ,,2004,Radiofrequency coagulation versus rubber bandligation in early haemorrhoids: pain versus gain,Medicina (Kaunas),40,232,7
BenzoniE,MilanE,CeratoF,NarisettiP,BresadolaV,TerrosuG,,2006,Second degree haemorrhoids: patient's satisfaction, immediate and long term results of rubber band ligation treatment,Minerva Chir,61,119,24
TakanoM,IwadareJ,OhbaH,TakamuraH,MasudaY,MatsuoK,,2006,Sclerosing therapy of internal hemorrhoids with a novel sclerosing agent,Comparison with ligation and excision Int J Colorectal Dis,21,44,51
SuppiahA,PerryEP,,2005,Jaundice as a presentation of phenol induced hepatotoxicity following injection sclerotherapy for haemorrhoids,Surgeon,3,43,4
Al-GhnaniemR,LeatherAJ,RennieJA,,2001,Survey of methods of treatment of hemorrhoids and complications of injection sclerotherapy,Ann R Coll Surg Engl,83,325,8
WatsonNFS,LiptrottS,Maxwell-Armstrong CA,,2006,A Prospective audit of early pain and patient satisfaction following outpatient band ligation of Haemorrhoids,Ann R Coll Surg Engl,88,275,79
JorgeJM,WexnerSD,MorgadoPJ,JamesK,NoguerasJJ,JagelmanDG,,1994,Optimization of sphincter function after the ileoanal reservoir procedure: a prospective randomized trial,Dis Colon Rectum,37,419,23
MajidA,MalikAM,ButtMQ,,2006,Hemorrhoids management by rubber band ligation,Professional Med J,13,664,68
AftabML,,1997,A comparative analysis of infrared coagulation and injection sclerotherapy as non-operative treatment for the management of haemorrhoids,Biomedica,13,70,2
MahmoodS,MalikAU,QureshiS,KhanIA,,2001,Rubber bandligation vs injection sclerotherapy in early haemorrhoids,Ann KE Med Coll,7,219,23
SaleemSM,ArbabGR,QayyumA,GorayaAA,AhmedJ,,2001,Results of injection sclerotherapy in 1st and 2nd degree hemorrhoids,Pakistan J Med Res,40,27,8
OliverGC,,2001,Office Management of Hemorrhoids: Banding, sclerotherapy and excision of thrombosis,Operative Techniques in Gen Surg,3,78,85
Al-GhnaniemR,LeatherAJ,RennieJA,,2001,Survey of methods of treatment of haemorrhoids and complications of injection sclerotherapy,Ann R Coll Surg Engl,83,325,8
0

Citations

0

Downloads

128

Views