No Detail Found!

Organic Farming Based on Participatory Guarantee Systems: Exploring Economic Performance of Farmers in the Northern Delta Provinces of Vietnam

Author(s)
Phan Thi Thuy Faculty of Economics, Tay Nguyen University,567 Le Duan Street, Buon Ma Thuot City, Dak Lak Province,Vietnam
Le Duc Niem Faculty of Economics, Tay Nguyen University,567 Le Duan Street, Buon Ma Thuot City, Dak Lak Province,Vietnam
Abstract
The study aims to evaluate the economic performance of Participatory Guarantee Systems (PGS) in certifying organic vegetable farmers in Northern Vietnam. Moreover, this study identifies the differentiation between prosperous and nonprosperous farmers by analyzing critical factors associated with farm management. With a multi-stage cluster sampling technique, the data were collected from three provinces in Northern Vietnam between March and April, 2023. The findings indicate that PGS farming has the potential to be more efficient than conventional farming, mainly due to reduced intermediate costs and access to niche markets. However, PGS farms are more labor-intensive due to their reliance on manual practices. In addition, the selling approaches and technical progress significantly impact economic viability. These findings highlighted the need to develop market access and enhance farmers' confidence in sustainable agricultural practices to advise the competitiveness of PGS farms.
Publication Details
Page(s) 149-156
Published Journal: Journal of Global Innovations in Agricultural Sciences, Volume: 13, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Determinants, Vietnam, Economic performance, market access, participatory guarantee systems, labor cost, organic farms
References
Abadi B.,Yadollahi A.,Bybordi A.,Rahmati M. .2020 .The discrimination of adopters and non-adopters of conservation agricultural initiatives in northwest iran: attitudinal, soil testing, and topographical modules. land use policy, 95 : 104634.
Aryal J. P.,Sapkota R.,Khurana A.,Khatri-Chhetri D.B.,Rahut M.L.,Jat M.L. .2020 .Climate change and agriculture in south asia: adaptation options in smallholder production systems. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 22 : 5045-75.
Ayinla S.,Adekunle B. K. .2021 .An overview and application of discriminant analysis in data analysis. IOSR Journal of Mathematics, 11 : 2278-5728.
Ayuya O.I.,Gido E.O.,Bett H.K.,Lagat J.K.,Kahi A.K.,Bauer S. .2015 .Effect of certified organic production systems on poverty among smallholder farmers: empirical evidence from Kenya. World Development, 67 : 27-37.
Bizimana C.,Nieuwoudt W.L.,Ferrer S.R.D. .2002 .Factors influencing adoption of recommended farm practices by coffee farmers in Butare, Southern Rwanda. Agrekon, 41 : 237-48.
Böttinger C. .2019 .Self-Organized community institutions: a way to strengthen local social sustainability? a case study of pgs viêt nam. , : .
Brown C.E. .1998 .Multiple discriminant analysis. Applied Multivariate Statistics in Geohydrology and Related, : 115-128.
Commission U.N.S. .2016 .Agricultural cost of production statistics: guidelines for data collection, compilation and dissemination. Global Strategy., : .
Endalew B.,Elias A.,Yasunobu K. .2024 .Impact of cluster farming on smallholder farmers teff commercialization in Ethiopia. CABI Agriculture and Bioscience, 5 : 18.
FAO. .2019 .Tool for agroecology performance evaluation. process of development and guidelines for application.. , : .
Finley L.,M.J. Chappell P.,Thiers J.R.,Moore J.R. .2018 .Does organic farming present greater opportunities for employment and community development than conventional farming? a survey-based investigation in california and washington. Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems, 42 : 552-72.
Grovermann C.,Hoi P.V.,Yen P.,Schreinemachers M.N.,Hai P.,Ferrand P. .2024 .Impact of participatory guarantee systems on sustainability outcomes: the case of vegetable farming in Vietnam. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 22 : 2338028.
Grovermann C.,Quiédeville S.,Muller A.,Leiber F.,Stolze M.,Moakes S. .2021 .Does organic certification make economic sense for dairy farmers in europe?-a latent class counterfactual analysis. Agricultural Economics, 52 : 1001-12.
Hoi P.V.,Mol A.P.J.,Oosterveer P.,Huong P.T.M. .2016 .Pesticide use in vietnamese vegetable production: a 10-year study. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 14 : 325-38.
Home R.,Bouagnimbeck H.,Ugas R.,Arbenz M.,Stolze M. .2017 .Participatory guarantee systems: organic certification to empower farmers and strengthen communities. Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems, 41 : 526-45.
Hruschka C.R.,Vogl C.R. .2022 .The benefits and challenges of participating in participatory guarantee systems (pgs) initiatives following institutional formalization in chile. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 20 : 393-407.
IFOAM. .2018 .How governments can recog-nize and support participatory guarantee systems (pgs). International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements., : .
Kaufmann C.R.,Vogl C.R. .2018 .Participatory guarantee systems (pgs) in mexico: a theoretic ideal or everyday practice?. Agriculture and Human Values, 35 : 457-72.
Kerr M.S.,Liebert J.,Enloe S.,Borghino N.,Parros P.,Prudhon M.,Wezel A. .2021 .Can agroecology improve food security and nutrition? a review. Global Food Security, 29 : 100540.
Klecka W. R.,Sage W. R. .1980 .Discriminant Analysis. , 19 : .
Lobley M.,Butler A.,Reed M. .2009 .The contribution of organic farming to rural development: an exploration of the socio-economic linkages of organic and nonorganic farms in england. Land Use Policy, 26 : 723-35.
Marey-Pérez M.F.,Rodríguez-Vicente V. .2011 .Factors determining forest management by farmers in northwest spain: application of discriminant analysis. Forest Policy and Economics, 13 : 318-27.
Martín-García J.,Gómez-Limón J.A.,Arriaza M. .2024 .Conversion to organic farming: does it change the economic and environmental performance of fruit farms?. Ecological Economics, 220 : 108178.
Meemken E.M.,Qaim M. .2018 .Organic agriculture, food security, and the environment. Annual Review of Resource Economics, 10 : 39-63.
Mishra A.K.,Kumar A.,Joshi P.K. .2020 .Transforming agriculture in south asia: the role of value chains and contract farming. Routledge., : .
J. Douwe Van der P.,Barjolle D.,Bruil J.,Brunori G.,Madureira L.M.C.,Dessein J.,Drąg Z.,Fink-Kessler A.,Gasselin and M.G.d. Molina P. .2019 .The economic potential of agroecology: empirical evidence from Europe. Journal of Rural Studies, 71 : 46-61.
Qiao Y.,Halberg N.,Vaheesan S.,Scott S. .2016 .Assessing the social and economic benefits of organic and fair trade tea production for small-scale farmers in asia: a comparative case study of China and Sri Lanka. , : 246-257.
Schader C.,Heidenreich A.,I. Kadzere A.,I. Egyir A.,Muriuki A.,Bandanaa J.,Clottey J.,Ndungu J.,Grovermann C.,Lazzarini G. .2021 .How is organic farming performing agronomically and economically in sub-saharan africa?. Global Environmental Change, 70 : 102325.
Schleifer P.,Sun Y. .2020 .Reviewing the impact of sustainability certification on food security in developing countries. Global Food Security, 24 : 100337.
Schreinemachers P.,Afari-Sefa C.H.,Heng P.T.M.,Dung S.,Praneetvatakul R.,Srinivasan R. .2015 .Safe and sustainable crop protection in southeast asia: status, challenges and policy options. Environmental Science & Policy, 54 : 357-66.
Thuy P.T.,Niem L.D.,Lebailly P. .2020 .Recent evolution of perennial crop farms: evidence from dak lak province, vietnam. agris on-line papers in economics. , 12 : 87-100.
Tran D.,Goto D. .2019 .Impacts of sustainability certification on farm income: evidence from small-scale specialty green tea farmers in vietnam. Food Policy, 83 : 70-82.
Tu T.N C.W.,Whitney C.W. .2017 .Changes in organic participatory guarantee systems (pgs) in northern vietnam. proceedings of the scientific track at the organic world congress 2017. Johann Heinrich von ThuenenInstitute, 2 : 784-86.
Vos R. .2018 .Agricultural and rural transformations in asian development: past trends and future challenges. wider working paper., : .
Wezel A.,Herren B.G.,Kerr R.B.,Barrios E.,Gonçalves A.L.R.,Sinclair F. .2020 .Agroecological principles and elements and their implications for transitioning to sustainable food systems. a review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 40 : 1-13.
Zhen Y.,Qiao X.,Ju F.,Hashemi M.T.,Knudsen M.T. .2023 .Organic conversion tea farms can have comparable economic benefits and less environmental impacts than conventional ones-a case study in china. Science of the Total Environment, 877 : 162698.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

91

Views