No Detail Found!

Maximizing Key Opinion Leader (KOL) Collaborations for Corporate Success in Malaysia's Cosmetic Industry: A PRISMA-Based Systematic Review

Author(s)
Wan Arfan Rusyaidi Wan Abdul Rashid Universiti Tun Abdul Razak, Malaysia
Farhana Tahmida Newaz Universiti Tun Abdul Razak, Malaysia
Johari Mat Universiti Tun Abdul Razak, Malaysia
Azrul Fazwan Kharuddin Universiti Tun Abdul Razak, Malaysia
Darvinatasya Kharuddin INTI International University,,Malaysia
Abstract
This study systematically reviews the role of Key Opinion Leaders (KOLs) in shaping corporate success within Malaysia's cosmetic industry. The objective was twofold: (1) to identify the competencies developed through KOL collaborations, and (2) to examine the barriers that hinder their effectiveness. Drawing on the PRISMA 2020 framework, a bibliometric review was conducted across Scopus, Web of Science, and ERIC, covering literature from 2012 to 2025. After identification, screening, and eligibility filtering, 38 peerreviewed articles were selected for in-depth analysis. Data were coded and thematically synthesized following Whittemore and Knafl's (2005) method, supported by bibliometric visualization. The literature review highlighted that KOLs are central to digital brand-building due to their credibility, authenticity, and ability to foster parasocial relationships with consumers. However, their effectiveness is moderated by cultural sensitivity, halal branding, transparency in disclosure, content quality, and strategic selection between macro- and micro-influencers. The findings revealed six dominant thematic clusters: (1) credibility and authenticity, (2) halal and cultural branding cues, (3) sponsorship disclosure and transparency, (4) micro vs. macro-KOL dynamics, (5) content quality and engagement, and (6) measurement and accountability challenges. Competencies developed through successful collaborations include enhanced consumer trust, stronger cultural resonance, and deeper engagement, while barriers often arise from over-commercialization, weak disclosure practices, inadequate halal literacy, and reliance on vanity metrics. This study contributes to influencer marketing scholarship by contextualizing KOL effectiveness within Malaysia's cultural and religious dynamics. The results carry practical implications for firms seeking to balance visibility and authenticity, enforce transparent practices, and adopt data-driven evaluation frameworks. The study aligns with Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 12: Responsible Consumption and Production, as it underscores the importance of transparent, ethical, and culturally sensitive marketing practices in promoting consumer trust and sustainable industry growth.
Publication Details
Page(s) 847-861
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Key Opinion Leaders (KOLs) Influencer Marketing Corporate Success Corporate Success Consumer Trust
References
Abdullah S. I. N. W.,Syed Ali S. F.,Teng P. K. .2025 .Love, trust and follow them? The role of social media influencers on luxury cosmetics brands' purchase intention among Malaysian urban women. Malaysian Consumer and Family Economics Association, : .
Bakar M. S.,Rahman A. A.,Hashim N. .2024 .Halal branding and consumer trust in Malaysia's cosmetics industry. Journal of Islamic Marketing, 15(2) : 215-232.
Chin J. Y. .2019 .The effect of social media influencers featured in beauty care products advertisements on purchase intention. Journal of Promotion Management and Marketing, 3(1) : 29340-70.
Doshi R.,Ranganathan A. R.,Rao S. .2021 .Modeling influencer marketing campaigns in social networks. , : .
Fouzi N. A.,Ismail S.,Ariffin M. .2024 .Authenticity and consumer engagement in cosmetic influencer marketing: Evidence from Malaysian Gen Z. Asian Journal of Business Research, 14(1) : 77-95.
Hack-Polay D.,Stevenson S.,Tehseen S. .2022 .Social media influencers: The new advertising agency? Examining the impact of social media influencer marketing on the cosmetics industry. International Journal of Public Sector Social Services, 2(1) : 1-20.
Hossain M. S. .2025 .The influence of celebrity credibility on consumer behavior: Evidence from beauty influencers. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 04(4) : 210-223.
Isa N. S.,Hassan Z.,Omar M. .2023 .Religiosity, halal cosmetics, and influencer credibility in Malaysia. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 47(5) : 1894-1907.
Isa R. M.,Hassan Z.,Omar M. .2023 .Determinants of consumer adoption of halal cosmetics: A systematic literature review. Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 22(8) : 3215-3226.
Koc F. .2024 .The effects of trust and religiosity on halal product purchase intention. Emerging Markets Journal, 20(5) : 141-158.
Lim J. .2024 .Measuring influencer marketing effectiveness: Beyond vanity metrics. Journal of Digital Marketing Analytics, 12(3) : 145-163.
Mathur A.,Narayanan A.,Chetty M. .1809 .Endorsements on social media: Affiliate marketing disclosures on YouTube and Pinterest. , : .
Mejova Y.,Benkhedda Y.,Khairani Y. .2017 .#Halal culture on Instagram. , : .
Pan Y.,Liu S.,Zhang H. .2025 .Influencer marketing effectiveness: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Advertising, 54(1) : 22-45.
Respati T. .2024 .Halal awareness in online social networks: Influencer marketing of halal cosmetics. KnE Social Sciences. , : .
International RSIS .2025 .Halal branding and brand love: Consumer perspectives from Malaysia. RSIS International Journal of Economics & Business Studies, 10(4) : 99-110.
Ryu S.,Han J .2022 .Dimensions of social media influencer reputation: Communication skills, authenticity, and expertise. Social Media and Communication, 12(2) : 45-61.
Sikdar A. .2024 .Micro vs. macro influencers: Comparative insights into cosmetic brand engagement. Journal of Business Research, 09 : 125-138.
Studio UTAR. .2025 .How influencer marketing affects Malaysian Gen Z consumer intentions in purchasing fashion and beauty products. UTAR e-Print Archive. , : .
Sweet T.,Rothwell A.,Luo X. .1901 .Machine learning techniques for brand-influencer matchmaking on Instagram. , : .
Business Vogue .2022 .The evolving rules of influencer disclosure in beauty marketing. Vogue Business Reports, March, 18 : .
Wang S.,Yu C.,Fesenmaier D. R. .2020 .Source credibility and consumer persuasion in social commerce. Journal of Interactive Marketing, 03 : 79-90.
Zhao X.,Xu Z.,Ding F.,Li Z. .2024 .The influencers' attributes and customer purchase intention: The mediating role of customer attitude toward brand. SAGE Open, 14(2) : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

33

Views