Empirical Investigation into Collaborative Model Development for Resolving Tenure Conflicts in Forested Regions

Nurahdiat Mustika Aungadi; Marsuki Iswandi; Lukman Yunus; Safril Kasim; Hasddin Hasddin

doi:10.22194/JGIAS/24.1313

No Detail Found!

Empirical Investigation into Collaborative Model Development for Resolving Tenure Conflicts in Forested Regions

Author(s)

Nurahdiat Mustika Aungadi Halu Oleo University,Kendari,Indonesia

Marsuki Iswandi Department of Agricultural Socioeconomics, Faculty of Agriculture, Halu Oleo University, Kendari, Indonesia

Lukman Yunus Department of Agricultural Socioeconomics, Faculty of Agriculture, Halu Oleo University, Kendari, Indonesia

Safril Kasim Department of Environmental Sciences, Halu Oleo University,Kendari, 93132,Indonesia

Hasddin Hasddin Department of Regional and Urban Planning, Lakidende University, Unaaha, Indonesia

Abstract

Tenure conflict is a challenge and dilemma experienced by many countries. The dilemma is because on the one hand, there is an interest in preserving forests, on the other hand, there are claims to land ownership in forest areas long before they are designated as forest areas. The next dilemma is that the party claiming property rights is generally used for agricultural activities which have been the main livelihood for generations. This study tries to examine the incidence of tenure conflicts in various countries to map how these conflicts occur, the factors that encourage land tenure approaches in resolving them, and government (state) policies. Using secondary data resulting from a review of previous research published in reputable international journals and other reliable and credible reports. The review study model used is systematic with meta-synthesis. Apart from journals, secondary data comes from other reliable and credible reports. Data and materials consist of 67 reputable international journals and 14 books/reports published in the last ten years. The results of the analysis found that tenure conflicts were caused by many things, motivated by the ownership and interests of natural resources specifically for agriculture for the lives of the surrounding community. An interesting fact is that the handling of tenure conflicts in several countries is considered successful, marked by the provision of access to forest management ownership. Other studies such as those conducted in Latin America, Africa, and Asia offer partnership models to resolve tenure conflicts. Similar things have also been done in Indonesia but have not been completely successful. Learning from this, this research offers a model for developing forest management partnerships to resolve tenure conflicts in forest areas, while also accommodating special agricultural activities for local communities. The model offered theoretically complements and/or perfects the models used so far which have proven unsuccessful in resolving conflicts. The practical implications are a reference for the government and interested parties to resolve tenure conflicts so that forests are maintained and can provide benefits for community welfare.

Publication Details

Page(s) 457-469

DOI 10.22194/JGIAS/24.1313

Published Journal: Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 12, Issue: 2, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords

forest, model development, Agricultural activities, tenure, Collaborative, Forest preservation, Resolving Conflict, Land ownership claims, Livelihood., Tenure conflicts

References

Abimanyu R. .2023 .Keterkaitan kebijakan perhutanan sosial dalam upaya penyelesaian konflik tenurial di kawasan hutan (The Relationship of Social Forestry Policy to Resolve Tenurial Conflict in Forest Area). Wahana Forestra: Jurnal Kehutanan, 18 : 1-12.

Aggarwal S,A.M. Larson C.,McDermott P.,Katila L.,Giessen L. .2021 .Tenure reform for better forestry: an unfinished policy agenda. Forest Policy and Economics, 123 : 1-5.

Ambarwati ME,Gatot S.,Wilson M.A.T. .2018 .Dinamika konflik tenurial pada kawasan hutan negara (Kasus di BKPH Tanggung KPH Semarang). Jurnal Sosiologi Pedesaan, 6 : 112-120.

Banjade T.,Herawati N.,Liswanti E.,Mwang E. .2016 .Forest tenure reform in Indonesia: When? What? Why?. Brief Info, 163 : .

Bennett C.P.A.,Ridwansyah M.,Siscawati M.,Sommerville M. .2019 .Indonesia land tenure and property rights assessment. USAID Integrated Land and Resource Governance Task Order under the Strengthening Tenure and Resource Rights II (STARR II) IDIQ. , : .

Boaheng I. .2023 .Theological principles for ecological sustainability and human flourishing. International Journal of Social Science Research and Review, 6 : 416-427.

Brata N.T.,Setyowati D.L.,Setiaji K. .2022 .Agrarian conflict resolution, forestry companies versus plantation companies in North Kalimantan. International Journal of Indonesian Society and Culture, 14 : 66-76.

Camara G.,Simoes R.,Ruivo H.M.,Andrade P.R.,Soterroni A.C.,Ramos F.M.,Ramos R.G.,Scarabello M.,Almeida C.,I. Sanches C.,Maurano L.,Coutinho A.,Esquerdo J.,Antunes J.,Venturieri A.,Adami M. .2023 .Impact of land tenure on deforestation control and forest restoration in Brazilian Amazonia. Environ. Res. Lett, 18 : 1-13.

Chipofya M.,Karamesouti M.,Schultz C.,Schwering A. .2020 .Local domain models for land tenure documentation and their interpretation into the LADM. Land Use Policy, 99 : 1-15.

Chopra B.,Singh B.,Khuman Y.S.C. .2022 .International review for spatial planning and sustainable development A: Planning Strategies. Design Concepts, 10 : 128-147.

Kompas.com. .2023 .-cepat-soal-deforestasi-hutan-larang-setara-5-8-miliarlapangan-sepak-bola-. page=all . Broadcast, 12(9 March 2024) : .

Dassir M. .2008 .Resolusi Konflik Pemanfaatan Lahan Masyarakat dalam Kawasan Hutan di Kabupaten Luwu Timur. Jurnal Hutan dan Masyarakat, 3 : 1-9.

Dini A.,Setiawan B.,Ali Y.,Harpendya G.,Munawaroh F. .2024 .The Riau Province local government role in handling of tenurial conflict as an effort to resolve forest and land fires during a pandemic. Riau Journal of Empowerment, 6 : 99-113.

FAO .2020 .. The State of The World's Forests, : .

.2006 .Forest Resources Assessment. FAO FAO [Food and Agriculture Organisasi], : .

Fisher L.A.,Kim Y.S.,Latifah S.,Makarom M. .2017 .Managing forest conflict: perspectives of Indonesia's forest management unit directors. Forest and Society, 1 : 8-26.

Francis C .2006 .Systematic Reviews of Qualitative Literature. , : .

Franklin J,Serra-Diaz JM,Syphard AD,Regan HM. .2016 .Global change and terrestrial plant community dynamics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 113 : 3725-3734.

Fuad S.,Maskanah S. .2000 .Inovasi penyelesaian sengketa pengelolaan sumber daya hutan. Pustaka LATIN. Bogor., : .

Gamin N.B.,Kartodihardjo H.,Kolopaking L.M.,Boer R. .2014 .Penyelesainan konflik penguasaan hutan melalui pendekatan gaya sengketa pada pihak di Kesatuan Pengelolaan Hutan Lakitan. , 11 : 71-90.

Gilliam F.S. .2016 .Forest ecosystems of temperate climatic regions: from ancient use to climate change. New Phytologist, 212 : 871-887.

.2016 .Supporting forest conflict resolution in indonesia through mediation experiences from multi-stakeholder processes at national and local levels in Kalimantan. Bonn and Eschborn. GIZ [Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit], and Kementerian Lingkungan Hidup dan Kehutanan Republik Indonesia, : .

Golar G.G.,Hasriani H.M.,Wahyu W.S.S. .2022 .Conflict variety and the facilitation role of forest managemen unit (FMU) on resolution of tenurial conflict. Jurnal Wasian, 9 : 30-47.

Handayani I.G.A.K.R.,Karjoko L.,Jaelani A.K.,Barkhuizen J. .2022 .The politics settlement of land tenure conflicts during Jokowi's Presidency. Journal of Indonesian Legal Studies, 7 : 487-524.

Hansen M.C.,Potapov P.V.,Moore R.,Hancher M.,Turubanova S.A.,Tyukavina A.,Thau D.,Stehman S.V.,Goetz S.J.,Loveland T.R. .2013 .High-resolution global maps of 21st-century forest cover change. Science, 342 : 850-853.

Herawati T.,Wmangi E.,Liswanti N. .2019 .Implementing forest tenure reforms: perspectives from Indonesia's forestry agencies. Indonesian Journal of Forestry Research, 6 : 117-132.

Holland Y.J.,Masuda B.E.,Robinson B.E.,Development Sustainable .2022 .Land Tenure Security. , : .

Irawan A.,Mairi K.,Ekawati S. .2016 .Analisis konflik tenurial di Kesatuan Pengelolaan Hutan Produksi (KPHP) Model Poigar. Jurnal Wasian, 3 : 79-90.

Jaya D.J.,Hidayah R.,Akmal D.U.,Kamlasi A.Y. .2021 .Categorization of solutions for indigenous people in customary land-use conflicts in Indonesia. Journal Sampurasun: Interdisciplinary Studies for Cultural Heritage, 7 : 1-16.

Jenke M and J.,Pretzsch M and J. .2021 .The impact of community forest formalisation on tenure security and comanagement in Thailand. International Forestry Review, 23 : 29-40.

Karousakis K,Coffee-Morlot K .2007 .Financing mechanisms to reduce emissions from deforestation: issues in design and implementation. , : .

Kartodihardjo H. .2014 .Krisis konflik tenurial psda indonesia: pembelajaran dari dewan kehutanan nasional, hutan untuk rakyat jalan terjal reforma agraria di sektor kehutanan. LKIS. Yogyakarta., : .

Kitchenham B. .2004 .Procedures for performing systematic reviews. , : .

Komitmeniklim.id. .2023 ./luas-hutan-alam-menurundan-terancam-tinjau-ulang-kebijakan-dan-izin-usaha. Accessed, 18 : .

Kunz S.,Steinebach C.,Dittrich B.,Hauser-Schäublin I.,Rosyani E.,Soetarto H.,Faust H. .2017 .The fridge in the forest': Historical trajectories of land tenure regulations fostering landscape transformation in Jambi Province. Forest Policy and Economics, 81 : 1-9.

Kurnijanto S.,Rojal A.,Mujetahid M.,Dassir M. .2023 .Central Sulawesi Forest Park: A pattern of tenure conflict resolution. International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning, 18 : 2121-2126.

Lal R. .2004 .Soil carbon sequestration to mitigate climate change. Geoderma, 123 : 1-22.

Larson A.M.,I. Monterroso A.M.,Liswanti N.,Tamara A. .2023 .What is forest tenure (in) security? Insights from participatory perspective analysis. Forest Policy and Economics, 147 : 1-16.

Lewin S. .2008 .Methods to Synthesise Qualitative Evidence Alongside a Cochrane Intervention Review. London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. London., : .

Li W. ,Chen J.,Wu F.,Zhang Z. .2023 .Collective forest tenure reform and forest conditions: evidence from the social-ecological system in Southwest China. Front. For. Glob. Change, 6 : 1-17.

Madiong B.,Almusawir R.,Renggong B.,Oner B.,Yulia. Z.,Makkawaru A.,Tira A. .2023 .Dynamics of tenure conflict in Ammatoa Kajang Customary Forest Area, Bulukumba Regency. Russian Law Journal, 11 : 688-699.

Malhi Y.,Gardner T.A.,Goldsmith G.R.,Silman M.R.,Zelazowski P. .2014 .Tropical forests in the Anthropocene. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 39 : 125-159.

Marina I,Dharmawan A.H. .2011 .Analisis konflik sumberdaya hutan di kawasan konservasi. jurnal transdisiplin sosiologi, komunikasi. dan ekologi manusia, 5 : 90-96.

Maring P. .2022 .Conflict transformation and collaboration in developing social forestry in Flores, Indonesia. Forest and Society, 6 : 40-66.

Maring P. .2013 .Kekuasaan dan Konflik Sosial: Kasus Penguasaan Hutan Noge di Tanaloran Flores. Jurnal Insani, 15 : 1-11.

Markum. ,Sayuti R.H.,Hilyana S.,Anugrah G. .2022 .The dynamics of spatial utilization and tenurial conflict in conservation area of Moyo Island, West Nusa Tenggara. Journal of Natural Resources and Environmental Management, 12 : 445-455.

Megawati T.F.,Semedi B.,Afandhi A. .2023 .Land tenure of forest fringe communities and their impact on deforestation: A Case Study in Soeharto Forest Park. Media Komunikasi dan Pengembangan Teknik Lingkungan, 20 : 417-427.

Nuhidayah L.,Davies P.J.,Alam S. .2020 .resolving landuse conflicts over Indonesia's customary forests. Contemporary Southeast Asia, 42 : 372-392.

Nuraeny T.D.A. .2023 .Resolusi konflik tenurial di kawasan Hutan Desa Pemandang Kecamatan Rokan IV Koto Kabupaten Rokan Hulu. Jurnal Hutan Tropika, 7 : 183-191.

Nurlia A.,Widarti A.,Utami S.,Nurvianto S. .2022 .Forest and land rehabilitation based on superior seeds as a tenurial conflict resolution at register 38 Gunung Balak, Lampung Province. Proceedings of the 3rd Sriwijaya International Conference on Environmental Issues, SRICOENV, : .

Nurlia A.,Waluyo E.A.,Asmara W.H. .2019 .Management (ICFCM) 2019: Innovative Solution for Managing Tropical Forests. Sustainable Development Goals 28 August, 533 : 1-11.

Ogunrinola O.F.,Ogunwale T.O.,Oyetola S.O.,Salami K.D. .2023 .Tree species diversity status and contributors to forest degradation in Shasha Forest Reserve, Nigeria. Global Journal of Science Frontier Research: H Environment & Earth Science, 23 : 47-57.

Parker C.,Trivedi M.,Mardas N. .2009 .The Little REDD+ Book, an updated guide to governmental and non-governmental proposals for reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation. Oxford: Global Canopy Programme, : .

Perry A and N.,Hammond A and N. .2002 .Systematic Review: The Experience of a PhD Student. Psychology Learning and Teaching, 2 : 32-35.

Pruitt D.G,Rubin J.Z. .2009 .Teori Konflik Sosial. , : .

Purnomo E.P and P.B.,Anand E.P and P.B. .2014 .The conflict of forest tenure and the emergence of community-based forest management in Indonesia. Journal of Government and Politics, 5 : 20-31.

Ragandhi A.,Hadna A.H.,Setiadi S.,Maryudi A. .2021 .Why do greater forest tenure rights not enthuse local communities? An early observation on the new community forestry scheme in state forests in Indonesia. Forest and Society, 5 : 159-166.

Rahmawati R.,Hernawan D.,Maksudi B.I.,Dharmawan A.H.,Darusman D.,Kinseng R. .2018 .Conflict management in forest resouces in West Java and West Kalimantan, Indonesia. In Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Recent Innovations (ICRI, : 26-28.

Rakotonarivo O.S.,Rakotoariso M.,Rajaonarivelo H.M.,Raharijaona S.,Jones J.P.G.,Hockley N. .2023 .Resolving land tenure security is essential to deliver forest restoration. Communications Earth & Environment, : 1-8.

Ratner B. D.,Mam K.,Halpern G. .2014 .Collaborating for resilience: Conflict, collective action, and transformation on Cambodia's Tonle Sap Lake. Ecology and Society, 19 : 1-14.

Resosudarmo I. A. P.,Atmadja S.,Ekaputri A.D.,Intarini D.Y.,Indriatmoko Y.,Astri P. .2014 .Does tenure security lead to REDD+ project effectiveness? Reflections from five emerging sites in Indonesia. World Development, 55 : 68-83.

Riggs R.A.,Sayer J.,Marqules C.,Boedhihartono A.K.,Langston J.D.,Sutanto H. .2016 .Forest tenure and conflict in Indonesia: Contested rights in Rempek Village, Lombok. Land Use Policy, 57 : 241-249.

Rositah E.,Sardjono M.A.,M.I. Aipassa M.A.,Obeth E. .2019 .Tenurial Conflicts Within Protected Forest Management Unit (PFMU) of Tarakan, North Kalimantan. The symposium theme is “Green Innovation on Tropical Forest and Forest Industries Toward Sustainable Livelihood. 4-6 September, 11 : 122-125.

Safitri M.A,M.A. Muhshi M.,Muhajir M.,Shohibuddin Y.,Arizona M.,Sirait H.,Santoso H. .2011 .Menuju kepastian dan keadilan tenurial (Edisi revisi). Epistema Institute, : .

Saputra J and I.,Dewata J and I. .2019 .Tenurial conflict between parties in the technical implementation unit of the Banjar Regency Forest Management Unit in the Province of South Kalimantan. IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 314 : 1-9.

Sardjo S.,Dharmawan A.H.,Darusman D.,Wahyuni E.S. .2022 .Transformation of farmer resistance in conservation areas: land occupation by farmers in Mount Halimun-Salak National Park, West Java. Jurnal Sosiologi, 27 : 1-32.

Senoaji G.,Hidayat M.F. . .Tipologi dan alternatif resolusi konflik tenurial dalam hutan konservasi taman wisata alam pantai panjangpulau Baai di Kota Bengkulu. Jurnal Ilmu Lingkungan, 18 : 323-332.

Senoaji G.,Hidayat M.F. . .Characteristics of Forest Farmers and Tenurial Conflicts Resolution in Rimbo Donok Protection Forest, Kepahiang District, Bengkulu Province. Jurnal Agrisep, 19 : 241-254.

Siscawati M. .2020 .Gender and forest tenure reform in Indonesia. , : .

Siscawati M.,Banjade M.R.,Liswanti N.,Herawati T.,Mwangi E.,Wulandari C.,Tjoa M.,Silaya T. .2017 .Overview of forest tenure reforms in Indonesia. , : .

Siry J. P.,K. McGinley F.W.,Cubbage P.,Bettinger P. .2015 .Forest Tenure and Sustainable Forest Management. Open Journal of Forestry, 5 : 526-545.

Soares-Fihlo B.S. D.C.,Nepstad L.M.,Curran G.C.,Cerqueira R.A.,Garcia C.A.,Ramos E.,Voll A.,McDonald P.,Lefebvre P.,Schlesinger P. .2006 .Modelling conservation in the Amazon basin. Nature, 440 : 520-523.

Steffen. W. ,Persson A.,Deutsch L.,Zalasiewicz J.,Williams M.,Richardson K.,Crumley C.,Crutzen P.,Folke C.,Gordon L.,Molina M.,Ramanathan V.,Rockstrom J.,Scheffer M.,Schellnhuber H.J.,Svedin U. .2011 .The Anthropocene: from global change to planetary stewardship. Ambio, 40 : 739-761.

Sukirno. S. ,Rini Y.C.,Yuridis Penyelesaian Konflik Tenurial Dalam Kawasan Hutan Sebagai Upaya Menjaga Kelestarian Fungsi Lingkungan Di Perum Perhutani Jawa Tengah. Economics Tinjauan .2023 .. Humanities Journal (ESOCHUM) 3, : 1-15.

Syahputra O.K.H and N.,Anggraini O.K.H and N. .2023 .Tenurial Conflict Resolution Analysis of Indigenous People of Pandumaan - Sipituhuta in Humbang Hasundutan District, North Sumatera Province. Journal of Sylva Indonesiana, 6 : 19-28.

Syahputra B.,Nugroho H.,Kartodihardjo N.,Santoso N. .2020 .Mangrove Forest Tenure Conflicts: Institutional Approach to the Forest Management Unit Context in Aceh Province, Indonesia. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Research in Social Sciences and Humanities (ICORSH, 584 : 585-595.

Sylviani S & I. Hakim. .2014 .Analisis Tenurial dalam Pengembangan Kesatuan Pengelolaan Hutan (KPH): Studi Kasus KPH Gedong Wani Provinsi Lampung. Jurnal Penelitian Sosial dan Ekonomi Hutan, 11 : 309-322.

Tarigan A.P.P and M.,Kuruniasa A.P.P and M. .2021 .Analysis of agrarian conflict resolution through social forestry scheme. Journal of Environmental Science and Sustainable Development Symposum., IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 716 : 1-9.

Tuan M.T. .2023 .Land Tenure and Land Acquisition Enforcement in Vietnam. , : 1-14.

Winarno. G.D. S.P.,Harianto B.S.,Dewi B.S. .2023 .Landscape characteristics analysis of Rawa Bunder Resort at Way Kambas National Park. Journal of Natural Resources and Environmental Management, 13 : 199-210.

Wulandari C.,Fitriana Y.R.,Febryano I.G.,Herwanti S.,Kaskoyo H.,Putra H.J. .2021 .Complexity of Unsolved Forest Tenurial Conflict: A Case of Way Terusan Forest Management Unit. Jurnal Manajemen Hutan Tropika, 27 : 21-31.

Xu X.F.,Tian H.Q.,Wan S.Q. .2007 .Climate warming impacts on carbon cycling in terrestrial ecosystems. Chin. J. Plant Ecol, 31 : 175-188.

Yasmi Y and H.,Schanz Y and H. .2010 .Managing conflict escalation in forestry: logging versus local community interests in Baru Pelepat village. International Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services & Management, 6 : 43-51.

Zhao X.,Zheng Y.,Wang W.,Wang Z.,Zhang Q.,Zhang C. .2023 .Habitat Suitability Evaluation of Different Forest Species in Lvliang Mountain by Combining Prior Knowledge and MaxEnt Model. Forests, 14 : 1-15.

Citations

Downloads

Views