No Detail Found!

Eco-Critical Discourse Analysis: Introducing Identifying Greenwashing Tactics

Author(s)
Tanzeela Ishaq Department of English Literature, National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad, Faisalabad Campus, Pakistan
Maimoona Abdulaziz Department, Assistant Professor, Department of English Literature, National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad, Faisalabad Campus, Pakistan
Abstract
Greenwashing, the practice of misrepresenting environmental efforts, poses a critical challenge in eco-advertising, often blurring the line between authentic sustainability and strategic deception. This study introduces the Tanz Model of Eco-Critical Discourse (TMED), a multi-dimensional framework designed to analyze green marketing practices through the integration of semiotic, linguistic, eco-critical, and compliance-based perspectives. TMED operates across three phases: (1) semiotic and linguistic analysis to decode visual and verbal cues in advertisements, (2) eco-critical appraisal to assess the authenticity of environmental claims and classify them into compliance, ambivalent, or defiance categories, and (3) social impact assessment to examine consumer engagement, market positioning, and societal influence of green claims. Data were collected purposively from product packaging, advertising materials, regulatory frameworks, and scholarly literature to support model construction and application. The framework was refined through expert feedback and pilot testing to ensure validity and practical relevance. TMED offers a comprehensive tool for evaluating the credibility of environmental claims, bridging theoretical insights with practical applications in academia, marketing, and policy-making, and contributes to advancing transparency, accountability, and ethical practices in environmental communication.
Publication Details
Page(s) 696-710
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 2, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Compliance Verification Eco-Advertising Greenwashing Linguistic Analysis Semiotic Analysis Social Impact Assessment Tanz Model of Eco-Critical Discourse (TMED)
References
Ala T. F. .2011 .A semiotic analysis on the A-Mild advertisements using Roland Barthes' theory (Undergraduate thesis). Fakultas Adab dan Humaniora, : .
Alniacik U.,Yilmaz C.,Alniacik E.,Ilkhan M. N. .2011 .How green are you, really? Consumers' skepticism toward green advertising. Social Behavior and Personality: An International Journal, 39(4) : 503-518.
Amato L. H.,Zillante A.,Amato C. H. .2015 .Corporate environmental claims: A game theory model with empirical results. Social Responsibility Journal, 11(1) : 36-55.
Aslam M. M. .2006 .Are you selling the right colour? A cross-cultural review of colour as a marketing cue. Journal of Marketing Communications, 12(1) : 15-30.
Banerjee S.,Gulas C. S.,Iyer E. .1995 .Shades of green: A multidimensional analysis of environmental advertising. Journal of Advertising, 24(2) : 21-31.
Barthes R. .1964 .. , : .
Barthes R. .1977 .Image, music, text (S. Heath. Trans.), : .
Basanta A. .2010 .Syntax as sign: The use of ecological models within a semiotic approach to electroacoustic composition. Organised Sound, 15(2) : 125-132.
Bhardwaj S.,Nair K.,Tariq M. U.,Ahmad A.,Chitnis A. .2023 .The state of research in green marketing: A bibliometric review from 2005 to 2022. , 15(4) : 1-16.
Bianchi C. .2011 .Semiotic approaches to advertising texts and strategies: Narrative, passion, marketing. Semiotica, 183 : 243-271.
Bortree D. S. .2012 .Persuading publics: The impact of corporate blogs on public attitudes toward organizations. Public Relations Review, 38(3) : 511-513.
Bottega L.,De Freitas J. .2009 .Public, private and nonprofit regulation for environmental quality. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 18(1) : 105-123.
Bruno R. X. .2024 .The crucial role of transparent communication in sustainability: Challenges and opportunities. International Seven Journal of Multidisciplinary, 3(5) : 1414-1422.
Carlson L.,Grove S. J.,Kangun N. .1993 .A content analysis of environmental advertising claims: A matrix method approach. Journal of Advertising, 22(3) : 27-39.
Chen Y.-S. .2016 .Green brand affect: Antecedents and consequences. Journal of Business Ethics, 135(3) : 569-585.
Choudhury S.,D. K. S. S. .2023 .Review of marketing and sustainability considering green, social, and critical marketing factors. SSRN Electronic Journal, 4585744 : 1-35.
Chu A.,Ang L. H.,Halim H. A. .2024 .Theory and Practice in Language Studies. , 14(11) : 3431-3442.
Crowley T. .2010 .From "natural" to "ecosocial flourishing": Evaluating evaluative frameworks. Ethics & the Environment, 15(1) : 100-119.
Delmas M. A.,Burbano V. C. .2011 .The drivers of greenwashing. California Management Review, 54(1) : 64-87.
Dewanti D. .2023 .Semiotic analysis of Ferdinand de Saussure's structuralism on Energen Green Bean advertisement. SSRN Electronic Journal, 4487450 : 1-12.
Eyada B. .2024 .The role of advertising in shaping consumer perceptions of sustainable brands. Journal of Ecohumanism, 3(3) : 930-943.
Fairclough N. .1995 .Critical discourse analysis: The critical study of language. , : .
Fill A.,Penz A. .2017 .The Routledge handbook of ecolinguistics. , : .
Fliegelman J. E. .2010 .The next generation of greenwash: Diminishing consumer confusion through a national eco-labeling program. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 37 : 1001-1042.
Frich B. A.,Espejel B. O. .2006 .Semiótica ambiental y gestión comunitaria. Horizontes Antropológicos, 12 : 257-269.
Goatly A. .2002 .The language of metaphors (2nd ed. , : .
Goatly A. .2002 .The representation of nature on the BBC World Service. , 22(1) : 1-27.
Gordon R.,Carrigan M.,Hastings G. .2011 .A framework for sustainable marketing. Marketing Theory, 11(2) : 143-163.
Hartono D. A.,Prima S. A. B.,Dewobroto W. S. .2022 .A multimodal critical discourse analysis of Garnier green beauty advertisement. International Journal of English and Applied Linguistics, 2(2) : 301-312.
Huang Z.,Shi Y.,Jia M. .2024 .Greenwashing: A systematic literature review. Accounting & Finance., : .
Jaiswal S. .2024 .Greenwashing and the ethics of CSR. International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research, 6(5) : 1-14.
Jam F. A.,Ali I.,Albishri N.,Mammadov A.,Mohapatra A. K. .2025 .How does the adoption of digital technologies in supply chain management enhance supply chain performance? A mediated and moderated model. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 219 : 124225.
Keilmann J.,Koch T. .2023 .When environmental claims are empty promises: How greenwashing affects corporate reputation and credibility. Environmental Communication, 18(2) : 266-284.
Kidaye N.,Saoussany A. .2020 .La communication environnementale: Une étude de la revue de littérature. Revue Internationale Des Sciences De Gestion, 3(3) : 366-388.
Kosatica M. .2024 .Semiotic landscape in a green capital: The political economy of sustainability and environment. Linguistic Landscape, 10(2) : 136-165.
Kostan H.,Salendu A. .2020 .Logic vs aesthetic: The effect of environmental claim and visual design in green advertising. Media Ekonomi dan Manajemen, 35(2) : 164-177.
Naderer B.,Schmuck D.,Matthes J. .2017 .Commercial communication in the digital age: Information or disinformation. , : .
Nemes N.,Scanlan S. J.,Smith P.,Smith T.,Aronczyk M.,Hill S.,Stabinsky D. .2022 .An integrated framework to assess greenwashing. Sustainability, 14(8) : 4431.
Nyilasy G.,Gangadharbatla H.,Paladino A. .2014 .Greenwashing: A consumer perspective. Journal of Business Ethics, 125(4) : 693-707.
O'Hara S. U. .1996 .Discursive ethics in ecosystems valuation and environmental policy. Ecological Economics, 16(1) : 95-107.
Olteanu A.,Rabitz F.,Jurkevičienė J.,Budžytė A. .2019 .The case for a semiotic method in Earth system science: Semantic networks of environmental research. Sign Systems Studies, 47(3) : 552-589.
.2011 .Environmental claims: Findings and conclusions of the OECD Committee on Consumer Policy. , : .
Ostrom E.,Cox M. E. .2010 .Moving beyond panaceas: A multi-tiered diagnostic approach for social-ecological analysis. Environmental Conservation, 37(4) : 451-463.
Ottman J. A. .2011 .The new rules of green marketing: Strategies, tools, and inspiration for sustainable branding. , : .
Satrisna D. A. A. D.,Ariyaningsih N. N. D. .2024 .Unveiling meanings in Skin 1004 advertisements. ELYSIAN JOURNAL: English Literature, Linguistics and Translation Studies, 4(4) : 414-423.
Seele P.,Gatti L. .2017 .Greenwashing revisited: In search of a typology and accusation-based definition incorporating legitimacy strategies. Business Strategy and the Environment, 26(2) : 239-252.
Shingrup S. .2013 .Ecolabels: A green sustainability recital in marketing-An empirical framework. Voice of Research, 2(1) : 53-57.
Smith K. T.,Brower T. R. .2012 .Longitudinal study of green marketing strategies that influence Millennials. Journal of Strategic Marketing, 20 : 535-551.
Somany N. .2023 .Greenwashing in business: Examining the impact of deceptive environmental claims on consumer behavior and corporate accountability. International Journal of Social Science and Economic Research, 8(4) : 908-920.
Spaniol M. J.,Danilova-Jensen E.,Nielsen M.,Rosdahl C. G.,Schmidt C. J. .2024 .Defining greenwashing: A concept analysis. Sustainability, 16(20) : 9055.
Stibbe A. .2014 .An ecolinguistic approach to critical discourse studies. Critical Discourse Studies, 11(2) : 117-128.
Stibbe A. .2015 .Ecolinguistics: Language, ecology and the stories we live by. Routledge:, : .
Stibbe A. .2015 .Ecolinguistics: Language, ecology and the stories we live by. London: Routledge., : .
Taufique K. M.,Siwar C.,Talib B. A.,Chamhuri N. .2014 .Modelling consumers' environmental responsibility and understanding of eco-labels: A conceptual framework for empirical research in Malaysia. International Journal of Green Economics, 8(3) : 199-225.
TerraChoice Environmental Marketing. .2009 .The seven sins of greenwashing: Environmental claims in consumer markets. Summary report for North America., : .
Testa F.,Iraldo F.,Tessitore S.,Frey M. .2011 .Strategies and approaches to green advertising: An empirical analysis of the Italian context. International Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development, 10(4) : 375-395.
Torelli C. J.,Monga A. B.,Kaikati A. M. .2012 .Doing poorly by doing good: Corporate social responsibility and brand concepts. Journal of Consumer Research, 38(5) : 948-963.
Torelli R.,Balluchi F.,Lazzini A. .2020 .Greenwashing and environmental communication: Effects on stakeholders' perceptions. Business Strategy and the Environment, 29(2) : 407-421.
Van Leeuwen T. .2005 .Introducing social semiotics. , : .
Vetrova K. O. .2021 .Semiotic analysis of R. Barth's advertising: Possibilities, limitations and prospects. , 13(4) : 5-11.
Wagner K. .2015 .Reading packages: Social semiotics on the shelf. Visual Communication, 14(2) : 193-220.
Welsh M. S.,Lamesse M.,Karpinski E. A. .2000 .The verification of hazardous ingredient disclosures in selected material safety data sheets. Applied Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 15(5) : 409-420.
Westerveld J. .1986 .Halfway to greenwashing. , : 32-35.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

42

Views