No Detail Found!

Effectiveness of Horizontal Peer-assisted Learning in Physical Examination Performance.

Author(s)
Inamullah Shah Department of Surgery, Foundation University Medical College, Islamabad, Pakistan
Usman Mahboob Khyber Medical University, Peshawar, Pakistan
Sajida Shah Department of Radiology, Shifa International Hospital, Islamabad-Pakistan
Abstract
Background: All students cannot be individually trained in physical examination skills due to faculty and time limitations. Peer-assisted learning (PAL) can solve this dilemma if it is used in undergraduate curriculum. Empirical effectiveness of horizontal peer-assisted learning model has not been reported previously. The objective of this study was to compare horizontal peer-assisted learning (PAL) with expert-assisted learning (EAL) in teaching of physical examination skills. Methods: This is a randomized controlled study (Solomon four group design) carried out at a medical school. A total of 120 undergraduate year 5 students were randomized into two groups to undergo training in four areas of physical examination. Stratified random sampling technique was used. Group 1 was trained by EAL while Group 2 by PAL. Half students from both groups were given a pre-test to assess the testing effect. Both groups were given a post-test in the form of an OSCE. Independent samples t-test and paired sample t-test were used as tests of significance. Results: Group 2 scored significantly higher than Group 1. There was significant difference (p=.000) in mean post-test scores of Group-1 (69.98±5.6) and Group-2 (85.27±5.6). Difference in mean scores was not significant (p=.977) between students who had taken the pre-test and those who had not. Conclusion: This study has implications in curriculum development as it provides quantitative evidence indicating that horizontal PAL as a learning strategy can actually replace, rather than augment, expert-assisted learning in teaching clinical skills to undergraduate students.
Publication Details
Page(s) 559-565
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Journal of Ayub Medical College, Volume: 29, Issue: 4, Year: 2017

Request the full text from PASTIC

References
BuckleyS,ColemanJ,DavisonI,KhanKS,ZamoraJ,MalickS,,,The educational effects of portfolios on undergraduate student learning: a Best Evidence Medical Education (BEME) systematic review,BEME Guide No. 11.,,,
LiewSC,SowCF,SidhuJ,NadharajaVD,,2015,The near-peer tutoring programme: embracing the “doctors-to-teach” philosophy - a comparison of the effects of participation between the senior and junior near-peer tutors,Med Educ Online,20,27959,
KhawC,,2016,The outcomes and acceptability of nearpeer teaching among medical students in clinical skills,Int J Med Educ,7,188,94
PreeceR,DickinsonEC,SherifM,IbrahimY,NinanAS,AildasaniL,,2015,Peer-assisted teaching of basic surgical skills,Med Educ Online,20,27579,
MortelTF,SilberbergPL,AhernCM,Pitt SW,,2016,Supporting near-peer teaching in general practice: a national survey,BMC Med Educ,16,143,54
RiazI.,,2014,Peer assisted versus expert assisted learning: A Comparison of effectiveness in terms of academic scores,J Coll Physicians Surg Pakistan,24,825,9
BerghmansI,DruineN,DochyF,StruyvenK.,,2012,A facilitative versus directive approach in training clinical skills? Investigating students' clinical performance and perceptions,Perspect Med Educ,1,104,18
BurgessA,McGregorD,MellisC,,2014,Medical students as peer tutors: a systematic review,BMC Med Educ,14,115,22
MenezesA,BurgessA,ClarkeAJ,MellisC,,2016,Peer-assisted learning in medical school: tutees' perspective,Adv Med Educ Pract,7,31,8
WeberschockTB,GinnTC,ReinholdJ,StrametzR,KrugD,BergoldM,,2005,Change in knowledge and skills of Year 3 undergraduates in evidence-based medicine seminars,Med Educ,39,665,71
RingstedC,HodgesB,SherpbierA.,,2011,The research compass': An introduction to research in medical education:,AMEE Guide No. 56. Med Teach,33,695,709
LarsenDP,ButlerAC,RoedigerHL,,2008,Test-enhanced learning in medical education,Med Educ,42,959,66
TeddlieC,Yu F. Mixed Methods,,2007,Sampling: A Typology with Examples,J Mix Methods Res,1,77,100
FraenkelJR,WallenNE,HyunHH,,2012,How to design and evaluate research in education,,,642,
DeanAG,SullivanKM,SoeMM,,,,[cited 2017 May,31,,
Lawshe CH,,1975,A quantitative approach to content validity,Pers Psychol,28,563,75
DeVonHA,BlockME,Moyle-WrightP,ErnstDM,HaydenSJ,LazzaraDJ,,2007,A psychometric toolbox for testing validity and reliability,J Nurs Scholarsh,39,155,64
BannerjiM,CapozzoliM,McSweeneyL,SinhaD.,Beyond,,1999,Kappa: A review of inter-rater agreement measures,Can J Stat,27,3,23
WeirJP,,2005,Quantifying test-retest reliability using intraclass correlation coefficient and SEM,J Strength Cond Res,19,231,40
VieraJA,GarrettJM,,2005,Understanding inter-observer agreement: The Kappa Statistic,Fam Med,37,360,3
Bangert-DrownsRL,KulikCC,KulikJA,MorganM.,,1991,The instructional effect of feedback in test-like events,Rev Educ Res,61,213,38
KangSH,McDermottKB,RoedigerIII,,2007,Test format and corrective feedback modulate the effect of testing on longterm retention,Eur J Cogn Psychol,19,528,58
SaymaM,Williams HR,,2016,A new method for teaching physical examination to junior medical students,Adv Med Educ Pract,7,91,7
GlynnLG,MacFarlaneA,KellyM,CantillonP,MurphyAW,,2006,Helping each other to learn - A process evaluation of peer assisted learning,BMC Med Educ,6,18,
WadoodiA,CrosbyJR,,2002,Twelve tips for peer-assisted learning: a classic concept revisited,Med Teach,24,241,4
AllikmetsS,VinkJP,,2016,The benefits of peer-led teaching in medical education,Adv Med Educ Pract,7,329,30
NestelD,KiddJ,Nurses,,2006,' perceptions and experiences of communication in the operating theatre: a focus group interview,BMC Nurs,5,1,9
LockspeiserTM,O'SullivanP,TeheraniA,MullerJ,,2008,Understanding the experience of being taught by peers: the value of social and cognitive congruence,Adv Heal Sci Educ Theory Pract,13,361,72
MellerSM,ChenM,ChenR,HaeselerFD,,2013,Near-Peer Teaching in a Required Third-Year Clerkship,Yale J Biol Med,86,583,9
0

Citations

0

Downloads

45

Views