No Detail Found!

Debunking the One-size-fits-all Approach: Synergistic and Trade-off Effects of Collective Action on Household Food Security Among the Smallholder Farmers in Central Kenya

Author(s)
Catherine Nyambune Maindi Department of Agricultural Economics and Extension, University of Embu, Embu, Kenya
Wilckyster Nyateko Nyarindo Department of Agricultural Economics and Extension, University of Embu, Embu,Kenya
Samuel Njiri Ndirangu Department of Agricultural Economics and Extension, University of Embu,Embu,Kenya
Hezron Nyarindo Isaboke Department of Agricultural Economics and Extension, University of Embu Embu,Kenya
Abstract
Collective action is important in ameliorating the negative externalities in agriculture to promote household food security (HFS). This study explored the effects of efficiency and livelihood collective action initiatives (CAIs) on HFS along the pathways of production and income. The efficiency CAIs pursue efficiency-enhancing collective activities including input sourcing and output marketing. The livelihood CAIs engage in household livelihood and resilience enhancing collective activities such as provision of credit and informal insurance, pooling savings and acquisition of assets. A multinomial endogenous treatment effects (METE) model and an ordered probit model were employed on cross-sectional data drawn from 532 households from Murang'a County in central Kenya. The results revealed significant differences in HFS between the efficiency and livelihood CAIs. The differences were accounted for by the variations in household and organizational characteristics that determine the capacity to leverage HFS benefits along the pathways of production and income. Both efficiency and livelihood CAIs showed a positive significant effect on HFS through production. The results further showed that income positively influenced HFS among the livelihood members contrary to efficiency CAIs that showed negative HFS effects. The HFS across the combined pathways of income and production was lower for the efficiency CAIs than the livelihood CAIs. This was mainly due to the trade-off income effects exhibited by the former and the synergies accrued from income and production on the latter. The findings suggest that the overall performance of both efficiency and livelihood CAIs in leveraging HFS from joint income and production remains tentative. Therefore, a one-size-fits-all collective action promotional policy and program design approaches for improved HFS outcomes are inadequate. The study suggests a portfolio of context-specific collective action policies and interventions that match the differences between the efficiency and livelihood CAIs and their links to HFS. The policies would confer potential synergies, spillover effects and complementarities in strengthening the synergies while mitigating the trade-offs along the income and production pathways between the efficiency and livelihood CAIs. There is a need to enhance access to information, extension and advisory services and ICT among the members of the livelihood CAIs to improve production. It is important to incentivize the non-farm livelihood-enhancing economic activities among the livelihood members to fill the household food gaps arising from low production. It is also important to establish collective action funds and micro-credit schemes with affordable interest rates. This would help to tap the opportunities for credit sourcing and pooling savings among the livelihood members while promoting collective input sourcing and output marketing among the efficiency CAIs.
Publication Details
Page(s) 815-830
Published Journal: Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 12, Issue: 3, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
income, production, Food security, Kenya, multinomial endogenous treatment effect model, Collective action
References
Andersson S.,Gabrielsson S. .2012 .Because of poverty, we had to come together: Collective action for improved food security in rural Kenya and Uganda. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 10 : 245-262.
Bernard T.,Taffesse A. S. .2012 .Returns to scope? Smallholders' commercialisation through multipurpose cooperatives in Ethiopia. Journal of African Economies, 3 : 440-464.
Cohen J. .1988 .Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioural Sciences. , : .
Cramer L.,Förch W.,Thornton P. K. .2016 .Connecting Women, Connecting Men: How Communities and Organizations Interact to Strengthen Adaptive Capacity and Food Security in the Face of Climate Change. Gender, Technology and Development, 20 : 169-199.
Deb P.,Trivedi P. K. . .Specification and simulated likelihood estimation of a non-normal treatment-outcome model with selection: Application to health care utilization. Econometrics Journal, 9 : 307-331.
Dhal S.,Lane L.,N. Srivastava L. .2020 .Women's Collectives and Collective Action for Food and Energy Security: Reflections from a Community of Practice (CoP) Perspective. Indian Journal of Gender Studies, 27 : 55-76.
Dohmwirth C.,Hanisch M. .2018 .Women and collective action: Lessons from the Indian dairy cooperative sector. Community Development Journal, 53 : 1-19.
Fischer E.,Qaim M. . .Gender, agricultural commercialization, and collective action in Kenya. Food Security, 4 : 441-453.
Fongar A.,Gödecke T.,Qaim M. .2019 .Various forms of double burden of malnutrition problems exist in rural Kenya. BMC Public Health, 19 : 1-9.
Food Agricultural,Organization Agricultural .2023 .Urbanization, agrifood systems transformation and healthy diets across the rural-urban continuum. , : .
Ganle J.K.,Afriyie K.,Segbefia A.Y. .2015 .Empowerment and disempowerment of rural women in Ghana. World Development, 66 : 335-345.
Analysis Greene. 2016. Econometrics . .. , : .
Gyau A.,Mbugua M.,Oduol J. .2016 .Determinants of participation and intensity of participation in collective action: Evidence from smallholder avocado farmers in Kenya. Journal on Chain and Network Science, 16 : 147-156.
Harris-Fry N.,Shrestha A.,Costello N. M.,Saville N. M. .2017 .Determinants of intra-household food allocation between adults in South Asia - A systematic review. International Journal for Equity in Health, 16 : 1-21.
Hintz K.S.,Pretzsch J. .2023 .Co-creation of business models for smallholder forest farmers' organizations: Lessons learned from rural Ethiopia and Tanzania. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 4 : 1-29.
Kaiser S.,Barnhart S.,Huber-Krum S. .2020 .Measuring Social Cohesion and Social Capital within the Context of Community Food Security: A Confirmatory Factor Analysis. Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition, 15 : 591-612.
Kehinde A.D.,Adeyemo R.,Ogundeji A. A. .2021 .Does social capital improve farm productivity and food security? Evidence from cocoa-based farming households in Southwestern Nigeria. Heliyon e06592., : .
.2022 .Demographic and Health Survey 2022. In Demographic and Health Survey, : .
Kihiu E.N.,Amuakwa-Mensah F. .2021 .Agricultural market access and dietary diversity in Kenya: Gender considerations towards improved household nutritional outcomes. Food Policy, 100 : 2019-2021.
Kirimi L.,Gitau R.,Olunga M. .2015 .Household Food Security and Commercialization Among Smallholder Farmers in Kenya. 4th International Conference of the African Association of Agricultural Economists, : 1-20.
Koster T.,Motovska N.,Kunz M.O.,Ayuya I.,S. I.,Mugwe J.,Nigat B. .2023 .Impact of collective marketing participation on farmers' income: Evidence from smallholder avocado farmers of Murang'a County, Kenya. Social Sciences and Humanities Open, 8 : 1.
Larsen A.F.,Lilleør H.B. .2014 .Beyond the Field: The Impact of Farmer Field Schools on Food Security and Poverty Alleviation. World Development, 64 : 843-859.
Linderhof V.,Janssen V.,Achterbosch T. .2019 .Does agricultural commercialization affect food security: The case of crop-producing households in the regions of PostReform Vietnam?. Sustainability, 11 : 5-7.
Lupi C.,Candelise M.A.,Calull S.,Delvaux P.,Valkering W.,Hubert A.,Sciullo N.,Ivask I. J.,Iturriza D.,Paci N Della,Valle T.,Dunlop T. .2021 .A characterization of european collective action initiatives and their role as enablers of citizens' participation in the energy transition. Energies, 14 : 24-28.
Lutomia C. K.,Obare G.A.,Kariuki I.M.,Muricho G. S. .2019 .Determinants of gender differences in household food security perceptions in the Western and Eastern regions of Kenya. Cogent Food and Agriculture, 5 : 1-7.
Magambo G.,Moraa C. .2022 .Does the adoption of soil carbon enhancing practices translate to increased farm yields ? A case of maize yield from. Western Kenya Heliyon, 5 : 22-25.
Malual J. D.,Mazur R. E. .2022 .Social capital and food security in post-conflict rural Lira District, northern Uganda. Disasters, 46 : 80-94.
Min-Han Tsai ,Yir-Hueih .2022 .Group Heterogeneity and the Economic Effect of Farmer Organisation Participation: Empirical Evidence from Taiwan. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 74 : 473-491.
Mutungi C.,J. Manda S.,Feleke A.,Abass M.,Bekunda G.,Fischer G. .2023 .Adoption and impacts of improved post-harvest technologies on food security and welfare of maize-farming households in Tanzania: a comparative assessment. Food Security, 15 : 1007-1023.
Mwambi M.,Bijman J.,Mshenga P. .2020 .Which type of producer organization is (more) inclusive? Dynamics of farmers' membership and participation in the decisionmaking process. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 91 : 213-236.
Nakazi F.,Aseete P.,Katungi E.,Ugen M. Adrogu .2017 .The potential and limits of farmers' groups as catalysts of women leaders. Cogent Economics and Finance, 5 : 1-16.
Niles M.T.,Rudnick J.,Lubell M.,Cramer L.,Niles M. T. .2021 .. Food Security, 5 : 1-14.
Njuguna K.H.N.,Isaboke S.N.,Ndirangu S.N. .2022 .Determinants of smallholders' choice of avocado marketing outlets and profitability in Murang'a County, Kenya. SN Business and Economics, 2 : 8-15.
Njuki S.,Eissler H.J.,Malapit R.S.,Meinzen-Dick E.,Bryan A.R.,Quisumbing A.R. .2021 .A review of evidence on gender equality, women's empowerment, and food systems. SSRN Electronic Journal., : .
Nosratabadi S.,Khazami N.,Abdallah M. Ben,Lackner Z.,Band S. S.,Mosavi A.,Mako C. .2020 .Social Capital Contributions to Food Security: A Comprehensive Literature Review. Foods, 11 : 1-18.
Agriculture Poole. 2017. Smallholder,Participation Market,Participation Market,A.R. Market,Sproule K.,Martinez E.M.,Malapit H. .2021 .Do tradeoffs among dimensions of women's empowerment and nutrition outcomes exist? Evidence from six countries in Africa and Asia. Food Policy, 100 : 102001.
Ragasa C.,Aberman N.L.,Mingote C. Alvarez .2019 .Does providing agricultural and nutrition information to both men and women improve household food security? Evidence from Malawi. Global Food Security, 18 : 45-59.
M.D'Haese Z. .2018 .Do Coffee Farmers Benefit in Food Security from Participating in Coffee Cooperatives? Evidence from Southwest Ethiopia Coffee Cooperatives. Food and Nutrition Bulletin, 39 : 266-280.
Sraboni E.,Quisumbing A. .2018 .Women's empowerment in agriculture and dietary quality across the life course: Evidence from Bangladesh. Food Policy, 81 : 21-36.
Sseguya H.,Mazur R. E.,Flora C. B. .2018 .Social capital dimensions in household food security interventions: Implications for rural Uganda. Agriculture and Human Values, 35 : 117-129.
Valujeva K.,Freed E.K.,Nipers A.,Jauhiainen J.,Schulte R.P.O. .2023 .Pathways for governance opportunities: Social network analysis to create targeted and effective policies for agricultural and environmental development. Journal of Environmental Management, 325 : 116563.
Waha K.,M. T.Van Wijk S.,Fritz L.,See P. K.,Thornton J.,Wichern M.,Herrero M. .2018 .Agricultural diversification as an important strategy for achieving food security in Africa. Global Change Biology, 24 : 3390-3400.
Wegi B.,Haji J.,Mirzabaev A. .2023 .Determinants of food and nutrition security : Evidence from croplivestock mixed farming households of Central and Eastern Ethiopia. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research, 12 : 100556.
Woldu T.,Tadesse F.,Waller M.K. .2018 .Women ' s participation in agricultural cooperatives in Ethiopia Women's Participation in Agricultural Cooperatives in Ethiopia. International Association of Agricultural Economists (IAAE) 2015 Conference, 8 : 9-14.
World Food Programme .2015 .Consolidated Approach to Reporting Indicators of Food Security (CARI) Guidelines, Food security analysis (VAM). November., : .
Zou Y.,Wang Q. .2022 .Impacts of farmer cooperative membership on household income and inequality: Evidence from a household survey in China. Agricultural and Food Economics, 10 : 1-8.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

46

Views