No Detail Found!

Organizational Facilitators and Barriers to Implementing Effective Clinical Audit: Systematic Review

Author(s)
Reza Gholi Vahidi Associate Professor of of Health Services Management, Tabriz Health Service Management Research Center, Department of Health Service Management, Faculty of Health Service Management and Medical Informatics, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
Jafar Sadegh Tabrizi Associate Professor of of Health Services Management, Tabriz Health Service Management Research Center, Department of Health Service Management, Faculty of Health Service Management and Medical Informatics, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
Shabnam Iezadi M.Sc Student, Health Service Management, Science and Research Branch, Azad University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
Kamal Gholipour M.Sc Student, Health Service Management, Faculty of Health Service Management and Medical Information, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
Farokh Mojahed M.Sc Student, Health Service Management, Faculty of Health Service Management and Medical Information, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
Vahid Rasi M.Sc Student, Health Service Management, Faculty of Health Service Management and Medical Information, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Clinical audit is a systematic and critical analysis of "quality of care" to improve clinical care. This study was aimed to find organizational and managerial facilitators and barriers of effective clinical audit implementation in hospitals. METHODS: A systematic literature review was performed using the PubMed, Google Scholar and Cochrane databases with key words of “clinical audit”, “effective audit”, “evaluation of audits” and “medical audit” supplemented by hand-search. Content analysis was used to identify external and organizational factors that influence implementation of clinical audit. RESULTS: Of the 53 scientific articles about clinical audit, 4 core themes with 11 main themes and 50 subthemes related to negative factors affecting clinical audit and 5 core themes with 15 main themes and 92 subthemes about organizational facilitator factors were found. Resource limitation, poor information management system, lack of audit support centers, excessive workload and time constraint, lack of organizational support for building audit team, unavailability of evidence-based guidelines and bureaucratic hurdles were highlighted as organizational barriers in clinical audit. On the other hand, instructional support, effective training programs, participation of local ownership, high capacity for quality improvement, intensive feedback mechanisms, resource commitment and rational basis for allocation and evidencebased researches for setting standards are mentioned as factors which promote effectiveness of clinical audit programs. CONCLUSION: For clinical audit and its role in improving quality of care, identifying barriers, and facilitating factors in organizational setting can help managers and professionals to prepare the organizations which are suitable for implementing the clinical audits in proper manner.
Publication Details
Page(s) 38-45
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Journal of Pioneering Medical Sciences, Volume: 3, Issue: 1, Year: 2013

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Systematic review, Effectiveness, Clinical audit, Barriers, Facilitators, organizational factors, Barriers
References
JMA Bohnen .2005 .Audit to improve. Canadian Medical Association, 48(1) : 10-1.
Jsanzaro P. .1976 .Medical audit, continuing medical education and quality assurance. The Western Journal of Medicine, 125 : 241-52.
Baker R,Hearnshaw H,Cooper A,Cheater F,Robertson N. .1995 .Assessing the work of medical audit advisory groups in promoting audit in general practice. Quality in Health Care, 4 : 234-9.
Maher D. .1996 .Clinical audit in developing country. Tropical Medicine and International Health, 1(4) : 409-13.
Grol R,Wensing M. .1995 .Implementation of quality assurance and medicalaudit: general practitioners' perceived obstacles and requirements. British Journal of General Practice, 48 : 548-52.
Morehead MA .1967 .The medical audit as an operational tool. AJPH, 57(9) : 1643.
Foy R,Eccles M,Grimshaw J,Baker R .2005 .What do we know about how to do audit and feedback? Pitfalls in applying evidence from a systematic review. BMC Health Services Research, 5 : 50-7.
Bowie P,Bradley NA,Rushmer R. .2010 .Clinical audit and quality improvement - time for a rethink? Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice. , 18 : 42-8.
Gullo A .2006 .Prospective manage monitoring; principle, organization and quality of care. Minerva anestesial, 72 : 71-81.
Benjamin A.,Audit A. .2008 .: how to do it in practice. BMJ, 336 : 1241-5.
Williamson J D .1973 .Quality control, medical audit and the general practitioner. Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners, 23 : 697-706.
Wright J,Ayres P,Hill P . .Public health in hospitals: new steps in old directions. Journal of Public Health Medicine, 19(4) : 408-12.
Tsaloglidou .2009 .A. Does Audit Improve the Quality of Care?. International Journal of Caring Sciences, 2(2) : .
Williamson JD .1973 .Quality control, medical audit and the general practitioner. Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners, 23 : 697-706.
Rigge M. .1994 .Involving patients in clinical audit. Quality in Health Care, 3 : 5.
Nyamtema AS,Jong ABd,Urassa DP,Jv Roosmalen .2011 .Using audit to enhance quality of maternity care in resource limited countries: lessons learnt from rural Tanzania. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 11 : 94-100.
Editorial .2005 .Audit-using both the good and the bad news to improve patient care. British Journal of Anaesthesia, 95(2) : 121-3.
Guryel E,Acton K,Patel S K .2008 .Auditing orthopaedic audit. The Royal College of Surgeons of England, 90 : 675-8.
Gillis A .1998 .Improving patient care in the UK: clinical audit in the oxford region. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 8(2) : 2141-152.
Redfern SJ,Norman IJ .1996 .Clinical Audit, Related Cycles and Types of Health Care Quality: a Preliminary Model. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 8(4) : 331-40.
Moore DA,Klingborg DJ DA .2003 .Using clinical audits to ldentify practitioner learning needs. JVME, 30(1) : 57-61.
Johnston G,Crombie IK,Davies HTO,Alder EM,Millard A .2000 .Reviewing audit: barriers and facilitating factors for effective clinical audit. Quality in Health Care, 9 : 23-36.
Wallin L,Boström A-M G,Wikblad K .2002 .Progress of unit based quality improvement: an evaluation of a support strategy. Qual Saf Health Care, 11 : 308-14.
Mcwhinney IR .1972 .Medical audit in North America. British Medical Journal, 2 : 277-9.
Spencer J. .1993 .Audit in general practice: where do we go from here? Quality in Health Care. , 2 : 183-8.
Moore DA,Kingborg DJ .1998 .Evidence of effectiveness of clinical audit in improving histopathology reporting standards of mastectomy specimens. J Clin Pathol, 51(1) : 30-3.
Hopkins A .1991 .Approaches to medical audit. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 45 : 1-3.
Gnanalingham J,Gnanaligham M,Gnanaligham K. .2001 .An audit of audits; are wwe completing the audit cycle. Journal of the Royal College of society medicine, 94 : 288-9.
Balogh R,Quinn H,Simpson A,Bond S. .1998 .A comparative analysis of six audit systems for mental health nursing. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 10(1) : 43-52.
McKee CM,Lauglo MM,Lessof L .1989 .Medical audit: a review. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 82 : 474-8.
Lord J,Littlejhons P .1996 .Impact of hospital and community provider based clinical audit programmes: Perceptions of doctors, nurses and other health professionals. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 8(6) : 527-35.
.1968 .. Why Audit Quality of Medical Care? Journal of The National Medical Association, 60(3) : 228-33.
Gabbay J,McNicol MC,Spiby J,Davies SC,Layton AJ .1990 .What did audit achieve? Lessons from preliminary evaluation of a year's medical audit. BMJ, 301 : 26-9.
Tabrizi J .2009 .Quality of delivered care for people with Type 2 diabetes: a new patient centered model. Journal of research in Health Sciences, 9(2) : 1-9.
Hearnshaw H,Harker R H . .A study of the method used to select criteria for clinical audit. Health Technology assessment. 20002;6, (1) : .
Mooney G,Ryan M. .1992 .Rethinking medical audit: the goal is efficiency. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 46 : 180-3.
Buxton MJ .1994 .Achievements of audit in the NHS. , 4(3) : 31-4.
Graham W,Wagaarachchi P,Penney G .2000 .Criteria for clinical Audit of the Quality of Hospital based Obstetric Care in developing country. Bulletin of the health organization. , 778(5) : 614-20.
Walshe K. .2012 .Opportunities for improving the practice of clinical audit. Quality in Health Care, 4 : 231-2.
Robinson MB .1994 .Evaluation of medical audit. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 48 : 435-40.
Editorial .1980 .Aspects of Audit; 1 The background. British Medical Journal, : 1256-8.
Millard .1999 .A. Scaling the quality of clinical audit projects: a pilot study. International journal for Quality in Health care, 241(3) : 9.
Gumpert R,Lyons C .1990 .Setting up a district audit programme. British Medical Journal, 301 : 162-5.
Yorston D,Wormald R. .2003 .Clinical auditing to improve patient outcomes. Community Eye Health Journal, 23(4) : 748-49.
Shaw CD,Costain DW .1989 .Guidelines for medical audit: seven principles. British Medical Journal, 299 : 498-9.
Maire JA. .2003 .Clinical Activities Audit A Useful Tool for Changing Clinician's Practice.. ACO, 11(1) : 27-33.
Sanzoro P. Medical .1974 .Audit: Experience in the U.S.A. British Medical journal. , 1 : 271-4.
.2011 .European Commission guidelines on clinical audit. Statement by the European Society of Radiology. Insights Imaging, 2 : 97-8.
.2009 .How to Prepare for an Audit. Journal of Oncology Practice, 5(1) : 35-7.
Tabrizi JS,Gholipour K,Mohammadzadeh M,Farahbakhsh M. . .Health assessment among pregnant women through a PHC audit for hypertension and preeclampsia. The First International & 4th National Congress on Health Education &Promotion; 2011; Tabriz - Iran. Health promotion perspective: an Tabrizi international journal; 2011, : 290.
Alipour R,GHolipour K,Mohammadzadeh M. . .Quality of maternal care from the perspective of pregnant women. The First International & 4th National Congress on Health Education &Promotion; 2011; Tabriz - Iran. Health promotion perspective: an international journal; 2011, : 289.
Tabrizi JS,GHolipour K,Alipour R,Farahbakhsh M. . .Adherence to maternity care standards to improve the health of pregnant women. Quality of maternal care from the perspective of pregnant women 2011; Tabriz - Iran. Health promotion perspective: an international journal; 2011, : 290.
Tabrizi J,Wilson A,O'Rourke P. .2009 .Customer quality in health care. Patient Education and Concealing, 74(1) : 130-1.
Ruckley CV .1984 .Mechanisms of audit: discussion paper. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 77 : 40-4.
Shaw CD .1990 .Criterion based audit. BMJ, 300 : 649-51.
Walshe K,Freeman T. .2002 .Effectiveness of quality improvement: learning from evaluations. Qual Saf Health Care, 11 : 85-7.
Radiology .2010 .ESo. Clinical audit-ESR perspective. Insights Imaging, 1 : 21-6.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

7

Views