This study aimed to compare the effects of three different concentrations of progesterone in handmade intravaginal sponges for estrous induction and synchronization, followed by fixed-time insemination, on the sexual behavior and reproductive performance of Etawah goats. Forty-five female goats were divided into three treatment groups (P410, P415, and P420), with 15 goats in each group. Each group received 100, 150, and 200 mg of progesterone, respectively, via intravaginal sponges for 12 days. All treated goats were inseminated at a fixed time of 48 h after sponge withdrawal. The recorded parameters included sexual behavior, mucus quantity, vulvar edema, estrous onset, estrous duration, non-return rate (NRR) at 19 to 21 and 40 to 42 days post-insemination, confirmed by ultrasonography on day 60, as well as kidding and prolificacy rates. Results showed significant differences (P < 0.05) in positive sexual behavior scores for P420 (85%) compared to P410 (67%) and P415 (67%). Significant differences (P < 0.05) were also noted in vaginal mucus scores and vulvar swelling in P420 compared with P410 and P415. The onset and duration of estrus were 32.2, 33.3, and 35.1 h for treatments P410, P415, and P420, respectively, with no significant diferences (P > 0.05). The percentages of estrus also showed no significant differences among the treatments. No significant different were observed in the NRR, pregnancy rate, kidding rate, or litter size across all treatment groups. Further research is needed to identify the optimal hormone levels, sperm concentrations per insemination, and timing across a larger sample.