No Detail Found!

Towards Cultivating a Global Cybersecurity Culture: A Multivocal Literature Review of Challenges and Practices

Author(s)
Nisar Muhammad Software Engineering Research Group (SERG), Department of Computer Science & IT, University of Malakand, Pakistan
Siffat Ullah Khan Software Engineering Research Group (SERG), Department of Computer Science & IT, University of Malakand, Pakistan
Abstract
Cybersecurity is a critical global concern that transcends national borders and requires coordinated responses. Cyber threats are becoming more frequent, sophisticated, and impactful. Existing research highlights that solutions that focus on technical, organizational, or individual aspects are insufficient to effectively secure cyberspace. In response, the development of Global Cybersecurity Culture (GCSC) has been recognized as a collective and long-term approach for mitigating the real-world impact of these cyber threats. However, limited studies have focused on how a GCSC can be developed and operationalized. In this study, we conducted a Multivocal Literature Review (MLR) to identify critical challenges and their associated practices that hinder the development of GCSC. This MLR was conducted following the established guidelines for MLR in Software Engineering research. A total of 39 primary studies, including both peer-reviewed and Grey Literature (GL) sources, were selected from an initial search of 3,549 literature sources. It identified 13 Critical Challenges, such as Lack of political consensus, the absence of international cyber law, digital sovereignty disputes, disputes over digital human rights, and lack of national cybersecurity capabilities. It also identified 41 associated practices to address these challenges. Furthermore, the identified challenges were clustered into four cultural layers including Knowledge, Tacit Assumptions, Espoused Values, and Artefacts, to provide a structured understanding of how they influence the development of GCSC. This research provides a basis for the development and operationalization of a GCSC by identifying its critical challenges and their associated practices. It also provides a foundation for future research and may inform the future development of maturity assessment models for GCSC.
Publication Details
Page(s) 67-100
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: The Sciencetech, Volume: 7, Issue: 2, Year: 2026

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Challenges, Cybersecurity, Multivocal Literature Review, Practices, Global Cybersecurity Culture, Software Engineering
References
Abdo J. B.,Hossain L. .2025 .Interdisciplinarity of cybersecurity: Towards convergence science. , : .
Adejumo A. P.,Ogburie C. P. .2025 .Strengthening finance with cybersecurity: Ensuring safer digital transactions. World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 25(03) : 1527-1541.
Admass W. S.,Munaye Y. Y.,Diro A. A. .2024 .Cyber security: State of the art, challenges and future directions. Cyber Security and Applications, 2 : 100031.
Afzal W.,Torkar R.,Feldt R. .2009 .A systematic review of searchbased testing for non-functional system properties. Information and Software Technology, 51(6) : 957-976.
Al-ma'aitah M. A. .2022 .Investigating the drivers of cybersecurity enhancement in public organizations: The case of Jordan. Electronic Journal of Information Systems in Developing Countries., : .
Amoo O. O.,Atadoga A.,Abrahams T. O.,Farayola O. A.,Osasona F.,Ayinla B. S. .2024 .The legal landscape of cybercrime: A review of contemporary issues in the criminal justice system. World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 21(2) : 205-217.
Kazakova Anastasiya,Serge V. R.,Droz V. R. .2023 .Geneva manual: On responsible behaviour in cyberspace, implementation of norms by relevant non-state stakeholders. DiploFoundation, : .
Forum. ASEAN Regional .2015 .Work plan on security of and in the use of Information and Communications Technologies (ICT).. , : .
Strategic Policy Institute Australian .2022 .-responsible-statebehaviour-cyberspace. , : .
Barrera M. A. .2017 .BARRERA_MULTINATIONAL_CYBER_TRE ATY. , : .
Amor Ben,Abdellatif H.,Ghaleb M.,T. M. .2025 .A comprehensive multi-vocal empirical study of ml cloud service misuses [Preprint]. , : .
Camino K. .2017 .-cyberspace-and-international-peace-and-security-en691.pdf. , : .
Chatinakrob T. .2024 .Interplay of international law and cyberspace: state sovereignty violation, Extraterritorial effects, and the paradigm of cyber sovereignty. Chinese Journal of International Law, 23(1) : 25-72.
Collett R. .2021 .Understanding cybersecurity capacity building and its relationship to norms and confidence building measures. Journal of Cyber Policy, 6(3) : 298-317.
.2004 .Convention on cybercrime (Budapest Convention). Council of Europe, : .
Creese S.,Dutton W. H.,Esteve-González P.,Shillair R. .2021 .Cybersecurity capacity-building: cross-national benefits and international divides. Journal of Cyber Policy, 6(2) : 214-235.
.2017 .Draft council conclusions on a framework for a joint EU diplomatic response to malicious cyber activities, Cyber diplomacy toolbox. , : .
Silva Da,Santos F. Q. B.,Soares A. L. M.,França S.,Monteiro A. C. C.,Maciel C. V. F.,F. F. C. V. F. .2011 .Six years of systematic literature reviews in software engineering: An updated tertiary study. Information and Software Technology, 53(9) : 899-913.
Dunn M.,Mauer V. .2006 .Center for Security Studies (CSS).. International CIIP Handbook, : .
Erez M.,Gati E. .2004 .A dynamic, multi-level model of culture: From the micro level of the individual to the macro level of a global culture. Applied Psychology, 53(4) : 583-598.
Esteve-González P.,Axon L.,Creese S.,Dutton W. H.,Saunders J.,Carver J.,Goldsmith M. .2025 .Cybersecurity capacities for the application of un cyber norms. , : .
Finnemore M.,Hollis D. B. .2016 .Constructing norms for global cybersecurity. American Journal of International Law, 110(3) : 425-479.
Garousi V.,Felderer M.,Mäntylä M. V. .2019 .Guidelines for including grey literature and conducting multivocal literature reviews in software engineering. Information and Software Technology, 106 : 101-121.
Gevorgyan M. R.,Minasyan S. M.,Manukyan L. M. .2025 .Exploring the role of cybersecurity: Interdisciplinary perspectives and strategies. Cross-Cultural Studies: Education and Science, 10(1) : 164-173.
Ghernaouti-Hélie S.,ARES S. .2009 .An inclusive information society needs a global approach of information security. Proceedings - International Conference on Availability, Reliability and Security, 658 : 662.
Glen C. M. .2021 .. Norm Entrepreneurship in Global Cybersecurity. Politics & Policy, 49(5) : 1121-1145.
Government .2018 .Paris call for trust and security in cyberspace. , : .
Gupta S. K.,Singh P.,Abraham P. .2025 .Technologies for Analysing Legal Complexity. , : 113-127.
Gurung A. .2025 .From battlefield to the servers: Cyber warfare and the conflicts. The Shivapuri Journal, 26(1) : 29-41.
Hurel L. M.,Lobato L. C. .2018 .Unpacking cyber norms: private companies as norm entrepreneurs. Journal of Cyber Policy, 3(1) : 61-76.
Hurwitz R.,Yannakogeorgos R.,Lowther R. .2013 .A new normal? The cultivation of global norms as part of a cybersecurity strategy. , : 233-264.
International Telecommunication Union. .2024 .-2024. Global Cybersecurity Index, : .
Lin Kai,T. Kai,- Kai .2023 .ASEAN Cyber-security cooperation: Towards a regional emergencyresponse framework. , : .
Kerttunen M.,Kiisel S. .2015 .Norms for international peace and security: The normative frameworks of international cyber cooperation (ICT4PEACE NORMS Project Draft Working Paper. , : .
Kesler E. .2024 .A transdisciplinary approach to cybersecurity: A Framework for encouraging transdisciplinary thinking [Preprint]. , : .
Khadka K.,Ullah A. B. .2025 .Human factors in cybersecurity: an interdisciplinary review and framework proposal. International Journal of Information Security, 24(3) : 1-13.
Khan A. W.,Saeed D. S.,Kakar M. S. .2024 .Cybersecurity as a geopolitical tool: The growing influence of digital warfare in statecraft. International Research Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 3(2) : 345-357.
Krishna B.,Krishnan S.,Sebastian M. P. .2022 .Examining the relationship between national cybersecurity commitment, Culture, and Digital payment usage: An Institutional Trust Theory Perspective. Information Systems Frontiers., : .
Krishnamurthy V. .2025 .Anchoring digital sovereignty. Chicago Journal of International Law, 25(2) : .
Kritika M. .2025 .A comprehensive study on cyber diplomacy as a tool for conflict prevention and cybersecurity governance. International Cybersecurity Law Review., : .
Madnick B.,Huang K.,Madnick S. .2024 .The evolution of global cybersecurity norms in the digital age: A longitudinal study of the cybersecurity norm development process. Information Security Journal: A Global Perspective, 33(3) : 204-225.
Mallick M. A. I.,Nath R. .2024 .Navigating the cyber security landscape: A comprehensive review of cyber-attacks, emerging trends, and recent developments. World Scientific News, 190(1) : 1-69.
Marina K.,Michael C. .2019 .. Advancing Cyberstability Final Report, : .
Maurer T. .2020 .A dose of realism: The contestation and politics of cyber norms. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, 12(2) : 283-305.
McDowell S. D.,Nensey Z.,Steinberg P. E.,Kremer F.,Müller F. .2014 .Cooperative International Approaches to Network Security: Understanding and Assessing OECD and ITU Efforts to Promote Shared Cybersecurity. , : 231-252.
Meyer P.,Gordijn B. .2020 .Norms of responsible state behaviour in cyberspace. The Ethics of Cybersecurity, : 347-360.
Corporation Microsoft .2014 .-conflict-in-lnternet-dependent-world. , : .
Corporation Microsoft .2013 .Five principles for shaping cybersecurity norms. , : .
Muhammad N.,Khan S. U. .2024 .Global culture of cybersecurity: A multi-vocal literature review protocol. The Lighthouse Journal of Social Sciences, 3(1) : 67-88.
Muhammad N.,Khan S. U.,Niazi M.,Shameem M. .2026 .An Empirical Study of Challenges for Developing Global Cybersecurity Culture. International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering (EASE), : .
Naeem U.,Siffat Ullah K.,Syed Muhammad Shakir B. .2025 .Multivocal literature review protocol for theidentification of cybersecurity challenges anditssolutions in the context of vehicleto-vehiclecommunications from software engineeringperspective. Spectrum of Engineering Sciences, 3(2) : 58-89.
Niekerk J. V.,Issa R. V. S. .2006 .Understanding information security culture: A conceptual framework. Citeseer., : .
OECD .2002 .OECD Guidelines for the security of information systems and networks. , : .
.2020 .Advancing international cyber norms: Multistakeholder recommendations (Paris Peace Forum, Issue. , : .
Paz S. .2023 .Cybersecurity standards and frameworks. IEEE Technology and Engineering Management Society Body of Knowledge (TEMSBOK), : 397-416.
Paziuk A.,Mitsik V. .2019 .Global cybersecurity culture in the international discourse: values and principles. National Academy of Managerial Staff of Culture & Arts(2), : 103.
Pernice I. .2018 .Global cybersecurity governance: A constitutionalist analysis. Global Constitutionalism, 7(1) : 112-141.
Pierucci F. .2025 .Sovereignty in the Digital Era: Rethinking territoriality and governance in cyberspace. Digital Society, 4(1) : 27.
Pijović N. .2021 .The cyberspace 'great game'. the five eyes, the sino-russian bloc and the growing competition to shape global cyberspace norms. 13th International Conference on Cyber Conflict (CyCon), : 25-28.
Portnoy M.,Goodman S. .2009 .International intergovernmental organizations. Cyberspace: An Emerging Landscape, : 1-22.
Prokopyshyn O.,Trushkina N. .2025 .The geopolitics of cybersecurity: A comparative analysis of national strategies for digital sovereignty. Politics & Security, 12(2) : 59-71.
Qu X. .2026 .International law and the regulation of cross-border cyberattacks: Challenges and solutions. International Journal of Computer Information Systems and Industrial Management Applications, 18 : 12-12.
Radanliev P.,Computing Quantum .2024 .Cyber diplomacy: defining the opportunities for cybersecurity and risks from Artificial Intelligence. Journal of Cyber Security Technology, : 1-51.
Reegård K.,Blackett C.,Katta V. .2020 .. The Concept of Cybersecurity Culture, : 4036-4043.
Riordan S. .2018 .The geopolitics of cyberspace: A diplomatic perspective. Brill Research Perspectives in Diplomacy and Foreign Policy, 3(3) : 1-84.
Schein E. H. .2009 .The corporate culture survival guide. , 158 : .
Schein E. H. .2010 .Three cultures of management: The key to organizational learning. Glocal Working. Living and Working Across the World With Cultural Intelligence. Milan, : 37-58.
Schjølberg T. .2020 .Guidelines for utilization of the global cybersecurity agenda (GCA) (Report by the Secretary-General, International Telecommunication Union (ITU), Issue. , : .
Serrano A. S. .2024 .The challenge of global cybersecurity. In Global Cybersecurity and International Law, : 1-9.
Shackelford S. J.,Proia A. A.,Martell B.,Craig A. N. .2015 .Toward a global cybersecurity standard of care: Exploring the implications of the 2014 NIST cybersecurity framework on shaping reasonable national and international cybersecurity practices. Tex. Int'l LJ, 50 : 305.
Singh M.,Srivastava S.,Mahanandia R. .2026 .Leadership and cybersecurity governance: building a human-centric protective culture in the digital age. IGI Global Scientific Publishing., : 1-28.
Steve M. .2023 ./cybercrimeto-cost-the-world-9-trillion-annually-in-2024/. , : .
Sund C. .2007 .Towards an international road‐map for cybersecurity. Online Information Review, 31(5) : 566-582.
Tabagari T. .2016 .Georgian cyber defense unit, cyber reserve. , : .
.2013 .tallinn manual on the international law applicable to cyber warfare. , : .
Thakur M. .2024 .Cyber security threats and countermeasures in digital age. Journal of Applied Science and Education (JASE), : 1-20.
Touré H. I.,Schjølberg S. .2007 .ITU Global Cybersecurity Agenda (GCA) High-Level Experts Group (HLEG) Chairman's Report. , : .
Tziarras Z. .2014 .Cyber-Democracy: Challenges, Opportunities and Implications for Theory.. In Cyber-Development, : .
Nations United,Final-report- United .2021 .Final substantive report of the Open-ended Working Group on developments in the field of information and telecommunications in the context of international security (OEWG). - CRP, : 290.
Nations General Assembly. United .2003 .Creation of a global culture of cybersecurity :resolution.. , : .
Nations General Assembly. United .2009 .Creation of a global culture of cybersecurity and taking stock of national efforts to protect critical information infrastructures. , : .
Nations General Assembly. United .2013 .Group of Governmental Experts on Developments in the Field of Information and Telecommunications in the Context of International Security. , 68 : 98-ES.
Nations General Assembly. United .2015 .Group of Governmental Experts on Developments in the Field of Information and Telecommunications in the Context of International Security. , 70 : 174-EN.
.2017 .The united nations, cyberspace and international peace and security: responding to complexity in the 21st century. , : .
Nations General Assembly. United .2015 .International Code of Conduct for Information Security. , 69 : 723-EN.
Van Horenbeeck M.,Kulesza J.,Paziuk A. .2018 .Cybersecurity: culture, norms and values, Background paper to the IGF Best Practices Forum on Cybersecurity. , : .
Wohlin C. .2014 .Guidelines for snowballing in systematic literature studies and a replication in software engineering. Proceedings of the 18th international conference on evaluation and assessment in software engineering,, : .
Wongmahesak K.,Singh B.,Kaunert C. .2025 .The complex interplay of generational differences, digital literacy, and cybercrime fear. Asian Crime and Society Review, 12(1) : 3-3.
.2005 .Geneva Declaration of Principles and. World Summit on the Information Society, 0005 : .
World Bank. .2024 .Digital first responders: The role of computer security incident response teams (CSIRTs) in developing countries. , : .
World Economic Fourm. .2025 .Global cybersecurity outlook 2025. , : .
Wouters J. .2020 .Filling global governance gaps in cybersecurity: International and european legal perspectives. International Organisations Research Journal, 15(15) : 141-172.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

11

Views