No Detail Found!

Natural and artificial sweeteners a blessing or curse: a phyto-genotoxic study in Allium cepa L. root tip cells

Author(s)
Sadaf Tabasum Qureshi Institute of Plant Sciences, University of Sindh,Jamshoro,Pakistan
Sindhu Zahid Al-Tibri Medical college, Isra University Karachi Campus ABSTRACT,,
Muhammad Ramzan Laghari Institute of Plant Sciences, University of Sindh,Jamshoro,Pakistan
Shafique Ahmed Rajper Institute of Plant Sciences, University of Sindh,Jamshoro,Pakistan
Shamshad Ali Jarwar Institute of Plant Sciences, University of Sindh,Jamshoro,Pakistan
Sooraj Kumar Bheel Institute of Plant Sciences, University of Sindh,Jamshoro,Pakistan
Kainat Anwar Arian Institute of Plant Sciences, University of Sindh,Jamshoro,Pakistan
Abstract
The study investigated the comparative phyto-genotoxic impacts of natural and artificial sweetener brands using the Allium cepa L. (onion) assay to predict potential phyto-genotoxic associated with long-term intake. Onion bulbs were exposed for 48hours to 1% aaqueous solutions of natural and artificial sweeteners (Honey, Date, Jaggery, Canderel, Sucral, Stiva and Refined sugar) and distilled water was used as the negative control. All the tested sweeteners exhibited significant variations at LSD=0.05 for all phytotoxicity and genotoxicity parameters. The results phytotoxicity, characterized by a marked failure of root emergence and reduction in root length and Mitotic index (M.I.%). Genotoxic analysis showed that both sweetener categories induced a substantial increase in Abnormality Index (A.I.%), escalating from 14.2% at the lowest concentration to 47.2% at the highest. The most prevalent chromosomal aberration was DNA fragmentation in all the tested sweeteners and while occurrences of sticky metaphase and micronuclei were also recorded in low number. Stiva induced nuclear lesions, and impaired chromosome condensation. These two are checkpoints of carcinogenesis in addition to chromosomal aberrations. The high frequency of nuclear damage and cellular membrane irregularities suggests that exposure to 1% solutions of both natural and artificial sweeteners can induce measurable genetic instability. Overall results suggest that Stiva followed by Canderel, Sucral and refined sugar were severely phyto-genotoxic, while honey was moderately phyto-genotoxic and Dates followed by jaggery were the mild phyto-genotoxic. It is concluded that sweetener intake must be minimized to avoid possible cellular and DNA damages. A dose dependent animalbased study must be conducted to estimate cancer risk to humans. Reactive oxygen species generation, lipid peroxidation profiling is also recommended.
Publication Details
Page(s) 31-41
Published Journal: Journal of Applied Research in Plant Sciences (JOARPS), Volume: 7, Issue: 1, Year: 2026

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Allium cepa L, phytotoxicity, genotoxicity, sweeteners, Oxidative damages, Carcinogenesis
References
Abdelbaky A.S.,Tammam M.A.,Ali M.Y.,Sharaky M.,Selim K.,Semida W.M.,Abd T.A.,Ramadan M.F.,Oraby H.F.,Diab Y.M. .2023 .Antioxidant and Anticancer Assessment and Phytochemical Investigation of Three Varieties of Date Fruits. , 10(7) : 816.
Arshad S.,Rehman T,Rajoka S.,Ranjha M.S.R.,Hassoun M.M.A.N.,Cropotova A.,Trif J.,Younas M.,Aadil A.,R.N. A. .2022 .Replacement of refined sugar by natural sweeteners: focus on potential health benefits. Heliyon, 8(9) : .
Atalay E.C.,Celep A.G.S.,Catanzaro R.,Marotta F. R. .2025 .Aspartame, saccharin, sucralose, and stevia: Oxidative stress pathways and functional food perspectives. Bioactive Compounds in Health and Disease, 8(11) : 474-48.
Banerjee A.,Das D.,Maji B.K.,Mukherjee S. .2018 .An in vitro cytotoxic activity of Bees' honey in Huh-7 cell line. Biotechnology and Microbiology, 09(1) : 555751.
Bezerra M.D.S.,Malaquias G.D.S.,J.M.D. G.D.S.,Peron A.P. .2016 .Cytotoxic and genotoxic potential of powdered juices. Food Science and Technology, 10(1) : 0006-457X.
Cavalli G.,Misteli T. .2013 .Functional implications of genome topology. Nature Structural and Molecular Biology, 20(3) : 290-299.
Channar A.P.,Soomro S.T.,Saddar A.N.,Sadia A.N. .2025 .DNA damaging effects of lotion vs electric mosquito repellent assessed via chickpea chromosomal aberration assay. Journal of Applied Research in Plant Sciences, 06(2) : 143-154.
EFSA FAF .2021 .Scientific opinion on the safety evaluation of steviol glycoside preparations, including rebaudioside AM, obtained by enzymatic bioconversion of highly purified stevioside and/or rebaudioside a stevia leaf extracts. EFSA Journal, 6691(8) : 6691.
Firbas P.,Amon T. .2014 .Chromosome damage studies in the onion plant Allium cepa. International Journal of Cytology, Cytosystematics and Cytogenetics, 67(1) : 25-35.
Helal E.G.E.,Abdelaziz M.A.,El-Gamal M.S. .2019 .Effects Of CANDEREL® and the ameliorative role of stem cell eenhancer on some physiological parameters in male albino rats. The Egyptian Journal of Hospital Medicine, 76(3) : 3702-3708.
Hirpara P.,Thakare N.,Kele N.,Patel D. .2020 .Jaggery: A natural sweetener. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry, 9(5) : 3145-3148.
Ibrahim E.S.,Ragheb E.M.,Yousef F.M.,Abdel-Aziz M.F.,Alghamd B.A. .2020 .Nutritional value, cytotoxic and antimicrobial activities of Stevia rebaudiana leaf extracts. Journal of Biochemical Technology, 11(12) : 108-115.
Diabetic Federation (I.D International,northafrica International .2024 .-members/middle-east-and-. , : .
Ismail I.,Zakaria N.F.,Yong J.H. Y.,Ismail N. .2025 .Lessons From Practice: Severe Hyperkalemia and life-threatening events after dates consumption during Ramadan in end-stage renal failure patient. Malaysian Journal of Emergency Medicine, 7(1) : 41-43.
Kulkarni A.S.,Karkhanis D.,Barve S.S.,Sharma S. .2021 .Antioxidant and cytotoxic study of extract of vegetative and flowering stages leaves Stevia rebaudiana. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry, 10(4) : 303-306.
Lanctôt C.,Cheutin T.,Cremer M.,Cavalli G.,Cremer T. .2007 .Dynamic genome architecture in the nuclear space: regulation of gene expression in three dimensions. Nature Reviews Genetics, 10(2) : 104-15.
Magliano D.J.,Boyko E.J. .2021 .Chapter 3, Global picture. 10th edition, : .
Mongi R.J.,Ruhembe C.C. .2024 .Sugar profile and sensory properties of honey from different geographical zones and botanical origins in Tanzania. , 10(18) : .
Nurcayani N.,Barliana M.I.,Dandan K.L. .2025 .Cytotoxic effects of tea (Camellia sinensis), stevia (Stevia rebaudiana), moringa (Moringa oleifera) leaves, and their potential as functional beverages for cancer patients. Bioactive Compounds in Health and Disease, 8(8) : 1690-307.
Nuryandani E.,Kurnianto D.,Jasmadi J.,Sefrienda A.R.,Novitasari E.,Apriyati E.,Wanita Y.P.,Indrasari S.D.,Sunaryanto R.,Tjokrokusumo D.,Yani A.,Suryaningtyas I.T.,Andriana Y. .2024 .Phytotoxic and Cytotoxic Effects, Antioxidant Potentials, and Phytochemical Constituents of Stevia rebaudiana Leaves. , 2200993 : .
Ogwu M.C.,Izah S.C. .2025 .Honey as a Natural Antimicrobial. , 14(255) : 1-29.
Oliveira V.A.D.,Oliveira V.M.A.D.,Oliveira T.W.N.D.,Damasceno A.N.C.,Silva C.E.D.O,Medeiros S.R.A.,Soares B.M.,Silva F.C.C.D.,Aguiar R.P.S.D.,Islam R.P.S.D.,MeloCavalcante A.A.D.C.,Peron A.P.,Sousa A.P.,J.M.D.C.E. A.P. .2017 .Evaluation of cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of two artificial sweeteners using eukaryotic test system. African Journal of Biotechnology, 6(11) : 547-551.
Orellana-Paucar A.M. .2023 .Steviol Glycosides from Stevia rebaudiana: An Updated Overview of Their Sweetening Activity, Pharmacological Properties, and Safety Aspects. , 28 : .
Perrier J.D.,Mihalov J.J.,Carlson S.J. .2018 .FDA regulatory approach to steviol glycosides. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 09 : 132-142.
Prakash M.D.,Stojanovska L.,Feehan J.,Nurgali K.,Donald E.L.,Plebanski M.,Kitchen B.,Apostolopoulos V. .2021 .Anti-cancer effects of polyphenol-rich sugarcane extract. PloS One, 0247492(3) : .
Qureshi S. T.,Chandio P.,Noman A.,Parveen A.,Soomro Y. .2015 .Cytotoxic and genotoxic and oxidative effects of aqueous extract of some frequently used medicinalplants in Pakistan. , 8(1) : 29-35.
Racuciu M. .2009 .Effect of radiofrequency radiation on root tip cells of Zea mays. Romanian Biotechnologycal Letters, 14(3) : 4365-4369.
Sachan M.,Singh P. M.,Perspectives Regulatory .2026 .. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Development, 10(5) : 1624-43.
Sadia S.T.,Soomro A.N.,Malik S.,Punar Z. .2024 .Mutational and carcinogenic potential of Amaltas fruit via oxidation. Journal of Applied Research in Plant Sciences, 05(2) : 269-280.
Selvapriya S.,Priyadharshini R.,Kumar S.R.,Sinduja P. .2021 .Anti-Inflammatory and Cytotoxic Effect of Stevia and Neem Based Herbal Formulation. Journal of Pharmaceutical Research International, 10(59) : 150-160.
Tkach V.V.,Morozova T.V.,Gaivão I.O.,Ivanushko Y.G.,Martins J.I.F.,Barros A.N. .2025 .Sucralose: A review of environmental, oxidative and genomic Stress. , 10(13) : .
Wisal A.,Asad-Ullah B.,Sıcak Y.,Öztürk M.,Muhammad A.,Anwar W.,Begum S.,Zafar S.,Carvalho P.V.S.D.,Hassan S.S.,Halim S.A.,Khan A. .2025 .The cytotoxic, antioxidant, and anticholinesterase activity of steviol and isosteviol analogues, together with structure-activity relationships and molecular docking studies. Journal of Molecular Structure, 1345 : 43049.
Xu X.,Wand Q.,Li B.,Liu C.,Cu C.,Yi M.,Zhai L.,Wong R.M.Y.,Zhang R.M.Y.,Cheung W.C. .2025 .Effect of artificial sweeteners on the Musculoskeletal system: A systematic review of current evidence. Nutrients, 17(21) : .
Zahadi N.A.,Berahim Z.,Zainuddin S.L. .2026 .Evaluating the effect of Tualang honey on the viability and migration of human gingival fibroblasts. Journal of Orofacial and Health, 7(1) : 425-39.
Zink D.,Fischer A.H.,Nickerson J.A. .2004 .Nuclear structure in cancer cells. Nature Reviews Cancer, 10(9) : 677-87.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

14

Views