No Detail Found!

Comparison of Floored and Cage Housed Broiler Breeder Farms for Energy and Economic Eficiency in Pakistan: A Case Study of Broiler Breeder's Farm in District Punjab

Author(s)
Ishtiaq Ahmad Khan Department of Poultry Science, Faculty of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Sciences, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar, Pakistan
Sarzamin Khan Department of Poultry Science, Faculty of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Sciences, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar, Pakistan
Muhammad Shuaib Arid Zone Small Ruminants Research Institute, Ghulam Banda, Kohat, Pakistan
Sohaib Ul Hassan College of Veterinary Sciences, Faculty of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Sciences, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar, Pakistan
Abdulmohsen Hussen Alqhtani Animal Production, College of Agriculture and Food Sciences, King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Anthony Pokoo-Aikins US National Poultry Research Center, Toxicology and Mycotoxin Research Unit, USDA ARS, Athens, GA 30605, USA
Ashraf Ali Qureshi Ruminants Research Institute, Ghulam Banda, Kohat, Pakistan
Majid Ali Arid Zone Small Ruminants Research Institute, Ghulam Banda, Kohat, Pakistan
Waqas Alam Department of Poultry Science, Faculty of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Sciences, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar, Pakistan
Abstract
Research trials were conducted at commercial broiler breeder farms (n=60,000) to compare the economic and energy efficiency of floored and caged housing systems. Efficiency was evaluated by the inputs and outputs used. The egg prices were as per market rates at the time of this study. The cost for good settable eggs was 12% higher in floor-house (24.8) compared to enriched cages (22.1). The settable egg cost and the input costs during the entire egg production cycle for the floor and caged houses were human resource (labor) 3.03, 12.2% and 2.49, 11.3%; energy 0.5, 2.02% and 0.49, 2.26%; inputs purchased 11.4, 46.1% and 9.36, 42.3% and growing, rental and depreciation 9.81, 39.6% and 9.77, 44.2%, respectively. The floored flocks exhibited higher revenues when compared to caged broilers and had a total revenue of dayold chicks; 65.3, 92.6% and 53.4, 94.1%; spent birds 2.98, 4.22% and 3.12, 5.42% and manure; 2.26 and 3.2% and 0.22, 0.39% respectively. Except for spent birds, all output variables contributed more to the total higher sales revenue generated by caged flocks. Production costs per hen (4,456) and per hatched chick (33.4) at the floor houses were higher by 5.6 and 29% than the flocks housed in the enriched houses (4,219 and 25.8). Net income generated was 2.3 times higher in the enriched cages and they generated 1.67 more than floored flocks (1.27). The energy input and output values of the floored houses were 16% higher and 9% less than cage houses, respectively. Eggs were the highest energy output contributors followed by manure and meat. Energy efficiency for both types of housing were economical however, the energy used at the enriched cage housing was more efficient than in the floor pens. Specific energy use was 0.25 MJ kg-1 for the floor houses and 0.2 MJ kg-1 for the enriched cage houses, indicating judicious energy use in the current trials. The cost per chick is the determining factor for choosing the type of housing, considering addition to the environmental safety and bird’s welfare
Publication Details
Page(s) 1695-1705
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Zoology, Volume: 57, Issue: 4, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
efficiency, poultry, manure, eggs, Housing, Cages
References
Acil F. .1980 .Calculation of the agricultural product costs and development in agricultural product costs in Turkey. , : 665.
Afolabi O.I.,Adegbite D.A.,Ashaolu O.F.,Akinbode S.O.,Busi Nigeria. Afric. J. .2013 .Profitability and resourceuse eficiency in poultry egg farming in Ogun State. , 7 : 1536-1540.
Alexandratoss N.,Bruinsma J.,Organization Agriculture .2050 .The 2012 revision. , 12 : 03.
Ali M.S.,Hossain M.M. .2010 .Factors influencing the performance of farmers in broiler production of Faridpur District in Bangladesh. World's Poult. Sci. J, 66 : 123-128.
Aral Y.,Arikan M.S.,Onbasilar E.E.,Unal N.,Gokdai A.,Erdem E. .2017 .Economic comparison of unenriched and alternative cage systems used in laying hen husbandry recent experience under Turkish commercial conditions. World's Poult. Sci. J, 73 : 69-76.
Atilgan A.,Koknaroglu H. .2006 .Cultural energy analysis on broilers reared in diferent capacity poultry houses. Ital. J. Anim. Sci., 5 : 393-400.
Badubi S.S.,Ravindran V. .2004 .A survey of smallscale layer production systems in Botswana. Int. J. Poult. Sci., 322 : 322-325.
Banga-Mboko H.J.,Mabas S.,Adzona P.P. .2010 .Efect of housing system (battery cages versus floor pen) on performance of laying hens under tropical conditions in Congo Brazzaville. Res. J. Poult. Sci., 1 : 4-4.
Banga-Mboko H.,Mabanza-Mbandza B.,Adzona P.P.,Batessana C. .2007 .Response a' l'alimentation calcique separee de lignees commerciales de poules pondeuses Shaver sous les conditions tropicales du Congo Brazzaville. Bull. Anim, 55 : 43-50.
Bock B.R. .1999 .Poultry litter to energy: Technical and economic feasibility. TVA Public Power Instute, : .
Carvalho E.H.,Zilli J.B.,Mendes A.S.,Morello G.M.,Bonamigo D.V. .2015 .Main factors that afect the economic eficiency of broiler breeder production. Rev. Brasil. Ciência Avícola, 17 : 1516-16.
Celik L.O. .2003 .Efects of dietary supplemental L-carnitine and ascorbic acid on performance, carcass composition and plasma L-carnitine concentration of broiler chicks reared under diferent temperature. Arch. Anim. Nutr, 57 : 27-38.
Chisanga B.,Zulu-Mbata O.N. .2017 .Agrifood systems transformation in zambia: How have consumption patterns changed? Indaba Agricultural Policy Research Institute. , : .
Costa A.,Ferrari S.,Guarino M. .2012 .Yearly emission factors of ammonia and particulate matter from three laying-hen housing systems. Anim. Prod. Sci., 52 : 1089-1098.
Coufal C.D.,Chavez C.,Niemeyer P.R.,Carey J.B. .2006 .Nitrogen emissions from broiler measured by a mass balance over eighteen consecutive flocks. Poult. Sci., 85 : 384-391.
Ellen H.H. .2005 .Emissions, regulations and impact in the European Union and The Netherlands. J. appl. Poult. Res., 14 : 651-655.
Esengun K.,Gündüz O.,Erdal G. .2006 .Inputoutput energy analysis in the dry apricot production of Turkey. Energy Conv. , 06 : 592-598.
FAO World Livestock .2011 .Livestock in food security. , : 115.
Faridi A.,Mottaghitalab M.,Rezaee F. .2011 .Narushin-Takma models as flexible alternatives for describing economic traits in broiler breeder flocks. Poult. Sci., 90 : 00825-515.
Figueiredo A.M.,Santos P.A.,Santolin R.,Reis B.S. .2006 .. Rev. Econ. Soc. Rural, 44 : 713.
Fluck R.C. .1992 .Energy in farm production (ed. -444- 88681-1, : 50008-9.
Fournel S.,Pelletier F.,Godbout S.,Lagace R.,Feddes J. .2012 .Greenhouse gas emissions from three cage layer housing systems. Animals, 2 : 1-15.
Gates R.S.,Casey K.D.,Wheeler E.F.,Xin H.,Pescatore A.J. .2007 .broiler ammonia emissions inventory model. Atmos. Environ., 06 : 3342-3350.
Gocsik E.,Lansink A.O.,Voermans G.,Saatkamp H.W. .2015 .Economic feasibility of animal welfare improvements in Dutch intensive livestock production: A comparison between broiler, laying hen, and fattening pig sectors. Livest. Sci., 10 : 38-53.
Groen A.F.,Jiang X.,Emmerson D.A.,Vereijken A. .1998 .A deterministic model for the economic evaluation of broiler production systems. Poult. Sci., 77 : 925-933.
Harper L.A.,Flesch T.K. .2010 .Ammonia emissions from broiler production in the San Joaquin Valley. , 89 : 00718-1814.
Heidari M.D.,Omid M.,Akram A. .2011 .Energy eficiency and econometric analysis of broiler production farms. Energy, 09 : 6536-6541.
Kilic I. .2015 .Analysis of the energy eficiency of poultry houses in the Bursa region of Turkey. J. appl. Anim. Res., 44 : 165-172.
Kitani O. .1999 .Energy and biomass engineering. CIGR handbook of agricultural engineering, (vol. St. Joseph, : 330.
Kizilaslan H. .2008 .Input-output energy analysis of cherries production in Tokat Province of Turkey. , 07 : 1354-1358.
Knowlton K.F. .2000 .Ammonia emissions: The next regulatory hurdle. , 47 : 56-57.
Kozłowski S. .2008 .Zrównoważony rozwój w ujęciu interdyscyplinarnym. Uniwersytet Rzeszowski, : 9-22.
Lay D.C.,Fulton R.M.,Hester P.Y.,Karcher D.M.,Kjaer J.B.,Mench J.A.,Mullen B.A.,Newberry R.C.,Nicol C.J.,Sullivan N.P.O.,Porter R.E. .2011 .Hen welfare in diferent housing systems. Poult. Sci., 90 : 00962-294.
Li H.,Xin H. .2013 .Lab-scale assessment of gaseous emissions from laying-hen manure storage as afected by physical and environmental factors. Trans. ASABE, 53 : 593-604.
Lopes M.A.,Lima A.L.R.,Carvalho F.M.,Reis R.P.,Santos R.P.,Saraiva R.P. .2004 .. Ciência Agrotecnol, 28 : 883-892.
Maba S.J. .2008 .etudes pour l'obtention du diplome d'ingenieur des travaux de developpement rural. Universite Marien Ngouabi, 38 : .
Matthews W.A.,Sumner W.A. .2015 .Efects of housing system on the costs of commercial egg production. Poult. Sci., 94 : 552-557.
Sariozkan S.,Sakarya E. .2006 .The profitability and productivity analysis of layer hen enterprises in Afyon province. Turkey. J. Lalahan Livest. Res. Inst., 46 : 29-44.
Sefeedpari P.,Rafiee S.,Akram A. .2013 .Identifying sustainable and eficient poultry farms in the light of energy use eficiency: A data envelopment analysis approach. J. Agric. Eng. Biotechnol, 1 : 1-8.
Sousa F.H.M.,Batalha M.O. .2005 .Gestão integrada da propriedade familiar. , : .
Sumner D.A.,Rosen-Molina J.T.,Matthews W.A.,Mench J.A.,Richter K.R. .2008 .Economic efects of proposed restrictions on egg-laying hen housing in California. , : .
Tschirley D.,Haggblade S.,Reardon T. .2013 .Africa's emerging food system transformation. Global Center for Food System Innovation, East Lansing. , : .
Uzal S. .2012 .Comparison of the energy eficiency of dairy production farms using diferent housing systems. Environ. Prog. Sust. Energy, 32 : 1202-1208.
Vaarst M.,Steenfeldt S.,Horsted K. .2015 .Sustainable development perspectives of poultry production. World's Poult. Sci. J, 71 : 609-620.
Van Horne P.L.M. .2003 .The impact of laying hen welfare on the competitiveness of the EU egg industry. World's Poult. Sci. J, 19 : 18-21.
Yassin H.,Velthuis A.G.J.,Giesen G.W.J.,Lansink Oude,A.G.J.M. Oude .2012 .Comparative analysis as a management tool for broiler breeder farms: Simulated individual farm analysis (IFAS). Poult. Sci., 91 : 01623-757.
Zangeneh M.,Omid M.,Akram A. .2010 .. , : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

113

Views