No Detail Found!

Lethality-Driven Hazard Ranking for Underground Coal Mining Fatalities in Pakistan: A CRITIC- MARCOS Analysis of Technical Failure Pathways

Author(s)
Atif Javed Central South University of China,,China
Rana Muhammad Asad Khan Pak-Austria Fachhochschule (PAF-IAST),Haripur,Pakistan
Ghufran Ur Rehman Pak-Austria Fachhochschule (PAF-IAST),Haripur,Pakistan
Hira Hameed Department of Physics, University of Punjab,Pakistan
Abstract
Underground coal mining in Pakistan continues to face recurrent fatal accidents caused by methane explosions, toxic gas exposure, roof and ground failures, flooding, blasting, mechanical haulage, and electrical hazards. Although earlier studies have reported accident patterns in Pakistan’s coal sector, limited work has converted recent fatal incident evidence into an objective and reproducible hazard prioritization framework. This study develops a data driven engineering assessment of fatal hazard pathways in Pakistan’s underground coal mines using a newly compiled public source dataset covering the period 2016-2026, supplemented by a historical listing of incidents from 2011-2015 for contextual background. After excluding security related attacks that do not represent underground technical hazard mechanisms, 30 fatal technical incidents involving 164 fatalities from the 2016-2026 period were retained for the primary analysis. A decision matrix was constructed using three quantitative criteria: accident share, fatality share, and lethality factor. The Criteria Importance Through Intercriteria Correlation (CRITIC) method derived objective criterion weights from the variability and conflict structure of the data, while the Measurement of Alternatives and Ranking according to Compromise Solution (MARCOS) method ranked hazard pathways according to their relative criticality. CRITIC results assigned the highest weight to lethality factor, followed by accident share and fatality share, indicating the importance of considering both occurrence and fatality intensity. The MARCOS ranking identified methane/gas explosion as the highest priority fatal hazard pathway, followed by flooding/water inrush, suffocation/toxic gas exposure, and collapse/ground failure. Flooding showed high lethality but was represented by fewer documented events; therefore, its ranking should be interpreted cautiously. These findings highlight methane control, ventilation reliability, gas monitoring, emergency preparedness, and ground control management as urgent engineering priorities for reducing fatality risk in Pakistan’s underground coal mines
Publication Details
Page(s) 1-92
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Book of Abstracts: 8th International Conference "Earth Sciences Pakistan 2026" (ESP-2026), June 12-14, 2026, Volume: 1, Issue: 1, Year: 2026

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Risk prioritization, CRITIC– MARCOS method, Coal mine safety, Underground coal mining, Methane explosion, Fatal accident analysis
0

Citations

0

Downloads

5

Views