No Detail Found!

Efficiency of proteolytic enzymes in treating lumbar spine osteoarthritis (low back pain) patients and its effects on liver and kidney enzymes

Author(s)
Hira Naeem Department of Pharmacology, Baqai Medical University,Karachi,Pakistan
Syed Naim-ul-Hassan Naqvi Department of Pharmacology, Baqai Medical University,Karachi,Pakistan
Rehana Perveen Department of Pharmacology, Baqai Medical University,Karachi,Pakistan
Farhan Ishaque Department of Physiotherapy, Dow University of Health Sciences,Karachi,Pakistan
Raheela Bano Department of Pharmacology, Dow University of Health Sciences,Karachi,Pakistan
Hina Abrar Department of Pharmacology, Dow University of Health Sciences,Karachi,Pakistan
Adeel Arsalan Department of Pharmaceutics, Ziauddin University,Karachi,Pakistan
Nousheen Malik Department of Pharmacology, Baqai Medical University,Karachi,Pakistan
Abstract
Lumbar spine osteoarthritis with 40-85% prevalence, degeneration of spine with remarkable narrowing of disc space and osteophytes formation trigger pain in lower back. Pain in lower portion of back is now considered to be the second most commonly treated health issue in primary health care setups. This pain causes disability, functional loss and job absentees. Commonly pain is managed pharmacologically by NSAIDS but resulted in severe gastric side effects. The purpose of this trial was to appraise the properties of bromelain and papain, the vegetal proteolytic enzymes, in comparison with standard drug on LBP patients. Forty men and women with lumbar spine osteoarthritis were recruited and divided into group 1, received aceclofenac 100mg tablet b.i.d as standard treatment, group 2, patients treated with aceclofenac 100 mg tablet b.i.d and enzyme supplements 250 mg b.i.d for 6 weeks. All the participants were evaluated for their body mass index, vital signs and liver/ kidney enzymes before and after treatment. Moreover intensity of pain were also measured through visual analogue scale (VAS) and oswestry low back pain questionnaire (ODI) before treatment (0 week), 3rd week and 6th week of treatment. The enzyme group patients showed significantly diminished pain scores VAS from 7.10±1.29 to 5.85±1.531*** (P= 0.001), ODI score from 56.2±8.70 to 51.6±8.125*** (P=0.000), significantly diminished enzymes; ALP from 210.00±55.24 to 196.90±51.02 (P=0.054*) and serum creatinine from 0.97±0.153 to 0.87±0.139 (P= 0.035*) and improved quality of life. Hence, this study suggested that the enzyme supplements for 6 weeks have prolonged beneficial carry-over effects in comparison to standard treatment without producing any change in BMI (P>0.05) and vital signs (P> 0.05).
Publication Details
Page(s) 371-378
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Volume: 33, Issue: SUP1, Year: 2020

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
proteolytic supplements, papain, Oswestry low back pain questionnaire, Low back pain, Visual analogue scale, Lumbar spine osteoarthritis, Bromelain
References
Ahmed A,Jehan F A .2017 .Medicinal role of papaya seeds on thrombocyte count tested on healthy rabbits. JPMA, 67(5) : 785-787.
Ahmed A,Saleem A,Shaikh AW,Jehan F .2017 .Incremental response of total thrombocyte count of papaya leaves. Pak. J. Med, 11(4) : 1583-1586.
Andrew CS,Robert M .2013 .. Chapter 419 - Papain. Handbook of Proteolytic Enzymes (Third Edition), : 1858-186.
Arshad ZIM,Amid A,Yusof F,Jaswir I,Ahmad K,Loke SP K .2014 .Bromelain: An overview of industrial application and purification strategies. Appl, 98(17) : 7283-7297.
Aruoma OI,Hayashi Y,Marotta F,Mantello P,Rachmilewitz E,Montagnier L E .2010 .Applications and bioefficacy of the functional food supplement fermented papaya preparation. Toxicology, 278(1) : 6-16.
Ashok AK,Mol N AK .2017 .Pharmacological potentials of Carica papaya. Innov. Int. J. Med, 2(1) : 18-20.
Boshra V,Tajul AY .2013 .Papaya-an innovative raw material for food and pharmaceutical processing industry. Health Environ. J., 4(1) : 68-75.
Brien S,Lewith G,Walker A,Hicks SM,Middleton D SM .2004 .Bromelain as a treatment for osteoarthritis: A review of clinical studies. Evid. Based Complement. Alternat. Med, 1(3) : 251-257.
Chintalacharuvu SR,Urankar-Nagy NANCY,Petersilge CA,Abdul-Karim FW,Emancipator SN .2001 .Treatment of collagen induced arthritis by proteolytic enzymes: Immunomodulatory and disease modifying effects. J. Rheumatol., 28(9) : 2049-2059.
Deyle GD,Allison SC,Matekel RL,Ryder MG,Stang JM,Gohdes DD,Hutton JP,Henderson NE,Garber MB .2005 .Physical therapy treatment effectiveness for osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomized comparison of supervised clinical exercise and manual therapy procedures versus a home exercise program. PTJ, 85(12) : 1301-1317.
Dixon JS,Bird HA .1981 .Reproducibility along a 10 cm vertical visual analogue scale. , 40(1) : 87-89.
Fahmy A,MacDonald G,Evans A .2018 .Abnormal liver function tests in inflammatory arthritis: Think beyond the DMARDs. Oxford medical case reports, : 275-277.
Fairbank JC,Couper J,Davies JB,O'brien JP JB .1980 .The Oswestry low back pain disability questionnaire. Physiotherapy, 66(8) : 271-273.
Farhan I,Naqvi SMH,Zia Z SMH .2015 .Effectiveness of proteolytic enzymes (Papain and bromelain) in comparison with physical therapy (Exercise and therapeutic ultrasound) in osteoarthritis of knee joint. Int. J. Biol. Biotech, 12(2) : 185-192.
Gert K and W Kullich .2000 .Short-term treatment of painful osteoarthritis of the knee with oral enzymes. Clin. Drug Investig, 19(1) : 15-23.
Goyal S,Manivannan B,Ansari AS,Lohiya NK .2009 .Safety evaluation of long term treatment of methanol sub-fraction of seeds of Carica papaya as a male contraceptive with particular emphasis on carcinogenicity in albino rats. Int. J. Pharmacol., 5(2) : 114-125.
Hernandez-Diaz S,Rodriguez LAG .2000 .Association between nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and upper gastrointestinal tract bleeding/ perforation: An overview of epidemiologic studies published in the 1990s. Arch. Intern. Med, 160(14) : 2093-2099.
Hoy D,Bain C,Williams G,March L,Brooks P,Blyth F,Woolf A,Vos T,Buchbinder R .2012 .A systematic review of the global prevalence of low back pain. Rheum., 64(6) : 2028-2037.
Johnson C .2005 .Measuring pain. Visual analog scale versus numeric pain scale: What is the difference?. J. Chiropr. Med, 4(1) : 43-44.
Klein G ,W .1999 .Reducing pain by oral enzyme therapy in rheumatic diseases. Wien. Med, 149 : 577-580.
Klein G,Kullich W,Schnitker J,Schwann H J .2006 .Efficacy and tolerance of an oral enzyme combination in painful osteoarthritis of the hip. A double-blind, randomised study comparing oral enzymes with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Clin. Exp, 24(1) : 25-30.
Koes BW,Van Tulder MW,Thomas S MW .2006 .Diagnosis and treatment of low back pain. BMJ, 332(7555) : 1430-1434.
Kumar NS,Devi S NS,Pharmacogn A. J. .2017 .The surprising health benefits of papaya seeds.. , 6(1) : 424-429.
Langworthy MJ,Saad A,Langworthy NM .2010 .Conservative treatment modalities and outcomes for osteoarthritis: the concomitant pyramid of treatment. Physician Sports Med, 38(2) : 133-45.
Leipner J,Iten F,Saller R F .2001 .Therapy with proteolytic enzymes in rheumatic disorders. Bio. Drugs, 15(12) : 779-789.
Lemmel EM,Leeb B,De Bast B,Aslanidis S B .2002 .Patient and physician satisfaction with aceclofenac: Results of the european observational cohort study (experience with aceclofenac for inflammatory pain in daily practice). Curr. Med. Res. Opin., 18(3) : 146-153.
Levy J ,Leighton C,Kadir JC .2014 .Incidence, prevalence, costs, and impact on disability of common conditions requiring rehabilitation in the United States: Stroke, spinal cord injury, traumatic brain injury, multiple sclerosis, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, limb loss, and back pain. Arch. Phys. Med, 95(5) : 986-995.
Maroon JC,Bost JW .2006 .ω-3 fatty acids (fish oil) as an anti-inflammatory: An alternative to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for discogenic pain. Surg, 65(4) : 326-331.
Müller A,Barat S,Chen X,Bui KC,Bozko P,Malek NP,Plentz RR .2016 .Comparative study of antitumor effects of bromelain and papain in human cholangiocarcinoma cell lines. Int. J. Oncol., 48(5) : 2025-2034.
Lenard L ,- .2013 .Controlling inflammation with proteolytic enzymes. , : .
Ojo OA,Ojo AB,Awoyinka O,Ajiboye BO,Oyinloye BE,Osukoya OA,Olayide II,Ibitayo A .2018 .Aqueous extract of Carica papaya Linn. roots potentially attenuates arsenic induced biochemical and genotoxic effects in Wistar rats. J. Tradit. Complement. Med, 8(2) : 324-334.
Olaogun MO,Adedoyin RA,Ikem IC,Anifaloba OR .2004 .Reliability of rating low back pain with a visual analogue scale and a semantic differential scale. Physiother. Theory Pract, 20(2) : 135-142.
Oloyede OI .2005 .Chemical profile of unripe pulp of Carica papaya. Pak. J. Nutr, 4(6) : 379-381.
Pahor M,Guralnik JM,Wan JY,Ferrucci L,Penninx BW,Lyles A,Ling S,Fried LP .1999 .Lower body osteoarticular pain and dose of analgesic medications in older disabled women: the women's health and aging study. Am. J. Public Health, 89(6) : 930-934.
Panda S,Panda SK,Martha SK .2018 .A mini review on Phytochemical and Pharmacological consideration of Carica papaya seed. J. Pharm. Adv. Res., 1(6) : 289-291.
Patel PB,Patel TK .2017 .Efficacy and safety of aceclofenac in osteoarthritis: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Eur. J. Rheumatol., 4(1) : 11-18.
Patil T,Patil S,Patil A,Patil S A .2014 .Carica papaya leaf extracts: An Ethnomedicinal boon. IJPPR, 6(2) : 260-265.
Puig A,Gil I,Sanchez O .2008 .Evaluation of drying techniques measuring proteolytic activity of papain obtained from unripe fruit and skin juice. Ind. Biotechn. Intern. Conference, : 8-11.
Radovanovic-Dinic B,Tesic-Rajkovic S,Zivkovic V,Grgov S V .2018 .Clinical connection between rheumatoid arthritis and liver damage. Rheumatol. Int., 38(5) : 715-724.
Rakhimov MR .2001 .Anti-inflammatory activity of domestic papain. Eksp, 64(4) : 48-49.
Ramli ANM,Aznan TNT,Illias RM .2017 .Bromelain: from production to commercialisation. J. Sci. Food, 97(5) : 1386-1395.
Ricci JA,Stewart WF,Chee E,Leotta C,Hochberg MC C .2006 .Back pain exacerbations and lost productive time costs in United States workers. Spine, 31(26) : 3052-3060.
Sadek KM .2012 .Anti-oxidant and immunostimulant effect of Carica papaya Linn. Aqueous extract in acrylamide intoxicated rats. Acta. Inform. Med, 20(3) : 180-185.
Sadia S,Tariq A,Shaheen S,Malik K,Ahmad M,Qureshi H,Nayyar BG H .2018 .Ethnopharmacological profile of anti-arthritic plants of Asia: A systematic review. Int. J. Herb. Med, 13 : 8-25.
Sagnia B,Fedeli D,Casetti R,Montesano C,Falcioni G,Colizzi V .2014 .Antioxidant and AntiInflammatory Activities of Extracts from Cassia alata, Eleusine indica, Eremomastax speciosa, Carica papaya and Polyscias fulva Medicinal Plants Collected in Cameroon. PLoS ONE, 9(8) : e103999.
Sahbaz A,Aynioglu O,Isik H,Ozmen U,Cengil O,Gun BD,Gungorduk K .2015 .Bromelain: A natural proteolytic for intra-abdominal adhesion prevention. Int. J. Surg., 14(1) : 7-11.
Salim E,Kumolosasi E,Jantan I .2014 .Inhibitory effect of selected medicinal plants on the release of proinflammatory cytokines in LPS-stimulated human peripheral blood mononuclear cells. J. Nat. Med, 68(3) : 647-653.
Singer F,Singer C,Oberleitner H C .2001 .Phlogenzym® versus diclofenac in the treatment of activated osteoarthritis of the knee. A double-blind prospective randomized study. Int. J. Immunother., 17(2) : 135-142.
Spaeth GL .1968 .The effects of bromelains on the inflammatory response caused by cataract extraction: A double-blind study. Eye Ear Nose Throat Mon., 47(12) : 634-639.
Taussig SJ .1980 .The mechanism of the physiological action of bromelain. Med, 6(1) : 99-104.
Vyas MB,Shah SK .2016 .Review on nutritional and medicinal values of Carica papaya. J. Pharmacogn. Phytochem., 5(4) : 284.
Ward Wang R,MM Wang R .2015 .Arthritis of the Spine. In: Li S and Yao J (eds.) Spinal Imaging and Image Analysis. Lecture Notes in Computational Vision and Biomechanics, 18 : 31-66.
Woolf RM,Snow JW,Walker JH,Broadbent TR .1965 .Resolution of an artificially induced hematoma and the influence of a proteolytic enzyme. J. Trauma Acute Care Surg., 5(4) : 491-494.
Yogiraj V,Goyal PK,Chauhan CS,Goyal A,Vyas B .2014 .Carica papaya Linn: An overview. J. Herb. Med, 2(5) : 01-08.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

10

Views