No Detail Found!

Fishermen and Farmers Communities Clientelism Practices and Electoral Politics

Author(s)
Muh. Endang Faculty of Cultural Sciences, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Nasruddin Suyuti Department of Anthropology, Faculty of Cultural Sciences, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Bahtiar Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Muhammad Najib Husain Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Abstract
Agriculture and fisheries are critical sectors for national development, yet some researchers argue that these sectors are closely tied to clientelism and electoral practices, including vote buying. This study seeks to provide both theoretical and empirical evidence on whether clientelism and electoral politics can be considered political commodities, particularly within the context of farming and fishing communities. The study examines the relationship between clientelism, electoral outcomes, and regional economic conditions, especially regarding poverty and local economies. Utilizing a systematic literature review of 30 accredited and reputable international journals, the research finds that clientelism continues to be prevalent in both developed and developing countries, particularly in regions with significant economic and welfare disparities. The journal criteria are: a) Literature is only in the form of international journals; b) Reputable international journals indexed by Scopus; and indexed in international databases such as Copernicus and others; and c) Current scientific journals published between 2014-2024. These disparities create fertile ground for clientelist practices, as they are used strategically by political actors to win elections. Empirical evidence from regional elections suggests that while clientelism may influence electability, its connection to economic improvement and the effectiveness of welfare programs remains weak. To mitigate the ongoing influence of clientelism in electoral politics, this study recommends several practical interventions: the regeneration of political candidates (patrons) from political parties, aligning campaign promises with the actual needs of communities, innovating electoral socialization strategies, presenting trustworthy and competent political figures, and fostering collective awareness at the community level about the importance of informed voting and social movements in elections. These measures aim to reduce the persistence of clientelism and promote more transparent and effective electoral practices.
Publication Details
Page(s) 1265-1282
Published Journal: Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 12, Issue: 4, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Regional Economy, Poverty, Farmers, agriculture and fisheries sector, Electoral Politics, Fishermen, Clientelism
References
Abdullah T.,Choudhury T. .2020 .An analytical study of the socio-economic and political status of the fishermen community in Golakganj, Dhubri District of Assam (INDIA). Ilkogretim Online-Elementary Education Online, 19 : 1080-1087.
Adisel A,Suryati S.,Riswanto R. .2023 .Portraying patron-client in fishermen work relationships: A phenomenon from Bengkulu, Indonesia. JSW: Jurnal Sosiologi Walisongo, 7 : 25-36.
Aida K.N.,A. Agustang. K.N.,Arlin A.,Agustang A.D.M. .2020 .The patron-client relationship patterns in Siwa Lima fishermen community, Aru Islands District Maluku, Indonesia. Iternational Journal of Scientific & Technology Research, 9 : 74-77.
Anderson S.,Francois P.,Kotwal A. .2015 .Clientelism in Indian villages. American Economic Review, 105 : 1780-1816.
Anzia S.F.,Jares J.A.,Malhotra N. .2022 .Does receiving government assistance shape political attitudes? Evidence from agricultural producers. American Political Science Review, 116 : 1389-4106.
Atkinson C.F. .2024 .Cheap, quick, and rigorous: artificial intelligence and the systematic literature review. Social Science Computer Review, 42 : 376-393.
Bahamonde H.,Canales A. .2022 .Electoral risk and vote buying, introducing prospect theory to the experimental study of clientelism. Electoral Studies, 80 : 1-12.
Baldwin K. .2019 .Elected MPs, traditional chiefs, and local public goods: Evidence on the role of leaders in coproduction from rural Zambia. Comparative Political Studies, 52 : 1925-1956.
Beg S. .2021 .Tenancy and clientelism. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 186 : 201-226.
Bøttkjaer L,M.K L .2021 .Why do voters support corrupt politicians? Experimental evidence from South Africa. The Journal of Politics, 83 : 788-793.
Boyd B.K,A.M. Solarino B.K .2016 .Ownership of corporations: A review, synthesis, and research agenda. Journal of Management, 42 : 1282-1314.
Cahyati ,Y.H.L. Lepo .2019 .Daily patronage politics: A village chief's route to power. PCD Journal, 7 : 169-196.
Carlborg P.,Kindström D.,Kowalkowski C. .2014 .The evolution of service innovation research: A critical review and synthesis. The Service Industries Journal, 34 : 373-398.
Cash P.J. .2018 .Developing theory-driven design research. Design Studies, 56 : 84-119.
Langara .2024 .Konawe Islands Regency in Figures 2024. Central Bureau of Statistics of Konawe Islands Regency, : .
Chandra K. .2004 .Why ethnic parties succeed: Patronage and ethnic head counts in India. , : .
Chukwuere J.E. .2023 .Exploring literature review methodologies in information systems research: A comparative study. Education & Learning in Developing Nations, 1 : 74-82.
Chyzh O.V.,Urbatsch R. .2021 .Bean counters: The effect of soy tariffs on change in republican vote share between the 2016 and 2018 elections. Journal of Politics, 83 : 415-19.
Cinar K. .2016 .A comparative analysis of clientelism in Greece, Spain, and Turkey: The rural-urban divide. Contemporary Politics, 22 : 77-94.
Corstange D. .2018 .Clientelism in competitive and uncompetitive elections. Comparative Political Studies, 51 : 76-104.
Dhanagare D.N. .1980 .Negative returns of ambivalence: Electoral politics of the farmers' movement,. Economic and Political Weekly, 49 : 40-50.
Diaz-Cayeros A. .2008 .Electoral risk and redistributive politics in Mexico and the United States. Studies in Comparative International Development, 43 : 129-150.
Ferrol-Schulte S.C.A.,Ferse M.,Glaser M. .2014 .Patron-client relationships, livelihoods and natural resource management in tropical coastal communities. Ocean & Coastal Management, 100 : 63-73.
Galvan J.L,M.C. Galvan J.L .2017 .Writing literature reviews: A guide for students of the social and behavioral sciences. , : .
Gans-Morse S.,Mazzuca S.,Nichter S. .2014 .Varieties of clientelism: Machine politics during elections. American Journal of Political Science, 58 : 415-432.
Goodin R.E. .2009 .The oxford handbook of political science. , : .
Gottlieb J and H.,Larreguy J and H. .2020 .An informational theory of electoral targeting in young clientelistic democracies: Evidence from Senegal. Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 15 : 53-104.
Gulotty R.,Strezhnev A. .2023 .The political benefits of the monoculture: Estimating the electoral effect of the market facilitation program. , : .
Gupta A. .2024 .Paddy politics: Is there an electoral cycle in India's agricultural policy. UCL Journal of Economics, 3 : 1-23.
Haryanto .2017 .Adaptation and continuities in clientelism in a fishing community in Takalar, South Sulawesi. Contemporary Southeast Asia, 39 : 511-31.
Hicken A.,E. Aspinall. A.,Weiss M.L.,Muhtadi B. .2022 .Buying brokers: electoral handouts beyond clientelism in a weak-party state. World Politics, 74 : 77-120.
Hicken A and N.L.,Nathan A and N.L. .2020 .clientelism's red herrings: dead ends and new directions in the study of nonprogrammatic politics. Annual Review of Political Science, 23 : 277-294.
Hicken A. .2011 .. Annual Review of Political Science, 14 : 289-310.
Holland A.C.,Palmer-Rubin B. .2015 .Beyond the machine. Comparative Political Studies, 48 : 1186-1223.
Issac L.W.,Harrison D.M.,Lipold P.L.,Harrison D.M.,Lipold P.L. .2022 .Class conflict in capitalist society. , : 118-136.
Jahan S.,Naveed M.,Zeshan M.A.,Tahir M.A. .2016 .How to conduct a systematic review: A narrative literature review. Cureus, 8 : 1-8.
Janzen J.P and N.P.,Hendricks J.P and N.P. .2020 .Are farmers made whole by trade aid?. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 42 : 205-26.
Jares J.A and N.,Malhotra J.A and N. .2024 .Policy impact and voter mobilization: Evidence from farmers' trade war experiences. American Political Science Review, : 1-24.
Kawata J. .2017 .Comparing political corruption and clientelism (eBook Published). , : .
Keefer P,Vlaicu R. .2017 .Vote buying and campaign promises. Journal of Comparative Economics, 45 : 773-792.
Kitschelt H. .2000 .Linkages between citizens and politicians in democratic polities. Comparative Political Studies, 33 : 845-879.
Kitschelt M.,Altamirano M. .2015 .Pursuing Representation and Accountability in Challenging Contexts. , : .
Kosztyán Z.T.,Csizmadia T.,Katona A.I. .2021 .Similarsystematic iterative multilayer review method. Journal of Informetrics, 15 : 1-19.
Kramon E.,Washington DC .2018 .Money for votes: the causes and consequences of electoral clientelism in africa. , : .
Kramon E. .2017 .money for votes: the csuses and consequences of electoral clientelism in africa. , : .
Kurosaki T.,Saumik P.,Firman W. .2021 .Out of communal land: Clientelism through delegation of agricultural tenancy contracts. IZA Discussion Papers, 14263 : 1-150.
Kvartiuk T.,Herzfeld T. .2021 .Redistributive politics in Russia: The political economy of agricultural subsidies. Comparative Economic Studies, 63 : 1-30.
Lame G. .2019 .Systematic literature reviews: an introduction. Delf. The Netherlands, 5-8 August, : 1633-1642.
Larreguy H.A. .2013 .Monitoring political brokers: evidence from clientelistic networks in Mexico. , : .
Lim S.,Kumar F.,Ali F. .2022 .Advancing knowledge through literature reviews: 'what', 'why', and 'how to contribute. The Service Industries Journal, 42 : 481-513.
Lindberg S.I. .2010 .What accountability pressures do MPs in Africa face and how do they respond? Evidence from Ghana. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 48 : 117-142.
Liu J. .2021 .The abolition of agricultural taxes and the transformation of clientelism in the countryside of Post Mao China. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 49 : 585-603.
Luft J.A.,S. Jeong. J.A.,Idsardi R.,Gardner G. .2022 .Literature reviews, theoretical frameworks, and conceptual frameworks: An introduction for new biology education researchers. CBE-Life Sciences Education, 21 : 1-10.
Majid M.,Shami M. .2024 .Unpacking rural-urban clientelist networks. Oxford Development Studies, 52 : 160-178.
Mares I.,Young L. .2016 .Buying, expropriating, and stealing votes. Annual Review of Political Science, 19 : 267-288.
McAngus C. .2018 .A survey of Scottish fishermen ahead of Brexit: political, social and constitutional attitudes. Maritime Studies, 17 : 41-54.
Mehta S.,Sinha S. .2022 .The rise and fall of agrarian populism in postcolonial India: Farmers' movements and electoral politics at crossroad. Sociological Bulletin, 71 : 1-21.
Mills E.N. .2023 .The politics of transnational fishers' movements. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 50 : 665-690.
Miñarro S.,Forero G.N.,Reuter H.,Putten I.E.V. .2016 .The role of patron-client relations on the fishing behaviour of artisanal fishermen in the Spermonde Archipelago (Indonesia). Marine Policy, 69 : 73-83.
Miscoiu S,Kakdeu L.M. .2021 .Authoritarian clientelism: The case of the President's 'Creatures' in Cameroon. Acta Politica, 56 : 639-657.
Nichter S. .2008 .Vote buying or turnout buying? Machine politics and the secret ballot. American Political Science Review, 102 : 19-31.
Noak P.A. .2024 .Political clientelism in rural areas: Understanding the impact on regional head elections in Indonesia. Journal of Ecohumanism, 3 : 3898-3909.
Palmatier R.W.,Hulland J. .2018 .Review articles: Purpose, process, and structure. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 46 : 1-5.
Pellicer M and E.,Wegner M and E. .2023 .What is bad about clientelism? Citizen perceptions in poor communities in South Africa and Tunisia. Electoral Studies, 84 : 102620.
Pellicer M.,E. Wegner. M.,Bayer M.,Tischmeyer C. .2021 .Clientelism from the client's perspective: A metaanalysis of ethnographic literature. Perspectives on Politics, 20 : 931-947.
Perry A and N.,Hammond A and N. .2002 .Systematic review: The experience of a PhD student. Psychology Learning and Teaching, 2 : 32-35.
Poteete A.R. .2019 .Electoral competition, clientelism, and responsiveness to fishing communities in Senegal. African Affairs, 118 : 24-48.
Pursell E and N.,McRae E and N. .2020 .How to perform a systematic literature review: a guide for healthcare researchers, practitioners and students. , : .
Ravitch S.,Riggan S. .2016 .Reason & rigor: How conceptual frame-works guide research. , : .
Risman. ,Muhiddin A.,Hartaman N. .2023 .Political participation of fishermen community voters amidst COVID-19 in the local election. JCLP: Journal of Contemporary Local Politics, 2 : 34-41.
Roberts N.,Mengge B.,Utina M.R.,Muhatar F.,Icwardanhi A.,Zulkifli R.M.,Humphries A. .2022 .Patron-client relationships shape value chains in an Indonesian island-based fisheries system. Marine Policy, 143 : 105142.
Rodell J.B.,Breitsohl H.,Schröder M.,Keating D.J. .2016 .Employee volunteering: A review and framework for future research. Journal of Management, 42 : 55-84.
Roniger L.,Jean-Louis B.,Frederic S.,Javier A.,Simona P. .2004 .Political clientelism, democracy, and market economy. Comparative Politics, 36 : 353-375.
Saikkonen I. .2021 .Coordinating the machine: Subnational political context and the effectiveness of machine politics. Acta Politica, 56 : 658-676.
Shaheen N.,Shaheen A.,Ramadan A.,Hefnawy M.T.,Ramadan A.,Ibrahim I.A.,Hassanein M.E.,Ashour M.E.,Flouty O. .2023 .Appraising systematic reviews: a comprehensive guide to ensuring validity and reliability. Frontiers in research metrics and analytics, 8 : 1-9.
Shim J. .2022 .Overpromising social welfare benefits? Electoral competition and welfare politics in Taiwan. Journal of East Asian Studies, 22 : 99-123.
Singer M. .2009 .Buying voters with dirty money: The relationship between clientelism and corruption. Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association Meeting. , : .
Sio U.N.,Kotovsky K.,Cagan J. .2015 .Fixation or inspiration? A meta-analytic review of the role of examples on design processes. Design Studies, 39 : 70-99.
Snyder H. .2019 .Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. Journal of Business Research, 104 : 333-339.
Stokes S. .2021 .Clientelism and development: Is there a poverty trap? WIDER Working. Paper, 91 : 1-16.
Stokes S.C.,Dunning T.,Nazareno M.,Brusco V. .2013 .Brokers, voters, and clientelism: The puzzle of distributive politics. , : .
Tricco A.C.,J. Antony W.,Zarin L.,Strifler M.,Ghassemi J.,Ivory S.E.,Straus S.E. .2015 .A scoping review of rapid review methods. BMC Medicine, 13 : 1-15.
Weitz-Shapiro R. .2012 .What wins votes: Why some politicians opt out of clientelism. American Journal of Political Science, 56 : 568-583.
Jr.R.T. Williams,Clark L.A.,Clark W.R.,Raffo D.M. .2020 .Re-examining systematic literature review in management research: Additional benefits and execution protocols. European Management Journal, 39 : 521-533.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

14

Views