No Detail Found!

Studies on the medical safety of botanical medicines: Novel toxic metals and microbial contamination approach

Author(s)
Roqayah Hassan Kadi Department of Biological Sciences, College of Science, University of Jeddah,Jeddah,Saudi Arabia
Uguru Hilary Department of Agricultural Engineering, Delta State University of Science and Technology,Ozoro,Nigeria
Akpokodje Ovie Isaac Department of Civil and Water Resources Engineering, Delta State University of Science and Technology,Ozoro,Nigeria
Idama Omokaro Department of Computer Engineering, Delta State University of Science and Technology,Ozoro,Nigeria
Rokayya Sami Department of Food Science and Nutrition, College of Sciences, Taif University,Taif,Saudi Arabia
Suha Abduljawad Department of Clinical Nutrition, College of Applied Medical Sciences, Taibah University,Medina,Saudi Arabia
Fayez Alsulaimani Department of Medical Laboratory Sciences, Faculty of Applied Medical Sciences, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia;Embryonic Stem Cell Unit, King Fahd Medical Research Center, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Ahmed Basri Department of Medical Laboratory Sciences, Faculty of Applied Medical Sciences, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia;Embryonic Stem Cell Unit, King Fahd Medical Research Center, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Ola Abu Ali Department of Chemistry, College of Science, Taif University,Taif,Saudi Arabia
Mahmoud Helal Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Taif University, Taif, Saudi Arabia
Abstract
The utilization of herbal therapies is increasing globally, prompting investigations into the health complications that may arise from drug side effects. A total of 160 herbal medicines (HMs), were used for this study, and their toxic heavy metal content, microbial load and dielectric properties were evaluated. The results obtained revealed that the crude HMs exhibited a greater proportion of heavy metals, microorganisms and a higher dielectric constant (?') value, in comparison to the refined HMs. Particularly, the powdered HMs contained high heavy metals and microbial contaminations. For the unrefined powders, HM samples exceeded the safety limits of cfu/g = 105, approved by World Health Organization for herbal medications. Regarding the electrical properties, the ?' for the crude unrefined HMs ranged from 9.19 to 92.67; while the refined HMs ?' values varied from 7.35 to 39.15. The hazard index (HI) analysis showed that unrefined HMs have higher non-carcinogenic toxicity than refined ones, with children facing serious health risks as their HI values surpass 1. Crude heavy metal consumption increases a child's risk of developing cancer. This research's findings highlighted the importance of consistent monitoring of herbal products, as heavy metals can accumulate, resulting in toxicity after prolonged use of these drugs.
Publication Details
Page(s) 1389-1397
Published Journal: Pakistan Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Volume: 38, Issue: 4, Year: 2025

Request the full text from PASTIC

Keywords
Heavy metals, microbial contamination, Medicinal herbs, Heavy metals, Heavy metals, Drug safety, Public health practice
References
Abdul JAH,Abdullah BM,Pawa NP,Shaikh YH .2018 .High quality dielectric properties of four medicinal herbs at different frequencies. IJRAR, 5(4) : 636-641.
Abdul JAH,Sayyeda RN,Shaikh IF,Shaikh YH .2020 .Dielectric properties of drugs at lower frequency range from 3 KHz to 5 MHz by using impedance analyzer. J. Chem, 6 : 209-214.
AJeroho O,Achara F,Adewoyin B,Abo K B .2018 .Determination of cadmium, chromium and lead in four brands of herbal bitters preparation sold in Benin-city, Southern Nigeria. Afr. J. Environ. Sci. Technol, 12(5) : 186-190.
Alghamdi W,Al-Fadel N,Alghamdi EA,Alghamdi M,Alharbi F M .2023 .Signal detection and assessment of herb-drug interactions: Saudi food and drug authority experience. DRWO, 10(4) : 577-585.
Alharbi SF,Mohammed AI,Alrasheed AH,Ismail MA,Allemailem M,Alnuqaydan KS,Baabdullah AM,Alkhalifah AM,A AM .2024 .Microbial and heavy metal contamination in herbal medicine: A prospective study in the central region of Saudi Arabia. BMC Complement. Med, 24(1) : 2-7.
Amir M,Vohra M,Raj RG,Osoro I,Sharma A .2023 .Adaptogenic herbs: A natural way to improve athletic performance. Health Sci. Rev, 7 : 100092.
Antar SA,Ashour NA,Sharaky M,Khattab M,Ashour NA,Zaid RT,Roh EJ,Elkamhawy A,AlKarmalawy AA A .2023 .Diabetes mellitus: Classification, mediators, and complications; A gate to identify potential targets for the development of new effective treatments. Biomed, 168 : 115734-115754.
Asiminicesei DM,Fertu DI,Gavrilescu M .2024 .Impact of heavy metal pollution in the environment on the metabolic profile of medicinal plants and their therapeutic potential. Plants, 13(6) : 913-927.
ASTM .2021 .Standard practices for digestion of water samples for determination of metals by flame atomic absorption, graphite furnace atomic absorption, plasma emission spectroscopy, or plasma mass spectrometry.. , 16 : .
ATSDR .2019 .Agency for toxic substances and disease registry substance priority List. , : .
Balkrishna A,Sharma N,Srivastava D,Kukreti A,Srivastava S,Arya V .2024 .Exploring the safety, efficacy, and bioactivity of herbal medicines: Bridging traditional wisdom and modern science in healthcare. FIM., 3(1) : 35-49.
Md Barkat,Goyal A,Barkat HA,Salauddin M,Pottoo FH,Anwer ET .2021 .Herbal medicine: Clinical perspective and regulatory status. CCHTS Journal, 24(10) : 1573-1582.
Brini E,Fennell CJ,Fernandez-Serra M,Hribar-Lee B,Lukšič M,Dill KA .2017 .How water's properties are encoded in its molecular structure and energies. Chem, 117(19) : 12385-12414.
Bhalla A,Pannu AK .2022 .Are Ayurvedic medications store house of heavy metals?. Toxicol. Res, 11(1) : 179-183.
De Sousa CM,Fujishima MAT,de Paula B,Mastroianni PC .2020 .Microbial contamination in herbal medicines: A serious health hazard to elderly consumers. BMC Complement. Med, 20(1) : 252-271.
Ekeleme UG,Ikwuagwu VO,Chukwuocha UM,Nwakanma JC,Adiruo SA,Ogini IO,Ude IU .2024 .Detection and characterization of microorganisms linked to unsealed drugs sold in Ihiagwa community. , 6(2) : 000752.
Ellwanger JH,Veiga ABG,Kaminski VL,ValverdeVillegas JM,Freitas AWQ,Chies JAB .2021 .Control and prevention of infectious diseases from a One Health perspective. , 44(Suppl 1) : e20200256-e20200271.
Gonelimali FD,Lin J,Miao W,Xuan J,Charles F,Chen M,Hatab SR M .2018 .Antimicrobial properties and mechanism of action of some plant extracts against food pathogens and spoilage microorganisms. Front. Microbiol., : 1639-1662.
Hassen G,Belete G,Carrera KG,Iriowen RO,Araya H,Alemu T,Bam DS,Debele T,Zouetr M,Jain N M .2022 .Clinical implications of herbal supplements in conventional medical practice: A US perspective. Cureus, 14(7) : e26893.
Hong LO,Ee Meng C,Mohamad CWS,Mohd Nasir,Xiao Jian NF,Chong You T,Ziezie Mohd Tarmizi B,Kim Yee E,Kok Yeow L,Shing Fhan Y,Kim Fey K,Kian Keong L,T L,SA L .2024 .Frequency-dependent dielectric spectroscopic analysis on phytochemical and antioxidant activities in radix glycyrrhizae extract. Heliyon, 10(17) : e37077.
Hu Y,Wang J,Yang Y,Li S,Wu Q,Nepovimova E,Zhang X,Kuca K X .2024 .Revolutionizing soil heavy metal remediation: Cutting-edge innovations in plant disposal technology. Sci. Total, 918 : 170577-170592.
Jităreanu A,Trifan A,Vieriu M,Caba IC,Mârțu I,Agoroaei L I .2023 .Current trends in toxicity assessment of herbal medicines: A narrative review. Processes, 11(1) : 83-105.
Kandic I,Kragovic M,Petrovic J,Janackovic P,Gavrilovic M,Momcilovic M,Stojmenovic M M .2023 .Heavy metals content in selected medicinal plants produced and consumed in Serbia and their daily intake in herbal infusions. Toxics, 11(2) : 198-215.
Lahane UR .2016 .Dielectric parameters of herbal medicines (. , 7(3) : 1109-1112.
Lima MBA,Yonamine M .2023 .Counterfeit medicines: Relevance, consequences and strategies to combat the global crisis. Braz. J. Pharm. Sci., 59 : e20402-e20418.
Lis-Cieplak A,Trześniowska K,Stolarczyk K,Stolarczyk EU K .2024 .Pyrrolizidine alkaloids as hazardous toxins in natural products: Current analytical methods and latest legal regulations. Molecules, 29(14) : 3269-3281.
Luo L,Wang B,Jiang J,Fitzgerald M,Huang Q,Yu Z,Li H,Zhang J,Wei J,Yang C,Zhang H,Dong L,Chen S. .2021 .Heavy metal contaminations in herbal medicines: Determination, comprehensive risk assessments, and solutions. , 11 : 1-14.
Mssusa AK,Holst L,Kagashe G,Maregesi S G .2023 .Safety profile of herbal medicines submitted for marketing authorization in Tanzania: A cross-sectional retrospective study. J. Pharm. Policy Pract, 16(1) : 241.
Meseret M,Ketema G,Kassahun H G .2020 .Health Risk Assessment and determination of some heavy metals in commonly consumed traditional herbal preparations in Northeast Ethiopia. J. Chemistry, 4 : 1-7.
Muyumba NW,Mutombo SC,Sheridan H,Nachtergael A,Duez P .2021 .Quality control of herbal drugs and preparations: The methods of analysis, their relevance and applications. Talanta Open, 4 : 100070-100085.
Okaiyeto K,Oguntibeju OO K .2021 .African herbal medicines: Adverse effects and cytotoxic potentials with different therapeutic applications. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 18(11) : 5988-6006.
Picot S,Beugnet F,Leboucher G,Bienvenu AL .2022 .Drug resistant parasites and fungi from a onehealth perspective: A global concern that needs transdisciplinary stewardship programs. One health, 14 : 100368-100382.
Quan NV,Dang Xuan T,Teschke R .2020 .Potential hepatotoxins found in herbal medicinal products: A systematic review. Int. J. Mol. Sci, 21(14) : 5011.
Lerner BL Schafer G .2022 .Physical and chemical characteristics and analysis of plant substrate. Ornam, 28(2) : 181-192.
Segatin N,Poklar Ulrih N .2020 .Dielectric properties and dipole moment of edible oils subjected to 'Frying' thermal treatment. Foods, 9(7) : 900-917.
Uguru H,Essaghah AE,Akwenuke OM,Akpokodje OI,Rokayya S,Mahmoud H S .2023 .Environmental impact of wasteyard leachate pollution, it's health risks with some microbial and ecological implications. J. Biobased Mater. Bioenergy, 17 : 270-285.
Uguru H,Efeoghene EA.,Issac AO,Sami R,Baakdah F,Pareek S F .2024 .Exposure to airborne pollutants in urban and rural areas: Levels of metals and microorganisms in PM10 and gaseous pollutants in ambient air. Air Qual. Atmos. Hlth., 1 : 40-61.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency) .1986 .Guidelines for the health risk assessment of chemical mixtures. Fed, 51 : 34014-34025.
Wang H,Chen Y,Wang L,Liu Q,Yang S,Wang C .2023 .Advancing herbal medicine: Enhancing product quality and safety through robust quality control practices. Front, 14 : 1265178.
World Health Organization .2008 .. , : .
WHO .2024 .Noncommunicable diseases. , : .
WHO .2007 .WHO Guidelines for Assessing Quality of Herbal Medicines with Reference to Contaminants and Residues. , : .
Wu X,Wu P,Gu M,Xue J .2022 .Trace heavy metals and harmful elements in roots and rhizomes of herbs: Screening level analysis and health risk assessment. Chin. Herb. Med, 14(4) : 622-629.
Yang CM,Chien MY,Chao PC,Huang CM,Chen CH .2021 .Investigation of toxic heavy metals content and estimation of potential health risks in Chinese herbal medicine. J. Hazard. Mater, 412 : 125142.
Yao Z,Liang M,Zhu S M .2024 .Infectious factors in myocarditis: A comprehensive review of common and rare pathogens. Egypt, 76(1) : 1-20.
Yesuf A,Wondimeneh Y,Gebrecherkos T,Moges F .2016 .Occurrence of potential bacterial pathogens and their antimicrobial susceptibility patterns isolated from herbal medicinal products sold in different markets of Gondar town. Northwest Ethiopia. Int. J. Bacteriol, : .
0

Citations

0

Downloads

83

Views