The role of brand positioning is vibrant and central in marketing and the consumers‘ perception is directly shaped by employing the suitable positioning strategy. Regardless the significance of positioning concept, there is scant study observed how positioning substitutes contribute to build the consumer perception, which positioning strategy outperforms and how it can be measured effectively. The study mode is quantitative and relative effectiveness of positioning strategies (feature, direct benefit, indirect benefit) is measured empirically regarding consumer viewpoint. The multidimensional scale is used to measure the relative effectiveness. The measuring items comprise of four dimensions that are favorability, dissimilarity, uniqueness, and credibility. The total number of items that is associated with these dimensions is seventeen. The relative performance of positioning strategies is observed hypothetically. For this purpose, two print advertisements of real brands from cellular industry are selected. The statistical technique that applied in the study is ANCOVA by considering age and monthly income as covariates. Descriptive statistics is also incorporated to prove the study hypothesis. The results demonstrated that the selected positioning strategy for the study affects the positioning success of a brand. More specifically, direct benefit and indirect benefit positioning strategies received much higher and significant score against the three dimension of positioning effectiveness (i.e., favorability, dissimilarity and credibility) in comparison of feature positioning, so benefit positioning strategy is superior, outperform, effective, consistent and leads to position the brand in a better way at least in the market of cellular category. Moreover, some limitations are reported along with the associated directions for future research.