Paper recycling renders sundry wastewater with high level of suspended solids, organic and short fibers which are normally lost along with the effluent, and it adds extra cost to treatment and environmental burden. The wastewater treatment was assessed using a synthetic flocculant and a natural polymer system separately, the primary goal of which was to improve the quality of the effluent and the reusability of the recoverable fibers. Firstly, the primary coagulant was alum along with synthetic polyacrylamide (PAM) as flocculant then the performance was assessed using as amphoteric guar gum as an independent natural coagulantflocculant system, without alum. Jar tests were also done to optimize dosage in turbidity, suspended solids and COD removal and in capturing fibers in the sludge. During the treatment, approximately 96% turbidity, 97% suspended solids and 90% COD were observed. The guar-only treatment was also compared with amphoteric and showed similar findings showing 96% turbidity removal, 96% suspended solids removal and 90% removal COD removal. Nevertheless, the amphoteric guar was more expensive based on a unit cost in comparison with the alum-PAM system and, thus, was not economically competitive. The fibers produced in the recovered sludge in both schemes were of high quality and could be used in the process of papermaking. In general, the findings demonstrate that amphoteric guar could be used technically as the equal to standard alum-PAM treatment, and it is possible to indicate that alum-PAM becomes more cost- effective in the present circumstances, and polymer-based coagulant/flocculants play the potentially important role in more sustainable paper-recycling activities