No Detail Found!

Power of Pardon in Common Law and the Shari'ah: Harmonisation for Enhancing Justice

Author(s)
Moin Uddin Faculty of Law,Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia
Shad Saleem Faruqi Tunku Abdul Rahman Chair at the Faculty of Law,Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia
Che Audah Hassan Faculty of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Jalan Sarjana , Shah Alam, Malaysia
Maruf Billah Faculty of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Jalan Sarjana , Shah Alam, Malaysia
Fuad Mahbub Faculty of Law,Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Jalan Sarjana, Shah Alam,Malaysia
Abstract
The power of pardon is an act of grace whereby state authorities are solely entrusted, in all cases of crime, with the power to pardon offenders without considering any rights or compensation for crime victims. In many countries, the pardon grants have been attached to immense controversy over the centuries due to occasional abuses of the pardon power and violations of the legitimate rights of crime victims. In contrast, the Shari'ah pardon principle empowers state authorities to pardon offenders in cases where no individual is directly affected by the crime. In other cases, the Shari'ah pardon principle grants a legal and exclusive right to crime victims to determine the fate of the criminals in deciding on the pardon petitions. The aims of this study are to examine the theory of the power of pardon in the federal law of selected common law countries, to compare and contrast it with the Shari'ah pardon principle, to identify the inadequacies of the applicability of pardon principles in both jurisdictions, and to harmonise the pardon principles of both jurisdictions to formulate a feasible and balanced pardon decision-making process that is substantively and procedurally just and enhances justice for both the victims or victims' heirs in murder cases and the convicts and protects the public interest. This study adopts a qualitative doctrinal research to accumulate research data and to gather in-depth insights into the research problem. The researchers employ various research approaches such as comparative, textual and evaluative to analyse research data and to achieve research objectives. This study submits that harmonisation of the pardon principles of common law and the Shari'ah will generate a pardon decisionmaking mechanism that is feasible, balanced and just for both disputing parties involved in the crime, averts frequent abuses of the pardon power, and protects the public interest.
Publication Details
Page(s) 3403-3418
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Power of Pardon, Common Law Shari’ah Justice Harmonisation of Pardon Principles
References
Abu-Nimer ,Ilham Nasser .2013 .“Forgiveness in the Arab and Islamic Contexts: Between Theology and Practice”. The Journal of Religious Ethics, 41 : .
Acton ,Lord .1887 .“Letter to Archbishop Mandell Creighton”. , : .
Adil .2016 .“The Application of Shariah Principles of Ta'zir in Malaysian Common Law: A Maqasid-Based Proposal”. Islam and Civilisational Renewal (ICR) 7. , : .
Al-Kashif ,El-Rehim Mohamed .2009 .“Shari'ah's Normative Framework as to Financial Crime and Abuse”. Journal of Financial Crime, 16 : .
Awdah ,Qadir ,Al-Jinai Al-Islami Muqaranan ,Al-Wadi .1985 .Islamic Criminal Law Compared with Positive Law]. , 2 : .
Aykut ,Ebru .2017 .“Judicial Reforms, Sharia Law, and the Death Penalty in the Late Ottoman Empire”. Journal of the Ottoman and Turkish Studies Association, 4 : .
Baderin Mashood A. .2010 .“Administration of Justice under the Shari'ah, Common Law and Civil Law System: Towards a Better Understanding”. Malaysian Journal of Syariah and Law, 2 : .
Barnett ,Hilaire .2003 .Constitutional and administrative law. , : .
Bari Abdul,Aziz Abdul .2004 .Constitution of Malaysia: Text and commentary. , : .
Bearman ,Peri .2016 .The Ashgate research companion to Islamic law. , : .
Black .2013 .Modern perspectives on Islamic law. Edward Elgar Publishing., : .
Bretgoltz .2021 .“An Absolute Power, or A Power Absolutely in Need of Reform? Proposals to Reform the Presidential Pardon Power”. Democracy and the Constitution Clinic. , : .
Dicey Albert,Venn Albert,Emlyn Capel Stewart Wade Albert .1959 .Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution. , : .
Duker .1977 .“The President's Power to Pardon: A Constitutional History”. William and Mary Law Review, 18(3) : .
Eckstein ,Mikaela Colby .2019 .“Presidential Pardon Power: Are There Limits and. Arizona State Law Journal, 51 : .
El-Awa .1982 .Punishment in Islamic law: A comparative study. American, : .
Faruqui ,Saleem .2008 .Document of destiny: The Constitution of the Federation of Malaysia. , : .
Faruqi ,Saleem .2003 .Constitutional Law, The Rule of Law and Systems of Governance in Islam in the Ummah at the Crossroads: The Role of the OIC. Ahmad Murad Merican, : .
Flanders ,Chad .2013 .“Pardons and the Theory of the Second-Best”. Florida Law Review, 65 : .
Fowler Kristen H. .2008 .“Limiting the Federal Pardon Power”. , : .
Genovese .2002 .“The Pardon Power under Clinton: Tested but Intact”. The Presidency and the Law: The Clinton Legacy. , : .
Gouda ,Moamen .2013 .“Islamic constitutionalism and rule of law: a constitutional economics perspective”. Constitutional Political Economy, 24 : .
Harding Andrew,James Andrew .1986 .“Monarchy and the Prerogative in Malaysia”. Malaya Law Review, 28 : .
Hascall Susan C. .2010 .“Shariʿah and Choice: What the United States Should Learn from Islamic Law about the Role of Victims' Families in Death Penalty Cases”. The John Marshall Law Review, 44 : .
Hickling ,Hugh .1975 .“The Prerogative in Malaysia”. Malaya Law Review, 17 : .
Majah Ibn .2007 .English Translation of Sunan Ibn Majah. , 3 : .
Kamali ,Hashim .2015 .“Amnesty and Pardon in Islamic Law with Special Reference to Post-Conflict Justice”. Islam and Civilisational Renewal (ICR) 6. , : .
Kamali ,Hashim .2007 .“Shari'ah and civil law: Towards a methodology of harmonisation”. Islamic Law and Society, 14 : .
Kamali ,Hashim .2012 .“Exploring Facets of Islam on Security and Peace: Amnesty and Pardon in Islamic Law”. Islam and Civilisational Renewal (ICR) 3. , : .
Karim .2017 .“A Comparative Analysis of Retributive Justice and the Law of Qisas”. Journal of Nusantara Studies, 2 : .
Kobil .1991 .“The Quality of Mercy Strained: Wresting the Pardoning Power from the King”. Texas Law Review, 569 : .
Krishnan ,Anandan ,Defined Judicially,Helen Judicially .2005 .“The Politics of Mercy: The Use of the Royal Pardon in Fourteenth-Century England”. PhD diss, : .
Lee Hoong,Phun Hoong,Colgate Hoong .2000 .Of Pardons, Politics and Collar Buttons: Reflections on the President's Duty to Be Merciful”. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 27 : .
Love ,Colgate .2008 .“Reinventing the President's Pardon Power”. The Journal of the ACS Issue Groups 2 Advance, 63 : .
Love ,Colgate .2015 .“Justice department administration of the president's pardon power: A case study in institutional conflict of interest”. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences 7, no. 1., : .
Rahami ,Mohsen .2007 .“Islamic Restorative Traditions and Their Reflections in the Post Revolutionary Criminal Justice System of Iran”. European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, 15 : .
Rai J. P. .2014 .“Exercise of pardoning power in India: Emerging challenges”. The NEHU Journal 12, No. 2., : .
Rothchild ,Jonathan .2011 .“Dispenser of the mercy of the government: pardons, justice, and felony disenfranchisement”. Journal of Religious Ethics, 39 : .
Sahai ,Rohan .2009 .“Limits of the Pardoning Power under the Indian Constitution”. NUJS Law Review, 293 : .
Sanmiha L. .2017 ./analysis-judicial-review-pardoningpower-president-governor-india/.. , : .
Shahrasbi ,Sanya .2020 .“Can a Presidential Pardon Trump an Article III Court's Criminal Contempt Conviction: A Separation of Powers Analysis of President Trump's Pardon of Sheriff Joe Arpaio”. Geo. JL & Pub. Pol'y 18., : .
Singh Mahendra P. .2007 .N Shukla's Constitution of India. Eastern, : .
Stanish .1978 .“The Effect of a Presidential Pardon”. Federal Probation, 42 : .
Tajuddin ,Nasimah Hussin .2022 .Harmonising Criminal Justice System in Shari'ah and Common Law: The Challenge of Harmonisation. Adnan Trakic, : .
Turpin ,Adam Tomkins .2011 .British government and the constitution: text and materials. , : .
Udofa ,Imo .2018 .“The Abuse of Presidential Power of Pardon and the Need for Restraints”. Beijing Law Review, 9 : .
Verreycken ,Quentin .2019 .“The Power to Pardon in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe: New Perspectives in the History of Crime and Criminal Justice”. History Compass, 17 : .
Waqas ,Humdia Qaiser .2014 .“A Comparative Analysis of Punishments Awarded in Islamic Legal System and Western Legal System”. International Research Journal of Social Sciences, 11 : .
Wasti ,Tahir .2006 .“Islamic Law in Practice: The Application of Qisas and Diyat Law in Pakistan”. Yearbook of Islamic and Middle Eastern Law, 13 : .
Weihofen ,Henry .1939 .“Effect of a Pardon”. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 88 : .
Weil ,Jessica .2017 .“Controversial Clemency: The President's Problematic Power to Pardon”. PhD diss, : .
Wells Michael,Burnett Michael .2000 .“When Cultures Collide: An Australian Citizen's Power to Demand the Death Penalty under Islamic Law”. Sydney Law Review, 22 : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

30

Views