No Detail Found!

Bibliometric insights of three decades of camel research in europe with an emphasis on collaboration, research themes and emerging topics

Author(s)
M. Kandeel Department of Biomedical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, King Faisal University,31982 Al-Ahsa,Saudi Arabia
M. Mahmoud College of Medicine, Delta University for Science and Technology,Gamasa 11152,Egypt
Abstract
Camels are essential to the livelihoods of pastoral communities in dry and semi-arid regions. Although camel research in Europe is not as prominent as in camel-rearing regions, it has gained considerable interest in recent years, focusing on various aspects such as disease transmission, genetics, and the nutritional benefits of camel products. This study aims to conduct a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of camel research in Europe. It evaluates the evolution of this field, emphasizing publication trends, citation impact, collaboration networks and emerging topics. Data was sourced from the Scopus database and 1385 documents were analyzed. The analysis was conducted using VOSviewer and the Bibliometrix package in R Studio. The analysis revealed steady growth in camel research output, with a 5.51% annual increase from 1995 to 2024. A total of 5094 authors contributed to the field, with an average of 22.61 citations per document and 77.69% of documents are from international collaboration. European countries, particularly France, the UK, and Germany acted as key hubs for international collaboration. The bibliometric analysis identified five main keyword clusters in camel research in Europe. These clusters include themes such as camel physiology and veterinary medicine, the nutritional and biochemical properties of camel milk, infectious disease and antibiotic resistance, zoonotic diseases and genetics, and immunology and molecular biology, reflecting the diverse research areas within this field. Future research should focus on expanding sources, including non-English publications, and exploring advanced technologies such as genomics and AI to enhance the understanding of camel biology and its global impact.
Publication Details
Page(s) 916-934
Published Journal: Journal of Animal and Plant sciences, Volume: 35, Issue: 4, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
International Collaboration, Camel milk, Bibliometric analysis, Scopus, R Studio, VOSviewer, camel milk, Europe, Camel research, Camel milk
References
Abdulrahman A.O.,Ismael M.A.,Al-Hosaini K.,Rame C.,Al-Senaidy A.M.,Dupont J.,Ayoub M.A. .2016 .7: 4. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne), 00004 : .
Adah A.S.,Ayo J.O.,Adah D.A. .2022 .Unique physiological and behavioural adaptive features of the One-Humped Camel (Camelus dromedarius) to arid environments. J Appl Vet Sci, 168375 : 57-64.
Abri Al,M. Al,Alfoudari A.,Mohammad Z.,Almathen F.,Al-Marzooqi W.,Al-Hajri S.,Al-Amri M.,Bahbahani H. .2023 .Assessing genetic diversity and defining signatures of positive selection on the genome of dromedary camels from the southeast of the Arabian Peninsula. , 1296610 : 1296610.
Ali S.,Ahmad N.,Akhtar N.,Noakes D.E. .2007 .Metabolite contents of blood serum and fluid from small and large sized follicles in dromedary camels during the peak and the low breeding seasons. Anim. Reprod. Sci, 10 : 446-456.
Almansour M.,Jarrar B.,Faye B.,Al-Doaiss A.,Shati A.,Meriane D. .2024 .The salivary glands of the camel: an element of adaptation to desert conditions and mitigation of climate change impacts. Jordan J Biol Sci, 10 : 99-108.
Almejnah O.,Saed H.A.,Marzok M.,Almubarak A.,Kandeel M.,Shosha S.,S. S.,Farag S. .2023 .Current profiling of research on donkeys and its implications in global studies based on bibliometric analysis. J. Adv. Vet. Res, 13 : 1835-1841.
Alsaleem A.,Kandeel M. .2024 .The trends of camel research in north America: a bibliometric approach. J Camel Pract Res, 00032 : 2277-8934.
Androniceanu A.,Veith C.,Ionescu P.,Marinescu A.G.,Sima A,Paru A .2024 .Shaping sustainable futures: public policies and renewable energy insights based on global bibliometric analysis. Sustainability, 10 : 4957.
Ghahroudi Arbabi,M. Arbabi,Desmyter A.,Wyns L.,Hamers R.,Muyldermans S. .1997 .Selection and identification of single domain antibody fragments from camel heavy-chain antibodies. FEBS Lett, 5793(97) : 01062-4.
Aria M.,Cuccurullo C. .2017 .Bibliometrix: an Rtool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. J informetr, 08 : 959-975.
Arruda H.,Silva E.R.,Lessa M.,Proenca D.,Bartholo R. .2022 .VOSviewer and Bibliometrix. J Med Libr Assoc, 1434 : 392-395.
Bilal Z.,Akhmetsadykova S.,Baubekova A.,Tormo H.,Faye B.,Konuspayeva G. .2024 .The main features and microbiota diversity of fermented camel milk. Foods, 10 : .
Boukria O.,Boudalia S.,Bhat Z.F.,Hassoun A.,Aït-Kaddour A. .2023 .Evaluation of the adulteration of camel milk by non-camel milk using multispectral image, fluorescence and infrared spectroscopy. Spectrochim Acta A Mol Biomol Spectrosc, 122932 : 122932.
Chen X.,Xie H.,Li Z.,Leng M.,Wang F.L. .2022 .Information fusion and artificial intelligence for smart healthcare: a bibliometric study. Inf Process Manag, 103113 : 103113.
Chu D.K.W.,Hui K.P.Y.,Perera R.,Miguel E.,Niemeyer D.,Zhao J.,Channappanavar R.,Oladipo J.O.,Traoré A.,Fassi-Fihri O.,Ali A.,Demissié G.F.,Muth D.,Chan M.C.W.,Nicholls J.M.,Meyerholz D.K.,Kuranga S.A.,Mamo G.,Zhou Z.,Hemida M.G.,Webby R.J.,Roger F.,Rambaut A.,Poon L.L.M.,Perlman S.,Drosten C.,Chevalier V.,Peiris M. .2018 .MERS coronaviruses from camels in Africa exhibit region-dependent genetic diversity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 10 : 3144-3149.
Dadar S.S.,Omar Y.,Shahali Y.,Fakhri J.,Godfroid J.,A.M. Khaneghah J. .2022 .The prevalence of camel brucellosis and associated risk factors: a global meta-epidemiological study. Qual Assur Saf Crops Foods, 10 : 1088-93.
Darnay L.,Barkó A.,Hidas K.,Pataki F.A.,Surányi J.,Laczay P. .2024 .Comparison of quality properties of pasteurized milk‐ based camel cheese depending on calf rennet concentration and microbial transglutaminase. Int J Dairy Technol, 10 : 13060-0307.
Flis Z.,Szatkowski P.,Pielichowska K.,Molik K. .2023 .The Potential of Sheep or Camel Milk Constituents to Contribute to Novel Dressings for Diabetic Wounds. Int J Mol Sci. 24, 10 : .
Haagmans B.L.,Al Dhahiry S.H.,Reusken C.B.,Raj V.S.,Galiano M.,Myers R.,Godeke G.J.,Jonges M.,Farag E.,Diab A.,Ghobashy H.,Alhajri F.,Al-Thani M.,Al-Marri S.A.,Al Romaihi H.E.,Khal A. Al,Bermingham A.,Osterhaus A.D.,M.M. AlHajri and M.P. Koopmans A.D. .2014 .Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus in dromedary camels: an outbreak investigation. Lancet Infect Dis, 3099(13) : 70690-x.
Hussen J.,Al-Jabr O.A.,Alkuwayti M.A.,Alrabiah N.A.,Falemban B.,Alouffi A.,Al Salim W.S.,Kamyingkird and M. Desquesnes K. .2023 .A flow cytometry study of the binding and stimulation potential of inactivated Trypanosoma evansi toward Dromedary camel Leukocytes. Pathogens. 13, 10 : .
Hussen J.,Althagafi H.,Alalai M.A.,Alrabiah N.A.,Al Abdulsalam N.K.,Falemban B.,Alouffi A.,Al-Salem W.S.,Desquesnes M.,Hébert M. .2024 .Surra-affected dromedary camels show reduced numbers of blood B-cells and in vitro evidence of Trypanosoma-induced B cell death. Trop Anim Health Prod, 10 : 223.
Pastrana Iglesias,C. Iglesias,González F.J. Navas,Macri M.,M.D.A. Martínez Martínez E.,Ciani J.V.,Delgado Bermejo J.V. .2024 .Identification of novel genetic loci related to dromedary camel (Camelus dromedarius) morphometrics, biomechanics, and behavior by genome-wide association studies. BMC Vet Res, 10 : 418.
Kandeel M. .2024 .Trends in camel research in South Asia: a bibliometric approach. Vet, 2763 : 2773-2773.
Kandeel M.,Morsy M.A.,Abd H.M.,Marzok M.,El-Beltagi H.S.,Al Khodair K.M.,Soliman W.E.,Albokhadaim I.,Venugopala K.N. .2023 .A century of “camel research”: a bibliometric analysis. Front Vet Sci, 10 : 1157667.
Kandeel M.,Morsy M.A.,El-lateef A.,Marzok M.,El-Beltagi H.,Alkhodair K.,Venugopala and M. AlRasheed K.N. .2023 .A century of" Anticoccidial Drugs": bibliometric analysis. Front. Vet. Sci, 10 : 1157683.
Kandeel M.K. .2024 .Bibliometric analysis of camel research in China: research trends and thematic evolution. Egypt J. Vet. Sci, 315756 : 16.
Khalafalla A.I. .2023 .Zoonotic diseases transmitted from the camels. Front. Vet. Sci, 1244833 : 1244833.
Khalafalla A.I.,Rashid J.,Khan R.A.,K.M. Alamin A.,Benkhelil P.,Calistri A.,Giovannini I.A.,Khan M.A. Al,Hosani S.S.,Al Muhairi S.S. .2019 .Preliminary Cc Brucellosis in Dromedary Camels (Camelus dromedarius). Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis, 2537 : 412-417.
Khalid N.,Abdelrahim D.N.,Hanach N.,Khan M.,Mahrous L.,Radwan H.,Naja F.,Madkour M.,Obaideen K.,Khraiwesh H.,Faris M. .2023 .Effect of camel milk on lipid profile among patients with diabetes: a systematic review, meta-analysis, and metaregression of randomized controlled trials. BMC Complement Med Ther, 10 : 438.
Cook E.A.J.,Okba N.M.A.,Kivali V.,Reusken C.,Haagmans B.L.,Fèvre E.M. .2020 .Middle East Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus (MERS-CoV) Seropositive camel handlers in Kenya. Viruses, 10 : .
Lado S.,Elbers J.P.,Rogers M.F.,Melo-Ferreira J.,Yadamsuren A.,Corander J.,Horin P.,Burger P.A. .2020 .Nucleotide diversity of functionally different groups of immune response genes in Old World camels based on newly annotated and reference-guided assemblies. BMC Genomics, 10 : 606.
Maitra A.,Iglesias Pastrana C.,Faye B.,Burger P.,Ciani P. .2025 .Breeding of camels in Europe: between continuity and innovation. Appl Sci, 10 : 1644.
Mejri L.,Vásquez-Villanueva R.,Hassouna M.,Marina and M.C. García M.L. .2017 .Identification of peptides with antioxidant and antihypertensive capacities by RP-HPLC-QTOF-MS in dry fermented camel sausages inoculated with different starter cultures and ripening times. Food Res Int, 07 : 708-716.
Melaku S.K.,Regassa F.,Tessema T.S.,Kassa T.,Vencato J.,Owiny D.O.,Stelletta C. .2015 .Testicular cytological profiles of apparently healthy male dromedary camels during rutting and non-rutting periods. Anim. Reprod. Sci, 10 : 105-111.
Mohandesan E.,Fitak R.R.,Corander J.,Yadamsuren A.,Chuluunbat B.,Abdelhadi O.,Raziq A.,Nagy P.,Walzer C.,Faye B.,Burger P.A. .2017 .Mitogenome sequencing in the genus camelus reveals evidence for purifying selection and long-term divergence between wild and domestic Bactrian camels. Sci Rep, 10 : 9970.
Muyldermans S. .2001 .Single domain camel antibodies: current status. J Biotechnol, 0352(01) : 00021-6.
Ommeh S.,Zhang W.,Zohaib A.,Chen J.,Zhang H.,Hu B.,Ge X.-Y.,Yang X.-L.,Masika M.,Obanda V. .2018 .Genetic evidence of Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERSCov) and widespread seroprevalence among camels in Kenya. Virol Sin, 10 : 484-492.
Reusken C.B.,Haagmans B.L.,Müller M.A.,Gutierrez C.,Godeke G.J.,Muth D.,Raj V.S.,Smits-De Vries L.,Corman V.M.,Drexler J.F.,Smits S.L.,El Y.E.,Tahir Y.E.,J. van Beek Y.E.,Nowotny N.,Maanen E.,Hidalgo-Hermoso B.J.,Bosch P.,Rottier A.,Osterhaus C.,Gortázar-Schmidt C.,Drosten M.P.,Koopmans M.P. .2013 .Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus neutralising serum antibodies in dromedary camels: a comparative serological study. Lancet Infect. Dis, 3099(13) : 70164-6.
Sahoo A. .2020 .Camel: a fast-declining animal species but can strive with its unique climate resilience and 'desert to medicine'application”. EC Vet Sci, 5 : 43-57.
Shawaf T.,Schuberth H.J.,Hussen H.J. .2022 .Immune cell composition of the bronchoalveolar lavage fluid in healthy and respiratory diseased dromedary camels. BMC Vet Res, 10 : 353.
Thelwall M.,Sud P. .1900 .Growth in articles, abstracts, countries, fields, and journals. Quant Sci Stud, 10 : 00177-50.
van Eck N.J.,Waltman N.J. .2010 .Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics, 10 : 523-538.
Wernery U.,Pfeffer U. .1997 .Camel pox in the United Arab Emirates and its prevention. J Camel Pract Res, 4 : 135-139.
Zubair S.,Fischer A.,Liljander A.,Meens J.,Hegerman J.,Gourlé H.,Bishop R.P.,Younan M.,Mustafa M.I.,Mushtaq M.,E. M.,Jores M. .2015 .Complete genome sequence of Staphylococcus aureus, strain ILRI_Eymole1/1, isolated from a Kenyan dromedary camel. Stand Genomic Sci, 10 : 109.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

17

Views