No Detail Found!

Psychometric properties of adapted mindset instruments: a comprehensive comparison

Author(s)
Lalu Hamdian Affandi Ganesha University of Education, Singaraja Bali, Indonesia
Nyoman Jampel Ganesha University of Education, Singaraja Bali, Indonesia
Gusti Ngurah Pujawan Ganesha University of Education, Singaraja Bali, Indonesia
Ni Made Sri Mertasari Ganesha University of Education, Singaraja Bali, Indonesia
Gede Ratnaya Ganesha University of Education, Singaraja Bali, Indonesia
Abstract
Mindset currently gains considerable attentions in educational field. Nevertheless, mindset effect on students’ achievement and teachers’ performance is still obscure. Inconclusive result potentially comes from variation of mindset instruments. Therefore, there is a need for assessing psychometric properties of mindset instruments. Current research is aimed at comparing psychometric properties of 2 adapted mindset instruments, namely Mindset Assessment Profile (MAP-V16) and Mindset Quizzes (MQ-V20). Prior to be distributed, both mindset instruments were translated into Indonesian language. Respondents of current research are 243 students of Elementary School Teacher Education Department at the University of Mataram, Indonesia. Most of them are female (89.5%) with 20.3 years old in average. Respondents filled both instruments via Google form. Data then analyzed by performing exploratory factor analysis, Partial Least Square Structural Equation Model, and item characteristic analysis. Result reveals that both mindset instruments accurately measure mindset with different coverage; MAP-V16 measures growth mindset and fixed mindset as two distinct constructs and MQ-V20 only measures growth mindset. All items in both instruments met the criteria for item fit and well-functioning response categories, but only 2 items did not meet the criteria of item invariance. Finding of this research indicates that adaptation of mindset instrument lacks inclusive definition of intelligence because they did not elicit cultural-based intelligent behavior. Current research suggests for researchers and school leader to clearly define mindset and research aims before deciding the instrument to be used for measuring it.
Publication Details
Page(s) 3696-3710
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Mindset instrument exploratory factor analysis PLS-SEM Rating scale model
References
Aditomo .2015 .Growth Mindset' as a Buffer Against Demotivation. International Journal of Educational Psychology, 1482(2) : 198.
Andrich D.,edited by M. L. Nering R.,Ostini R. .2010 .“Understanding the Response Structure and Process in the Polytomous Rasch Model. , : 123.
Bahník ,Marek A.,Vranka A. .2017 .Growth Mindset Is Not Associated with Scholastic Aptitude in a Large Sample of University Applicants. Personality and Individual Differences, 05 : 139-43.
Bai Jing,Wang Youyan,Nie Youyan .2020 .Self-Efficacy, Task Values and Growth Mindset: What Has the Most Predictive Power for Primary School Students' Self-Regulated Learning in English Writing and Writing Competence in an Asian Confucian Cultural Context?”. Cambridge Journal of Education, 1778639(1) : 1-20.
Bardach Keiko C. P.,Bostwick Keiko C. P.,Robert M. Klassen Jakob,Pietschnig Jakob .2024 .A Meta-Analysis on Teachers' Growth Mindset. , 36 : .
Bernardo Allan B. I.,Yuyang Cai,Ronnel B.,King B. .2021 .Society-Level Social Axiom Moderates the Association between Growth Mindset and Achievement across Cultures. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 10(4) : 1166-84.
Beziat and Erin F.,Klash and Erin F. .2017 .Metacognitive Awareness and Mindset in Current and Future Principals. ” School Leadership Review, 12(2) : 23-31.
Bond Z.,Yan M.,Heene M. .2021 .Applying The Rasch Model: Fundamental Measurement in the Human Sciences. , : .
Boone W. J.,Staver J. R. .2020 .Advance in Rasch Analysis in Human Sciences. , : .
Boone Amity,Noltemeyer Amity .2017 .Rasch Analysis: A Primer for School Psychology Researchers and Practitioners. Cogent Education, 1416898(1) : .
Boylan Lennie,Barblett Marianne,Knaus Marianne .2018 .Early Childhood Teachers' Perspectives of Growth Mindset: Developing Agency in Children. Australasian Journal of Early Childhood, 10(3) : 16-24.
Brez Eric M.,Hampton Josh,Powers Josh .2020 .Failure to Replicate: Testing a Growth Mindset Intervention for College Student Success. ” Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 1806845(6) : 460-68.
Burnette ,Jeffrey M.,Pollack M.,Forsyth Alexandra D.,Babij Anthony E.,Coy Anthony E. .2020 .“A Growth Mindset Intervention: Enhancing Students' Entrepreneurial Self-Efficacy and Career Development. Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice, 10(5) : 878-908.
Cooper S.,Lee E.,Jeter C. L.,Bradley C. L. .2020 .Psychometric Validation of a Growth Mindset and Team Communication Tool to Measure Self-Views of Growth Mindset and Team Communication Skills. ” Journal of the American Pharmacists Association, 04(6) : 818-26.
Corradi Jonas,Nicolaï François,Levrau François .2019 .Growth Mindset and Its Predictive Validity-Do Migration Background. Higher Education, 10(3) : 491-504.
Diehl E. .2008 .Motivating Students with Mindset Coaching and How Brains Work (Dweck).. , : .
Dweck Carol S. .2006 .Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. , : .
Dweck Carol S.,Willpower. Carol S. .2012 .“Mindsets and Human Nature: Promoting Change in the Middle East, the Schoolyard, the Racial Divide, and. American Psychologist, 10(8) : 614-22.
Dweck ,Ellen L.,Leggett L. .95 .“A Social-Cognitive Approach to Motivation and Personality. Psychological Review, 10(2) : 0033-295X.
Fabrigar L. R.,Wegener D. T. .2012 .Exploratory Factor Analysis. , : .
Ganimian Alejandro J. .2019 .Growth Mindset Interventions at Scale : Experimental Evidence from Argentina ∗. , : .
Grüning David J.,Beatrice Rammstedt,Clemens M.,Lechner M. .2023 .Fixed Is Not the Opposite of Growth: Item Keying Matters for Measuring Mindsets. , 10 : .
Hacisalihoglu Maurice,Edington Maurice .2020 .Enhancing Undergraduate Student Success in Stem Fields through Growth-Mindset and Grit. Education Sciences, 10(10) : 1-11.
Haimovitz ,Carol S.,Dweck S. .2016 .What Predicts Children's Fixed and Growth Intelligence Mind-Sets? Not Their Parents' Views of Intelligence but Their Parents' Views of Failure. ” Psychological Science, 10(6) : 859-69.
Hair J. F.,Black W. C.,Babin B. J.,Anderson R. E. .2019 .Multivariate Data Analysis. , : .
Hair J. F.,Hult G. T. M.,Ringle C. M.,Sarstedt M. .2017 .A Primer on Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM). Thousand Oaks, : .
Hambleton R. K.,Swaminathan H. .1985 .Item Response Theory: Principles and Applications. , : .
Hambleton R.K.,K. Hambleton P. F.,Merenda C. D.,Spielberg C. D. .2005 .-38 in Adapting Educational and Psychological Tests for CrossCultural Assessment. , : .
Howe Lauren C.,Carol S.,Dweck S. .2016 .Changes in Self-Definition Impede Recovery From Rejection. ” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 10(1) : 54-71.
Huang Yuanyuan,Shi Yuqi,Wang Yuqi .2022 .Does Growth Mindset Benefit Mental Health in Asia ? Evidence from Chinese Students. ” Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology, 10 : 1-11.
Hughes D.J.,Booth T.,Hughes David J. .2018 .a Multidisciplinary Reference on Survey, Scale, and Test Development. , : 751.
Ingebrigtsen Frode,Svartdal Frode .2018 .How to Measure a Growth Mindset :”. , : 1-75.
King Ronnel B. .2021 .Growth Mindset Predicts Achievement Only among Rich Students: Examining the Interplay between Mindset and Socioeconomic Status. Social Psychology of Education, 10(3) : 635-52.
Lai ,Michelle S.,Livings S.,Michelle P. D'Amico Matthew J.,Hayat Jeremiah,Williams Jeremiah .2018 .“A Growth Mindset Pilot Intervention for a Graduate-Level Biostatistics Course. Statistics Education Research Journal, 10(2) : 161-19.
Lee ,Chan ,Yuk-Yue Tong ,Chi-Yue Chiu .2023 .Growth Mindset Predicts Teachers ' Life Satisfaction When They Are Challenged to Innovate Their Teaching. ” Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology, 10 : 1-11.
Li ,Timothy C.,Bates C. .2020 .“Testing the Association of Growth Mindset and Grades across a Challenging Transition: Is Growth Mindset Associated with Grades?”. Intelligence, 101471 : 101471.
Lim .2020 .Integrated Work Study Program: Students Growth Mindset and Perception of Change in Work-Related Skills. International Journal of Work-Integrated Learning, 21(2) : 103-15.
Limeri Lisa B.,Nathan T.,Carter T.,Hannah R. Martin Annaleigh,Benton and Erin L.,Dolan and Erin L. .2020 .Growing a Growth Mindset: Characterizing How and Why Undergraduate Students' Mindsets Change. doi: 10.1186/s40594-020-00227-2., 7(1) : .
Lin-Siegler and Geoffrey L.,Cohen and Geoffrey L. .2016 .Introduction: Instructional Interventions That Motivate Classroom Learning. ” Journal of Educational Psychology, 10(3) : 295-99.
Lüftenegger Joy,Muth Joy,Practices Classroom .2024 .Teachers' Mindset Meaning System: Achievement Goals, Beliefs. , 10 : .
Masters G. N.,edited by M. L. Nering R.,Ostini R. .2010 .The Partial Credit Model. , : 109.
Mesler ,Catherine M. Corbin .2021 .Teacher Mindset Is Associated with Development of Students' Growth Mindset. ” Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology 76(March, 101299 : 101299.
Midkiff ,Panter A. T.,Culpepper S.,Janssen R.,González J.,Molenaar D. .2018 .“An IRT Analysis of the Growth Mindset Scale. , : 163.
Nalipay ,Ronnel B.,King Imelu,Mordeno Hui,Wang Hui .2021 .Are Good Teachers Born or Made ? Teachers Who Hold a Growth Mindset about Their Teaching Ab ility Have Better Well-Being. Educational Psychology, 2001791(1) : 23-41.
Park Alisa,Yu and Angela L.,Duckworth and Angela L. .2020 .The Development of Grit and Growth Mindset during Adolescence. ” Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 104889(104889) : .
Revelle W.,Condon D. M.,Booth T.,Hughes D. J. .2018 .a Multidisciplinary Reference on Survey, Scale, and Test Development. , : 709.
Rust J.,Kosinski M.,Stillwell D. .2021 .Modern Psychometrics: The Science of Psychological Assessment. , : .
Scherer .2022 .Measuring Those Who Have Their Minds Set: An ItemLevel Meta-Analysis of the Implicit Theories of Intelligence Scale in Education. Educational Research Review, 100479 : 100479.
Schraw Lori,Olafson Lori .2015 .s Beliefs, edited by Helenrose Fives and Michele Gregoire Gill. , : 87.
Sireci S. G.,Patsula L.,Hambleton R.K.,Merenda P. F.,Spielberger C. D. .2005 .Psychological Tests for Cross-Cultural Assessment, edited by Ronald K. , : 93.
Sovey Kamisah,Osman Kamisah .2022 .Rasch Analysis for Disposition Levels of Computational Thinking Instrument Among Secondary School Students. EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 18(3) : .
Stanovich K. E.,Stanovich P. J.,Sternberg R. J. .2010 .“A Framework for Critical Thinking. Teaching, and Human Development, : 195.
Sternberg R.J.,Development Human,Sternberg Robert J. .2010 .WICS: An Expanded Model for Effective Practice in School and Later Life. , : 403.
Sternberg Robert J.,Grigorenko and Elena L. .2004 .Intelligence and Culture: How Culture Shapes What Intelligence Means, and the Implications for a Science of Well-Being. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 1514(1449) : 1427-34.
Van de Vijner F. J. R.,Poortinga Y. H.,edited by R. K. Hambleton P. F.,Merenda C. D.,Spielberg C. D. .2005 .Psychological Tests for Cross-Cultural Assessment. , : 39.
West ,Martin R.,Matthew A.,Kraft A.,Angela L. Duckworth A.,Christopher F. O. Gabrieli John D. E.,Gabrieli John D. E. .2016 .“Promise and Paradox: Measuring Students' NonCognitive Skills and the Impact of Schooling. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 10(1) : 148-70.
Yan ,King ,Joseph Y.,Haw Y. .2021 .“Formative Assessment, Growth Mindset, and Achievement: Examining Their Relations in the East and the West. ” Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy and Practice, 1988510(5-6) : 676-702.
Yeager ,Carol S.,Dweck S. .2020 .. American Psychologist, 10(9) : 1269-84.
Yu Pia,Kreijkes Pia,Katariina Pia,Practices Teaching .2022 .. doi: 10, 101616 : .
Zilka Shiri,Nussbaum Ronit,Bogler Ronit,Burnout Teacher .2023 .The Relationships among Growth Mindset , Flow , Critically Reflective Behavior. International Journal of School & Educational Psychology, 2245372(4) : 367-79.
0

Citations

0

Downloads

77

Views