No Detail Found!

Assessment of Nurses’ Workplace Silence Behavior Motives: A critical review

Author(s)
Hanadi Mohammed Alhojairi Public Health Department, Faculty of Nursing, King Abdulaziz University,Jeddah,Saudi Arabia
Naglaa Abdelaziz Mahmoud Elseesy Public Health Department, Faculty of Nursing, King Abdulaziz University,Jeddah,Saudi Arabia
Sabah Mahmoud Mahran Public Health Department, Faculty of Nursing, King Abdulaziz University,Jeddah,Saudi Arabia
Abstract
The concept of nurses' silence refers to their tendency to refrain from expressing their opinions, thoughts, and suggestions, which could potentially enhance the organisation and facilitate the delivery of improved processes or services. Gaining a comprehensive understanding of the motives that contribute to silence is crucial. The lack of communication and limited interaction from nurses can have a range of adverse consequences for both patients and the nurses themselves. Experiencing burnout, high attrition rates, job discontent, decreased productivity, and emotional distress are some of the outcomes. This review examines the motives behind nurses' choice to remain silent in literature. Method: Search strategies identified studies published in peer-reviewed journals from 2016 to 2023. Twenty-four studies were found identifying the motives for nurse workplace silence. Three main themes were identified through the use of these search techniques. “Motives focused on the workplace”, “motives concentrated around leadership and management”, and "motives influenced by nurses' personality traits". In conclusion, the available data is scant, and more studies will be needed in the future to enhance the nursing profession's provision.
Publication Details
Page(s) 264-278
DOI DOI not available
Published Journal: Bioscience Research, Volume: 21, Issue: 2, Year: 2024

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
motives, Employee Silence, Workplace Silent Behavior, Nurses silence
References
El-Fattah Mohamed Aly Abd,El-Shanawany N.,Ghanem S. M.,M. S. M. .2022 .Workplace silence behavior and its consequences on nurses: A new Egyptian validation scale of nursing motives. Clinical Ethics, 17(1) : 71-82.
Abrams R.,Conolly A.,Rowland E.,Harris R.,Kent B.,Kelly D.,Maben J. .2023 .Speaking up during the COVID‐19 pandemic: nurses' experiences of organizational disregard and silence. Journal of advanced nursing, : .
Alheet A. F. .2019 .The impact of organizational silence causal factors on self-efficacy of health center employees in the Jordanian capital city (Amman). Academy of Strategic Management Journal, 18(3) : 1-13.
Alingh ,J. D. K.,Paauwe J.,Huijsman R. .2019 .Speaking up about patient safety concerns: the influence of safety management approaches and climate on nurses' willingness to speak up. -007163, 28(1) : 39-48.
Çaylak E.,Altuntas S. .2017 .Organizational silence among nurses: The impact on organizational cynicism and intention to leave work. Journal of Nursing Research, 10(2) : 90-98.
Cole D. A.,Bersick E.,Skarbek A.,Cumins K.,Dugan K.,Grantoza R. .2019 .The courage to speak out: A study describing nurses' attitudes to report unsafe practices in patient care. Journal of nursing management, 27(6) : 1176-1181.
Dedahanov A. T.,Abdurazzakov O. S.,Sun O. S. .2022 .When does abusive supervision foster ineffectual and defensive silence? Employee selfefficacy and fear as contingencies. Sustainability, 14(1) : .
Dong X. T.,Chung Y. W. .2021 .The mediating effect of perceived stress and moderating effect of trust for the relationship between employee silence and behavioral outcomes. Journal of Business and Psychology 13. Psychological Reports, 124(4) : 1715.
Erkutlu H.,Chafra J. .2019 ."Leader's integrity and employee silence in healthcare organizations". Leadership in Health Services, 32(3) : 419-434.
Abdelaliem Farghaly,S. M. Farghaly,Zeid and Abou,M. A. G. and Abou .2023 .The relationship between toxic leadership and organizational performance: the mediating effect of nurses' silence. BMC nursing, 22(1) : 1-12.
Gkorezis P.,Panagiotou M.,Theodorou M. .2016 .Workplace ostracism and employee silence in nursing: the mediating role of organizational identification. Journal of advanced nursing, 72(10) : 2381-2388.
Seren Harmanci,Topcu A. K.,Eskin Bacaksiz F.,Unaldi Baydin N.,Tokgoz Ekici E.,Yildirim A. .2018 .Organisational silence among nurses and physicians in public hospitals. Journal of clinical nursing, 27(7-8) : 1440-1451.
Mekawy Hassan,S. Hassan,S. Hassan .2018 .Workplace Silent Behavior Among Nurses: Its Motives and Its Relation to Engagement and Thriving at Work. Egyptian Journal of HealthCare, 9(4) : 644-656.
Jing F. F.,Wilkinson A.,Mowbray P. K.,Khan M. .2023 .How difficulties in upward voice lead to lateral voice: a case study of a Chinese hospital. Personnel Review, 52(3) : 760-776.
John S. P.,Manikandan K. .2019 .Employee silence: A meta-analytic review. International Journal of Indian Psychology, 10(1) : 354-366.
Kosarek J. G. .2018 .Relationships of the nursing practice environment, nursing silence behaviors, and nurse perceived patient safety http://hdl. net/11274/10172, : .
Kritsotakis G.,Gkorezis P.,Andreadaki E.,Theodoropoulou M.,Grigoriou G.,Alvizou A.,Ratsika N. .2022 .. , : .
Alhojairi . .environment and employee silence about patient safety: the mediating role of professional discrimination experienced by nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 78(2) : 434-445.
Labrague L. J.,J. A. L. J. .2020 .Association between nurse and hospital characteristics and organizational silence behaviors in nurses: A cross‐sectional study. Journal of Nursing Management, 28(8) : 2196-2204.
Lee S. E.,Choi J.,Lee H.,Sang S.,Lee H.,Hong H. C. .2021 .Factors Influencing Nurses' Willingness to Speak Up Regarding Patient Safety in East Asia: A Systematic Review. Risk management and healthcare policy, 14 : 1053-1063.
Levine K. J.,Carmody M.,Silk K. J. .2020 .The influence of organizational culture, climate, and commitment on speaking up about medical errors. Journal of nursing management, 28(1) : 130-138.
Li T.,Higgins J. P.,Deeks J. J. .2019 .Collecting data. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. , : 109-141.
Manapragada A.,Bruk-Lee V. .2016 .Staying silent about safety issues: Conceptualizing and measuring safety silence motives. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 02 : 144-156.
Otsupius A. I. .2022 .Employee Silence and Its Effects on Organizational Effectiveness. International Journal of Indian Economic Light (JIEL), 28 : 5661.
Richard O. C.,Boncoeur O. D.,Chen H.,Ford D. L. .2018 .Supervisor abuse effects on subordinate turnover intentions and subsequent interpersonal aggression: The role of power-distance orientation and perceived human resource support climate. Journal of Business Ethics, 164 : 549-563.
Sarkar M. P. .2020 .Even the silent one's speaksOrganizational silence and its antecedents. Global Journal of Enterprise Information System, 10(4) : 102-116.
Schwappach D.,Richard A. .2018 .Speak uprelated climate and its association with healthcare employees' speaking up and withholding voice behaviours: a cross-sectional survey in Switzerland. -007388, 27(10) : 827-835.
Umoren R.,Kim S.,Gray M. M.,Best J. A.,Robins L. .2022 .Interprofessional model on speaking up behaviour in healthcare professionals: a qualitative study. -000407, 6(1) : .
Wawersik D. M.,Jr Boutin,Gore E. R.,Nurses' Workplace Silence Behavior Motives Palaganas T.,J. C. T. .2023 .Individual characteristics that promote or prevent psychological safety and error reporting in healthcare: a systematic review. Journal of healthcare leadership, 10 : 59-70.
Woods M. .2020 .Moral distress revisited: The viewpoints and responses of nurses. International Nursing Review, 67 : 68-75.
Yang J.,Yang H.,Wang B. .2022 .Organizational silence among hospital nurses in China: a crosssectional study. BioMed Research International, : .
Yurdakul M.,Beşen M. A.,Erdoğan S. .2016 .The organisational silence of midwives and nurses: reasons and results. Journal of nursing management, 24(5) : 686-694.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

123

Views