No Detail Found!

Authenticity of Using Artificial Intelligence Systems in Electronic Evidence Proving

Author(s)
Murtada Abdalla Kheiri Civil Law at A'Sharqiyah University, Ibra, Oman
Nizar Qashta Civil Law at A'Sharqiyah University, Ibra, Oman
Dorgham Issa Aljaradat College of Islamic Sciences,Palestine,
Abstract
The digital age has brought a surge in technological advancements, impacting every facet of life. The emergence of artificial intelligence technologies and the achievements and radical changes they offer have led to the emergence of new types of crimes characterized by the use of electronic evidence and the use of machines to commit them. This has prompted governments, police and judicial authorities to use artificial intelligence technologies to help detect these crimes and reduce their occurrence. However, employing AI in the courtroom raises significant questions. Expand more Concerns surrounding the validity, weight in court, and proper limitations of evidence extracted using AI This research delves into the role of AI in evidence extraction and its admissibility within the legal system. The research focuses on the contemporary legal landscape, particularly regarding electronic evidence and its weight in court. It addresses the challenges posed by AI, such as relying solely on AI for crime investigation and prosecution, and the resulting legal complexities. The research aims to Define AI and electronic evidence. ? Identify the different types and characteristics of electronic evidence. ? Explore areas where AI can be applied in judicial evidence analysis. ? Examine the weight given to electronic evidence in court. The research utilizes a combined scientific approach, employing both descriptive and analytical methods. It found that AI excels in data analysis, facial/eye recognition, and multimedia analysis, surpassing traditional computer programs. However, legal and legislative hurdles remain, along with challenges related to the weight of evidence, algorithmic bias, and deep fakes (manipulated videos). The research recommends a balanced approach. It suggests allowing AI use in courts with strict safeguards to protect liberties and ensure justice. These safeguards include upholding the presumption of innocence, carefully evaluating the weight of digital outputs, and thoroughly discussing them in court proceedings. Additionally, the research emphasizes the need for: Updating laws and regulations to keep pace with AI advancements. Educating law enforcement and judicial personnel on AI technologies. Continuously seeking solutions to address algorithmic bias and other emerging challenges.  By implementing these recommendations, we can leverage AI's potential while ensuring its ethical and responsible use in the judicial system 
Publication Details
Page(s) 37-52
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences, Volume: 23, Issue: 1, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Artificial intelligence Electronic evidence Electronic proof Evidentiary weight Algorithmic bias
References
Mola Abdel .2023 .. The Negative Impact of Artificial Intelligence Developments on the authenticity of Electronic Evidence in Criminal Matters,' research published on the Electronic Encyclopedia of Protectors of Rights, December, 26 : .
Latif Abdul .1992 .. Publishing and Distribution, : 6.
Muttalib Abdul .2020 .Mamdouh Abdel Majeed, Using TCP/IP Protocol in Researching and Investigating Computer Crimes, published on the Internet (Dpolice. , 12 : .
Adel .2005 .. World of Artificial Intelligence, 1st edition King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology, Saudi Arabia, : .
Ahmed Electronic,Discovery Electronic,Studies Economic,Edition First .2022 .Digital Evidence Authority In proof between The Challenges of Acceptance and Information Security, Arab Democratic Center for Strategic, Political. , : .
Alai Ammar,Rashid Ammar,Issue 37 .2023 .. Muhammad Nour Al-Din. Using Artificial Intelligence Applications in Crime Prediction and Prevention, 20 : .
Al-Ajmani ,Said ,Muhammad Noor ,December .2023 .Legitimacy of Using Artificial Intelligence Techniques in Crime Investigation. , 20(4) : .
Al-Asyuti ,Al-Arabi Journal,Issue 1 .2020 .. Protect and Prove Legal Actions through the Application of Artificial Intelligence, 1 : .
Al-Balushi . .Rashid bin Hamad, 'Authenticity of Digital Outputs in Evidence,' a paper presented at the First International Conference on 'Protecting Information Security and Privacy in Internet Law,' sponsored by the International Association for Cybercrime Prevention in France, held from June 2 to 4, 2008. , : .
Al-Hussaini ,al-Bait Journal .2008 .The Legality of Mobile Phone Recordings as Evidence in Criminal Proceedings: A Comparative Study. , : .
Al-Hussaini ,Issue 1 .2014 .Ammar Abbas, Visual Imaging and its Evidence in Criminal Evidence. Journal of the College of Law, 16 : .
Ali Rizk,Saad Rizk,Studies A Refereed,Scientific Journal,Issue 3 .2023 .. Using Artificial Intelligence and Data Analysis Techniques in Detecting Crimes, Journal of Legal, 9 : .
Al-Jaafari .2013 .Badr bin Abdullah, The Validity of Electronic Evidence in Commercial Disputes, Evidence Means Forum. Chamber of Commerce and Industry, : .
Al-Jabour .2024 .(www. Algorithmic Bias and Favoritism in Artificial Intelligence,' article on LinkedIn. Accessed on June 27, : .
Al-Jamali .2009 .. First Maghreb Conference on Information Technology and Law held on 28-29-10, : .
Al-Jaradat .2022 .Dhurgham Issa, Jurisprudential Rulings Related to the Use of Smartphones. , : .
Al-Jazzar .2024 .Saadia, The Extent of Considering Audio Recording as a Modern Method of Proof: A Jurisprudential Study in Light of the Use of Artificial Intelligence Technology. University Journal, Research Extracted from the First Issue, 2 : 3.
Al-Khanin .2003 .Abdullah bin Muhammad, Description of Judiciary in Islamic Law, 1st edition. , : .
Al-Mahdi .2007 .Hussein bin Muhammad, 'The Evidentiary Power of Electronic Transactions,'. Judicial Research Journal, Republic of Yemen, Issue, 7 : .
Al-Nadawi ,Al-Qadisiyah Press .1976 .. 2nd edition, : .
Al-Nawafleh .2010 .. PhD Dissertation, : .
Al-Qarafi ,Sharh Tankeh .1973 .. United Technical Printing Company, First Edition, : .
Al-Sayed Muhammad .2016 .Electronic Facial Recognition as a Means of Evidence from an Islamic Jurisprudential Perspective,' Annual of the Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Girls in Zagazig. , : .
Al-Sharif .2021 .Mahmoud Salama Abdel Moneim. Saudi Arabia, 3 : .
Arnous Dar,Al-Sahab Publishing .2007 .. , : .
. .Article 1 of the Definitions in the First Chapter of Law No. 175 of 2018 on Combating Information Technology Crimes. , : .
. .Royal Care and Bahraini Leadership towards the Future, Haifa Adwan, was published on the Bahraini Al-Watan newspaper website. accessed on: 3, : .
.2002 .Artificial Intelligence article, on the Nokta website of the Arab Scientific Community. See the article on artificial intelligence on the Tumoohi website for universities. accessed on: 13/6, : .
Artificial . .Intelligence in Education, an article on the Mabarrat website. , 10 : .
Atiq ,Al-Sayed Muhammad Saeed .2005 .General Theory of Scientific Evidence in Criminal Proceedings. PhD Thesis, : .
Mashri Ben .2018 .The Reality of Human Rights Protection in the Algerian Penal Code. , : .
Younes Ben .2004 .Omar, Crimes Arising from the Use of the Internet. PhD Thesis, : .
Khalifa Bin .2014 .The Role of Fingerprints and Other Physical Traces in Criminal Evidence, Dar Al Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution. , : .
Cybersecurity . .Artificial Intelligence Study in Saudi Arabia, article on Easy Uni website: (https://www. , 25 : .
- Tech .2023 .. Egyptian Law No. 175 of 2018 on Combating Information Technology Crimes. Abdul Generative Artificial Intelligence, : .
Hamouda .2003 .Evidence Obtained from Electronic Means within the Framework of the Evidence Theory, presented in the proceedings of the First Scientific Conference on the Security and Legal Aspects of Electronic Operations, organized by the Dubai Police Academy on 4/26/. , : .
Hijazi ,Al-Kotob AlQanuniyah .2004 .. , : .
Abd Ibn,Abd Ibn,Al-Azhar Colleges Ibn .1991 .Qawaid Al-ahkam ,. , : .
Abidin Ibn .1966 .-Muhtar, ala al-Durr al-Mukhtar: Sharh Tanwir alAbsar. Mustafa Babi Halabi Library and Sons Press, Egypt, 2nd edition, : .
Manzur Ibn .1994 .. Dar Sadir, Beirut, 3rd edition, : .
Sidah Ibn,Al- Ibn,Al-Ilmiyyah- Beirut Ibn .2000 .a'zam. , : .
Sidah Ibn,Al-Arabi Ibn .1996 .. Beirut, 1st edition, : .
Ibrahim ,Jami' I,Alexandria I .2020 .an article published on his official website (https://kenanaonline. , : .
Al-Din Izz,Ghazi Izz .2007 .. Artificial Intelligence: Is it a Symbolic Technology? Journal of Thought in Humanities and Social Sciences, Faculty of Arts - Fez, 6 : .
Jihad .2014 .. Amjad Publishing and Distribution House, : 14.
Khawaled Abu,Bakr Abu .2019 .Artificial Intelligence Applications as a Modern Trend to Enhance the Competitiveness of Business Organizations, Arab Democratic Center for Strategic, Political and Economic Studies, 1st edition. , : .
Jurisprudence Kuwaiti,Encyclopedia Kuwaiti . .. , 1404 : .
Fatawa ,al-Hukmiyyah . .I'lam al-Muwaqqi'in (1/90. , 35 : 15-32.
Marqus .1981 .Principles of Evidence and its Procedures in Civil Matters in Egyptian Law Compared to the Techniques of Other Arab Countries, Alam Al-Kutub for Printing, Publishing. , : .
Muhammad Asmaa,Al-Sayed Muhammad Asmaa,Muhammad Asmaa .2020 .. Artificial Intelligence Applications and the Future of Educational Technology, Egyptian National Library, : .
Mukhtar .2008 .Ahmed Abdel Hamid Omar, with the assistance of a work team, Lexicon of the Modern Arabic language. Alam Al-Kutub, 1st edition, : .
Musa ,Bilal .2019 .A Revolution in Modern Technologies. , : .
.2024 .Nasser bin Abdullah, an article on the Omani electronic newspaper. accessed on 6/17, : .
.2017 .. Risks of Artificial Intelligence on Security and the Future of Work: An Analytical Perspective, published by RAND Corporation, : 6.
Sayed ,Muhammad Nour .2021 .Security Challenges in Using Artificial Intelligence and Digital Systems for Security Work. Police Sciences Academy, Sharjah Police General Command, : .
El-Din Shams .2021 .Arabiya for Publishing and Distribution. , : .
Yasser ,Al-Babli .2019 .. The Role of Artificial Intelligence Systems in Crime Prediction,' Police Thought Journal, 3(July) : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

47

Views