No Detail Found!

Effects of washing dirty eggs of geese with boric acid and vinegar on hatchability and microbial loads

Author(s)
M. Eroglu Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Siirt University,56100, Siirt,Türkiye
Z. Erisir Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Firat University,23119, Elazig,Türkiye
U. G. Simsek Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Firat University,23119, Elazig,Türkiye
S. Iflazoglu Mutlu Department of Animal Nutrition and Nutritional Diseases, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Firat University,23119, Elazig,Türkiye
Y. Baykalir Department of Biostatistics, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Balikesir University,10145 Balikesir,Türkiye
A. Gungoren Department of Food Hygiene and Technology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kastamonu University,37150, Kastamonu,Türkiye
M. Mutlu Elazıg Veterinary Control Institute, Republıc of Turkey Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry,23200, Elazig,Türkiye
G. Adiyaman Karakus Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Firat University,23119, Elazig,Türkiye
S. Akarsu Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Firat University,23119, Elazig,Türkiye
Abstract
This study aimed to evaluate whether washing dirty goose eggs with tap water, vinegar, and boric acid solutions could improve hatching performance and reduce microbial load. A total of 3,360 eggs were used for hatching performance assessments, while 84 eggs were analyzed for microbiological parameters. The study consisted of seven treatment groups: physically clean eggs (PC), unwashed dirty eggs (NC), eggs washed in tap water (TW), eggs washed with a vinegar solution containing 2% acetic acid (S2), eggs washed with a vinegar solution containing 4% acetic acid (S4), eggs washed with a 2% boric acid solution (B2), and eggs washed with a 4% boric acid solution (B4). Hatchability of set eggs and hatch of fertile eggs improved significantly in the PC, S2, and B2 groups (P<0.01). Embryonic mortality was significantly low in the PC and B2 groups (P<0.05). Significant differences were observed between the groups for total mesophilic aerobic bacteria (TMAB) (P<0.001), total coliforms (TCN) (P<0.01), and Escherichia coli (P<0.01). The lowest TMAB counts were recorded in the S2 and B4 groups, while the lowest TCN counts were observed in the B4 group. Bacterial analysis of egg contents showed that all bacterial groups were below detectable limits. In conclusion, washing dirty goose eggs with tap water, vinegar, or boric acid solutions (2% and 4%) effectively reduced the microbial load on the eggshell for all examined microorganisms and significantly improved hatching parameters compared to dirty eggs.
Publication Details
Page(s) 354-363
Published Journal: Journal of Animal and Plant sciences, Volume: 35, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Egg, vinegar, Microbial load, Boric Acid, Washing
References
Baylan M.,Bulancak A.,Akpinar G.C.,Canogullari S. .2015 .Natural products used in the disinfection of hatching eggs. Çukurova J. Agric. Food Sci, 30(2) : 25-32.
Buhr R. J.,Mauldin J.M.,Bailey J.S.,Cox N.A. .1994 .Automated spray sanitizing of broiler hatching eggs 2. Hatchability of nest clean and dirty eggs. J. App. Poult. Res, 3(3) : 226-233.
Budak N.H.,Aykin E.,Seydim A.C.,Greene A.K.,Guzel-Seydim Z.B. .2014 .Functional properties of vinegar. J. Food Sci, 79(5) : 12434-3841.
Chen T.,Chen P.,Giudici F.,Chen F. .2016 .Vinegar functions on health: constituents, sources, and formation mechanisms. Compr. Rev. Food Sci. Food Saf, 15(6) : 12228-4337.
Chen X.,Li X.,He Z.,Hou Z.,Yang N.,Zheng J .2019 .Comparative study of eggshell antibacterial effectivity in precocial and altricial birds using Escherichia coli. PLoS One, 14(7) : .
Clímaco W.L.D.S.,É.D.F. Melo D.P.,Vaz D.P.,M.M. Saldanha M.F.V.D.S.,Pinto L.C.C.,Fernandes N.C.,Baião L.G.,Oliveira F.M.,Sant'Anna M.R.,Souza L.J.C.,Lara L.J.C. .2018 .Eggshell microbiology and quality of hatching eggs subjected to different sanitizing procedures. Pes. Agropec. Bras, 53 : S0100-1183.
Dang D. X.,Zhou H.,Lou Y.,Li D. .2022 .Effects of in ovo feeding of disaccharide and/or methionine on hatchability, growth performance, blood hematology, and serum antioxidant parameters in geese. J. Anim. Sci, 100(2) : .
De Reu K.,Grijspeerdt K.,Messens W.,Heyndrickx M.,Uyttendaele M.,Debevere J.,Herman J. .2006 .Eggshell factors influencing eggshell penetration and whole egg contamination by different bacteria, including Salmonella enteritidis. Int. J. Food Microbiol, 04(3) : 253-260.
Deeming D.C. .1987 .Effect of cuticle removal on the water vapour conductance of egg shells of several species of domestic bird. Br. Poult. Sci, 28(2) : 231-237.
Durmus M.,Kutlu H.R. .2019 .Factors affecting chick quality in broiler chicken production and qualitative parameters used in quality classification. Çukurova J. Agric. Food Sci, 11(2) : 194-206.
Eroglu M.,Erisir Z. .2022 .The effects of breeder age and laying period on hatchability and some external egg quality characteristics in breeder geese. Anim. Sci. Pap. Rep, 40(1) : 89-98.
Eroglu M.,Erisir Z.,Mutlu S. I.,Baykalir Y.,Gungoren A.,Mutlu M.,Karakus G. Adiyaman,Akarsu S.,Bicer Z. .2024 .Investigating the disinfecting efficacy of acetic and boric acid used by spraying on hatching goose eggs. Eur. Poult. Sci, 392 : 1-9.
Erol İ. .2007 .. Gıda Hijyeni ve Mikrobiyolojisi. 1st Ed. Pozitif Yay. Ltd. Şti, : .
Fasenko G.M.,Christopher and L.M. McMullen E.O.D. .2009 .Spraying hatching eggs with electrolyzed oxidizing water reduces eggshell microbial load without compromising broiler production parameters. Poult. Sci, 88(5) : 00359-1127.
Fouad W. ,Abdelfattah and M. M.G.,Abdelnabi M.G. .2019 .Effect of spraying hatching eggs by different levels of vinegar on embryological development, hatchability and physiological performance of dandarwi chicks. Egypt. Poult. Sci. J, 39(1) : 291-309.
Gole V.C.,K.K. Chousalkar J.R.,Roberts M.,Sexton D.,May J.,Tan A,Kiermeier A .2014 .Effect of egg washing and correlation between eggshell characteristics and egg penetration by various Salmonella Typhimurium strains. Plos One, 9(3) : .
Harrigan W.F. .1998 .Laboratory methods in food microbiology. , : .
He Z.,Chen X.,Shi X.,Li X.,Li C.,Li J.,Xu G.,Yang N.,Zheng J .2020 .Acetic acid, vinegar, and citric acid as washing materials for cuticle removal to improve hatching performance of quail eggs. Poult. Sci, 04(8) : 3865-3876.
Hrnčár C.,Hanusová E.,Hanus A.,Arpášová H.,Kokoszyński D.,Bujko D. .2021 .The effect of various disinfectants on hatching results in chickens. Sci. Pap. Anim. Sci. Biotechnol, 54(1) : 193-196.
Karabulut O.,Hikmet U.N.,Garip M.,Bulut G. .2017 .Research on hatching yield in geese in Aksaray region. J. Bahri Dagdas Anim. Res, 6(1) : 13-22.
Legros S.,Jan S.,Bonnassie M.,Gautier T.,Croguennec S.,Pezennec M.F.,Cochet F.,Nau S.C.,Andrews F.,Baron F. .2021 .The role of ovotransferrin in egg-white antimicrobial activity: A review. Foods, 10(4) : 823.
Leleu S.,Messens W.,K. De Reu L.,Herman M.,Heyndrickx M.,J. De Baerdemaeker C.W.,Michiels M.,Bain M. .2011 .Effect of egg washing on the cuticle quality of brown and white table eggs. J. Food. Prot, 74(10) : JFP11-013.
Liu Q.,Liu Z.,Zhang C.,Xu Y.,Li X.,Gao and H. .2021 .Effects of 3% boric acid solution on cutaneous Candida albicans infection and microecological flora mice. Front. Microbiol, 12 : .
Melo E.F.,Clímaco W.L.S.,Triginelli M.V.,Vaz D.P.,M.R. De Souza N.C.,Baião M.A.,Pompeu L.J.C.,Lara L.J.C. .2019 .An evaluation of alternative methods for sanitizing hatching eggs. Poult. Sci, 98(6) : 2466-2473.
Messens W.,Grijspeerdt K.,Herman K. .2005 .Eggshell penetration by Salmonella: a review. Worlds Poult. Sci. J, 61(1) : 71-86.
Oliveira G.D.S. C.,McManus P.H.G.S.,Santos P.H.G.S.,D.E.R. de Sousa J.L.P.R.,Jivago J.L.P.R.,M.B. de Castro V.M.,Dos Santos V.M. .2024 .Hatching egg sanitizers based on essential oils: microbiological parameters, hatchability, and poultry health. Antibiotics, 13(11) : 1066.
Oliveira C.,McManus C.B.,Salgado V.M.,Dos Santos V.M. .2022 .Effects of sanitizers on microbiological control of hatching eggshells and poultry health during embryogenesis and early stages after hatching in the last decade. Animals, 12(20) : 2826.
Oliveira G.D.S.,Dos Santos V.M.,Nascimento S.T.,Rodrigues J.C. .2020 .Alternative sanitizers to paraformaldehyde for incubation of fertile eggs. Poult. Sci, 99(4) : 2001-2006.
Olsen R.,Kudirkiene E.,Pors S.,Karlskov-Mortensen P.,Li L.,Papasolomontos S.,Angastiniotou C.,Christensen C. .2019 .Impact of egg disinfection of hatching eggs on the eggshell microbiome and bacterial load. Poult. Sci, 11(11) : 3901-3911.
Onk K.,Kirmizibayrak T. .2019 .The egg production, hatchability, growing, slaughter and carcass characteristics of geese (Anser Anser) reared under breeders conditions in Kars Province; I. Egg production and hatchability characteristics. TURJAF, 7(3) : 2355-549.
Raimondi G.,Orsini F.,Maggio A.,Barbieri G. .2006 .Yield and quality of hydroponically grown sweet basil cultivars. Acta Hort, 723 : 357-363.
Salamon A. .2020 .Fertility and hatchability in goose eggs: A review. Int. J. Poult. Sci, 19(2) : 51-65.
Şeremet Ç. .2012 .Civciv kalitesini etkileyen etmenler ve değerlendirme yöntemleri. J. Anim. Prod, 53(1) : 38-43.
Sengun I.Y.,Kilic G.,Ozturk B. .2020 .Screening physicochemical, microbiological and bioactive properties of fruit vinegars produced from various raw materials. Food Sci. Biotechnol, 29(3) : 401-408.
Shahein E.H.,Sedeek E. .2014 .Role of spraying hatching eggs with natural disinfectants on hatching characteristics. Egypt. Poult. Sci. J, 34(1) : 213-230.
Shi X.,Li X.,Li X.,He Z.,Chen X.,Song J.,Zeng L.,Liang Q.,Li J.,Xu G.,Zheng J. .2022 .Antibacterial properties of TMA against Escherichia coli and effect of temperature and storage duration on TMA content, lysozyme activity and content in eggs. Foods, 11(4) : 527.
Sözcü A.,İpek A .2020 .The effects of lignocellulose supplementation on laying performance, egg quality parameters, aerobic bacterial load of eggshell, serum biochemical parameters, and jejunal histomorphological traits of laying hens. Poult. Sci, 01(6) : 3179-3187.
Sun C.,J. Liu W.,Li G.,Xu N.,Yang N. .2017 .Divergent proteome patterns of egg albumen from domestic chicken, duck, goose, turkey, quail and pigeon. Proteomics, 17 : 1700145.
Tan F. J.,Rungruengpet W.,Simsiri U.,Kaewkot C.,Sun Y.M.,Chumngoen W. .2022 .Influences of egg washing and storage temperature on quality and shelf life of duck eggs during storage. Braz. J. Poult. Sci, 24 : .
Van den Brand M.P.,Sosef A.,Lourens J. Van Harn .2016 .Effects of floor eggs on hatchability and later life performance in broiler chickens. Poult. Sci, 95(5) : 1025-1032.
Wales A.,Davies R. .2020 .Review of hatchery transmission of bacteria with focus on Salmonella, chick pathogens and antimicrobial resistance. Worlds Poult. Sci. J, 76(3) : 517-536.
Wang C.,Lien C.,Wang S.,Lin M.,Hsiao C.,Lin T. .2019 .The effect of the nest type on the nest egg ratio of the white Roman geese. J. Taiwan Live. Res, 52(1) : 45-50.
Wlazlo L.,Drabik K.,Al-Shammari K.I.,Batkowska J.,Nowakowicz-Debek and M. Gryzińska B. .2019 .Use of reactive oxygen species (ozone, hydrogen peroxide) for disinfection of hatching eggs. Poult. Sci, 12(5) : 2478-2484.
Yagnik D.,Serafin V.,Shah A.J. .2018 .Antimicrobial activity of apple cider vinegar against Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus and Candida albicans; downregulating cytokine and microbial protein expression. Sci. Rep, 8(1) : 1732.
Yakıncı Z.D.,Kok M. .2016 .The use of boron in the field of health. J. Inonu Univ. Heal. Serv. Voc. Sch, 4(1) : 36-44.
Yerpes M.,Llonch P.,Manteca X. .2020 .Factors associated with cumulative first-week mortality in broiler chicks. Animals, 10(2) : 310.
Yilmaz M.T. .2012 .Minimum inhibitory and minimum bactericidal concentrations of boron compounds against several bacterial strains. Turk. J. Med. Sci, 42(8) : 1423-1429.
Yoho D.E.,Moyle J.R.,Swaffar A.D.,Bramwell R.K.,Tabler G.T.,Watkins S.E. .2008 .. , : .
. .. , 87(Suppl 1) : 148.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

20

Views