Efficiency of productivity covariance analysis (PCA), Wilkinson nearest neighbour analysis (W-NNA) and Schwarzbach nearest neighbour analysis (S-NNA) in estimating environmental variation was compared with randomised complete block design (RCBD). The average coefficient of variation (CV) of 11 trials was 8.47, 9.75, 8.73 and 8.70% in PCA, W-NNA, S-NNA and RCBD, respectively. PCA, W-NNA and S- NNA demonstrated better control of experimental error in 4,2 and 4 trials, respectively, compared to RCBD. PCA was equal to RCBD in 7 trials whereas W-NNA and S-NNA over-estimated experimental error compared to RCBD in some trials. The data depicted that PCA, W-NNA and S-NNA were not efficient alternatives to RCBD. Nevertheless, these methods could be used as corrective measures if field blocking do not prove effective in removing effect of field variation on genotypic performance.