No Detail Found!

Profitability of Vannamei Shrimp Farming: Traditional vs. Intensive Systems in Kolaka District in Indonesia

Author(s)
Agus Salim Department of Agricultural Sciences, Postgraduate Program, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Haji Saediman Department of Agribusiness, Faculty of Agriculture, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Yusnaini Yusnaini Department of Aquaculture, Faculty of Fisheries and Marine Sciences, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Muhaimin Hamzah Department of Aquaculture, Faculty of Fisheries and Marine Sciences, Halu Oleo University,,Indonesia
Abstract
This study compares the profitability of traditional and intensive Vannamei shrimp farming in Kolaka District, Indonesia, focusing on cost structures, net returns, and revenue-to-cost (R/C) ratios. Data was collected from 50 shrimp farmers (40 traditional, 10 intensive) through surveys and observations. The analysis shows that intensive farming generates higher net returns (IDR 81,779,180/ha/year) than traditional farming (IDR 19,848,751/ha/year), due to increased productivity and advanced management. However, traditional farming has a higher R/C ratio (1.50 vs. 1.29), indicating greater cost efficiency. The findings highlight the trade-off between profitability and cost efficiency, with intensive farming offering higher returns but posing greater financial and environmental risks. Recommendations include improving input access, financing, extension services, market integration, and sustainability practices.
Publication Details
Page(s) 597-606
Published Journal: Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 13, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
profitability, Farming, whiteleg shrimp, traditional system, intensive system
References
Adhawati S.S,Sumarauw R.L.,Fakhriyyah S.,Tahang H.,Gosari B.A.J. .2020 .Input and output market risk vaname shrimp hatchery business (Litopenaeus vannamei). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 564 : 012072.
Ariadi H.,Fadjar M.,Mahmudi M. .2019 .Financial feasibility analysis of shrimp vannamei (Litopenaeus vannamei) culture in intensive aquaculture system with low salinity. Economic and Social of Fisheries and Marine Journal, 7 : 81-94.
Tenggara BPS Sulawesi .2024 .Kendari: BPS Sulawesi Tenggara. , : .
Ciptadi R,Rahardjo A.P.,Kamulyan B. .2021 .Evaluation and enhancement of sustainable organic fishpond farming in the Sei Teras fishpond irrigation area, central Kalimantan. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 930 : 012009.
Farionita I.M.,J.M.M. Aji A.,Supriono A. .2018 .Analisis komparatif usaha budidaya udang vaname tambak tradisional dengan tambak intensif di kabupaten situbondo. Jurnal Ekonomi Pertanian Dan Agribisnis (JEPA), 2 : 255-66.
Geo L.,Saediman H. . .Rice farming to brick production: what are major drivers of livelihood shift?. Bioscience Research, 16 : 3640-47.
Husada R.H.S.Y,Sari L.A.,Sahidu A.M. .2021 .Business analysis of vaname shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) culture in traditional ponds with monoculture system in sedati, sidoarjo. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 718 : 012021.
Isamu I.,Salam I.,Yunus L. .2018 .Analisis kelayakan usaha budidaya udang vaname pola tradisional plus di kecamatan samaturu kabupaten kolaka. Jurnal Sosio Agribisnis, 3 : 41-48.
Jamilah L.,Najib M. .2019 .Business model identification in vannamei shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) mariculture commodity (case study: sea farming project in Semak Daun Island, Indonesia). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 241 : 012037.
Karim M.,Sarwer R.H.,Phillips M.,Belton B. .2014 .Profitability and adoption of improved shrimp farming technologies in the aquatic agricultural systems of southwestern Bangladesh. Aquaculture, 429 : 61-70.
Kharisma A.,Manan A. .2012 .Kelimpahan bakteri vibrio sp. pada air pembesaran udang vannamei (Litopenaeus vannamei) sebagai deteksi dini serangan penyakit vibriosis. Jurnal Ilmiah Perikanan Dan Kelautan, 4 : 129-34.
Mira P.A.,Sujarwo R.,Triyanti N.,Shafitri A.,Zulham A. .2022 .Analisis komparatif usaha tambak udang vaname dengan teknik tradisional, semi intensif, dan intensif di wilayah pesisir. Journal Sosek KP, 17 : 51-62.
Nguyen C.,Jolly B.M.,Nguelifack B.M. .2020 .Economic efficiency of extensive and intensive shrimp production under conditions of disease and natural disaster risks in Khánh Hòa and Trà Vinh Provinces. Vietnam. Sustainability, 12 : 2140.
Paquotte P.L.,Chim P.L.,J-L.M. Martin E.,Lemos M.,Stern G.,Tosta G. .1998 .Intensive culture of shrimp penaeus vannamei in floating cages: zootechnical, economic and environmental aspects. Aquaculture, 164 : 151-66.
Putri D.S.,Affandi M.I.,Sayekti W.D. .2020 .Analisis kinerja usaha dan risiko petambak udang vaname pada sistem tradisional dan sistem semi intensif di kecamatan labuhan maringgai kebupaten lampung timur. JIIA, 8 : 625-32.
Saediman H. .2015 .Prioritizing commodities in Southeast Sulawesi province of Indonesia using ahp based borda count method. Asian Social Science, 11 : 171-79.
Saediman D.,Noraduola L.O.,Nafiu L.O. .2014 .Financial feasibility of traditional small-scale brick-making enterprises in Southeast Sulawesi, Indonesia. Ethiopian Journal of Environmental Studies and Management, 7 : 870-80.
Saediman Y.,Indarsyih S.,Abdullah S.A.,Fyka I. S.,Mboe I. S. .2021 .Assessing major drivers of crop shifting from rice to horticultural production: a case of Landono Sub-Regency in Southeast Sulawesi. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 724 : 012006.
Saediman H.,Amini A.,Basiru R.,Nafiu L.O. .2015 .Profitability and value addition in cassava processing in Buton district of Southeast Sulawesi province, Indonesia. Journal of Sustainable Development, 8 : 226-34.
Saediman S.,Kurniansi W.O.,Yusria L.,Geo L. . .Economic returns and production constraints in palm sugar processing in Kolaka district of Southeast Sulawesi. International Journal of Scientific & Technology Research, 8 : 3967-70.
Saediman H.,Mustika L.,Nalefo M.,Tufaila M.,Zani M. . .Cost and return analysis of rice farming and brick making in South Konawe District of Southeast Sulawesi. International Journal of Scientific & Technology Research, 8 : 835-38.
Samocha T.M.,Hamper L.,Emberson C.R.,Davis A.D.,McIntosh D.,Lawrence and P.M. Van Wyk A.L. .2002 .Review of some recent developments in sustainable shrimp farming practices in Texas, Arizona, and Florida. Journal of Applied Aquaculture, 12 : 1-42.
Shinji S.,Nohara N.,Yagi M.,Wilder M. .2019 .Bioeconomic analysis of super-intensive closed shrimp farming and improvement of management plans: a case study in Japan. Fisheries Science, 85 : 1055-65.
Sivaraman I.,Krishnan M.,Radhakrishnan K. .2019 .Better management practices for sustainable small-scale shrimp farming. Journal of Cleaner Production, 214 : 559-72.
Suhana K.,Sapanli S.,Fauzi S. .2023 .Dampak target produksi udang dua juta ton terhadap ekonomi kelautan indonesia: pendekatan model input-output. Jurnal Kebijakan Sosial Ekonomi Kelautan Dan Perikanan, 13 : 113-24.
Sulnidar A.,Laapo A. .2022 .Analisis pendapatan usaha tambak udang vannamei di desa tolai timur kecamatan torue kabupaten parigi moutong. Jurnal Agrotekbis, 10 : 278-86.
Surni S.,Saediman H.,Wulandari F.,Zani M.,Yunus L.,Taridala S.A.A. .2020 .Profitability and constraints of small-scale tomato production in baubau municipality of Southeast Sulawesi. WSEAS Transactions on Environment and Development, 16 : 219-25.
Thakur K.,Patanasatienkul T.,Vanderstichel R.,Corsin F.,Hammell L. .2018 .Production characteristics of intensive whiteleg shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) farming in four Vietnam provinces. Aquaculture Research, 49 : 2625-32.
Walker C.V.,Mohan C.V. .2009 .Viral disease emergence in shrimp aquaculture: origins, impact and the effectiveness of health management strategies. Reviews in Aquaculture, 1 : 125-54.
Wijaya R.A.,I. Muliawan R.A.,Hafsaridewi R.,Suryawati S.H.,Pramoda R. .2021 .Economic analysis of vannamei shrimp aquaculture in aceh besar regency based on different land areas. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 674 : 012039.
Zulkarnain R.,Adiyana K.,Nugroho H.,Nugraha B.,Thesiana L.,Supriyono E. .2020 .Selection of intensive shrimp farming technology for small farmers with analytical hierarchy process: a case for whiteleg shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 404 : 012017.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

43

Views