A study was conducted to compare the reproductive efficiency and egg quality characteristics of a locally evolved Lyallpur Silver Black (LSB) breed with Rhode Island Red (RIR) breeds of poultry. For this study, 42 birds (24 weeks of age) comprising 36 females and males of each breed were divided into six experimental units/replicates (six females and one male/replicate). Each replicate was placed in a separate breeding pen provided with a trap nest to obtain pedigreed offsprings. The birds were fed ad libitum. The data on egg weight, shell thickness, albumen height, and yolk height and yolk diameter was recorded fortnightly. The eggs obtained from the birds were incubated for fertility, hatchability and weight of day old chicks. RIR exhibited significantly more weight (36.66 g) of day old chicks than those of LSB (31.62 g). LSB layers produced significantly thicker shalled eggs (0.383 mm) than their counter parts (0.367 mm). However, the difference in haugh unit, yolk index, fertility percentage and hatchability percentage was found to be non significant.